If Joel were happier with Hillary then he would have stayed with her and if he wasn't happy with Nicole then the wouldn't be married with two beautiful kids so stop hating on Nicole there happy leave then alone
well they were a good couple but if you think about it .. they were happy together then that was the past and they are done now hilarys married to mike cominer
Joel is or isn't with Nicole Richie and they have to kids toegther , Joel dumped hil over the phone well a text message, there done now over! maybe Joel had sparkles in his eyes ya well so did my last boyfriend! he loves Nicole Richie other wise he wouldn't be with her!!!!!!!!! he does have sparkles in his eyes! ugh!
i remember thinking they were an odd couple when i first heard thet were dating but when i see them together they looked so happy and in love. i love the way joel would just glow and his eyes would light up whenever he looked at hilary. he always used to smile with his eyes. now hes with nicole and i love her but its different to me, he comes off serious and not as playful and the sparkle left his eyes. but joel seems like a great bf so any girl would be lucky to have him cuz hes so caring
Hey at least they are still friends. They are both happy in their lives. Let's just be happy for them both. Joel's a daddy of two now and Hilary has an amazing boyfriend.
Love lost because of circumstance is really sad. Anyone who loves Joel can see that the spark has gone from his eyes, since breaking up with Hilary. I hurt for him because he was old enough to know real love and she was too young to really understand it. While I like Nicole and I am sure he loves her, a huge part of his heart will always remain with Hilary.
And Nicole and Joel are having theyre second child, you can make this mistake once but not twice, so if they decide to have another child it's probably because they are in love and happy togheter.
theres a picture of hilary and joel and i think shes doing something on her phone and hes all interested but theres a pic of nicole on her phone and he doesnt care lol. it seems hil and joel were just deep in love with each other. nicole was more of a rebound for him... that turned out bad (she got preg and i bet he wasnt expecting that to happen)
i wonder how they feel when they see each other and how he feels going with nicole richie. he actually looked like he was in love with hilary but when yousee him with nicole you dont see that
i think they still love each other,Joel broke up with Hilary just because nicole richie was pregnat,he has made the foolest mistake of his life,Hilary is more beautiful than nicole
read Don't laugh at this! Just do it Start thinking something you really really want cause this is astounding the person that sent this to me said their wish came true 10 mins after they read the mail so I thought what the heck You have just been visited by DrSuess's Cat in the Hat. He will grant you one wish Make your wish when the count down is over 10,9,8,7,6,5,4,3,2,1 MAKE A WISH Send this to 10 videos within the hour you read this. If you do, your wish will come true
As much as i love Joel and Nicole together, because they seem like a such a geniune couple Hilary and Joel were really cute and i believe that they truly cared for each other. I hope they have still remained friends.
about Joel's tattoo, the one for hilary.. is that still on or joel have covered it?
GREAT VIDEO! i love it.
I miss JILARY.
You know the moment when Hilary was still with Joel and i saw a lot of photos of them taken by the paparazzi.. I always like aww.. they're sooo cute. wish i can be like that too with the one i love :p
Jilary is wayy cuter than madchie. Thats my opinion.
But if Joel really happy with Nicole now.. I'm also happy for him.
u guys fuckin right.. joel is with nicole only becuz of his lil cute baby harlow..he is so happy when he is with her he is like a lil kid too ..but when he is with nicole it just he looks like he is dead..its awful to watch him like that becuz he dont deserve to be so miserble..when he is with hilary and the band and the baby he is alive again he is happier then ever..
Oh My Gosh! there someone said that hilary doesn't deserve joel. if hilary doesn't how u guys think nicole deserves? cause hilary is much better. and only reason why joel broke-up with hil was that nicole was pregnant.
hey, did you guys notice that most of the pictures when hilary and joel still together, you can see him smile?? like he's hepi wif her...but, tha pictures when he's wif nicole, looks like he's in a stressed....err..maybe it jz me...lalala...lol
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
yeah, i did, but the duude who's made this video probably thought of that. I've seen A LOT of picture with joel and Nicoel where Joel's smiling buuuuuuuut the duude that's made the video obviously likes Hilary better so the duude picked out the photos where he wasn't smiling!
also have you guys noticed that both hilary and joel are dating people that sorta looks like each other? Nicole looks like a older hilary if she went on drugs and did alcohol all night.. sometimes nicole does look like hilary.. a skankier version. Whereas Mike sometimes looks like Joel but a more pissed off all the time version lol
if you guys listen to Good Charlotte's new song "Where would we be now" I think Joel wrote it with Hilary in mind.. especially with the part "i'll wait.. i'll wait" because she wanted to remain a virgin till marriage.. and a man has his needs... I guess he regrets it now :/ for pressuring her. I hope they get back together by some miracle Hilary x joel forever!
I'm not taking sides whether Joel was/is happIER with Hilary or Nicole, all I care about is that Good Charlotte are going strong and that they are HAPPY which Joel at the moment sure seems to be with his new family, but I hate it when people talk shit about him like asking why did he dump Hilary for that slut?! and stuff like that.
Just to point out that Hilary dumped Joel, because of the age difference and she knew he would probably want to settle down soon. She was right... =P
u so think that joel and hilary looks way better than nicole and joel i bet hilary is so mad that nicole is pregnant by joel but evantually hilary will get over it because she is a strong, sucsessful teen or woman and i am proud of her
I love Hilary Duff with Mike Comrie. However, I can see way everyone misses this couple, they do look very happy together!!! Poor Joel, he looks so unhappy with what's her name. I think everything backfired on Joel, in the process of trying to get Hilary back, he got what's her name pregnant and now he's stuck and looks like an asshole to all of us:o(
I don't like Hilary with Mike. I really do think Mike is way too protective, if a guy looks at Hilary Mike just gives u a nasty glance. Its totally obvious Hilay and Joel arent going to get back together, Joel got Nicole preganant and I don't think Hilary is going to date a dad. I mean shes so young she can do something better with her life
joel doesn't look happy with nicole at all he look more happy with hilary you can see how muck hilary and joel love each other in those pictures and the ones with him and nicole you don't see that sorry
If Joel were happier with Hillary then he would have stayed with her and if he wasn't happy with Nicole then the wouldn't be married with two beautiful kids so stop hating on Nicole there happy leave then alone
xSezzaTezzax 3 weeks ago
joel never looks happy in his pics with nicole, but looked extremely happy with hilary
aliciaranus 1 month ago
too bad both hilary and joel have moved on! :'(
hilary got married, & soon having her first child and joel has a new gf?
AlysoN654 3 months ago
1:15 isn't that Benji?
ashleyforeverrrr 5 months ago
Both Hilary & Joel have moved on w/ their life.
Kien8486 1 year ago
such shame they are not together!!!! love jilary!!! so much
sassyd9 1 year ago 2
THEY WERE SO CUTE TOGETHER, BUT I GUESS IT WAS BETTER OFF NOT TOGETHER..SHE WAS A DIFFERENT PERSON AND SHE SAID HERSELF.
MovieFanByHeart 1 year ago
Aww i loved the cute couple Hilary and Joel made :(....buu nicole
oxXKittyKatXxo 1 year ago
the best story- love ever =(
30secondstoMUSE 1 year ago
no joel had a kid of nicole so he needed to take care of his kid understand
cholindo142 1 year ago
well they were a good couple but if you think about it .. they were happy together then that was the past and they are done now hilarys married to mike cominer
Joel is or isn't with Nicole Richie and they have to kids toegther , Joel dumped hil over the phone well a text message, there done now over! maybe Joel had sparkles in his eyes ya well so did my last boyfriend! he loves Nicole Richie other wise he wouldn't be with her!!!!!!!!! he does have sparkles in his eyes! ugh!
sweetluverxoxoxo 1 year ago
he never smiles when he is with Nicole.... =/
ThePoph 1 year ago 3
How old were they when they went out ?
iRawrDinosaurx3 1 year ago
hilary and joel were both glowing when they were together.. literally glowing!and now..
kiddixa 1 year ago
i remember thinking they were an odd couple when i first heard thet were dating but when i see them together they looked so happy and in love. i love the way joel would just glow and his eyes would light up whenever he looked at hilary. he always used to smile with his eyes. now hes with nicole and i love her but its different to me, he comes off serious and not as playful and the sparkle left his eyes. but joel seems like a great bf so any girl would be lucky to have him cuz hes so caring
PeachesNSweetness05 1 year ago
I HAVE TO AGREE WITH THAT ONE PERSON HE DONT HAVE THE SPARK IN HIS EYES ANYMORE .......SUCKS
TheRoyalty714 1 year ago
So Hilary broke up with Joel 'cause of the age difference?
I hope so 'cause people keep saying he cheated on her =[ but I thought Nicole was just a rebound =S
TgGc83 2 years ago
ohh they look soo cute together... I'm gonna kill nicole!!!
TheHoNeYgIrL94 2 years ago 18
nicole richie BITCH¡¡¡
kmit2805 2 years ago 19
Hey at least they are still friends. They are both happy in their lives. Let's just be happy for them both. Joel's a daddy of two now and Hilary has an amazing boyfriend.
sinkist 2 years ago 3
Love lost because of circumstance is really sad. Anyone who loves Joel can see that the spark has gone from his eyes, since breaking up with Hilary. I hurt for him because he was old enough to know real love and she was too young to really understand it. While I like Nicole and I am sure he loves her, a huge part of his heart will always remain with Hilary.
cheekyoziechick 2 years ago 7
esta mejor hilary solita por ke ni mike me gusta para ella
hilaryfanforever 2 years ago
yes iths so true, they loked amazing together. but don't forget that hilary is with Mike :(
But i preffer joel, Hilaaaaaaary i love you so much
ThebestisHilary 2 years ago
They look so great together...
Brendagc22 2 years ago 4
I hate nicole!!!!
oliepolie90 2 years ago 11
If they brooke up it's beacuse maybe weren't so perfect togheter or not?? they are not dumb.
MarcoGaratti 2 years ago
And Nicole and Joel are having theyre second child, you can make this mistake once but not twice, so if they decide to have another child it's probably because they are in love and happy togheter.
MarcoGaratti 2 years ago
Comment removed
ferleiteable 2 years ago
i reli missed both of them hil and joel and perfect!!!!
sitsit08 2 years ago
not a a huge fan of neither girls but i think he looks way better with hilary than nicole. he seemed more down to earth when he was with her
sheenObeenO 2 years ago 6
I agree too Joel doesn't love Nicole....He is with her because he HAS to be....
Kassssia18 2 years ago
amazing!....they looked so happy 2gether!...now its like he HAS to carry nicole around wherever he goes and he s not happy...definitely not...
love hil and joel!!!
sharpestlives01 2 years ago 4
But now he is with nicole ?
i don't understand ! :S
Hilaaryy 2 years ago
la verdad los hombres las prefieren putas de eso me estoy dando cuenta la verdad esta mas linda hilary
totmatita 2 years ago
They´r soo perfect 4 eacher <3
tr0pizz 2 years ago
I found hilary and joel perfect together, but ...
kbral19 3 years ago
theres a picture of hilary and joel and i think shes doing something on her phone and hes all interested but theres a pic of nicole on her phone and he doesnt care lol. it seems hil and joel were just deep in love with each other. nicole was more of a rebound for him... that turned out bad (she got preg and i bet he wasnt expecting that to happen)
passmethat40 3 years ago
hilary and joel were so cute together.
i agree with you guys when you say its looked liked he loved and care for hilary more then he does for nicole ..
but i could be wrong
i miss them together
ps... i still love joel madden and hilary duff
teenagelier 3 years ago
i wonder how they feel when they see each other and how he feels going with nicole richie. he actually looked like he was in love with hilary but when yousee him with nicole you dont see that
Halle009 3 years ago
i miss this cute couple..... =(
pr3ciousbee 3 years ago
i miss this cute couple...
why did they have to broke up??
i hate joel and nicole...
pr3ciousbee 3 years ago 3
joel looked happier with hilary. i noticed that in the pictures.
and with nicole...i didnt see a pic of him smiling...
I MISS JILARY!!!!!!
MADCHIE SUCKS!!
miterdoug967 3 years ago 4
i think they still love each other,Joel broke up with Hilary just because nicole richie was pregnat,he has made the foolest mistake of his life,Hilary is more beautiful than nicole
1121Amanda 3 years ago 2
i think that Joel is more happy with Hilary
Anirhan 3 years ago 2
i wish hilary and joel would get back together. nicole richie looks like a chihuahua
LynnNguyen 3 years ago 3
i think hillary looks better
hillarygreen18 3 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
culary 3 years ago
As much as i love Joel and Nicole together, because they seem like a such a geniune couple Hilary and Joel were really cute and i believe that they truly cared for each other. I hope they have still remained friends.
ChimbaDoll 3 years ago
did joel cheat on hilary with nicole when they were still together cause i didnt know that!!!!
ValleyGurlFrmHell 3 years ago
For some reason he looks like he has a temper. He seems sweet to everyone but has a temper when theyre alone. He reminds me of someone I know :(
ValleyGurlFrmHell 3 years ago
about Joel's tattoo, the one for hilary.. is that still on or joel have covered it?
GREAT VIDEO! i love it.
I miss JILARY.
You know the moment when Hilary was still with Joel and i saw a lot of photos of them taken by the paparazzi.. I always like aww.. they're sooo cute. wish i can be like that too with the one i love :p
Jilary is wayy cuter than madchie. Thats my opinion.
But if Joel really happy with Nicole now.. I'm also happy for him.
I am Joel's no 1 fan!! i kissed him once. :p
MarissaRain 3 years ago 3
when everybody thought it was wrong that jilary were together i loved them together they're so cute!
the tattoo is so cute too!
and i noticed that in every picture in the vid with joel and nicole joel seems kinda sad
monicastar14 3 years ago 2
I'm still saying that Hilary deserves better.
But, why they break up?
ghostlsdori 3 years ago 3
I miss them!
lysia88ld 3 years ago
i dont get it, why he slept with nicole if he loved hilary? and of coz i can see he's happier with hilary, but still.. why?
lauchaipo 3 years ago
who knows maybe that was mistake that nicole used to get pregnant. but it's clear he was happier with hilary.i'm sorry for both of them.
goshxe 3 years ago 3
u guys fuckin right.. joel is with nicole only becuz of his lil cute baby harlow..he is so happy when he is with her he is like a lil kid too ..but when he is with nicole it just he looks like he is dead..its awful to watch him like that becuz he dont deserve to be so miserble..when he is with hilary and the band and the baby he is alive again he is happier then ever..
BloodyValentine16 3 years ago 5
Oh My Gosh! there someone said that hilary doesn't deserve joel. if hilary doesn't how u guys think nicole deserves? cause hilary is much better. and only reason why joel broke-up with hil was that nicole was pregnant.
goshxe 3 years ago 2
i miss them! badly!
LilFidzz 3 years ago 4
SHE LOOKS LIKE ANGEL
LACKILOVEYOU 3 years ago 2
oh yeah with hilary he seems to be happy, i think the only reason that hes with nicole is the baby
joslynp 3 years ago 4
joal seemed to be happy with hilary!
lolita917 3 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
hilart doesn't diserve joel
thelastfight93 3 years ago
hey, did you guys notice that most of the pictures when hilary and joel still together, you can see him smile?? like he's hepi wif her...but, tha pictures when he's wif nicole, looks like he's in a stressed....err..maybe it jz me...lalala...lol
PrinCessAeChi 3 years ago 5
I was thinking the same thing, I'm soooooo with you!!! Anyone else notice that too???
nan1esco 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
yeah, i did, but the duude who's made this video probably thought of that. I've seen A LOT of picture with joel and Nicoel where Joel's smiling buuuuuuuut the duude that's made the video obviously likes Hilary better so the duude picked out the photos where he wasn't smiling!
Joel is MUCH better off with Nicole
JM4LAJF 3 years ago
Yeah I've Noticed That Too.The Only Time He Looks Happy Anymore Is When Hes With Harlow Or With The Rest Of The Band...
lovatoswife23 3 years ago
i have noticed that also...Harlow is his pride and joy...he is happier with her and his band.
JoelsSexyRiotGrl 3 years ago
Exactly He Is..And Harlow Is Just Adorable..
lovatoswife23 3 years ago
good song, good pictures, good couple, good charlotte !!
moon0017 3 years ago 3
also have you guys noticed that both hilary and joel are dating people that sorta looks like each other? Nicole looks like a older hilary if she went on drugs and did alcohol all night.. sometimes nicole does look like hilary.. a skankier version. Whereas Mike sometimes looks like Joel but a more pissed off all the time version lol
pantysh0t 3 years ago
if you guys listen to Good Charlotte's new song "Where would we be now" I think Joel wrote it with Hilary in mind.. especially with the part "i'll wait.. i'll wait" because she wanted to remain a virgin till marriage.. and a man has his needs... I guess he regrets it now :/ for pressuring her. I hope they get back together by some miracle Hilary x joel forever!
pantysh0t 3 years ago 5
xlXlxGCxlXlx :
yeah i said it before that hilary dumped joel because of the age difference and she was right i agree what u said lol!
Rwimma 3 years ago 3
I'm not taking sides whether Joel was/is happIER with Hilary or Nicole, all I care about is that Good Charlotte are going strong and that they are HAPPY which Joel at the moment sure seems to be with his new family, but I hate it when people talk shit about him like asking why did he dump Hilary for that slut?! and stuff like that.
Just to point out that Hilary dumped Joel, because of the age difference and she knew he would probably want to settle down soon. She was right... =P
-xXx-
xlXlxGCxlXlx 3 years ago
Joel is so much better off w/ Nicole richie
I mean she used to be a party girl
but since she went w/ joel she stopped
because she learned responsiblities
and joel is now a great role model
i'm happy for them
mollymoon1234 3 years ago
u so think that joel and hilary looks way better than nicole and joel i bet hilary is so mad that nicole is pregnant by joel but evantually hilary will get over it because she is a strong, sucsessful teen or woman and i am proud of her
aaliyah450 3 years ago
yes you're right...:(
Rwimma 3 years ago
i can notice from the pics that joel looks happier with hilary than he does with nicole
yOuRsUpErGuRL19 3 years ago
i can notice from the pics that joel looks happier with hilary than he does with nicole
yOuRsUpErGuRL19 3 years ago
i bet it must be hard 2 c her ex with the most slutiest hoe ever and with her pregnancy.I hope their babby doesnt grow up 2 b a slut 2!!!
trae106319106319 3 years ago
kerrysimpson :
i got the picture of his arm tatoo (the bee) from a french blog of joel madden...i know it's reaaly cute but it doesn't count anymore...:(
Rwimma 4 years ago
omg where did you get the picture of his bee tattoo from?
kerrysimpson 4 years ago
yes...:(
moon0017 4 years ago
omg...the song,the pictures...:((...
ciocolatapoiana 4 years ago 2
I love Hilary Duff with Mike Comrie. However, I can see way everyone misses this couple, they do look very happy together!!! Poor Joel, he looks so unhappy with what's her name. I think everything backfired on Joel, in the process of trying to get Hilary back, he got what's her name pregnant and now he's stuck and looks like an asshole to all of us:o(
nan1esco 4 years ago 2
yea i agree, and joel does't look happy! but hilary does!i think she is very happy with mike now
eline55 4 years ago
I agree!!!
nan1esco 4 years ago
have you seen the tato on his arm:D that is so cute !
eline55 4 years ago
she is
hotpinkstuff101 4 years ago
I don't like Hilary with Mike. I really do think Mike is way too protective, if a guy looks at Hilary Mike just gives u a nasty glance. Its totally obvious Hilay and Joel arent going to get back together, Joel got Nicole preganant and I don't think Hilary is going to date a dad. I mean shes so young she can do something better with her life
hotpinkstuff101 4 years ago
eline55 :
i think that they broke up 'cause joel was a lot more old than her...well, that's what i heard...:D
simy4ever:
(...)
Rwimma 4 years ago
then why would they go out in the 1st place
hotpinkstuff101 4 years ago
hil and joel... i can't belive that they broke up!! it make me cry all the time
i have a question: has joel dump hilary or has hilary dump joel?
eline55 4 years ago 3
hilary dumped joel
hotpinkstuff101 4 years ago
:)..hilary & mike..4ever:)..joel suck!!
simy4ever 4 years ago
yes, bsm28 !! you're totally RIGHT !!
Rwimma 4 years ago
joel doesn't look happy with nicole at all he look more happy with hilary you can see how muck hilary and joel love each other in those pictures and the ones with him and nicole you don't see that sorry
bsm28 4 years ago 2
Thank you guys !! i'm really GLAd right now lol...!
Rwimma 4 years ago
fantastic ur job is gr8 :) keep it up!!! and i haaaaaaaaaaaaate nichole that slut!!!
yummyfruit6654 4 years ago 3
wow!! is best video !!!!
they were so cute! i hate nicole!
Lulyy1 4 years ago 2
sooo sad! They belong togeather!
brendaqrg 4 years ago 3
I love this video
great !
Jilary
4ever and ever (L)
mahpinheiro 4 years ago 3
no prob !! :)
moon0017 4 years ago
thnx moon0017...
Rwimma 4 years ago
nice vid !! i cried a lil bit lol !!
moon0017 4 years ago