Well, that's the thing, audio is approx. at 1/3's of a video on the file itself, if the game is long as hell, it CAN possible take upwards of 500 MB. Since it's using more than just music. What the 16 GB person failed to tell you, is that the game he mentioned is large in itself, and the audio at most only uses 4 GB.
Am I the only one who finds a problem with GabuEx speaking to imaginary talking candy-colored ponies, from a T.V. show meant for little girls. Seriously, that kind of thing is a good sign of insanity, get some help man, get some help... All joking aside, I listen to this every chance I get, and enjoy it everytime.
This is one of those hit-or-miss kinds of things.... unfortunately, I must admit that this is a miss in my book. The only voice actors I really liked were Applebloom and the Diamond Dogs. Rainbow Dash actually sounded more like Scootaloo than Scootaloo's voice actor herself.
I like the enthusiasm of everyone, I guess. Rarity and Pinkie Pie have the same enthusiasm, but I don't think their voices are... that great.
@CrispyYoshi I agree. Pinkie and Applebloom have the same voice actress, and I thought they were both great... but Rainbow Dash kept giving me Scootaloo vibes (I still like her voice though). The Diamond Dogs were spot on. But everyone else..... meeeeh. D:
Sorry for posting again, but I just HAVE to emphasize the need for a better mic for some of them. Especially Twilight and the CMC. The voices themselves aren't half-bad (although Sweetie Belle sounds like Twist D:) but the cloudly mics make them somewhat painful to listen to. *shrug*
On another note, THE DIAMOND DOGS WERE ''SPOT''-ON (see what I did there?)
Don't listen to the haters. I LOVE these voices. I was about to say Scootaloo was the most spot-on but then I heard the Diamond Dogs. WHOA. They are PERFECT. This is going to be amazing!
@dancinninja a lot of people aren't hating. we're giving CONSTRUCTIVE criticism. They should listen to other people's opinions if they want to improve.
So far, Pinkie was the best. She was spot on! Twilight has a good voice, but a TERRIBLE mic. I thought Applebloom was great. nothing to say there. Ppl keep portraying Sweetie Belle with a lisp-- SHE HAS NO LISP PPL. She has a very squeaky, childish voice, but no lisp. And Scootaloo-- what I noticed while watching the show is that her voice sound more like an older girl trying to SOUND young, rather than a childish voice like the others. keep that in mind.
I think VA's are not a bad idea at all; in particular, Pinkie's voice is fantastic! (i actually thought she would be the most difficult character to voice °-°)
@BarackOshama You're not the only person to have said that, so I can report that we do plan to provide the ability to turn off voice acting if you don't want it.
As a major MLP and Ace Attorney fan, I just have to keep cheering you guys on!
My ONLY small gripe is that the audio equipment with some of the voice actresses could be better, so it reduces that tinny, distorted sound. Other than that, I can actually FEEL the love of the craft for the fanwork. I'll be always cheering you guys on!
I personally think the VA's will be a bit much. Not to mention that the amount of disk space your resources will use will skyrocket as a result.
Let me put it to you this way, Star Wars: ToR uses a full 16 gigs of space. I predict for your game, you're going to end up taking at least 2. I would have honestly kept it to text.
That being said, the VA's themselves weren't bad... but I would definitely shop some of the voices, especially for the CCC's.
@ekimr90 2 GB for audio? The total disk space of all of the lines used in this video was about 5 MB. For Case 1 to take up 2 GB of space for audio, it would need to have 400 times as much audio as there was in this video. I don't exactly think it's going to have that much.
The voices are pretty good, though I think Sweetie Belle and Rarity were off. Rarity just needs to have more force in her voice, and Sweetie should be a little more high pitched. But all in all it's pretty good. Especially Pinkie Pie and the Diamond Dogs. Holy crap the Diamond Dogs (amazing).
I honestly think the voice acting nice, but a little too much. Only because having to add voice actors for every piece of diolauge (in a diolauge heavy series) is going to slow production down a lot, and since VA's weren't in the Pheonix Wright series you really didn't need them here. I think that it's nice that you're going to these lengths and others may like this idea, but I personally think it's a little much.
Somehow I knew that Bree would end up voicing Pinkie Pie in this. I mean, she voices Pinkie in, like, EVERYTHING. Not that I'm complaining of course. Bree's Pinkie Pie voice is Incredible.
They're all very talented and I know it's hard for adult women to make believable young girl voices, but the only ones that were slightly off were Scoots and Sweetie. They're both good, but Scoots sounded a tad too raspy... sort of like she was whispering aloud. Sweetie lisps a bit too much and sounds like Twist.
Those were my only thoughts though, otherwise they were good.
Pinkie Pie and the Diamond dogs are perfect.. the others are kinda off. Apple Bloom sounds nice too. Scoots is kind of quiet, Sweetie sounds slightly like Twist.
No offense but Rarity and Sweetie Belle could have better voice actors, Sweetie sounds like Twist and Rarity sounds like a generic high class woman. Pinkie Pie and the Diamond Dogs are PERFECT though.
Good: PP RD AB the dogs notably disliked: RT sweetie belle My opinion: Twilight's script and voice fit Rarity better. Scoots and Mayor are good. Not best but good. I really wish I wasn't typing this, but that Rarity was... bad... :(
My complaints are Sweetie Belle and Rarity. Sweetie was just kinda...off, and Rarity's needs to be a bit deeper, I think. Also, I think that "pompous/proper" accent thing she gets isn't present most of the time. Other than that, they were pretty darn close. Better than I could've pulled together.
I have an idea, we all know that the actual Sweetie-belle voice actor is on youtube, maybe she can be convinced to help out!! We all know how awesome that would be.
Diamond Dogs are actually pretty accurate, Rainbow Dash could go a little higher if she wants to be like her character, CMC is fine, Twilight's okay (I've never heard ANYONE get Tara's voice spot-on), Rarity could go a little higher, and I think we all can agree Pinkie Pie is as good as ever ^^.
Other than the lack of AJ or Fluttershy, it was all great.
Except Rarity and Sweetie Bell.... At least I think so. Dash could be a LITTLE better BUT still good. Pinkie and Applebloom are spot on and Twilight, Scootaloo and Mayor are all very, very good.
Didn't expect the Diamond Dogs honestly.
But, if this is the set list of voice actors, I can't wait for the MLI to come out.
@Renzor004 Applejack and Fluttershy are not present in the planned first case. Casting for them will be performed at a later date when there's a case where they are required.
@Renzor004 They were not written into case 1 when Gabu and I first wrote it. Sorry. :( I can safely say that they'll be involved in future cases, so don't worry about that. ;)
I have some good news for you then! Gabu, dawnmew (one of programmers), and I talked about this subject and we have found it very feasible to include a "Classic AA" mode where the voices are turned off (except for interjections like HOLD IT!, of course).
It hasn't been included yet, so please be patient!
To bad there wasn't a role I could do. I couldn't do any of the Diamond Dogs and my idea for an evil mastermind how is behind it all is merely a pipe dream at this point. Well I'll at least have the Let's Play.
@Sneider336 Fluttershy and Applejack don't appear solely because they don't appear in case 1 either. I still love them and didn't forget about them, don't worry. :P
Great choices except for Scootaloo and Sweetie Belle, both pitches are way too low and it seems like both have a lisp like too many teeth are missing.
If voice acting is to result in victory then you must act!
Sun tzooves said that
And I'd say and I'd say he knows a little more about pony voices than you do pal, because he invented them! And then he perfected them, so that no living pony could best him in the ring of friendship!
Well, that's the thing, audio is approx. at 1/3's of a video on the file itself, if the game is long as hell, it CAN possible take upwards of 500 MB. Since it's using more than just music. What the 16 GB person failed to tell you, is that the game he mentioned is large in itself, and the audio at most only uses 4 GB.
XainArchives 5 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
-PonyKart
-My little Investigations
-Fighting is magic
-Pony RPG
What do all these have in common?
There all WIPs >:(
spritefan10 6 days ago
my life in a nutshell
kingelvis24 1 week ago
^_^ Mm, nice. Good luck guys! Looking forward to seeing how this turns out.
omganotherun 2 weeks ago
Am I the only one who finds a problem with GabuEx speaking to imaginary talking candy-colored ponies, from a T.V. show meant for little girls. Seriously, that kind of thing is a good sign of insanity, get some help man, get some help... All joking aside, I listen to this every chance I get, and enjoy it everytime.
deathsheir2035 2 weeks ago
(blog copy-paste)
This is one of those hit-or-miss kinds of things.... unfortunately, I must admit that this is a miss in my book. The only voice actors I really liked were Applebloom and the Diamond Dogs. Rainbow Dash actually sounded more like Scootaloo than Scootaloo's voice actor herself.
I like the enthusiasm of everyone, I guess. Rarity and Pinkie Pie have the same enthusiasm, but I don't think their voices are... that great.
CrispyYoshi 2 weeks ago
@CrispyYoshi I agree. Pinkie and Applebloom have the same voice actress, and I thought they were both great... but Rainbow Dash kept giving me Scootaloo vibes (I still like her voice though). The Diamond Dogs were spot on. But everyone else..... meeeeh. D:
TawneyFox 2 weeks ago
Those were pretty good! The only ones I didn't care for was Rarity's and Sweetie Belle's. Im pretty good at Applejack. Can't wait till it comes out!
Mpshaymin 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
gshowguy 2 weeks ago
Aww... Sweetie Belle's so pwethiouth! (Sorry for the bad Twist imitation. And yes, she does sound like her.)
gshowguy 2 weeks ago
THIS IS ANNOYING ME
keno6307 3 weeks ago
okay Rover's VA is amazing
Darkmis13 3 weeks ago
Diamond dogs are the best XD
lemlolcat 3 weeks ago
i could voice for fluttershy i am really good :)
TheChaoGirl 3 weeks ago
Sorry for posting again, but I just HAVE to emphasize the need for a better mic for some of them. Especially Twilight and the CMC. The voices themselves aren't half-bad (although Sweetie Belle sounds like Twist D:) but the cloudly mics make them somewhat painful to listen to. *shrug*
On another note, THE DIAMOND DOGS WERE ''SPOT''-ON (see what I did there?)
TawneyFox 3 weeks ago
Best are:
Pinkie Pie
Scootaloo
Apple Bloom
The Mayor
Rover
Spot
RaqoushShortcake 3 weeks ago
@RaqoushShortcake Agreed...
EverFreeTree 3 weeks ago
Don't listen to the haters. I LOVE these voices. I was about to say Scootaloo was the most spot-on but then I heard the Diamond Dogs. WHOA. They are PERFECT. This is going to be amazing!
dancinninja 3 weeks ago
@dancinninja a lot of people aren't hating. we're giving CONSTRUCTIVE criticism. They should listen to other people's opinions if they want to improve.
TawneyFox 3 weeks ago
i'm pretty sure all these voices are great!
roxorsoxor 3 weeks ago
Also, Rarity has a very bold, strong, relatively deep voice, but she CAN go ridiculously high. In other words, she has a range.
The Rarity VA you picked here has a too soft and too high voice.
Just some constructive criticism.
TawneyFox 3 weeks ago
So far, Pinkie was the best. She was spot on! Twilight has a good voice, but a TERRIBLE mic. I thought Applebloom was great. nothing to say there. Ppl keep portraying Sweetie Belle with a lisp-- SHE HAS NO LISP PPL. She has a very squeaky, childish voice, but no lisp. And Scootaloo-- what I noticed while watching the show is that her voice sound more like an older girl trying to SOUND young, rather than a childish voice like the others. keep that in mind.
TawneyFox 3 weeks ago
it sure sounds tasty team :)
saldownik 3 weeks ago
Sweetie Bell sounded like Twist... I sensed a lisp. Just constructive criticism. :)
Wheelz567 3 weeks ago
I think VA's are not a bad idea at all; in particular, Pinkie's voice is fantastic! (i actually thought she would be the most difficult character to voice °-°)
00DeathScythe00 3 weeks ago
Awwww, I was hoping for no VA's...
BarackOshama 3 weeks ago
@BarackOshama You're not the only person to have said that, so I can report that we do plan to provide the ability to turn off voice acting if you don't want it.
EquestrianDreamers 3 weeks ago
@EquestrianDreamers Oh lawdy. I think I wuv you now.
BarackOshama 3 weeks ago
As a major MLP and Ace Attorney fan, I just have to keep cheering you guys on!
My ONLY small gripe is that the audio equipment with some of the voice actresses could be better, so it reduces that tinny, distorted sound. Other than that, I can actually FEEL the love of the craft for the fanwork. I'll be always cheering you guys on!
Shippoyasha 3 weeks ago
I think that the Rarity/Sweetie Belle voice actress was the best. Quite an impressive leap in voice between the two.
PainAndSacrifice 3 weeks ago
I personally think the VA's will be a bit much. Not to mention that the amount of disk space your resources will use will skyrocket as a result.
Let me put it to you this way, Star Wars: ToR uses a full 16 gigs of space. I predict for your game, you're going to end up taking at least 2. I would have honestly kept it to text.
That being said, the VA's themselves weren't bad... but I would definitely shop some of the voices, especially for the CCC's.
ekimr90 3 weeks ago
@ekimr90 2 GB for audio? The total disk space of all of the lines used in this video was about 5 MB. For Case 1 to take up 2 GB of space for audio, it would need to have 400 times as much audio as there was in this video. I don't exactly think it's going to have that much.
EquestrianDreamers 3 weeks ago 2
@ekimr90 CCC's? you mean CMC's?
starseekerX7 2 weeks ago
Sweetie Belle sounds kinda like Twist.
Who else is getting that vibe?
51stSheep 3 weeks ago
Pinkie Pie is spot on.
fjord407 3 weeks ago
The voices are pretty good, though I think Sweetie Belle and Rarity were off. Rarity just needs to have more force in her voice, and Sweetie should be a little more high pitched. But all in all it's pretty good. Especially Pinkie Pie and the Diamond Dogs. Holy crap the Diamond Dogs (amazing).
Lemonz617 3 weeks ago
Pinkie Pie was perfect! But no Spike in the first case? Poor Spike, he always gets left out of everything...
kenjutsukata1o1 3 weeks ago
RD's voice is okay but needs to sound more tomboyish.
GlowyPie 3 weeks ago
In my opinion Pinkie Pie is just perfekt :D
The others are fine, but I think Rarity has not quite the right voice...
R0flc0pter1000 3 weeks ago
Pinkie is amazing.
Cra5yxPineapple 3 weeks ago
I honestly think the voice acting nice, but a little too much. Only because having to add voice actors for every piece of diolauge (in a diolauge heavy series) is going to slow production down a lot, and since VA's weren't in the Pheonix Wright series you really didn't need them here. I think that it's nice that you're going to these lengths and others may like this idea, but I personally think it's a little much.
LunaGirl196 3 weeks ago in playlist More videos from EquestrianDreamers 2
Somehow I knew that Bree would end up voicing Pinkie Pie in this. I mean, she voices Pinkie in, like, EVERYTHING. Not that I'm complaining of course. Bree's Pinkie Pie voice is Incredible.
messybones 3 weeks ago
sweetie bell sound abit like twist xD
lolke12 3 weeks ago
Pinkie and applebloom sounded so close to on the show. That's amazing
MrAmaster102 3 weeks ago
Rainbow sounds like an older Scootaloo
Lethys1 3 weeks ago
Rainbow dash sound like Scoot imo.
zbere300 3 weeks ago
Dat Pinkie Pie. Dat Diamond Dogs. Omg! <3
Vanduhn 3 weeks ago 14
They're all very talented and I know it's hard for adult women to make believable young girl voices, but the only ones that were slightly off were Scoots and Sweetie. They're both good, but Scoots sounded a tad too raspy... sort of like she was whispering aloud. Sweetie lisps a bit too much and sounds like Twist.
Those were my only thoughts though, otherwise they were good.
Aceedius 3 weeks ago
Pinkie Pie and the Diamond dogs are perfect.. the others are kinda off. Apple Bloom sounds nice too. Scoots is kind of quiet, Sweetie sounds slightly like Twist.
Either way, they're all nice!
TKCAnimations 3 weeks ago
Rarity, the Mayor, Sweetie Bell and Rainbow Dash are a teeny tiny bit off... other than that, perfect!
incredicassio 3 weeks ago
Tips:
Rainbow Dash: Higher pitch in voice and more tomboyish.
'-doing huddled around that desk?', sounded too feminine for her.
Rarity: Roll the 'T's, don't enunciate them. Lower pitch and raise volume too.
Twilight: Same as Rarity except without needing to enunciate.
CMC: Actual children (depending on the scenarios) would make it sound more authentic.
Scoot and Sweetie (more-so) present problems. AB should try to maintain the voice.
Pinkie: Better microphone or clearer speech.
ForerunnerLuke 3 weeks ago
Unfortunately.. the only really accurate ones are Pinkie and the dogs.
Elliptisoar 3 weeks ago
Comment removed
Elliptisoar 3 weeks ago
You do realise that you can actually get Sweetie Belle to do your Sweetie Belle voice, right?
racoonknux49 3 weeks ago
@racoonknux49 Alot of professional Va's from shows have to be under contract that they can't do unofficial voices for the characters.
PrincessRil 3 weeks ago
Pinkie and the Diamond Dogs' voices sound a lot like the real ones. Great job xD
Doomwyte 3 weeks ago
No offense but Rarity and Sweetie Belle could have better voice actors, Sweetie sounds like Twist and Rarity sounds like a generic high class woman. Pinkie Pie and the Diamond Dogs are PERFECT though.
rupture1212 3 weeks ago 2
a story writing cutie mark would be quite a storymark!
creativeinsult 3 weeks ago
Some of them were great, others were just...making my ears bleed.
Gotmilk0112 3 weeks ago
hahahahah that was so funny XD
especialy the diamond dogs XD
ANZULonDA 3 weeks ago
Loved it :D ad me in stitches pretty much start to finish. Great selection of actors so far :D
rraazze 3 weeks ago
On the topic of voices, GabuEx sounds like Jay Baruchel. Just saying.
minimewcutie 3 weeks ago
1:18 made me laugh so hard.
protosega 3 weeks ago
smokeydops 3 weeks ago
My complaints are Sweetie Belle and Rarity. Sweetie was just kinda...off, and Rarity's needs to be a bit deeper, I think. Also, I think that "pompous/proper" accent thing she gets isn't present most of the time. Other than that, they were pretty darn close. Better than I could've pulled together.
22darthmaul22 3 weeks ago
Sweetie Bell sounds well not that good but she's not that bad either just not Sweetie Bell
KanaTokisho 3 weeks ago
I have an idea, we all know that the actual Sweetie-belle voice actor is on youtube, maybe she can be convinced to help out!! We all know how awesome that would be.
MetalShadowChaos 3 weeks ago
@MetalShadowChaos They can't do unofficial voices usually its in their contracts.
PrincessRil 3 weeks ago
The Diamond Dogs are PERFECT!
SurfingCA2 3 weeks ago 5
The Diamond Dogs are perfect. But for the ponies. .
Pinkie = a bit TOO high IMO, but I wasn't that big of a fan of BreeFaith :/ (so maybe it's just me)
Twilight = just needs to match Tara's (which is obviously a challenge)
Rainbow = has something I can't think of, but it's close.
Rarity = quite breathy and her accent is a little off. . .
Mayor Mare = older
Applebloom = sounds too much like Pinkie sometimes
Scootaloo = sounds like Rainbow to me. . .
Sweetie = she's not childish/high enough.
SweetSanctuarii 3 weeks ago
oh god can't stand that sweetie bell XD
neokillall 3 weeks ago
Sounds like a few of the CMCs could use a pop filter, other then that I think it's great.
StarWarsXM 3 weeks ago
Diamond Dogs are actually pretty accurate, Rainbow Dash could go a little higher if she wants to be like her character, CMC is fine, Twilight's okay (I've never heard ANYONE get Tara's voice spot-on), Rarity could go a little higher, and I think we all can agree Pinkie Pie is as good as ever ^^.
That's my opinion, take it as you will.
JKRgamer 4 weeks ago
Wow, the Diamond Dogs are SPOT-ON!
Nixitur 4 weeks ago
Other than the lack of AJ or Fluttershy, it was all great.
Except Rarity and Sweetie Bell.... At least I think so. Dash could be a LITTLE better BUT still good. Pinkie and Applebloom are spot on and Twilight, Scootaloo and Mayor are all very, very good.
Didn't expect the Diamond Dogs honestly.
But, if this is the set list of voice actors, I can't wait for the MLI to come out.
TalkingCactus 4 weeks ago
Hey, awesome! I didn't know you were hiring actors! I was going to just get used to the familiar PW text noise when you released the game.
herooftime1000 4 weeks ago
Bree is best pony.
I feel like the girl who did Twilight's voice in APPLE.MOV and DRESS.MOV would have been better...
The person who did Rainbow Glasses ( :P ) sounded like a better Rainbow Dash.
Rarity sounds good.
Sweetie Belle doesn't sound NEARLY as cute as in the show, nor does Apple Bloom, but Sweetie Belle's is worst (IMO).
The Mayor is fine... And I don't even want to HEAR the Diamond Dogs, regardless of who voices him
Rubberman202 4 weeks ago
I hate how I always miss out on these pony auditions! Is there a feed everyone gets this stuff from?!
chriserony 4 weeks ago
Is it going to be fully voiced? Or just certain parts?
Kyleology 4 weeks ago
APPLEJACK AND FLUTTERSHY
WHERE
ARE
THEY
>:|
Renzor004 4 weeks ago
@Renzor004 Applejack and Fluttershy are not present in the planned first case. Casting for them will be performed at a later date when there's a case where they are required.
ThatCanadianDude 4 weeks ago
@Renzor004 They were not written into case 1 when Gabu and I first wrote it. Sorry. :( I can safely say that they'll be involved in future cases, so don't worry about that. ;)
@TwilightDash1
I have some good news for you then! Gabu, dawnmew (one of programmers), and I talked about this subject and we have found it very feasible to include a "Classic AA" mode where the voices are turned off (except for interjections like HOLD IT!, of course).
It hasn't been included yet, so please be patient!
ZeusAssassin 4 weeks ago
To bad there wasn't a role I could do. I couldn't do any of the Diamond Dogs and my idea for an evil mastermind how is behind it all is merely a pipe dream at this point. Well I'll at least have the Let's Play.
railbaron1 4 weeks ago
All respect to these people, but will there be an option to mute voice acting? Just if you wanted to keep it closer to the Edgeworth game.
cheercomposerxo 4 weeks ago
It seems all the videos showcasing voice actors seem to always have this funny theme around them. Enjoyed it. :D Great way to show them off too.
TwilightDash1 4 weeks ago
Hahaha, this is so silly! I love it! XD
SuperZalex 4 weeks ago
All the voices are great, in my opinion, but Sweetie Belle sounds kind of like Twist.
And: NO FLUTTERSHY!? NO APPLEJACK!?
Keep up the good work!
Sneider336 4 weeks ago 26
@Sneider336 Fluttershy and Applejack don't appear solely because they don't appear in case 1 either. I still love them and didn't forget about them, don't worry. :P
EquestrianDreamers 4 weeks ago 15
@Sneider336: The same; i thought she is twist for a second. On the other hoof, Applebloom's voice sounds almost exactly like the original.
piotrmil 3 weeks ago
@Sneider336
yep, i totally agree with Sweetie Belle sounding a bit like Twist. but apart from that, the voices are great.
D0mmac 3 weeks ago
Great choices except for Scootaloo and Sweetie Belle, both pitches are way too low and it seems like both have a lisp like too many teeth are missing.
Slashyx 4 weeks ago
Comment removed
Slashyx 4 weeks ago
If voice acting is to result in victory then you must act!
Sun tzooves said that
And I'd say and I'd say he knows a little more about pony voices than you do pal, because he invented them! And then he perfected them, so that no living pony could best him in the ring of friendship!
ZombieMonkey7 4 weeks ago 40
I LOVE THIS! :D
Skai2O 4 weeks ago
Comment removed
AnimeLoveoftheGods 4 weeks ago