@2112dim I completely agree!! 11:20 through out.....is the piece that hits me the most off the whole album! It's such an insane buildup of sound. Cheers to ya.
La manera en que suena tu corazón hace toda la diferencia, es lo que decide si soportarás el dolor que todos sentimos. La manera en que suena tu corazón hace toda la diferencia en aprender a vivir. Por la gracia de la naturaleza inflexible, estoy aprendiendo a vivir...
UGH!!!!!!!!!!!!The fact that he didn't hit the F# really freaks me out everytime I listen to this version.The reggae thing going on in the song was really cool haha :D!!
I actually really like how James decided not to go for THE high note (he would probably not hit it and he knows that) and made amazing harmonies with guitar. I wish he would do that every time :)
This song is absolutely amazing live. Like at 7:04. That's so much more groovy live than it is in the studio version, I love it. And at 9:27 where they put that reggae groove in there, that's pretty cool. But my favorite is the extended ending. This gives me chills every time I hear it.
Sometimes in peoples lives have to figure out what is happening and what is going to happen. Find it in your heart to forgive yourself for any misgivings, move forward!
How great they play!!!, but this song for me is so wonderful that in this case I can't forgive so many changes, the music has to be the most important on the stage not the musicians. That's why I prefer the original studio song wich is a Masterpiece of DT.
Is it me, or is the Waits for Sleep reprise just pure ecstacy? This has just been elected my favorite song ever. Seriously, I could sing along with the ending for days...
Ganz ganz großartige Band. Great Band. Auf ihren Konzerten habe ich so viel empfunden wie noch fast nie in meinem Leben. Never felt so intensive like on concerts from dream theater. Hope to see them soon again live on stage!!!
@goblinondrums Wikipedia has the show at 190:00 .. which is over three hours long, thats a long concert for one band. MP passed out afterwards from all the drumming. So good observation!
You know whats funny? everyone that i know that grew up with rush actually prefers DT over them after I introduce these early albums. DT is so much more diverse and there musical abilities surpass all others. plus MP drumming on this album is un-comparable. Anyone can cover a rush song, but no one can run through this song in one go and have it near 100%. Its insanely tricky but good, it almost seems effortless.
This song is written by John Myung and Dream Theater's best epic (from my opinion). It's a pity that John Myung never wrote a song for Dream Theater again after "Fatal Tragedy". His song always be my favorite.
This one beats the studio and earlier live version by lightyears! It's epic how (on the ONCE IN A LIFETIME album) fades into The Crimson Sunset. Has been giving me the goosebumps for 14 years now. And going strong.
@nietjob Cut the man some slack, dude :-) This is at the end of a very long concert. You won't meet an awful lot of singers who can still hold a tune that well after more than 90 minutes of screaming their guts out!
Why do people compare Porcupine Tree to Dream Theater? There not even technically close. Mike is so technically fluent on this album, And this song is one of those songs that no one dares to cover on youtube. Gavin is technical, But his playing is predictable. Its too dry and stale, And his sound has alot to do with it. Theres not one song they play that can rival this masterpiece. I mean come on, This is a complete mindfuck for drummers!..
I don't listen to DT much anymore but this song still amazes me. Great musically and lyrically. Myung wrote the best words... sure beats Mike Portnoy's juvenile drivel from Train of Thought.
James looks like Bryn Terfel (bass-baritone)
Gerezieta 1 day ago
James - Thank you everyone! Good night! (Hoping the song now ends)
Petrucci - DRRZTDRZZTDRZTJWOEPLDJGD (Stfu James, song didn't end yet /care)
Portnoy- DABADABADABADABATISSTISDABA (I agree.)
Jordan- DJJAUJAUJDDAZTAJAUVVV (Me too)
Myung- DBBDBBDBBDBMDMDM (I don't care)
James- ....
exheberria 5 days ago 2
great music ever...
zorkva 3 weeks ago
7:11 WO OHOOOOOO WO OHOOOOOO WO OHOwowooooo What the fuck? this is supposed to be : WOHO OAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA!!!! ; )
chenille75 1 month ago
@chenille75 its high pitched, i think james very tired.. he trying to do the best, not bad.
zorkva 3 weeks ago
11:20 until the end of this MASTERPIECE,some of the most amazing minutes of the music we love.
2112dim 1 month ago
@2112dim I completely agree!! 11:20 through out.....is the piece that hits me the most off the whole album! It's such an insane buildup of sound. Cheers to ya.
Ziggywompus 4 weeks ago
Miss you K2600 . . .
88rudess 1 month ago
Jordan Rudess looks odd with hair :/
joshrochanroolzutoob 1 month ago
@joshrochanroolzutoob Agree! It looks like a post Napoleonic style wig.
dandisil 1 month ago
@joshrochanroolzutoob Isn't this footage with Derek Sherinian? It's not Jordan, is it? I don't know, I'm asking....
Ziggywompus 4 weeks ago
@Ziggywompus It's actually Jordan! As strange as it may sound today, he hasn't always been bald ;)
luckyluke193 3 weeks ago
GOD DAMN IT !!!!!!!!!!! I watch this video like 5 or 6 times all day since two weeks, I can't stop watch it and listen o_o
Xcbtribe 1 month ago
someone throw some kind of solid to Labrie... wtf is he singin'? :D
zazajojua 1 month ago
12:50 Proof that LaBrie does participate in the instrumental sections of DT.
dragoncrashhero12 2 months ago
@dragoncrashhero12 hahaha I thought the same :)
Xcbtribe 2 months ago
Yo0o0o0o0oMaaaanNn... \m/
rickiycuyt 2 months ago
best song ever!
Anliz90 2 months ago
uhynhiinj
ZarKaiser7798 2 months ago
ddesayretdjures7yrurxrut
ZarKaiser7798 2 months ago
3:48
Awesome part!!!
Astrixone 2 months ago
when was the last time they played this?
Thr4sh4lot 3 months ago
La manera en que suena tu corazón hace toda la diferencia, es lo que decide si soportarás el dolor que todos sentimos. La manera en que suena tu corazón hace toda la diferencia en aprender a vivir. Por la gracia de la naturaleza inflexible, estoy aprendiendo a vivir...
OrkusMethedrine 3 months ago
wow this is so fucking perfect! :|
alexmtz191 3 months ago
executed perfectly until 7.15... LABRIE!! LETDOWN!!!
mistersusan1471 3 months ago
κομματαρα !!!!!!!!!!!
mixalisatreides 3 months ago
labri canta como el poto wn
berner2010 4 months ago
UGH!!!!!!!!!!!!The fact that he didn't hit the F# really freaks me out everytime I listen to this version.The reggae thing going on in the song was really cool haha :D!!
kankuro1701 4 months ago
I actually really like how James decided not to go for THE high note (he would probably not hit it and he knows that) and made amazing harmonies with guitar. I wish he would do that every time :)
battalion30 4 months ago
@battalion30 Perfectly right. This sounds perfect.
hyphen8nick 3 months ago
Jordan had such a great sound with the Kurz...
2Slipperman 4 months ago
watch?v=LfPSRb8btjA&feature=related this version is better!
OlhuscOmuns 5 months ago
13:48 fuck you!
extremities9 5 months ago
good song .regards from chile
xnic0491x 5 months ago
wich concert is this?
dael101 5 months ago
@dael101 Live Scenes from New York
ezequieltcd 5 months ago
@ezequieltcd THANKS!
dael101 5 months ago
@dael101 Live Scenes From New York(
roaldski 4 months ago
10:38-10:51 is the best guitar/keyboard harmony solo ever.
civilengsi 5 months ago
10:38-10:51 is the best guitar/keyboard harmony solo ever.
civilengsi 5 months ago
just heard breaking all illusions and said to myself...Learning to Live next!!!
thecountoftuscany198 5 months ago
I hope they close with this one when they come to Orlando
borikualoco 6 months ago
LaBrie F sharp fail so he decides to sing over Petrucci to make up for it -_-
Meph761 6 months ago
just fucking awesome,amazing
song.
this it's the shit
my favorite song all time
MrJugoso10 6 months ago
It seems Petrucci really loves playing these old songs... It's the first live where I see he's really enjoying the music !
gigabroly 6 months ago
1:27, am i the only one thinking"shut up petrucci, let me hear myung 5 seconds ?"
dias17se 6 months ago 21
@dias17se nope.
321acb123 6 months ago
@dias17se mmmm.... yup, you are
gmangsxr750 5 months ago
@dias17se Yes
aperezrodriguez 3 weeks ago
I wish I could click "like" a thousand times.
musicaselecta 6 months ago
I wish I could click "like" a thousand times.
musicaselecta 6 months ago
I like how the songs get so melodic near the end.
TpRunelover2008 6 months ago
couldn't stop smiling when watching this video. the day just got awesome! such musical talent gives me goosebumps
yuki777guitar 6 months ago 14
Comment removed
yuki777guitar 6 months ago
rudess wore a rug
jpaulom 7 months ago
I think this was the biggest disappointment of the whole show, him not hitting the F#. Id be pissed too. I can hear VERY faint booing.
TheBassBender 7 months ago
@TheBassBender Come on bro. He can't hit the F5 like he used to. Cut the man some slack.
Spideymania 5 months ago
great composition
kostasssism 7 months ago
O.o oh mio Dio è stupenda!! mozzilla-you tube-learning to live-play-replay-replay-replay-replay ecc.
simo90msn 7 months ago
Reggae into kick ass keyboard solo, beautiful live change-up.
alzico 7 months ago
One of the greatest songs... not only for Dream Theater, but for whole Progressive Metal
VNtinos 7 months ago
no F#, hahahahaha !!
VNtinos 7 months ago
This song is absolutely amazing live. Like at 7:04. That's so much more groovy live than it is in the studio version, I love it. And at 9:27 where they put that reggae groove in there, that's pretty cool. But my favorite is the extended ending. This gives me chills every time I hear it.
RainbowRaider7 7 months ago
@RainbowRaider7 ah same here! goose bumps every time!
tandersn9 5 months ago
My all time favourite song ;-)
vasmacsek 7 months ago
Makes deep purple look like green! Bad ass band!!
Sometimes in peoples lives have to figure out what is happening and what is going to happen. Find it in your heart to forgive yourself for any misgivings, move forward!
TheCrisco68 7 months ago
Makes deep purple look like green! Bad ass band!!
TheCrisco68 7 months ago
How great they play!!!, but this song for me is so wonderful that in this case I can't forgive so many changes, the music has to be the most important on the stage not the musicians. That's why I prefer the original studio song wich is a Masterpiece of DT.
Tenken81 7 months ago
Trying to dance to all the odd time signatures in this song = the most succesful failure ever.
NailsForDinner 7 months ago
I'm gonna be in Vienna in 2 days!!!!
MuseumofmyPhilosophy 7 months ago 2
3 simple words - best song ever !!!
petiu2005 7 months ago
Motherfucking boss of a song.
pear928 7 months ago
this song is to be repeated eternally
iseiji22 7 months ago 2
Finally I was hoping to find a live performance of this song, thank you =D...
osalbaro 7 months ago
Learning, Learning..
303026116 7 months ago
Trying to headbang this song is certain death to either your neck or your brain, or both.
iVanHalen666 7 months ago
1:25 ish, count of tuscany ftw
ACBWBand 8 months ago
They learned ME to live!!!! Guys from DT: I love you!!!
Depalma74 8 months ago 2
I love how people try to headbang to DT songs!!!
I mean,isn't that easy,they're changing the time signature almost ten times at minute.
jereibanez 8 months ago
Not bad for a song about AIDS craze of the 80's and 90's.
borikualoco 8 months ago
Second DT song I ever heard, this "eargasm" was better than the first.
borikualoco 8 months ago
7:54 - 8:25
10:38 - 10:52
Two of the most amazing riffs ever.
DTkeysplayer16 8 months ago
Does anyone know what time signature this is in?
ConorITC 8 months ago
@ConorITC Lol...time signatures change, but the intro is 15/8.
Megadedly 8 months ago
7:12 to 7:45, best feeling ever
ThalesBrazil 8 months ago
'silent man' should write more lyrics..this one is just fuckin EPIC..as this piece itself !
mariuszBORISboruta 8 months ago 2
11:25 - great song farewell !
matkokvesic 8 months ago
Written by John Myung !!!! the ace !
uncinghiale 8 months ago 32
@uncinghiale
John Myung wrote this whole song ?!?!?!
Brutalyeah 3 months ago
@Brutalyeah yes :)
uncinghiale 3 months ago
@uncinghiale
Respect increased.
I first thought Steve DiGiorgio was the best bassist but this fellow is definatly right on par ^^.
Brutalyeah 3 months ago
@uncinghiale
Just learned the first 55 secs of this song on bass... pretty fucking hard <_<
Brutalyeah 3 months ago
@Brutalyeah unluckily for you this is one of the easier DT's songs on bass, try dance of eternity :D
uncinghiale 3 months ago
@uncinghiale
I know I know ^^
I can only do gallops lol, if I have to do a constant speed I need plectrum XD. Still learning ^^
You also know Steve DiGiorgio?
Brutalyeah 3 months ago
@Brutalyeah yes I really like death's basslines, also them are difficult to learn but are precious !
The thing that make great these bassists, is not only technic but also passion, and you can feel it !
uncinghiale 3 months ago
@uncinghiale
Exactly. :)
You know any other band like Death and DT that have such amazing songwriting and basslines?
Brutalyeah 3 months ago
1:18 el sonido del bajo en esa parte es poderoso , contundente joder ...
Sirist10 8 months ago
Jon Petrucci is GOD!!!!!!!!!
Depalma74 8 months ago
What the hell can you say about this song besides, it's the shit
squeak145 8 months ago
Is it me, or is the Waits for Sleep reprise just pure ecstacy? This has just been elected my favorite song ever. Seriously, I could sing along with the ending for days...
superhomsar2112 8 months ago
Ganz ganz großartige Band. Great Band. Auf ihren Konzerten habe ich so viel empfunden wie noch fast nie in meinem Leben. Never felt so intensive like on concerts from dream theater. Hope to see them soon again live on stage!!!
Depalma74 8 months ago
i love how jordan makes the solo his, but then is like, BAM! and then theres kevin's
HunterKolb 9 months ago
meskipun lagu lawas..tetapi enak didengar setiap waktu...i love'it...
SuperBamsbams 9 months ago
6:11 - He's like "That's right, you'll never be able to write a guitar solo as good as that!"
EquinoxParadox91 9 months ago
Não tem pra esses caras,
são deuses.
Dream Theater, eu os idolatro.
oficialreinaldoneves 9 months ago
I'm thinking he might want to change one line of the song "The 90s bring new questions" The 90s are long over now.
HelloFade2 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I could stay all the eternity hearing this song...
oficialreinaldoneves 9 months ago
I could stay all the eternety hearing this song...
oficialreinaldoneves 9 months ago
hahah they sound all tired from playing this gig.
goblinondrums 9 months ago
@goblinondrums Wikipedia has the show at 190:00 .. which is over three hours long, thats a long concert for one band. MP passed out afterwards from all the drumming. So good observation!
Bishoblivion 8 months ago
You know whats funny? everyone that i know that grew up with rush actually prefers DT over them after I introduce these early albums. DT is so much more diverse and there musical abilities surpass all others. plus MP drumming on this album is un-comparable. Anyone can cover a rush song, but no one can run through this song in one go and have it near 100%. Its insanely tricky but good, it almost seems effortless.
FanaticDrummer 9 months ago 2
Which DVD is this?
pauturvalles 9 months ago
@pauturvalles Metropolis 2000: Scenes From New York I think it is
zonic26 9 months ago
John Pettruci looks kind of like Dave Grohl
HelloFade2 9 months ago
I Want to know WHO voted "THUMB DOWN" to this video!!!!
yesoppazz 9 months ago
@yesoppazz someone who´s learning to live.
Quinterocornejo 9 months ago
The extended solo around 9:30 is probably my favourite piece of music ever written.
timmily 9 months ago
@timmily Yeah I've noticed that bit is the same part as Wait For Sleep and that part at 11:40 sounds a lot like Pull Me Under
zonic26 9 months ago
this song is just so complete there's nothing else in this song i would change and i'm sure everyone thinks the same
JL199598 9 months ago
awesome,great¡¡¡
best band
emrock16 9 months ago
i was waiting for the F#.... =(
JaciX666 9 months ago
I hear this song then me thinking.....early DT much better.
FJSP 9 months ago
All those bastards who say that petrucci has no feel have obviously never listened to this song :P
DemonEyesDara 9 months ago
it took me a while to realize how good this song was
beastguitaist 9 months ago
I love John Petrucci...
wiiman250 10 months ago
Justin Bieber disliked this video because he can't match labrie's vocal range
gozac123 10 months ago 3
@gozac123 no helen kellers sense of hearing was healed and she tried to like it but still couldnt see so accidentally disliked
beastguitaist 9 months ago
quien es el pelotudo qe no le gusta este video ?
juanu14399 10 months ago
This song is written by John Myung and Dream Theater's best epic (from my opinion). It's a pity that John Myung never wrote a song for Dream Theater again after "Fatal Tragedy". His song always be my favorite.
audrian88 10 months ago
@audrian88 Its because Petrucci and Portnoy kept having to change Myungs songs to suit them, and basically changed the entire song :(
Meph761 9 months ago
this is the only video when every guy is filmed equally!
challengeleo 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
lol....the way LaBrie looks Portnoy at 13:11 like saying....hey!! you don't wait me for the EPIC close!!! hahahahahahahahahahaha
fdiaz4 10 months ago
lol....the way LaBrie looks Portnoy at 13:11 like saying....hey!! you don't wait me for the EPIC close!!! hahahahahahahahahahaha
fdiaz4 10 months ago
I think this is the only Dream official DVD where you can HEAR the bass.
MrMrEFE 10 months ago 2
maybe the best song ever recorded, i'm going to miss MP behind the kit
stevehaigh2112 10 months ago 45
@stevehaigh2112 No one can replace what MP brought to the table, but MM sure does make me feel good about the band's future.
fingerboy18 8 months ago
Even though LaBrie didn't go for the F#5, he did an incredible job on this.
XxboVodxX 10 months ago 4
Ma che sound ha Petrucci qui!!!Me sento male
Gtrgym 10 months ago
It's just magical how it kicks back in into the song after Jordan's solo. ♥
x8xOneWingedAngelx8x 10 months ago
This one beats the studio and earlier live version by lightyears! It's epic how (on the ONCE IN A LIFETIME album) fades into The Crimson Sunset. Has been giving me the goosebumps for 14 years now. And going strong.
irelandexplorer 10 months ago
Did someone watch it from the top ten list? "Top Ten Dream Theater Songs" What do you think?
jpdelamiche 10 months ago
This whole album is epic. I love DT and always have since the 90-'s but there is something about this album that will always be #1 in my heart
guitarplyer27 10 months ago
La mejor cancion de Dream Theaterr...
TheUniversomerodea 10 months ago
1 person is gonna die in 5 minutes
eliceus 11 months ago 3
@eliceus Maybe cross-eyed? Drunk? On acid? Missed the Thumbs-Up by accident? There can't be any other explanation!
irelandexplorer 10 months ago
WTF??? jordan rudess with hair??
u2nthevines 11 months ago
@u2nthevines another born-yesterday DT fan! hahahaha. no ofense, man : D
felipeadroc 11 months ago 2
@felipeadroc LMFAO! that was funny!
just4thelolz 11 months ago
lol 4:48 XD
rsyyjh4n6r7xtygb45bt 11 months ago
is he gonna do it?? is he going to hit the F#??? *biting nails* awwwwwww.........
nietjob 11 months ago 38
@nietjob This would be by far DT's best DVD if JLB had a better night.
Golem29 11 months ago
@nietjob Cut the man some slack, dude :-) This is at the end of a very long concert. You won't meet an awful lot of singers who can still hold a tune that well after more than 90 minutes of screaming their guts out!
irelandexplorer 10 months ago 3
@irelandexplorer oh i think the man is an awesome singer but those where the words that came through my mind during the particular moment
nietjob 10 months ago
@nietjob Hah! I bet he broke his voice simply recording that note for the album, and was never able to do it again....
uberdawg 9 months ago
Comment removed
czeslawkl 9 months ago
@uberdawg are you sure?
/watch?v=nTzlEadGeTo&feature=related check it out. after watching this go and don't sin any more..
czeslawkl 9 months ago
@nietjob I believe this version was actually better than some of his live attempts to hit the F#.
zepedrorock 8 months ago
Who was the fucking asshole that doesn't like this masterpiece?
rruizjl 11 months ago
Why do people compare Porcupine Tree to Dream Theater? There not even technically close. Mike is so technically fluent on this album, And this song is one of those songs that no one dares to cover on youtube. Gavin is technical, But his playing is predictable. Its too dry and stale, And his sound has alot to do with it. Theres not one song they play that can rival this masterpiece. I mean come on, This is a complete mindfuck for drummers!..
FanaticDrummer 11 months ago
@FanaticDrummer Gavin = jazz drummer. Mike = prog metal drummer. I personally love both of them, and I agree that they're different, but I <3 Gavin.
lalakekela 9 months ago
I don't listen to DT much anymore but this song still amazes me. Great musically and lyrically. Myung wrote the best words... sure beats Mike Portnoy's juvenile drivel from Train of Thought.
CallistoAshus 11 months ago
8:32 Chocolate rain
TheHornet79 11 months ago
WOAHH OHH OHH WOAH OH OHHHH! WOAH OH OHHHHHHHHHHHHH!
Langtw 11 months ago 6
All hail...
Sirhc161 1 year ago
You know a fourteen minute song is good when it makes you feel like its five minutes.
markmanchico 1 year ago 2
My thoughts at 7:17
AWWWW!!!! He wussed out!!!
cliffordodelljones2 1 year ago
Rudes is amazing;d
1234shayia 1 year ago 2
I wouldve love to have gone and been in that concert during this song but at least here i can, RAPE THE REPLAY BUTTON!!!
ferrari0243 1 year ago 2
@ferrari0243 Hahahaha, you're so right!!!!! :D
IsraelSilvaMonje 1 year ago
I wouldve love to have gone and been in that concert during this gone but at least here i can, RAPE THE REPLAY BUTTON!!!
ferrari0243 1 year ago
anyone knows what chords use in the reggea section??
DANGILBERT03 1 year ago
@DANGILBERT03
Am Bm7 Em C
baronser 1 year ago
@baronser im doubt with you men, thanks!!!!!
DANGILBERT03 1 year ago
There is ONE GUY that doesn't hit the F# ¬¬
x8xOneWingedAngelx8x 1 year ago