Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (242)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I dont understand.... I dont see what the hype is about her. Celine will always own this girl. In every way. Her voice is mediocre and many singers would destroy her vocally. I think the biggest reason shes famous is because shes not a typical pop singer. (Beautiful with a thin body) I mean Im an advocate for everybody to sing but I just dont see why this girl is making millions, and there are better singers out there not making it. Pity. Congratulations I suppose, Susan Boyle.

  • Legends like Michael jackson and Celine dion you never try to compete with

  • Céline Dion > Susane Boyle

  • Piers is so lame. Who gives a shit about his faxing on. Such a faker.

  • Lovely woman and perfect the way she is. I like her version but Celine owns that song inside and out. =)

  • She's got guts to sing that song, because everyone in the world would compete her with Celine Dion. She might have sang it a little fast, but that is only because she did not have the music in the background to follow.

  • pause at 2:40 and see what it says on the bottom update as she sings the stupid song

  • heý_ÀNY_gÚys_wÀÑt_tø_chåt_wïth­_mÊ

  • she sings it too fast 

  • made my day!!! thanks downloadmusic .im

  • nobody's version of My Heart Will Go On will ever be better than Celine Dion's but Susan Boyle's voice is beautiful

  • i love susan but i still love love celine dion version better.

  • If I were Susan which, I'm not unfortunately,I'd refuse all interviews and I'd only sing on stage with the proper setting. People should stop dwelling on her looks as if all those sex pots today look any better-they look and act like whores, the lot of them. Now here's a person with dignity and should be treated so. I love her eyes, there so expressive and I'd rather see her sing any day.

  • Susan's voice is so incredible!!!! Her sweet and charming personality makes her even more appealing!!!! :) I'd love to hear her sing Via Dolorosa by Sandi Pati.

  • LARRY KING? WHOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO?????????

  • Clearly, Susan is much better than Celine Dion. No doubt!!!!

  • @isaul07 It´s joke, right?

  • And to be honest, does anybody remember who won the Supertalent 2009? She was "only" second...

  • I think that's really, really rude! I wanted to kill myself listening to that..

  • cette video ne sert a rien pour youtube cet une honte !! =)

  • For people to criticise the acopella performance with no music backing her just show that they really don't understand how hard this is to do. I try singing in my car with the radio and find it almost impossible to stay on key, and for Susan to sing on live TV and give a near perfect performance is truely amazing and should be praised instead of put down. Celine probably enjoyed this spur of the moment performance just as much as the majority of people who listen to it. Leave susan alone.

  • @ClemTigers77 I agree with you 100%

  • Piers Morgan is a prat.

  • Please people!!!!! Stop with the negativity!!!!!! I am a Celine Fanatic and I dont have the need to put her down....Susan has a very powerful and beautiful voice...she has a proper operatic voice that many modern pop stars can only dream of....She is unique and yes she is different....but no where at all below average or untalented...she is a gem...So lets stop with the negativity.....there's no need for it. Grow up!!!!

  • she reminds me of Julia Child

  • Susan Boyle têm voz e talento, mas não se esqueçam de que ela está na mídia há pouco mais de um ano ( 1 ano gente), essas outras cantoras estão aí desde o tempo dos dinossauros. Susan Boyle é bonita e nasceu com um dom que muitas nem com o tempo de treino que têm vão chegar perto dela...A Voz...O Timbre que a diferencia das demais. Desde que nasci que ouço Celine Dion cantando essa música do Titanic.

  • Please don't ever sing that song again!!! Thank you!

  • @82celinedion82

    Desculpe-me, mas você têm algum problema auditivo?

  • I really like Susan but Celine's voice is SO MUCH better!

  • I just dont get it she has a very below average voice when u think of all the fantastic female stars such as celine dion whitney houston natalie cole shirley bassey and many more she murdered my heart will go on it was fucking naff pure shit

  • No one can be better than Celine ! This song can be sung only by Celine!

  • If she's messing up on the lyrics, then why don't you go on live television with your singing voice and perform on the spot? Stop critizing her. Gosh.

  • What a gem of a woman, to have that unwavering courage to stand in front of thousands of cynical people who were stupid enough to judge her and make fun of her before she even opened her mouth. I frown upon those who STILL judge her just because she's not the stereotypical pretty lady. She is living proof that it's never too late to chase your dreams, so at least they should respect her for that.

  • she got her shot alright, and it was SO worth it! Way to Go Ms. Boyle,

  • she messed up the lyrics.....

  • @bearcat6800

    impromptu, no warm up, no prep, and we expect perfection?

  • @mkayk55 ....if you were going to sing anything on tv, wouldnt you make sure if was something you knew very well?...she did a good job, dont get me wrong, she just messed the lyrics up

  • Susan Boyle is adorable in her simplicity. No music. Just her beautiful voice. Considering where she is coming from... pleeeeease.... let's be fair here. Celine Dion is an accomplished singer. Susan is a "home made" talent with learning challenges... No comparition. Celine is a godess. Susan is a humbled human being . Both wonderful in their own way. God bless both.

  • meagan660 Celine has had alot of years with vocial coachs dont get me wrong Celine has a very powerfull voice I have been a fan of Celines for many years and I dont think anyone can sing My Heart Will Go On as well as Celine. But lets give Susan a chance she has only just begun.

  • Everyone, please quit comparing this version to Celine. At least until Susan officially produces this song on an album or live with an orchestra like Celine does. You can't compare someone who is singing in her living room in this video against something that has been prodcued in a studio to sound perfect like Celine's well played rendition. Don;t get me wrong, I like Celine's siging very much, but let's make sure we compare apples to apples.

  • I hate her

  • I totally agree with shanc1978 xD

  • really a big joke

  • @kevinatlarge

    lotta people no longer laughing.

  • She has a good voice, but she's no Celine Dion. =)

  • Susan is good, but Céline is so much better than her!

  • too much vibrato i think... but the overal performance was good..

  • celine the best

  • no one cancompete to celine dions voice. shes the best.

  • Susan boyle ahah Celine Dion So far!!!

    Susan it's very good but she is bored!

  • This version can stand on equal footing with Roberta Flack's version.

  • she made it  her own! and i'm the biggest celine dion fan.

  • I prefer Susan. Although I have a problem understanding Susan's English when she speaks because of her accent, when she sings her English is totally clear & understandable. With Celine, I have the opposite problem -- I understand her when she speaks, but cannot make out the words when she sings.

  • I perfer Celine Dion!!!

  • I perfer Celine. CELINE IS THE BEST!

  • this movie at best-watch-movies(  . )c om now

  • This is great i dont think the title should be competing against Celine because Celine is better it is her song.......they are both great in your own ways....They really can not be compared Celine has been a professinal singer for a lot longer than Susan has personally I perfer Celine.....but Susan is great

  • thats so sad the first thing she says :(

  • SUSAN WE WANT YOU!

  • I wanna hear her record a studio version of "My Love will Go On"

  • Long live Queen Susan de Boyle of Scotland! The Scottish monarchy's back! Learn Scottish history free from the Historyscoper. See my profile for the url.

  • i hope she comes out with some new video songs because i like her live for some reason -but with the music too. over the rainbow would be good -its over 20 yrs since willie nelson did it

  • Susan iS THE FEMALE VERSION OF pIERS!!!

  • Fast forward to her upcoming July 20th and July 22nd NBC viewings of Susan's interview with Meredith Vieira's interview with the poised Susan Boyle, in her lovely purple business suit and makeup. Susan, I love your "BRUSH UP"! And if any of you have not followed her stunning vocal performances (and glamous looks) of her BGT tour...you have no clue as to what you have been missing! ~Trish (Pat Pierce)

  • She seemed so happy at this time in her life. I do hope she experiences this same happiness and more in her future... She probably thought once she was recognized as a professional singer, the bullies would go away. Little did she realize the cruel and evil critics were waiting on the side lines to attack and get their kicks upon an innocent soul who wanted to please people. In this case, Susan simply wanted to sing and be liked. I don't expect everyone to like her, but leave the cruelty behind.

  • I have to tell you, that when Larry was asking her about changing her appearance, if Piers had not said "quite right" when she said, "why should I change, it would change my identity" larry would have comment more on about why she should change her looks.

  • U can never top Celine's version

  • exatly

  • I like her Scottish accent, it's totally adorable!

  • Its so cute!!! Its like she'a singing it to Piers!!! What if they became a couple!!

  • I love this! thank you!

  • susan is a grand singer, she is phenominal!

  • I'm almost certain that she would have won BGT 2009 if she would have sung this song!

  • My skin turns cold every time I hear her sing this. Not only no accompaniment but no warm-up or even mental preparation to get herself together.

    Amazing.

  • Celine is a fabulous singer. However, I have never heard hear sing without music sitting in her living room. Until that happens (unlikely) I can not judge who is the better singer. We've never heard Susan sing in a studio where everything is enhanced and you can do it over and over until it is perfect.

  • con mi tia antonia en ecuador te felicitamos tenias que haber ganado

  • º¤ø„...ø¤º° ¸„ø¤º°¨¸„ø¤º°¨

    ¨°º¤ø„¸ GO SUSAN ¸„ø¤º° copy and paste

    ¸„ø¤º°"" BOYLE !!!!! °°º¤ø„¸. if you think

    ¸„ø¤º°¨¸„ø¤º°¨¨°º¤ø„¸¨°º¤„¸, Susan is the best

  • and Celine's performance song was enhanced in the studio and mixed.......

    hello..............

  • susans way better

  • its hard to take that comment seriously when you're obviously a hardcore fan of Celines lol

  • i agree.... this Susan Boyle bitch, I mean hearing that voice sing  made me forget that I am:::: unemployed, uneducated, unworthy, unimportant, unwilling and just a plain loser! GO Suzie!!!

  • She has a wonderful and delicios voices.

  • zucchini2007 I am not now, and NEVER have been a Madonna fan. I was simply stating what is on wikipedia - she has sold more than 257 million records - more than any other female in the world. My personal favorite is Whitney Houston, and I am white, so therefore, I cannot be called a racist. If Whitney had not started doing drugs a few years ago and dropped out of sight she would easily be the best-selling female artist of all time. What a loss!

  • Yeah.,..I was Never a Madonna fan either. Geesh...you think with all that money Madonna has...she would have her neck sewed back together.. What a hag she is!

  • Whitney Houston....sigh...doesn't come even close to the likes of Ella Fitzgerald and Sarah vaughan just to name two.

  • Actually, Madonna is the biggest selling female artist of all time with 257,000,000 albums. Then Mariah Carey, Whitney Houston, etc. Celine is no. 7 in the world!

  • Oh, please...Madonna is not much of a vocalist, and even all of you die-hard Madonna fans know it. The only reason why Madonna's net worth is over $300M is because she's a good dancer.

  • my nan crys lol but it is touching

  • She has a wonderful voice and it is obvious she is intelligent.

    When one person is intelligent and has talent, it is impossible to see "uglyness" or in her or to find something to to laugh at in her. I think at a lot of famous, well looking but stupid chicks, which have nothing but theit good look and their celebrity -- and which are more less interesting than this woman - at least that's my point of view.

    Right?

  • hardi har har

    maybe u should keep your commets to yourself.

  • that voice makes MY heart go on! I love her!

  • I like susan boyle too..She is just like this young singer who got fame because of their different kind of existence in life..now they are being heard...their beautiful voice that needs to be heard..

    watch?v=0twzwGOdhZw

  • I think I really like this one! i had to get it on my fone, I found the download today at EveryFreeRingTone. Com

  • Susans Singing will always touch my heart for sure. That was truely amazing Susan. Good luck right on through your entire life. May you always be happy. So may the sun shine on you and in your heart daily.

    Fantastic.

  • well ,who,s says what good looks ,is like i fine her verry prety , for she as that smile stuck in her beautyful face and i see good and pations and honest,real angel like femme,her voices mm their,s no name we will have to iinvented another word,to say she,s perfecto,canada with you also,can,t wait to buy yuo,re c,ds, u r a qeen ,susan do not change u are beauty and u give beauty to us i thank you from all my heart..

  • Susan singing can make the worst ever day turn into sunshine and roses and take a good day and make it phenomenal! I so hope she goes all the way to the Queen! And I can't wait until her album comes out! She's got a fan here in Michigan, for sure!

  • :) just showed in UK

  • beautiful lady with a orsum talent. wonderful so makes me cry everytime i hear her voice.

  • driscollnh, I totally agree with everything you wrote.

    You go Susan, many of us here in the USA are behind you and waiting eagerly for your first CD.

    Good luck in the show!

  • not only in the US, she's become a sensation in the WHOLE world, it's amazing.

  • I love everything Susan Boyle! Susan, don't change yourself with plastic surgery or anothing like that. I like the bit of color you've added to your hair and the other minor adjustments you have made, which any lady would want to do to be on the public stage. You are definitely not a slave to the fashions of this world! It would be a compliment to any woman to have it said of her, "You are so like Susan Boyle!".

  • who sings like an angel

  • congratulation susan for never lose your pasion to dream

  • Susan Boyle is a courageous woman A blessing from above, She looks like an Angel And is filled with Gods love. She has the talent and the gift To make her dreams come true, And the voice of a Angel She wants to share with you. Susan is quite young and single God has made her that way, She lives alone with her cat, Pebbles And treasures him everyday. So when you hear Susan sing With her voice reaching the skies, Just say a little prayer for her Till tears fills your eyes. ©
  • She brought tears to my eyes when I heard her sing at Britain's Got Talent. God has given her this wonderful gift, and He must be enjoying watching her use it, and amaze a cynical unbelieving world, as she proves that dreams do come true when you have something so beautiful to offer. God bless you, Sister, and stay lovely and innocent and unspoiled as you are now, forever. Love Judy.

  • You have a gift from god! Your voice is like an angel ! Blessings to you Susan, you bring much happiness and joy to this world! Hugs!

  • Who's getting more hits on youTube lately, Celine or Susan? I rest my case

  • Mejo sobra din xa mag vibrato eh..

    kaya un..

    pero magaling.. Sobra.!!

  • I agree..:P

    She can't compete with celine dion..

    She has an amazing voice, if she will be trained more about her singing, then will she compete with celine..:P

    I know that she can, because, her voice is such a natural..:P Shes very good..

    Well.. More Power SUSAN!!..:P

  • never judge a person by his/her appearances:)susan rocks

  • She's very good, but is not competition for Celine Dion by any means.

  • Well, Celine Dion owns "my heart will go on". But more than 100M people around the world like Susan Boyle, you can't ignore that mind-boggling number of people.

  • Celine has actually the biggest ammount of albums sold for all the female singers worldwide, 230 millions albums sold. Say whgatever you want she will never be touched by this Susan.

  • I don't think so, Mariah Carey has been mentioned as the #1 best-selling female artist in history several times. And I'm a huge MC fan, so I think it's actually MC that's the queen of record sales.

  • that was a few years ago mate;)

  • Holland loves you too ;-)

  • Wow you people putting her down are a buncha crabsniff potlickers. To sing a random song on request out of the blue the way she just did without a microphone in a room without equipment and no accoustics - talent friends talent.

  • Don't exagerate ok. That was not consider as a talent..

    Her voice was the talent but not what she did on this video..

    that was acapella.. everyone could sing acappella.. whenever they wanted..

  • I agree to that...

    People are just so exagerated..

    3:23 - 3:39..

  • NO !! We're just saying our opinion !!! and she can't sing this song! REALLY!

  • True True. The point is, on demand, most even professional musicians will sound unrefined, but it is important to distinguish rather than say everybody is the same. Anybody can sing but a singer who has enough generosity to do something like this rather than say "No thanks, another time" is a lot less selfish than the average musician.

  • You negative folks must not be able to see a wonderful talent and a sweetheart of a lady. She needs a mic, backup singers and a cool dress and she could be superstar. She doesn't need to be Dion, Her name is Susan or have you forgotten. She didn't ever say she wanted to be Celine. Susan is a breath of fresh air in the stale world of phonies. She deserves some success. Leave her alone! YOU GO SUSAN HONEY!

  • no one can compare to Celine Dion... but she did AMAZING!

  • Norway loves you Susan!

  • Obviously this impromptu redition without accompaniment and with poor recording quality does not compete with a slick Celine Dion track. I still really like her. And people who just keep insisting on trashing her because of looks make me wonder about what kind of superficial, insecure people they must be.

  • people don't be humorous! This is bullshit! Celine Dion - THE BEST!

  • da..obviously she's sung fine...if she sing with music and microphone, i bet you all will stunning

  • kalood ini na tiguwang.... wara dakan kamatay..hehehehhehe

  • OMFG - MY EARS!!!!!

    How the hell could he say that she sang like an angel here?? Too much vibrato and gossshhh, was it me or did she messed up with the lyric? *wanna scream* -

    This is a baaaad version - my ears are bleeding!!! Stop this bullshit...

  • i totally agree she was so crappy

  • ROTFL

    EXACTLY!!!

  • lovely hair. cobwebs in the vagina.

  • agreed.

  • she sounds great but...celine gives it a meaning to me.

  • she is like a New Barbara Striesand!

  • Such a typical thing of X Factor, Britians got talent....lets stick a popular song in there that everyone else has covered. If people thought she wasnt a joke act she will be now.

  • Well i like susan because she have a great voice and a lovely history but i think anyone canott compare susan with celine!!!!

    I think the people exagerete when say that in the nex time she sing a whitney song and averyone compare to her for exemple! :(

    I hope susan can win the program and realise her dream i dont have any debought....she will be a great singer!

    And i hope she record new song and after that anyone needs to compare susan with anybody!!!!! ;)

  • You're right about that. Why must we always compare. I love Susan, and I do hope she chooses an amazing song to sing.

  • Comment removed

  • it was good at the beginning but when it came to the middle & end it turned out to be a little awkward and sounds a bit 'in a rush' and a bit awkward improvisation at the end

  • I also like the way she smiles when she talks.

  • apparently she is a regular visitor to the Knock shrine in Ireland, where she honed her talent.

    The Le Mis song was perfect for her voice, the Celine one did not suit her voice and you could tell she had no practised it!

  • Heck no... she cannot be compare with Celine.. She doesn't even know the lyrics..

    She's guessing the lyrics.. I'm sorry but I don't think she's ready to record..

    I'm so sorry.. I mean I was amazed that she maintain that voice with her age but.. you know.. not about her appearance..

    No offense to her, and the people who love her..

  • She has great skill.. She cannot, most definitely, compete with Celine, but neither can anyone who has tried to sing that song (and this Larry King crap isn't to be compared to anything professional). If anything comes out of this Susan Boyle thing it's that you shouldn't give up and that's what she's proven. Does she deserve a recording career? I'm with you to say no on that as well. And again, neither do most of those who "simon" recommended. She's just going to be a one hit wonder.

  • I agree..

    and I'm sorry again for what I said.. I didn't mean to offend Susan or else.. I thought she's awesome too, because for all those years she had maintained her voice with her. So that impressing me.

    I'm not mad at Susan, I'm mad at the people who always exagerate.. just because she sang the song My heart will go on they're gonna compare her with Celine. Isn't that rude for Celine and Susan, they're diffent.

  • obviously celions dion version is best, only enjoy the beautiful susan's voice and the performance

  • fuck u she is godly

  • im sorry but that sucked her singing celine dion.. i think she needs to practice the song...

  • why did she choose that song? very difficult and a little too "epic" for a sitting. should have chosen something soft and lovely

  • the past week, I've been praising Susan for her exceptional rendition of I Dreamed A Dream & Cry Me a River. However, her rendition of this song, My Heart Will Go On, is mediocre, frankly speaking.

  • i prefer Cline Dion's version there is no comparison for me.

  • shes got a good voice but i prefer celine singing it personally :))

  • Do not judge a book on its cover ;-)

  • Hi Sissyloveschucky: I'm with you! I think you're right on both of your comments! Very nice!

  • Hi,

    I did close my eyes and it was okay. not great or amazing like some people think, but okay.

    That's why i was making that point.