Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (131)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Good job guys Im a huge Smiths & coheed fan. Your take on the song is great.

  • I love the original of this but just the way Claudio sings it gives me chills

  • completely ruined the song

  • @JulianosKahlonos You need to shut your whore mouth.

  • YOU DIRTY BASTARDS..IF IT AINT BROKE DONT BREAK IT!

  • Oh dear,.. 

  • Day:23  I'm begining to run out of supplies and I have yet to find AviatorAndyK's commnet.... i'm starting to wonder if I will ever find it....

  • @playdoughcannon Control+F, my son.

  • Very nice. It's really hard to do a Smiths song justice and Coheed did it.

  • i love thiiiiiiiiiiiiis.

  • THIS SHIT SUCKS SO MUCH

  • @Guru57577 Says the guy with Kid Cudi in his favorites, troll harder bro.

  • @Guru57577 YOU SUCK SO MUCH

  • Having never heard of The Smiths or this song before i'm an immediate fan. Sanchez is a real gem in the music world. Amazing.

  • this sounds wonderful,if u dont like it DONT WATCH IT,duh...but if u want to go ahead,ur only making the views larger :P

  • this is blasphemy

  • they are playing only using their minds!

  • Any clue on how a person can get the audio for this song?!?!?

    This cover is EPIC and I would love to be able to have it in my music collection

  • @weise1717 I'm sure you've got it now, but if not you can download a youtube downloader and it will let you convert the track to mp3

  • Pretty good cover, I think that it doesn't have some of the mystique and charm that the original has. It's really hard to cover Smith songs as it's really hard to capture the qualities that make the originals so great. Big props to these guys for paying tribute though.

  • at least they are into some good music.....

  • two great, original bands

  • coheed can make any song sound incredible!

  • at least they've made the song sound there own. good on them!

  • NO!

  • Gaaaah...

    My boner has a boner.

  • AV Club is a bunch of snobbish hipsters anyway.

  • This is so terrible I can't even articulate my anger properly

  • @Staniel420 I hope you choke on your saliva. I love The Smiths, but this version absolutely annihilates it.

  • @RandomJackOfDoom The Smiths are great, Coheed is better.

  • @superstriker00 HAH HAH of course they aren't. The Smiths are revered, remembered and touched so many people. Coheed won't be. They just aren't on the same level. lol. On the video, his voice doesn't suit the song I don't think. Expected better.

  • @TheModCon I'm sorry, but Coheed is one of the most influential rock bands at the moment. They've been at it for 16 years. Also, I stated my personal opinion. I prefer Claudio Sanchez so Morissey. What the fuck does it matter to you if my opinion is different? IT. IS. AN. OPINION. Get out of here, you're not superior because you like The Smiths more than Coheed. I'm not superior because I like Coheed more than The Smiths. In fact, I love them both equally. Now go be butthurt somewhere else.

  • @superstriker00 Um, sure. Being around for 16 years doesn't make influential and/or good mate (I do like them btw) Yes, you stated your opinion, but guess what idiot, I stated mine too! I also have opinions, AND just as much right to state them on youtube. Don't like it? Fuck off my internets quite frankly. >>Implying I think Im superior >>Implying Im butthurt. Paradox there mate CS > Mozza but love them both equally. Doesn't make sense. LAWL.

  • @TheModCon The bands are equal in my opinion, but Claudio is certainly a better musician. I prefer his solo work to Morissey. Also, clearly you are nothing more than a troll, so really, find somebody else.

  • @superstriker00 You can't really say certainly about something purely subjective no? Obviously don't know what a troll is -.-

  • @TheModCon Dude shut up. Coheed is better. Their jazz influences have surpassed the level of semi-rock tones that the Smiths created. And also you are acting super butt hurt, so shut up. Your just some douche who dosent listen to anyone, so fuck off my internets quite frankly. Peace hater haha.

  • @11792627 Oh, so jazz influence > better and more meaningful music? And anyway, standing on the shoulders of giants. Just because something has progressed, doesn't mean what it stood on to progress isn't as good or redundant. You know it's "you're" and "doesn't" don't you? No, ofcourse you don't -.- Lawl someone doesn't know what butthurt is. People being ridiculous and me saying so doesn't make me butthurt. Better how? Moz touched generations. C&C have....... Welcome Home haha. lol@joo sir. ^^

  • @TheModCon Dude your a retard. If you knew anything about music you would just shut your prissy know it all ass up. If only the world where full of people like you. That way when i run someones ass over with my fucking car i know im ridding the world of... well..... and asshole like you. So shove off bitch and go somewhere where i dont have to listen to your idiot ass talk.

  • @11792627 Hah hah it's nice to see that ignored all my points, and just went to insulting. Sounding intensely butthurt to me bro. I'm not being know it all, I'm pointing out obvious points, and the fact that you can't accept them, and are deluded to think C&C are some god band that will be remembered in 30 years, doesn't make me a retard, or a know it all. The fact is cunt, you would do shit in RL, acting tough on the internetz just makes you look like a pussy. Hah hah C&C fans are lolz.

  • Oh, and I'm laughing at the irony of you calling ME a retard, with your various spelling and grammatical errors throughout our conversation. Lawl.

  • @TheModCon Your so gay. Haha at least i have the satisfaction of knowing your only form of trying to gain some satisfaction is by bitching about grammer. Just shut up and go somewhere where you wont piss anyone off will you.

  • @11792627 Totally wrong, I gain satisfaction from my satisfying life. And also laughing at ignorant, retarded, deluded people such as yourself. I'll stay here as long as I want to, cause it seems you're just gonna keep on talkin'. At least I have the satisfaction of knowing, you can't actually discuss a point in a manner that doesn't result to insults and bitchass whinin' when someone puts across their point in a coherent manner, and that it destroys your childish delusion.

  • @TheModCon Really?? Because you started this whole thing with someone else, saying that the Coheed cover is bad. I never said the Smiths were bad. I only said that i think that Coheed uses more musical influences and thats why i think they are better. Than you had to bitch about how Coheed is shit. Well guess what they arent, people like you are the ignorant ones. I dont believe that there is any bad music. Just music, but im done with this, your probably just some kid who im wasting my time on.

  • @11792627 Yes really. The fact I started discussing it with someone else doesn't change it. Also, I didn't say it was bad, I said in my first comment, that C&C are no way on the same level as The Smiths, and that the cover wasn't to my taste. Where did I say C&C were bad? I just said The Smiths were better. You've been reading shit that I didn't type kiddo. Hah hah I'm not ignorant, and I also do not think there is bad music. Im the kid? Yes, shit spelling and swearing at me, but I'm the kid.Lol

  • @TheModCon Thank god damn god! a smart person.

  • @11792627

    I second this. No such thing as bad music. : >

    

  • @littledeadybear Right. Thats all i wanted to say. Music is music, there is nothing else to say.

  • @TheModCon

    I have to disagree. This version is more emotional, to me. I think Claudio's voice holds the capacity to express so much, even past his artistic phrasing of words. CoCa has forever touched my life, and near anyone else that I've introduced his music to have agreed that they're something special--even if not they're type of music. Go see a LIVE recording of The Light & The Glass, or In Keeping Secrets of Live Earth--The crowd's reaction is enough to bring tears to your eyes.

  • ...they´re pretty talented I think - but I still prefer the original....by far....just my two cents....

  • That cover... destroys the spirit of the original.

  • Love ur rendition of one of my favorite song's, you are awsum Coheed

  • this is a fucking joke....shit cover.

  • @AviatorAndyK Your existence is a joke.

  • @AviatorAndyK

    Urgggh!! I disagree with your opinion in musical taste! Raaawwwr!

    I don't know, I dig this cover. As a fan of The Smiths and Coheed, I think this is pretty good.

    Raaawwwr!

  • @AviatorAndyK Your existence is a joke.

  • Whoa this was posted on my birthday. lol.

  • @Utheused4 Whoa!

  • @Utheused4 I have most of the Starland Ballroom uploaded on mine ^_^ SongsOfShipwreck's uploads I think? I was so pleased! :D

  • Dap dap dap dada dap dap dada....

  • Coheed>The Smiths

  • not a bad cover, gotta rock the smiths version tho

  • @catsdontshave the smiths suck dick and so do you

  • What a great cover, thank you for this interpretation of the song

  • @catsdontshave Gahh.. This would be okay to listen to in an isolated room but trute, it would be ineffectual when compared with the original.

    This wasn't that bad. The vocal stylings at the end worked a treat.

  • @catsdontshave explain yourself... how is it a "mother fucking abomination"?

  • @catsdontshave lmao, you have no knowledge of what real music is.  This version is more haunting, melodic, it has better vocals and doesn't sound cheesy like the original. This version is so brooding and great.

  • @DemonInJerseyCity you're a fucking idiot. that is all I can say.

  • @FRANMAN1979 You just proved to me that I'm right. You're response to something serious I was trying to say (like the fact that this version is more melodic, which is a fact) was "you're a fucking idiot."

    I love irony.

  • @catsdontshave It's good to know the English language before you try insulting others.

    1.motherfucking is one word

    2. it's spelled "douchebag"

    3.apostrophes denote ownership, so "morrisey's shoes"

    4.on that note, proper nouns are capitalized.

    5. Commas. Use them.

  • Comment removed

  • @thumby1212 FUCK YOU AND FUCK THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE ITS THE INTERNET AS LONG AS YOU GET THE POINT ACROSS WHO THE FUCK CARES MORON. Fuk yu hows this gramr moron. wow your so smart cus u can bring up grammar on the internet where it doesnt matter. do you tell people who send you a text theyre spelling it wrong when they say u and not you? gtfo youtube btw you didnt capitalize the first letter of those sentences so gfu hypocrite

  • @GoodApolloIV23

    1. ITS should be IT'S

    2. hows should be how's

    3. your should be you're

    4. doesnt should be doesn't

    5. theyre should be they're

    6. You are an inbred backwater retard who will never succeed in anything and don't deserve the computer that you type on. Your friends make fun of you behind your back and you are not sexually satisfying. Your breath is stinky and your weight is out of control. Your existence fills me with disgust and I hope that you are hit in the head with a lava lamp.

  • @thumby12 ill stop you there before you get nasty.

  • @MELiddy1 It's a good thing that you stopped me, or I might have posted a negative comment! You're truly a paladin of internet justice, MELiddy. Your selfless actions have made the world a better place and I'm glad that your sperm cell was the mightiest of your father's litter.

  • @catsdontshave Thank You

  • I wish more of Coheed's acoustic tracks were this raw, Claudio layers his vocals way too much on most of them.

  • @fallforthesky11 Agreed. This is why I would love to hear more of Coheed's music accoustic. Don't get me wrong, I adore their music, but to hear just Claudio's voice completely unfettered....it's angellic.

  • the smiths are awsum!

  • I only just checked out the original song, and I'd say the original is better, but now I know how well done this is.

  • I am a massive Smiths fan, and having heard covers of them by other bands i started watching this with very low expectations, however, this was actually one of the best covers i've heard. Well done Coheed and Cambria.

  • @MsGeebus :D your comment just made my day, very well said. I am a huge coheed fan myself and I was glad to see that you took them into consideration instead of just bashing them because they are a very talented band. good comment :D

  • @sabian1312 aw well i'm glad i could raise a smile :) i hate it when people get into slagging matches over which band is better than which, especially if a song's done in different styles.

    what matters is the quality of the cover, and in this case it's good :D

  • beautifully executed

  • This cover was so amazing. I cannot believe all the haters on the comments page at their site. -_-

  • my best mate is a massive Smiths fan and A Huge Coheed Fan, man he's gunna shit the bed when i show him this. Great cover

  • Coheed killed this, i like it better then the original

  • @jaco88laze claudio is godly. i love the acoustic stuff they do :)

  • great! 

  • This is by far the most beautiful thing I've heard in a very long time. I can't stop coming back to this to chill and relax. An unearthly high feeling.

  • I usually hate Smiths covers but i really like this :)

    Nothing on Moz of course

    Well done C&C

  • From the AV Club wall thing:

    "I find it funny that everyone is ragging on C&C for being nerds, when the name of the site is AV Club...

    NERDS!!!"

    ^nice

  • @j1goreczny XD

  • Comment removed

  • the smiths version is better.

  • @ljwifey Considering Its A Smiths Cover And The Original Is Always Better. I Would Say So. But Its Still A Good Cover, Broadway Calls Does A Good Cover Of This Song Also.

  • @ljwifey Probably if you're a Smiths fan...

  • this cover misses the point whereas broadway calls' version totally hits the mark.

  • I cannot stop listening to this song

  • BLASPHEMERS

  • Soooo good.. I love Coheed sooo much!

  • His voice is so like pristine in this video. I swear he could tell me my Mom died and as long as he was singing it I'd enjoy it

  • Comment removed

  • CAN SOMEONE LINK ME TO THE MP3 DOWNLOAD?

  • @MsLeadingg there isn't one atm, just get a youtube audio converter or something.

  • @MsLeadingg Try using mediaconverter . org. It converts videos from many sites. You can convert it to any format one may possibly use regularly.

    Enjoy the pristine masterpiece.

  • @MsLeadingg Just copy the url from this video and paste it in the box. and A Rush and a Push and the Mp3 is yOURS

  • @MsLeadingg Ugh, it wouldn't let me comment the link. but it's just video2mp3

  • Tab is up on ultimate guitar.

  • Woah..

  • It Sounds like he's saying homie

  • No problem guys. :)

    As for tabs, I believe one of the guys over on Cobalt & Calcium is working on one at the moment.

  • wow, amazing

  • tab anyone? i must play this

  • Amazing. Eat your heart out hipsters, Coheed is here to stay.

  • Whoohoo!!! Thanks for finally uploading this!!! One of their best covers!! :)

  • God, Claudio's voice in this song is absolutely angelic.

    That man is a fucking beast.

    Thanks for posting. I was going to, myself, but after seeing you already have I have no reason to. I was getting tired of using that fucking AV bullshit. x_x

  • @GodsentHellraiser Not only is the website broke as fuck, they are totally pretentious over there. They're allowed to have opinions on music, but to openly bash bands like they do over there without any real reserve for anyone that might like them, bashing Claudio's appearance, and his voice, is totally disrespectful to not only them, but us as fans. Musical elitism at it's finest, I could careless if AVClub and the Encyclopedia Metallum closed down. Fuck them and their elitist bullshit.

  • @shreddybits Couldn't have said it better myself.

  • @GodsentHellraiser I Completely Agree. I Have A Wide Variety Or Music That I Listen To And Coheed Being My Favorite. Im Sure I Have Tastes That None Of You Share, But i Have Respect For All Sorts Of Genres As Im Sure You Do Too. But Those Dicks Are Just A Bunch Of Hipsters Trying Make It A Point That Everyone Knows They Listen To Indy Bands And Not Mainstream. Totally Pretentious To Quote Shreddybits. Fuck'm

  • Anyone read the comments under the source video?

    What a bunch of fucktards. Seriously, AVClub's followers are nothing more than a bunch of snobby and pretentious music elitists, who think because they like Radiohead and listen to bands that aren't signed to major labels that they are some how ahead of the edge and their taste in music is superior to other peoples.

  • @shreddybits I Completely Agree. They Need To Just Fucking Die. I Cant Even Believe They Compared Them To Nickelback And Creed. No Taste Whatsoever. But I Guess Thats What Happens When You Give A Redneck A Computer.

  • @shreddybits I never knew that, maybe you are right. This song does ring of it. That sense. Bollocks I heard this when I was 16.

  • @shreddybits Thus they are hipsters. Gotta love the jet song "One hipster one Bullet" haha.

  • godlike

  • Amazing...Claudio is God.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more