Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,215)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Love this song why doesnt she put it in one of her albums anyways!! Its an amazing song!!!

  • It was just too good for the movie.

  • parts of me wanted Jake and Bella to be together. but then i read the leaked "midnight sun' (which is on Stephenie Meyer's website) and i fell in love with Edward even more! so now I'm just lost lol.

  • If you are big fan of Twilight you should take a look at Twilight Eclipse at OnEclipse(.)info  I can`t stop thinking about this movie

  • I just saw new Twilight eclipse movie at EclipseGet(.)info Its pretty awesome xD

  • PUTAA!

  • Empty As I Am is finded on youtube search.

    Kelly Clarkson Emtpy As I Am one of them are the real song this is did you not empty as i am.

    She sang Empty As I Am on all i ever wanted tour on the last US tour she had.

    Now she is going to have a europe tour touring a few days in europe countries and then she will most likely release her 5th album she said she has been working on it during her All i ever wanted tour and they are already recording it so it's ready soon :)

  • i love the song

  • I like this song, i want to download it but can't find anywhere to do so...

  • i wish this song had been on the "new moon" soundtrack. it's a great song.

  • I don't know why they didn't use this or Empty as I Am (or even "Haunted"). They're much better songs than half of the crap that made it onto the New Moon Soundtrack.

  • but I like the song!!!!

  • This was not on the soundtrack....

  • THIS IS NOT IN THE MOVIE

  • this song reminds me of damon & caroline from the vampire diaries in way...

    but love this song :D

  • I wish her all I ever wanted album had songs like this. I think haunted would of been better for new moon. I really like the books when I heard there was a movie coming out I got excited, but the movies were ok.

  • this song wasn't for the new moon soundtrack o.o it was a song that didn't make it onto the My December album. The song she wrote about New Moon was Empty as I am. Idiots. o.o

  • this one is did you , not empty as i am ...

  • man wish I could have this on my ipod

  • This song is called 'Did You'.

    'Empty As I Am' is beautiful :)

  • THis is one of her best songs!

    Really!

    Awesome!:)

  • LOVE TWILIGHT AND LOVE THIS SONG

  • For the best love songs that go perfectly with The Twilight Saga check out "Winter Air" and "This is Love" by the band Annasay. on itunes and youtube

  • well i gotta say that the german song for it is much better its called "es tut wieder weh" by Jennifer Rostock you should listen to it! it's soooo awesome! <3

  • this song never made it on the soundtrack?

  • 1. Hello Kitty is not childish it's fashion!

    2. WTH it doesn't matter if it's not in the movie it's a beautifull song.

    3.Kelly Clarkson is the best :'D

  • ew.

    this isnt my type of music.

    and sorry, i dont think this is in the movie.

    tell me if im wrong though.

    i wasnt really paying attention to the music.

  • @jacquicullen111 you sucks motherfucker, kelly clarkson is the best.

  • NOT IN THE MOVIE

  • they did that with decode in twilight

  • i love this song, kelly is awesome!

    dunno if it really fits bella though..

  • this song ish awesome it totelly fits bella's feelings new moon was brillent i did like the frist one but they missed out so many things so new moon was fantasic!!

  • I love it :D

  • this was posted on my b-day lol!

  • your birthday is on cinco de mayo? thats sick!! lol

  • äh, no thats the date he loaded this song up.

  • he/she said "this was POSTED on my birthday" idiot

  • No. Idiots cant say cinco de mayo in English ;) And Youtube sucks because it wasnt obvious that your post was a answer to twilightmadness.

  • interesting how racist and unkind an Italian (or wherever you from) can be to a modern non-nazi german.^^

  • Ignore the moron. The rest of us will. Some italian village is missing it's idiot. LOL...

  • i hate how people think this is called Empty As I Am. This songs called 'Did You'

    ;D

  • heey hellokitty7654321 we give a flying fuck!!!! dumb bitch you grow upp!!!!!

  • vampires and wolves are not that childish stuffs compare to hello kity..

  • Twilight's Soundtrack was way better than this one!

  • ) - Alexandre Desplat1. Meet Me On The Equinox - Death Cab For Cutie

    2. Friends - Band Of Skulls

    3. Hearing Damage - Thom Yorke

    4. Possibility - Lykke Li

    5. A White Demon Love Song - The Killers

    6. Satellite Heart - Anya Marina

    7. I Belong To You (New Moon Remix) - Muse

    8. Rosyln - Bon Iver & St. Vincent

    9. Done All Wrong - Black Rebel Motorcycle Club

  • are that the soundtracks from the movie ?

  • love Kelly's voice!

    But unfortunately, this song isnt be on NM Soundtrack...

    5 *

  • I like it but i think it's too rocky for how bella felt when edward left her. I LOVE TWILIGHT!!!!!!

  • it's a great song but it's not intense enough for how bella feels when edward leaves her..

  • i know just how bella feels...

  • i really wish this was on the album!

  • I'm so upset she didn't make it on the soundtrack for New Moon, I bought the soundtrack and some of the songs didn't fit anywhere near as well as this does.

  • i liked haunted .

    i think it fits for the movie better.

  • they should use flyleaf or whithin temptation for the next movie commin

  • I agree with you on that one!!! lol

  • This song fits the story of New Moon better than any song on the current New Moon soundtrack, but because Kelly herself does not fit the image they wanted for New Moon, this song is not there. The Twilight series soundtracks are not at all about the lyrics -- they are all about the image of the singers. Please give me the name of one song on either the Twilight or the New Moon soundtrack that fits the movie better than KC's Addicted (for Twilight) or KC's Did You or Haunted (for New Moon).

  • this isn't it...

  • Comment removed

  • new moon song arent even that good as the movies looks

  • which album does this song come from?

  • It's not on any of her albums so far, but she is currently working on a new album so who knows.

  • i like this song except i doesnt really match the theme of the movie or the plot a bit.

  • Shes A great singer but this shouldent be on the movie.......11/22/09

  • the movie comes out 11/20/09

  • 11/18/09 <3

  • i know im so exicted i cant wait

  • i just bought the soundtrack and am highly disappointed with all the songs. i feel like i wasted 14 bucks little more than mad

  • this isnt on it

  • It not on there

  • She doesnt fit in there.

    And I also think this song isnt sad enough at all.

    I hope this will not be on the soundtrack list!! Oo

  • I love Kelly Clarkson and this song would've been awesome for new moon. I think her song 'Haunted' to be better suited for the movie though

  • Pls don't use that damn Did You song,I didn't like that!lol!!!

  • it was a contender. they were gonna use it but didn't

  • shes def. not on the album. This is false.

  • gostei muito

  • I did not no that kelly clarkson was in the cd

  • its an awesome song

    kelly good job

  • what z that cap song

  • this song really fits new moon..paramores music might not b in new moon because they didnt want to bt keely Clarkson is a good singer to..i like the beat tho..u go kelly

  • oh no she didnt hum um

    its not on da cd

  • can someone pleasssssssssse messege me and tell me why this song is not on itunes or if it is where I can find it? I would really appreciate it. Thank you!!!!

  • limewire

  • support kelly and buy her amazing new album ' all i ever wanted :)

  • Comment removed

  • isnt this song called did you?

  • This would've been a good song on the soundtrack. But people if you call it bullshit prove it.

    I dont think its on the playlist at itunes

  • this isnt on the soundtrack.

    this doesnt fit perfectly with the book

    because this isnt the track she wrote for it.

    the trak for new moon is called

    "empty as i am".

  • NOT ON THE SOUNDTRACK!!!!!!!! Good song that fits, but it's not on the soundtrack!!!!!!!!!

  • i dont think this song goes with the book

    a lot but it pretty good it's funny cuz i read all the books a long ass time ago but i've also been loving paramore since a long asss time ago so im not like the followers of twilight that now follow paramore, who only really read the twilight books because people are talking about it so much!!

  • TBH this ain't on the soundtrack! But some of the lyrics make sense to the book...In a way...

  • Paramore are WAY Better!

    The song is nothing like New Moon<3

    She shoulda read the book first and if she did then I don't know how she came up with a song like that?!

  • I like paramore too, but she came out with the song before new moon, just like in the first soundtrack, Muse was already written

  • Comment removed

  • obiously that song goes with new moon I read all 4 books and yes It goes with it. ! and is a beautiful song

  • NO she isn't on the soundtrack!

  • i dont think the song goes with new moon

  • ssssuuupppeerrr i love kelly but also PARAMORE

    xx

  • this isnt Empty As I Am

  • not on there!!!! lolz but i do like the song  =]

  • I Heard That Kelly Isnt Gonna BE On The Soundtrack AT All! : [[

  • she is not on the soundtrack!!! it totally sucks this song would have been good!!!!!! i didnt make it up either they have the confirmed soundtrack on itunes

  • this is on the soundtrack

  • Kelly is mainstream... anyone who plays on popular radio sations is mainstream. That is what mainstream is. Not that i am saying its a bad ting cuz i like kelly clarkson too but she is mainstream.....

  • this song isn't going to be on the new moon soundtrack, they've released a copy of the song that are and it's not on there!

  • this isnt on the offical list lol

  • in*

  • I think 'cry' by kelly clarkson fits better to new moon :)

  • till 0:17 fits in new moon

    the rest not really :I

  • "They couldv'e pick the Veronicas, Katy Perry ^^

    But Kelly and Paramore are both gooooood xD"

  • I'd rather have PARAMORE!!! I like the song but the pitches are way off!!

  • I KNOW LIFE SUCKS I WANT PARAMORE

  • This song sucks it has so many different pitchs that she sings its a mess......why would they change paramore i think there song fit the movie better....

    it sucks

  • They offered Paramore a New Moon soundtrack deal, but they declined. They said they didn't want to be known as the 'Twilight band'

    I, personally, think they made a wonderful choice by declining. ^^

  • That was... pretty awful.

  • woww this is so boring

    its not big and powerful like decode!

    this is shit

  • ummm i likee thee song but , it seems like " just like me , & all i wanted " by paramore should havee been on the soundtrack but i still love kelly clarkson !

  • WOW IT DOES FIT NEW MOON!!

  • I really like Kelly Clarkson - but this song really doesn't fit New Moon))

    they would rather have taken Need - by Hana Pestle. Too bad - but well it isn't our decision!

  • this song doesn't fit New Moon

  • wtf the beat to this song is way to cheery & fast past. I hope it's not played too much during the movie.

  • I lovee Kelly Clarkson but i think i would rather Paramore do this song THEY ARE AUSUM !!!!

  • aaaw. this is too new moon like

    like i love twilight and decode was amaizing song. But this O.o

  • I like the song and i think the lyrics fit new moon perfectly, i mean what bella is thinking after edward has left is exactly what this sing is saying.

  • I think decode is sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­ooooooooooooooooooooooooooo much better than this one!!

    I'm sorry for her cuz I like her music but this is soooo boring!!!

  • hmm.. i don't think it fits new moon. O_O

  • Yeah it's not really her best song, but it's still enjoyable. Twlight isn't really worthy of a Kelly Clarkson #1. I mean come on...let's be honest.

  • no no no not another muse song, and not i belong to you... thats like the best song of the album

  • i dont like this one! If they were going to do kelly song i like the new one that just came out saying were not right for eatchother so she moved on- not sure of the name but i really liked it.. I love kelly songs but this one was really boring

  • yeah too bad she's not actually on the list... the real list is too good for this stupid song

  • Worst of her songs.

  • i wish this song was used

  • This song is NOT on the soundtrack--she confirmed that it is not!!!! She wrote this song based on the "NEW MOON Movie" because she's such a huge fan of the books. She wrote this song, with her back up singers--before they even knew there would be a new moon movie!! She leaked it for the fans to have...don't worry all that are worried about this song being on the soundtrack, because she said from her own mouth...that it IS NOT ON THE SOUNDTRACK!!!

  • yeah its called as empty as i am something like that

  • Yes...I thought I said that...LOL!! =) my bad!! <333 Song Called: Empty as I am

  • I think if they do put any of her songs on there they should use Haunted like for real cause that sin amazingly fits New Moon! And if you hae neer heard it you should totally check it ou!

  • I just looked on the list for the REAL New Moon Soundtrack and she's not on it.

  • were is the list... I want it please!?

  • ~Death Cab For Cutie - Meet Me On The Equinox ~Band Of Skulls - Friends ~Thom Yorke - Hearing Damage ~Lykke Li - Possibility ~The Killers - A White Demon Love Song ~Anya Marina - Satellite Heart ~Muse - I Belong To You (New Moon) ~Bon Iver and St. Vincent - Rosyln ~Black Rebel Motorcycle Club - Done All Wrong ~Hurricane Bells - Monsters ~Sea Wolf - The Violet Hour ~OK Go - Shooting The Moon ~Grizzly Bear - Slow Life ~Editors - No Sound But The Wind ~Alexandre Desplat - New Moon (The Meadow)
  • the soundtrack...but dont ask me anything!!i got it from someone else!lol....

  • i absolutly hate this. bring back the ALT!

  • Errr.. No ._.

  • I can't imagine Kelly's voice in the movie soundtrack...

  • they chose songs that have are so opposite of the movie. its aweful

    its not a drama, its about a freaking vampire, fix up the soundtrack?

  • her song "haunted" would have been better!!!

  • Lele I know!

  • kelly clarkson has some ok songs, but for new moon? its rediculous!

  • not a very twilighty song

    it would never fit in with the first soundtrack

  • It says right here in the comments on this song that this is in fact NOT the song that will be on the soundtrack .. . that the (and I'm quoting here "REAL SONG SUBMITTED FOR THE NEW FILM IS CALLED "EMPTY AS I AM" " . .. so this is not the song that will be on the soundtrack.

  • No just no

  • no.. . i mean the song is nice but .. JUST nice.. nothing more i need emotions!!

  • Not that, the same mistake as paramore

  • NO...not at all!!!! It's not suitable for the Twilight Saga! It doesn't bring the wanted emotion in me! "Haunted" would fit better.

  • ew. i dont like it at all! bad choice for the sound track, but i am glad they are using need by hana pestle

  • is it really being used!?! i am so confused... i heard theyre not using need?

  • nope there not!

  • The lyrics is just like the scene where he left her in the woods.

  • Yeah, This is Kellys songs called "Did you", Empty as I am , has NOT been released yet

  • ooooh so she wrote 2 songs for NM?

  • Not that im aware, i think "Did you" was just another song she wrote. the song that she DID write about NM was "Empty as I am" but i saw an interview saying that she didnt write it to submit for the movie , just because she likes the books, but she might release it sometimes just for people to make.

  • no offence i like kelly klarkson and all but this song does not sound good at all at it doesnt fit the theme of new moon or anything.......srry but this song ia pretty terrible... :P :(

  • sorry,

    but paramore is way better!

    xx

  • I just think this so is too cliche for the movie i think. i love the song and kelly Clarkson. But god. of course he loved her and cared for her. Bella KNEW that. Its obvious. So why would this song fit..at all? I dont think it does. Im kind of disappointed

  • actually bella didn't,

    she believed him when he told her in the forest that he didn't.

    thats why in the end when they got back from italy, he told her how shocked he was that she had believed him. she even thought he was gonna leave again and was just staying out of guilt.

  • Actually I dont really care...Its just that the song is too cliche. Could have picked a song with more powerfull lyrics that fit better. Dont you think the music needs to be more emotional or depressing? Not so much deressing though because..that would be too depressig. lol. I just think Kelly Clarkson doesnt fit. Come on. But whatever. I dont care.

  • this isnt Empty As I Am, but i personally think her style doesnt go with it at all either... i hope need by hana pestle was chosen!

  • OH GAAAAWD NOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!! Y DID THEY HAVE TO GO WITH KELLY CLARKSON!?!?!?!!!!! PARAMORE IS WAAAAAAAYYY BETTER ( for the movie ) !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • this isn't gonna b on new moon, its empty as i am that will b

  • ...uggg...i dont like it at all

  • irs okay it not great i dont think the song fits toghther right though