I love Death Cab, I love Ben, but I'm not sure about this. I'm certainly not bashing, and the person who said it took balls to get up and sing in front of millions of people is absolutely right. I don't know ... this just feels ... out of context, maybe. But hey, good for him, trying something out of the norm.
I love Death Cab/Postal Service, but... ugh. This sort of thing just isn't for Ben. Was he trying to go for an awkward and cute sort of performance? It really didn't work out. Oh well.
When musicians step outside of their comfort zone and step up to the plate (no pun intended) they should be supported, not judged by a bunch of "critics". Unless any of the complainers would be brave enough to sing the National Anthem in front of millions of people (live audience and t.v. viewers) themselves they should fuck off . Find something you enjoy instead and let people enjoy the vid, or if you must pick out all the dislikes in life, pursue a career as a professional music/singer critic.
The guy does not have the full vocal range the song requires. I am sure his intention was not to be "classy or simple". He simply does not have the pipes to deliver the high or low notes on the Star Spangled Banner. Having said that, when he was within his vocal range, he sang it beautifully.
Do people ever get tired of hating on shit that has no immediate effect on them?? I think that was beautiful and im Canadian for fucks sake. Cant compete with subtlety.
To all those bashing this, you're insane. This is exactly what the national anthem should be: simple, heartfelt, and classy. He didn't use the chance on national television to show off like a lot of pop singers do, and stretch their range to the absolute brink of disaster. He sang it just like he'd sing Cath, Or What Sarah Said, and that's what made it great. It was an American, singing just like he always does, for our country's anthem. It's not supposed to be flashy, just well done.
@BigD4u2nv70 I usually don't mind Ben Gibbard's voice, but the Star Spangled Banner is not a Death Cab song. Singing it unaccompanied in a stadium as though it's a whispery acoustic ballad doesn't work. He swallowed the high notes and the low notes. It's a tough song to sing, and I too hate the flashy melismatic over-singing that the American idol types like to give it, but this was not good singing.
Ben is not the kind of singer that should be singing a National Anthem. He is a great singer and amazing at what he does, but just not his best effort. Not making any comparisons to singing styles or anything like that, but it'd be like Adam Levine singing the National Anthem. Go Giants!!
freaking the best!!!! :D did such a beautiful job...saw him in concert! ;) haha.
famousgirll77 4 months ago
That was beautiful :)
rockel1986 4 months ago
I always hate that cheap patriotism than Americans have the same powers that give the ass to the Middle East for example but Ben Gibbard sing nice
Yoamm 10 months ago
Absolutely amazing
paytonn911 1 year ago
AMAZING. <3 I love him so much.
jodanjodanjodan 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Original. Which is what this country should be all about.
TwilightandShadow16 1 year ago
Wow that was good. Way to go Gibbard!!! Ahh, definitely an honor to sing that for our country and he nailed it. SO neat.
Shepsterof92 1 year ago
Dude looks like he is about to piss his pants from being so nervous.
jefferygwatkins 1 year ago
I love Death Cab, I love Ben, but I'm not sure about this. I'm certainly not bashing, and the person who said it took balls to get up and sing in front of millions of people is absolutely right. I don't know ... this just feels ... out of context, maybe. But hey, good for him, trying something out of the norm.
MegaCrasher2000 1 year ago
amazing
PurplekushX 1 year ago
I love Death Cab/Postal Service, but... ugh. This sort of thing just isn't for Ben. Was he trying to go for an awkward and cute sort of performance? It really didn't work out. Oh well.
aodpod 1 year ago
When musicians step outside of their comfort zone and step up to the plate (no pun intended) they should be supported, not judged by a bunch of "critics". Unless any of the complainers would be brave enough to sing the National Anthem in front of millions of people (live audience and t.v. viewers) themselves they should fuck off . Find something you enjoy instead and let people enjoy the vid, or if you must pick out all the dislikes in life, pursue a career as a professional music/singer critic.
nomoredead2nite 1 year ago 2
The guy does not have the full vocal range the song requires. I am sure his intention was not to be "classy or simple". He simply does not have the pipes to deliver the high or low notes on the Star Spangled Banner. Having said that, when he was within his vocal range, he sang it beautifully.
xxcarlos 1 year ago
Do people ever get tired of hating on shit that has no immediate effect on them?? I think that was beautiful and im Canadian for fucks sake. Cant compete with subtlety.
HCMos 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
fuck that fagot
exxmodel 1 year ago
@exxmodel he's going out with Zooey Deschanel...until you pull a bitch like shut the fuck up
dude12nothin 1 year ago
@dude12nothin this aint 2003 nigga lmao
postshanna 1 year ago
@postshanna kicking it out school cuz im so cool
dude12nothin 1 year ago
@dude12nothin he's actually MARRIED to Zooey now. So just to further emphasize your bashing...
agmorlan2 1 year ago
@agmorlan2 MARRIED... Going to have to break that up.
dude12nothin 1 year ago
Comment removed
Robot10 3 months ago
He's not married to her anymore! Haha.
Robot10 3 months ago
@exxmodel You're the reason why the boys killed themselves. Think about what you do, for fucks sake.
kev2594 1 year ago
@exxmodel Why? Is it because he's a lot more successful than you? (I mean, you are an "ex model").
VIVALASTEPHANI3 1 year ago
To all those bashing this, you're insane. This is exactly what the national anthem should be: simple, heartfelt, and classy. He didn't use the chance on national television to show off like a lot of pop singers do, and stretch their range to the absolute brink of disaster. He sang it just like he'd sing Cath, Or What Sarah Said, and that's what made it great. It was an American, singing just like he always does, for our country's anthem. It's not supposed to be flashy, just well done.
BigD4u2nv70 1 year ago 77
@BigD4u2nv70 Thank YOU! Very well said. He kept it simple and respectful and it sounded perfect. Not that I'd expect anything less from Ben...
blackdove623 1 year ago 2
@BigD4u2nv70 I usually don't mind Ben Gibbard's voice, but the Star Spangled Banner is not a Death Cab song. Singing it unaccompanied in a stadium as though it's a whispery acoustic ballad doesn't work. He swallowed the high notes and the low notes. It's a tough song to sing, and I too hate the flashy melismatic over-singing that the American idol types like to give it, but this was not good singing.
steveschnee 1 year ago
say what you want, but that was remarkable.
amandalynnieface 1 year ago 18
@amandalynnieface .. that shit fucking sucked (as per your advice)
FundedByTheMob 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
haha what a fag
postshanna 1 year ago
Comment removed
igludsss 1 year ago
Ben is not the kind of singer that should be singing a National Anthem. He is a great singer and amazing at what he does, but just not his best effort. Not making any comparisons to singing styles or anything like that, but it'd be like Adam Levine singing the National Anthem. Go Giants!!
agmorlan2 1 year ago
aaand the phillies lose! thank you ben
TheLemur47 1 year ago
this was so great! and then zooey sang God Bless America during the 7th inning stretch
Jrples 1 year ago
I love Death Cab and I love the Giants. This leaves a lot to be desired.
talefromthepit 1 year ago
@talefromthepit
too bad hes a die hard mariners fan and zooey is a dodger fan!
asdfcris 1 year ago
@asdfcris I remember when DCFC played the Fillmore and he joked about not doing what he wanted to do (play SS for Seattle).
talefromthepit 1 year ago
@talefromthepit
hahaha! i hear he throws an awesome knuckle ball as well!
asdfcris 1 year ago
pretty good I think
pntbllrspdr 1 year ago
so disappointed Ben
Drewnielsenable 1 year ago
Thanks! I'm missing this due to work, I hope you record Zooey singing too.
boddah84 1 year ago
thank you! I just missed it...:)
dancingbearjam 1 year ago