She had me right up until the "AGE OF OBAMA" He has nothing to do with gay mariage, in fact he publicly admited being against it. However everything else she mentions is very good and I agree with her 1000% People need to stop putting false hope on Obama, he's also a st8 white man just like condoleezza rice. Which is the only reason he is where he is. Not because he has the experience or the skill.
Well, that's what she said. She said that Obama himself needs to start living in "the age of Obama." She acknowledged that he needs to get on board with the issue.
The violets in the mountains have broken the rocks. - great Tennessee Wms quote, i had not heard previously. thanks, Patricia, for being there for us!
When it comes to an injustice there is no such thing as relavance. Any human being, gay or straight, who speaks out against opression is surely relevant. Comments debating whether she is 'qualified' enough is the only thing of irrellevance. Proposition 8 was passed because a majority of the public, who were seemingly irrelevant to the issue of gay marriage, voted for it. Everyone who can vote, EVERY citizen of America, is therefore relevant. I am happy that such a respected woman is on our side.
I don't really know her as an actor and for me this speech sounds more like a Jay Leno monologue but she makes good points and she appears to be using her status to help us so I guess I agree that anyone who speaks up is relevant regardless of why they decide to make a speech.
I have to agree with FortunateSon87. This actor appears to be taking bows before the speech! Perhaps, this is a PR thing for her. Who knows...anyway, glad to have someone rooting regardless of motives.
She is a native New Orleanian and just happy to be home again. She had been mingling with EVERYONE and chatting ... You'd have to get to know her to make such a judgment about if she did or did not use this speech for PR. Fact is, famous people get heard .. and her message was pro-US gay people and therefore made a positive impact.
Hate is Un-Christlike. Hiding behind God to support violence against anyone is Un-Godlike. Men wrote the Bible and all men are flawed. We need to come out of the dark ages as a society and strive to evolve into people who love and behave peacefully. Any other goal as a society to exclude a type of person of basic human rights is a stifling us to stay in the dark ages. Love...pass it on!
Right ON RoxyLucy... this Algiers idiot thinks that because she stood up for something she must be it! What a total fool! Like she is supposed to fix everything all over the globe... reality check Algiers you are obsessed is right, with your own experience... it's not about Algiers here it's about the U.S. and it's Human Rights Laws... get with the picture you dope.
Algiers Obbsessed, there are injustice issues around the globe, and it isn't Patricia's job to fix them all, maybe it's yours. She is starting with one issue, and I would suspect it's better than you are doing ranting on and on about Algiers... that country has it's own resources and occupants to fight it's own issues, Patricia is fighting the ones within her OWN country... so get a grip...
Ms. Clarkson speaks so boldly about the fruits of love for all human beings, and I just wonder if that powerful rock that she mentions had any part in crushing the love that she had etched in her heart for this young, Bonafide, Certified, Heterosexual, African American MAN is what motivates and empowers her to now speak out about loving others inspite of their cultural, gender, or sexual orientation??? Hypocrisy! Hypocrisy! Hypocrisy!
Whew!! simply not tolerated in her community, and the peoples that be just might have had the dogs set out on you if you walked through Aurora as an African American man, woman or child as recently as the 1980's, when we were so ignorantly misled to think that we had a few human/civil rights. The beautiful violets in the rocks are colorful indeed, but are they alive?
Was he was exterminated? It appears that the "no questions no answer" doctrine that she speaks about is still playing out in solving his murder, oooh what dirty little secrets that the powerful rocks within that community can sweep under the rug! What a friend she is; and with the platform and political connections she has I have to wonder "why so hushed?" Was his name etched in her heart and crushed by that rock?
. Is it still a criminal offense warranting secret society punishment, against any black male who dares to accept the invitation of any form of friendship or relationship that would threaten or spoil the so called supreme status and ideals of the royal Clarkson plantation? By the way, I wonder what happened to that fine young African American man that Patricia dated from the lower Algiers community?
Talking about hypocrisy, hatred and falsehood! and being broken apart by a force.... Well, while Ms. Clarkson so eloquently and humorously speaks on gay rights issues. I just wonder when she will speak on the issues of hatred and violence that still permeates and rots from top to bottom in the apparently forgotten community of lower Algiers.
Patricia, you forget to mention the remnants of hatred that still hold fast in Algiers. A community that you frequented very often and lived within; the community so closely intertwined but separated by the very thing you speak about. Are the young straight African American males allowed to date or build any type of friendships with the Caucasian girls from the aurora subdivision of the lower Algiers community these days?
Well said sftenderloin... very well said... it's amazing isn't it how these religious people pay no taxes and then preach hate and intolerance and yet gay people get no break on their taxes yet have less equal rights? It just somehow doesn't seem "right?" I think maybe the religious right should lose their rights and pay double taxes... that might be a solution?
Gay and lesbian rights groups have voiced increasing dismay that their high hopes for the Obama administration remain unfulfilled so far.
The president has yet to follow through on a White House promise to end the ban on gays serving openly in the US military.
Obama has also said he believes marriage is a sacred union between a man and woman, though supports same-sex civil unions, and that he is a "fierce advocate" of gay and lesbian rights.
If he's a fierce advocate, then he should fiercly defend gay and lesbian people their rights to marriage otherwise give them half their taxes back... simple!
WASHINGTON (AFP) President Barack Obama will Wednesday extend some federal benefits to same-sex partners of US government workers, in a nod to an increasingly restive gay and lesbian community.
The president will sign an executive order in the Oval Office making the change, an administration official said on condition of anonymity, noting that the move would not extend to total health benefits.
Now If everyone will PLEASE pay attention to Obama... and these issues. Cause he's LOSING me fast, he's NOT behind this the way he said he would be! THIS IS IT...SPEAK UP EVERYONE...BE A VIOLET, OBAMA IS TURNING TO STONE. YELL,SCREAM ,CRY , SMILE , LOVE LOUD ON THESE ISSUES! MAKE SURE OBAMA HEARS YOU!!!
Look North of your border U.S.A. and around the globe. Stop being so insular. The world has grasped the reality that just because YOU don't approve doesn't make it right to deny someone else their rights. It just doesn't. Time to get on the train and make your leaders pay the price if they don't.
I don't trust HRC since their betrayal of Transgenders, and I always wonder at our fawning over movie stars rather than trusting in our own voices, but I've long loved Ms. Clarkson and she totally rocks here! Go, Patricia!
Brilliant. She and Newsweek are right - the train has already left the station on the issue of gay marriage, and Barack Obama has missed it. He wasn't even paying attention, and now because of it, hundreds have been discharged from the military. What a shameful thing to live with.
Bravo Patricia Clarkson. Such brilliance, compassion and humour all over that speech! And that funny remark about Condi Rice: "And a straight, white man named Condoleezza Rice." - a riot! Laugh out loud - for real!
I live in Canada where human rights have long been a much more fair issue... blacks, gays, etc. We never had segregation here, although some people may have thought we should have... it still was not "right," therefore it was not done. Gay people in Canada have equal marriage rights as of 2003, and although many a paranoid right winger thought it would deteriorate their family rights, their religious rights, and more... it hasn't changed a damn thing... so get with the times U.S.A. for equality!
Rango you are so right... they hypocrasy is amazing with the religious right... they restructure everything to suit their hate and then spew it at everyone hoping to control them... what is then that they are really afraid of... YES YOU GUESSED IT... THEMSELVES...
"The violets in the mountains have broken the rocks."
This is a sentence that anyone and everyone needs to repeat themselves and SEE, day in, day out, as they continue to lobby and forward this cause. To acknowledge a nay-sayer is to give him strength; I don't give him or her that right.
To want to reason with someone that sociologically damaged is to attempt to extract honey from Africanized bees---and that is how I see the religious mass. just because, and never seem to have a clear answer as to WHY we cannot be 100 per cent citizens of a quasi-modern country.
She strikes another truth that you and I and everyone who has the capacity to think have pondered about: it is appalling that the biblical-folk of all religions have a habit of twisting words to fit their own needs, but (as I said earlier) never have a clear answer on how to defend their beliefs because they "leave it up to God or Allah or Mohammed or even /Bubbles the Clown."
How it is possible that the Bible has all the horror that it has in its pages and allows the nonsense that it allows (check Deuteronomy for a chock-fulla examples, as well as Genesis) but then no one who preaches addresses them when questioned? Talks about stoning to death, concubines, slaves, even borderline child-brides (pedophilia) and incest, yet I, a gay man, cannot marry?
"The violets in the mountains have broken the rocks."
Such power in a simple poetic sentence. It's the sole reason I cannot---and no gay men, no gay woman, not you, not me, not ANYONE who acknowledges the simple rights we ask for---see this small loss of Prop 8 as a loss.
To acknowledge a loss is to magnify it.
This shall happen. I see it as a tangible FACT. While I may not ever marry---then again, who knows---I see my friends married all around the country, not just a smattering of states.
this world is changing w/ a doubt.. I am not sure i am ready for it.. I want to love those who do not agree w/ my politics and hope they will me - but i am not ready to drink the kool-aid.... Patricia needs to go back to Bible school.. Romans is clear about Homosexuality.. I will love the people (always) but not the sin - i am sorry... IF it is an abomination to God - it is to me as well... With that said - God is LOVE and He loves regardless of the sin!!!
I'm glad she mentioned the hypocrisy of divorce. The Bible is much more outspoken (and quite clear) about its opposition against divorce - particularly in 1 Corinthians - yet nobody's even thinking of trying to ban THAT.
WOW! Patricia Clarkson has always been my favorite actress! And for her to stand up to speak for human rights just shows how incredible and wonderful this woman is! She certainly have "balls"! Even took on Obama. What a gal!
FANTASTIC, Ms. Clarkson! 4 standing ovations for a funny, dramatically presented speech for EQUALITY! The Violets in the Mountains Have Broken the Rocks - the hard, the cold, the oppressive, will be broken by love and truth! THANK YOU PATRICIA!
Bla Bla Bla more words without action from HRC ...only thing missing was the RaRa Ra !!! Another Big HRC Peep Rally ....serving up more of the same ole HRC Kool Aide.
We don't want cretins to accept our "lifestyle". We just want you to slink off to your dark corners and nurse your hatred without making life miserable for everyone else.
Absolutely unbelievable speech! Patricia nailed all the major issues right on the head. I felt honoured to be in the presence of such an amazing poignant moment in GLBT history.
UNBELIEVABLE NIGHT!!! My partner and I were at the front table of this event. Though I currently work in the civil rights non-profit world, Patricia Clarkson ignited all of us to create the change we deserve and finally correct these injustices. Nowhere more appropriate to say it, to hear it and see it than New Orleans!!!
UNBELIEVABLE NIGHT!!! My partner and I were at the front table of this event. Though I currently work in the civil rights non-profit world, Patricia Clarkson ignited all of us to create the change we deserve and finally correct these injustices. Nowhere more appropriate to say it, to hear it and see it than New Orleans!!!
I attended the dinner and heard the speech. I wasn't expecting to be moved but I was. Her timing was impeccable. She was hilarious at one moment and went for the jugular the next. She was inspiring and, more importantly, she was right. We pay tax money for services but can't get the wedding certificate we pay for.
That was me in the white suit with the pearl tie......
I know who she is, I don't know how she's relevant. Like I said, I tried to find out, but it appears she's never done anything for the GLBT community except say a few nice words.
As many of you are learning with Obama, talk is nice, but action is what we need.
She played a lesbian (Ally Sheedy's lover) in the movie High Art, an iconic lesbian film. Many xs HRC has ppl speak who are not gay in real life but who have portrayed gays/lesbians in TV & film(such as Jennifer Beals who was in the L Word). If they are advocates for the GLBT community in real life they have every right to make a speech & a few nice words can go a long way. yes actions speak louder than words but don't discount the impact that ppl speaking out in support of gay rights can make.
I don't "discount" vocal support in the arts completely, but I do *compare* them to the actions of those of us who have actually made serious sacrifices and have been in the fray of this civil rights battle.
And of course, I never said anything about her "right" nor HRC's "right" to have her speak at the event. I just prefer substance over lip service.
Even if she did write the speech, which I doubt, it's nothing that any of us didn't already know. She's preaching to the choir. It's pointless.
Alrighty I was mostly just commenting to say why HRC might have found her to be relevant to make a speech.I am really not on here to debate w/ anyone, you are entitled to your opinion. My personal opinion is that anyone who lends their support in any way shape or form to help our movement is doing something positive and productive. And the speech sounded pretty heartfelt and personal to me. I didn't find it pointless, I found it moving. But that's me. Just my two cents.
Yeah it absolutely is positive. I'm not saying she's worthless; I'm saying she's not *as* worthy as many of the other prospects out there.
To me, if someone's speaking at an event like this it's because that person has real experience and/or some wisdom to impart, and sometimes to inspire. But this was just a speech saying everything we already know. It's a great speech to be given to a crowd of people who AREN'T already 100% on our side.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
No I didn't listen to this speech, I've heard enough empty speeches.
Meanwhile, CNN reports on the HRC's buddies in power:
"A former Army captain who was dismissed under a federal law dealing with gays and lesbians in the military lost his appeal Monday at the U.S. Supreme Court.... The Obama administration had asked the high court not to take the case, and White House officials had said they would not object to homosexuals being kicked out of the armed services."
You didn't listen to the speech .... then your comments on it are completely invalid ... and your comment regarding CNN has nothing to do with this video of a brilliant and poignant speech ...
This speech was in New Orleans. Maybe "they" are "smug" in LA in New York .. I can only speak for my town ... we are hard-working, equality-loving people, so I don't think you know what you're talking about in the least. No one cried or whined at this dinner.
I did listen to the speech and it was great. That being said, I agree with Sub for the most part. The HRC has lost a lot of credibility with average queers. They supposedly have Obama's ear, do something with it. I am saying this as someone who has supported our current leader every way I could and still do but it is time for him to be the "fierce advocate" he promised he would be and it is time for the HRC to be more than just empty rhetoric.
A genuine actress with a genuine heart!!!!! I love you Patricia!!!!
kidneythief91 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
kidneythief91 2 weeks ago
What an amazing, encouraging speech. Thank you, Patricia <3
chambersdawn84 1 month ago
Comment removed
chambersdawn84 1 month ago
Shes awesome!
AvalonJoyous666 2 months ago
I love this woman for her acting, sense of humor and open mind!! Thank you Patricia Clarkson!!
You Are fantastic!!!
Aleja741 2 months ago 2
I love every character she plays. She was good as Ms. Ness and in Green Mile
Talljim01 3 months ago
I love her!
warriorsoul79 4 months ago
Patricia Clarkson is a flawless human being and I adore her beyond reason.
simplystreeptacular 4 months ago 4
Does she write her own speeches? She did a great job of weaving the same visual image throughout the speech. That was a very moving speech.
library1966 9 months ago
I love this woman what a great speech what a great actress what a great person.
cto69 1 year ago 2
LOVE her
actuallyadam 1 year ago 2
I love her! White straight man George Bush (...) white straight man Condoleezza Rice. And yes, she is so right in this speech.
alyvvie 1 year ago
is that emblem for bi sexual people??
HugoIStayHere 1 year ago
Wow, Patricia is an amazing woman. Her speech is magnificent. If only this was shown to the bigots.
TheIceyeddy 1 year ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
blah blah blaaaah
jammyjo610 2 years ago
I love this woman
funsize 2 years ago 27
@funsize -
Me, too. She's got a lot of class, both professionally and as a human being.
TreblePop 2 years ago 4
She had me right up until the "AGE OF OBAMA" He has nothing to do with gay mariage, in fact he publicly admited being against it. However everything else she mentions is very good and I agree with her 1000% People need to stop putting false hope on Obama, he's also a st8 white man just like condoleezza rice. Which is the only reason he is where he is. Not because he has the experience or the skill.
pgruver 2 years ago
Well, that's what she said. She said that Obama himself needs to start living in "the age of Obama." She acknowledged that he needs to get on board with the issue.
DancinDiva925 2 years ago 6
pgruver, that's why she said "The person who needs to realize we are in the age of Obama IS Obama. He can not fall right on this issue."
Thewaiter525600 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Lakeside Lovers - _BADXXXCHICKS._COM_
MURPHYHoliday4589 2 years ago 3
The violets in the mountains have broken the rocks. - great Tennessee Wms quote, i had not heard previously. thanks, Patricia, for being there for us!
wsguyinsf 2 years ago
When it comes to an injustice there is no such thing as relavance. Any human being, gay or straight, who speaks out against opression is surely relevant. Comments debating whether she is 'qualified' enough is the only thing of irrellevance. Proposition 8 was passed because a majority of the public, who were seemingly irrelevant to the issue of gay marriage, voted for it. Everyone who can vote, EVERY citizen of America, is therefore relevant. I am happy that such a respected woman is on our side.
beazkneaz 2 years ago
I don't really know her as an actor and for me this speech sounds more like a Jay Leno monologue but she makes good points and she appears to be using her status to help us so I guess I agree that anyone who speaks up is relevant regardless of why they decide to make a speech.
MrTwilightone 2 years ago
You speak the truth, bea.
We ALL have a voice, so USE IT! That is how things get changed. We may be a small group, but we are a vocal one. And we will not be silenced.
RapscallionRebellion 2 years ago 3
I have to agree with FortunateSon87. This actor appears to be taking bows before the speech! Perhaps, this is a PR thing for her. Who knows...anyway, glad to have someone rooting regardless of motives.
MrTwilightone 2 years ago
She is a native New Orleanian and just happy to be home again. She had been mingling with EVERYONE and chatting ... You'd have to get to know her to make such a judgment about if she did or did not use this speech for PR. Fact is, famous people get heard .. and her message was pro-US gay people and therefore made a positive impact.
Devalmont2 2 years ago
Just watched one of her film also..you're right. She is a fantastic actor and can bow whenever she wants to. with that talent she's allowed!!
Uliprc 2 years ago 4
Algiers is not in another country it is a section of New Orleans. Ms. Clarkson is from New Orleans.
MrTwilightone 2 years ago
Hate is Un-Christlike. Hiding behind God to support violence against anyone is Un-Godlike. Men wrote the Bible and all men are flawed. We need to come out of the dark ages as a society and strive to evolve into people who love and behave peacefully. Any other goal as a society to exclude a type of person of basic human rights is a stifling us to stay in the dark ages. Love...pass it on!
bronzjag 2 years ago
she is hot.
sarahshi8 2 years ago 2
Right ON RoxyLucy... this Algiers idiot thinks that because she stood up for something she must be it! What a total fool! Like she is supposed to fix everything all over the globe... reality check Algiers you are obsessed is right, with your own experience... it's not about Algiers here it's about the U.S. and it's Human Rights Laws... get with the picture you dope.
DivaForeverDiana 2 years ago 2
Algiers Obbsessed, there are injustice issues around the globe, and it isn't Patricia's job to fix them all, maybe it's yours. She is starting with one issue, and I would suspect it's better than you are doing ranting on and on about Algiers... that country has it's own resources and occupants to fight it's own issues, Patricia is fighting the ones within her OWN country... so get a grip...
ROXYLUCY 2 years ago
Comment removed
TheAlgiersjustice 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Family Politickin!!
TheAlgiersjustice 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Ms. Clarkson speaks so boldly about the fruits of love for all human beings, and I just wonder if that powerful rock that she mentions had any part in crushing the love that she had etched in her heart for this young, Bonafide, Certified, Heterosexual, African American MAN is what motivates and empowers her to now speak out about loving others inspite of their cultural, gender, or sexual orientation??? Hypocrisy! Hypocrisy! Hypocrisy!
TheAlgiersjustice 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Whew!! simply not tolerated in her community, and the peoples that be just might have had the dogs set out on you if you walked through Aurora as an African American man, woman or child as recently as the 1980's, when we were so ignorantly misled to think that we had a few human/civil rights. The beautiful violets in the rocks are colorful indeed, but are they alive?
TheAlgiersjustice 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Was he was exterminated? It appears that the "no questions no answer" doctrine that she speaks about is still playing out in solving his murder, oooh what dirty little secrets that the powerful rocks within that community can sweep under the rug! What a friend she is; and with the platform and political connections she has I have to wonder "why so hushed?" Was his name etched in her heart and crushed by that rock?
TheAlgiersjustice 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
. Is it still a criminal offense warranting secret society punishment, against any black male who dares to accept the invitation of any form of friendship or relationship that would threaten or spoil the so called supreme status and ideals of the royal Clarkson plantation? By the way, I wonder what happened to that fine young African American man that Patricia dated from the lower Algiers community?
TheAlgiersjustice 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Talking about hypocrisy, hatred and falsehood! and being broken apart by a force.... Well, while Ms. Clarkson so eloquently and humorously speaks on gay rights issues. I just wonder when she will speak on the issues of hatred and violence that still permeates and rots from top to bottom in the apparently forgotten community of lower Algiers.
TheAlgiersjustice 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Patricia, you forget to mention the remnants of hatred that still hold fast in Algiers. A community that you frequented very often and lived within; the community so closely intertwined but separated by the very thing you speak about. Are the young straight African American males allowed to date or build any type of friendships with the Caucasian girls from the aurora subdivision of the lower Algiers community these days?
TheAlgiersjustice 2 years ago
Obama will have us in another war real soon.
utubefavorsdems 2 years ago
I love how she stood up to religious pastors in their "multi-million dollar mega churches advocating for our damnation!" They can suck it!
sftenderloin 2 years ago
Well said sftenderloin... very well said... it's amazing isn't it how these religious people pay no taxes and then preach hate and intolerance and yet gay people get no break on their taxes yet have less equal rights? It just somehow doesn't seem "right?" I think maybe the religious right should lose their rights and pay double taxes... that might be a solution?
ROXYLUCY 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
So what, is Patricia a lesbian now? no disrespect intended.
TheAlgiersjustice 2 years ago
Gay and lesbian rights groups have voiced increasing dismay that their high hopes for the Obama administration remain unfulfilled so far.
The president has yet to follow through on a White House promise to end the ban on gays serving openly in the US military.
Obama has also said he believes marriage is a sacred union between a man and woman, though supports same-sex civil unions, and that he is a "fierce advocate" of gay and lesbian rights.
maxxatl 2 years ago 2
If he's a fierce advocate, then he should fiercly defend gay and lesbian people their rights to marriage otherwise give them half their taxes back... simple!
ROXYLUCY 2 years ago
WASHINGTON (AFP) President Barack Obama will Wednesday extend some federal benefits to same-sex partners of US government workers, in a nod to an increasingly restive gay and lesbian community.
The president will sign an executive order in the Oval Office making the change, an administration official said on condition of anonymity, noting that the move would not extend to total health benefits.
maxxatl 2 years ago
PERFECT!
Now If everyone will PLEASE pay attention to Obama... and these issues. Cause he's LOSING me fast, he's NOT behind this the way he said he would be! THIS IS IT...SPEAK UP EVERYONE...BE A VIOLET, OBAMA IS TURNING TO STONE. YELL,SCREAM ,CRY , SMILE , LOVE LOUD ON THESE ISSUES! MAKE SURE OBAMA HEARS YOU!!!
maxxatl 2 years ago 4
Look North of your border U.S.A. and around the globe. Stop being so insular. The world has grasped the reality that just because YOU don't approve doesn't make it right to deny someone else their rights. It just doesn't. Time to get on the train and make your leaders pay the price if they don't.
ROXYLUCY 2 years ago
I don't trust HRC since their betrayal of Transgenders, and I always wonder at our fawning over movie stars rather than trusting in our own voices, but I've long loved Ms. Clarkson and she totally rocks here! Go, Patricia!
JackFertig 2 years ago
Amazing.
crazitenniskid 2 years ago 4
Brilliant. She and Newsweek are right - the train has already left the station on the issue of gay marriage, and Barack Obama has missed it. He wasn't even paying attention, and now because of it, hundreds have been discharged from the military. What a shameful thing to live with.
Bravo Patricia Clarkson. Such brilliance, compassion and humour all over that speech! And that funny remark about Condi Rice: "And a straight, white man named Condoleezza Rice." - a riot! Laugh out loud - for real!
fashionista444 2 years ago 6
She really is brilliant.
cclovesyoutoob 2 years ago 5
Comment removed
jl1100 2 years ago
Comment removed
PartialBystander 2 years ago
That was a great speech. If only more people thought like you do...
brandoneggar 2 years ago 3
Love the violets story!!! Way to go Patricia!! I posted this on my blog, shared via twitter, MySpace & Facebook. Great speech
alohalondon 2 years ago 4
Fantastic speech!
Rock on, violets :)
Mams31383 2 years ago 2
I live in Canada where human rights have long been a much more fair issue... blacks, gays, etc. We never had segregation here, although some people may have thought we should have... it still was not "right," therefore it was not done. Gay people in Canada have equal marriage rights as of 2003, and although many a paranoid right winger thought it would deteriorate their family rights, their religious rights, and more... it hasn't changed a damn thing... so get with the times U.S.A. for equality!
ROXYLUCY 2 years ago 5
Besides being an accomplished and fascinating actress, a great human being.
Thanks Miss Clarkson for being yourself.
Thank you for sharing beauty!
coaragdlm 2 years ago 6
great speech, very stiring...
Eltoca21 2 years ago 5
She is just brilliant.
Androjai 2 years ago 3
Rango you are so right... they hypocrasy is amazing with the religious right... they restructure everything to suit their hate and then spew it at everyone hoping to control them... what is then that they are really afraid of... YES YOU GUESSED IT... THEMSELVES...
ROXYLUCY 2 years ago 3
"The violets in the mountains have broken the rocks."
This is a sentence that anyone and everyone needs to repeat themselves and SEE, day in, day out, as they continue to lobby and forward this cause. To acknowledge a nay-sayer is to give him strength; I don't give him or her that right.
Rango9 2 years ago
To want to reason with someone that sociologically damaged is to attempt to extract honey from Africanized bees---and that is how I see the religious mass. just because, and never seem to have a clear answer as to WHY we cannot be 100 per cent citizens of a quasi-modern country.
Rango9 2 years ago
She strikes another truth that you and I and everyone who has the capacity to think have pondered about: it is appalling that the biblical-folk of all religions have a habit of twisting words to fit their own needs, but (as I said earlier) never have a clear answer on how to defend their beliefs because they "leave it up to God or Allah or Mohammed or even /Bubbles the Clown."
Rango9 2 years ago
How it is possible that the Bible has all the horror that it has in its pages and allows the nonsense that it allows (check Deuteronomy for a chock-fulla examples, as well as Genesis) but then no one who preaches addresses them when questioned? Talks about stoning to death, concubines, slaves, even borderline child-brides (pedophilia) and incest, yet I, a gay man, cannot marry?
Rango9 2 years ago
Why?... Read More
Because marriage is defined by 'state' as that of a man and a woman?
Nope.
Love is love. And religion is eyeball-deep in the wrong, eyes wide shut.
Rango9 2 years ago
"The violets in the mountains have broken the rocks."
Such power in a simple poetic sentence. It's the sole reason I cannot---and no gay men, no gay woman, not you, not me, not ANYONE who acknowledges the simple rights we ask for---see this small loss of Prop 8 as a loss.
To acknowledge a loss is to magnify it.
This shall happen. I see it as a tangible FACT. While I may not ever marry---then again, who knows---I see my friends married all around the country, not just a smattering of states.
Rango9 2 years ago
The essence of this video is summed up in one neat little phrase:
"The violets in the mountains have broken the rocks."
Rango9 2 years ago
this world is changing w/ a doubt.. I am not sure i am ready for it.. I want to love those who do not agree w/ my politics and hope they will me - but i am not ready to drink the kool-aid.... Patricia needs to go back to Bible school.. Romans is clear about Homosexuality.. I will love the people (always) but not the sin - i am sorry... IF it is an abomination to God - it is to me as well... With that said - God is LOVE and He loves regardless of the sin!!!
meszolis 2 years ago
Home run, amazed at someone who does righteous indignation so much better than my (far more obscure) self.
tkdcoach 2 years ago
One of the greatest speeches on gay marriage I've ever heard, and one of the most FUN serious speeches I've heard period.
friscowala 2 years ago
Thank you so much Patricia, for laying the facts on the line... we pay taxes, we get pissed on in return and denied our human rights... enough!
ROXYLUCY 2 years ago
I'm glad she mentioned the hypocrisy of divorce. The Bible is much more outspoken (and quite clear) about its opposition against divorce - particularly in 1 Corinthians - yet nobody's even thinking of trying to ban THAT.
johnbohl 2 years ago
"Straight white man...CONDOLEZZA ..." hahahahahahahahahh
championxeneixe 2 years ago
WOW! Patricia Clarkson has always been my favorite actress! And for her to stand up to speak for human rights just shows how incredible and wonderful this woman is! She certainly have "balls"! Even took on Obama. What a gal!
CarlaFreakFreak 2 years ago
Oratory Update: Reagan and Obama kicked to the curb.
jlpogwc 2 years ago
Wow, what an amazing speech. THANK YOU PATRICIA!!!
sms1777 2 years ago
the speech is too good!
danijel223 2 years ago
I heart Patricia.
CarbonFilmsInc 2 years ago
this is great...
allisongeddie 2 years ago
Everyone get on the train
softlandiing7 2 years ago 2
lol "if jesus made good furniture, every gay man in nazareth knew him."
0g0c0b0 2 years ago
Patricia is phenomenal!
MendocinoCoastFilms2 2 years ago 2
i kind of love this.
no, i really love this. end of story.
technicolor444 2 years ago 4
Um, PERFECTION.
roryfreedman 2 years ago
FANTASTIC, Ms. Clarkson! 4 standing ovations for a funny, dramatically presented speech for EQUALITY! The Violets in the Mountains Have Broken the Rocks - the hard, the cold, the oppressive, will be broken by love and truth! THANK YOU PATRICIA!
I am grateful to have heard her in person!
4thespacebetween 2 years ago
Bla Bla Bla more words without action from HRC ...only thing missing was the RaRa Ra !!! Another Big HRC Peep Rally ....serving up more of the same ole HRC Kool Aide.
Brandi Parker
sweetbrandigirl 2 years ago
I don't think mocking and belittling Christians is the best way to get them to accept your lifestyle.
korrdxl 2 years ago
She was funny.
Christians with a sense of humour will laugh with her, for they will sense her humane sensibility, and her deliciously funny exaggerations.
TecoloteOne 2 years ago 2
We don't want cretins to accept our "lifestyle". We just want you to slink off to your dark corners and nurse your hatred without making life miserable for everyone else.
Azzenstudent 2 years ago
and denying gays their civil rights and condemning them to hell won't make them disappear or "turn" them straight either.
GirlsThatWearBlue 2 years ago
And what do you think hating gays is going to do for you?
TheDesperateHodges 2 years ago
I don't hate gays.
korrdxl 2 years ago
PATRICIA IS INCREDIBLE & if YOU HAVENT SEEN HER IN "HIGH ART"....MMM...YOU DEFINITELY SHOULD!
JO *_*
AKMCGRATH 2 years ago
"there will be no marriage in the kingdom of heaven."
--j. christ
blackwaternorth 2 years ago
AWESOME!
mericship 2 years ago 4
Witty, classy and incredibly true! Fantastic speach Patricia Clarkson!
denveraztec 2 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Another gay speech....boring!!!
spareaxe 2 years ago
Boring? Are you kidding me? Get the wax out your ears! And it wasn't a a "gay" speech .. it was a speech about equality and equal rights.
Devalmont2 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
-_- Another Youtube retard....boring!!!
JaydeeVonJ 2 years ago
Comment removed
Devalmont2 2 years ago
So who's gotten it to Rachel Maddow...And Big Daddy's to get the swing ready...?
postwarbrit 2 years ago 2
She is brilliant!
mrsdalloway0189 2 years ago 6
Absolutely unbelievable speech! Patricia nailed all the major issues right on the head. I felt honoured to be in the presence of such an amazing poignant moment in GLBT history.
theladyvernotico 2 years ago 6
UNBELIEVABLE NIGHT!!! My partner and I were at the front table of this event. Though I currently work in the civil rights non-profit world, Patricia Clarkson ignited all of us to create the change we deserve and finally correct these injustices. Nowhere more appropriate to say it, to hear it and see it than New Orleans!!!
We love you Patricia!
postwarbrit 2 years ago 8
UNBELIEVABLE NIGHT!!! My partner and I were at the front table of this event. Though I currently work in the civil rights non-profit world, Patricia Clarkson ignited all of us to create the change we deserve and finally correct these injustices. Nowhere more appropriate to say it, to hear it and see it than New Orleans!!!
We love you Patricia!
postwarbrit 2 years ago 8
I attended the dinner and heard the speech. I wasn't expecting to be moved but I was. Her timing was impeccable. She was hilarious at one moment and went for the jugular the next. She was inspiring and, more importantly, she was right. We pay tax money for services but can't get the wedding certificate we pay for.
That was me in the white suit with the pearl tie......
PunaGlen 2 years ago 8
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this is a stupid pointless speech though..
I don't even know who this person is. i googled but it just said she did a couple movies here and there..
this stuff is so stupid. HRC isn't being self-congratulatory. this woman is. she seems to think she's soooo wonderful because she's pro-gay. stupid.
and she quotes all this stupid shit that we all already know.
and fuck her stereotypical bull shit too.
FortunateSon87 2 years ago
She's an Oscar nominated and Emmy winning actress. The fact that YOU don't know who she is, doesn't make her irrelevant.
TheDesperateHodges 2 years ago 15
I know who she is, I don't know how she's relevant. Like I said, I tried to find out, but it appears she's never done anything for the GLBT community except say a few nice words.
As many of you are learning with Obama, talk is nice, but action is what we need.
FortunateSon87 2 years ago
She played a lesbian (Ally Sheedy's lover) in the movie High Art, an iconic lesbian film. Many xs HRC has ppl speak who are not gay in real life but who have portrayed gays/lesbians in TV & film(such as Jennifer Beals who was in the L Word). If they are advocates for the GLBT community in real life they have every right to make a speech & a few nice words can go a long way. yes actions speak louder than words but don't discount the impact that ppl speaking out in support of gay rights can make.
Gigi8877 2 years ago 3
I don't "discount" vocal support in the arts completely, but I do *compare* them to the actions of those of us who have actually made serious sacrifices and have been in the fray of this civil rights battle.
And of course, I never said anything about her "right" nor HRC's "right" to have her speak at the event. I just prefer substance over lip service.
Even if she did write the speech, which I doubt, it's nothing that any of us didn't already know. She's preaching to the choir. It's pointless.
FortunateSon87 2 years ago
Alrighty I was mostly just commenting to say why HRC might have found her to be relevant to make a speech.I am really not on here to debate w/ anyone, you are entitled to your opinion. My personal opinion is that anyone who lends their support in any way shape or form to help our movement is doing something positive and productive. And the speech sounded pretty heartfelt and personal to me. I didn't find it pointless, I found it moving. But that's me. Just my two cents.
Gigi8877 2 years ago
Yeah it absolutely is positive. I'm not saying she's worthless; I'm saying she's not *as* worthy as many of the other prospects out there.
To me, if someone's speaking at an event like this it's because that person has real experience and/or some wisdom to impart, and sometimes to inspire. But this was just a speech saying everything we already know. It's a great speech to be given to a crowd of people who AREN'T already 100% on our side.
FortunateSon87 2 years ago
Excellent speech. The violets in the mountains have broken the rocks.
marygriggs 2 years ago 4
This was awesome! I was there the room was on fire! Patricia Clarkson was beyond great this is going to be a youtube classic!
cdavidwilburn 2 years ago 5
Sub, did you even listen to this speech before you posted your vileness? What are YOU doing to make this country a better place?
Devalmont2 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
No I didn't listen to this speech, I've heard enough empty speeches.
Meanwhile, CNN reports on the HRC's buddies in power:
"A former Army captain who was dismissed under a federal law dealing with gays and lesbians in the military lost his appeal Monday at the U.S. Supreme Court.... The Obama administration had asked the high court not to take the case, and White House officials had said they would not object to homosexuals being kicked out of the armed services."
SubmarinerAndroid 2 years ago
You didn't listen to the speech .... then your comments on it are completely invalid ... and your comment regarding CNN has nothing to do with this video of a brilliant and poignant speech ...
Devalmont2 2 years ago
They have long since stopped being worth listening to. They are a shitstorm of fail.
They just need to be destroyed so real, grassroots no-corporate activists can be heard.
The HRC represents a few well-to-do smug gays in NY and LA and no one else.
SubmarinerAndroid 2 years ago
I'm behind you on this Submariner-it is time we stop whining and crying about DOMA laws and prop 8's and start standing up and being heard.
sunfighter86 2 years ago 3
Thank you.
SubmarinerAndroid 2 years ago
Patricia calls Obama on his wavering to stand up for us!
Devalmont2 2 years ago
This speech was in New Orleans. Maybe "they" are "smug" in LA in New York .. I can only speak for my town ... we are hard-working, equality-loving people, so I don't think you know what you're talking about in the least. No one cried or whined at this dinner.
Devalmont2 2 years ago
I did listen to the speech and it was great. That being said, I agree with Sub for the most part. The HRC has lost a lot of credibility with average queers. They supposedly have Obama's ear, do something with it. I am saying this as someone who has supported our current leader every way I could and still do but it is time for him to be the "fierce advocate" he promised he would be and it is time for the HRC to be more than just empty rhetoric.
Soulkeeper65 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
you're right! HRC should have supported McCain!!!
not really.
FortunateSon87 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Just more self-congratulatory Hollywood crap from the HRC
The HRC is a parasite whose days are numbered
And btw fuck Melissa Etheridge too
SubmarinerAndroid 2 years ago