Roger Waters - It's a Miracle (Live)

[aramt6687]

ur voice, ur music ur everything.. driving me crazyyyyyyyyyUR SO AMAZINGGGGGGG

[aramt6687]

ur voice, ur music ur everything.. driving me crazyyyyyyyyy

[Fred196407]

I`m with Roger Waters. He`s a man i aspire to & share his concerns. Basically the good of mankind is surrounded by C**ts who just want to Pillage & destroy everything. I fear he will die a man with a sad Heart as probably will i.

[srizon]

Deeply sorry for the spelling mistake earlier should be Roger Waters. It's my bloody iPhone let me down!!!!

[srizon]

I like both Roger Walter & David Gilmore but my heart says Roger Walter and my head says David Gilmore.

Pink Floyd was born once and there will never be a band like them again.

[alqpymfgrzcb]

Roger, we love you! that one of your most awesome song, the lyrics are soooo deep! A-M-A-Z-I-N-G

[thecalikid1970]

i remember when this album came out, seems just like yesterday but 20 years have gone. Its a miracle.......................­............Jerome Deaver

[atheer2002]

RW actually predicted the Bermuda shorts in my Baghdad.. many years prior.. wow..

[RudyPFT]

this rates as one of my top 10 favourites ao all time. I used to lay flat on a carpet in the dark, big ass head phones and listen to this album full blast.

[awesomemouse]

it's a really magic song.

[darkgem100]

i've listened to both songs, ehcoes and the Phantom title song, i don't hear any resembemence, AND I'M A COMPOSER MYSELF! if they were so sure Webber stole it, they would have taken legal action. which they didn't. i don't think that was the wisest move.

[broskutzaaa1]

yes , It's a Miracle.... life it's a Miracle ..existence

[broskutzaaa1]

yes , It's a Miracle.... life is a Miracle ..existence

[petrosonrocking]

such peace in my heart while listening to this... it's a miracle :)

[ucutumia]

godlike



[PETESEYESBLUE]

I,ve noticed that the song PHANTOM OF THE OPERA I know well is from the first album bye IRON MAIDEN,correct what other band plays that tune? This tune when listened to from the Album really can give such emotional lifting.When I first bought the Album and played Three Wishes followed Bye Its A Miracle,An absolute testament that Roger will always place his fans before controvercy.As far as im cocerned ECHOES was and is a the Phenom of FLOYD,This is a tearjerker for sure.STAY SOLID LOYAL FANS.

[lorax121323]

5:55 the piano lid comes down/and breaks his fucking fingers/It's a miracle.

[magalhaes333]

dave gilmore is the best

[swingersonian]

@magalhaes333 --and you are the worst

[spaden2112]

@swingersonian yay you can insult people on the internet because their opinions differ from yours. You are a load that should have been swallowed.

[ucnobia]

This song is miracle ))))))

[PFforever1]

When Snowy White's solo kicks-in at the 7:30 mark, I feel my soul being transported to another level...

[megacrawshaw]

why dont we tear down the walls you all sit hear procastinating about roger and floyd but still the world is a shitty place full of wankers and bankers and cock suckers like peter garrett

[megacrawshaw]

why dont we tear down our walls have we learnt nothing you all sit hear preaching about roger and floyd but your all just fucken sheep baaaaaaaaaaaaaah

[rufinoman]

A poet!

[ManosRK]

WOW...

[cameroncda]

Again on of his lesser known yet thought inspiring songs. A perfect accompaniment for his amazing balladeer's voice. Truly wonderful. Thanks for posting.

[TheBitchAssMongoose]

Powerful. Emotionally deep. Brilliant song. You can always count on Roger Waters :)

[powells84]

de pelossssssssssssssssssssssssss­sssssss

[spaden2112]

Is there no limit to his genius?

[spaden2112]

Is this just "Careful With That Axe Eugene" reprised?

[jusdoitokay]

@spaden2112 no

[swingersonian]

@spaden2112 --No, it is not.  Idiot.

[swingersonian]

Roger's accountant is playing bass guitar on this song, I see.

[dadautube]

"A Brazilian grew a tree ..."

and another cut it down when it was fully grown! =[

[butot81]

Really Amazing

[mrjacob7471]

I know he have god"s gift. It's God"hand.

[swingersonian]

@mrjacob7471 --Roger IS god!

[mrjacob7471]

I know he hve god"s gift. It's God"hand.

[zety211]

the best of

[Aztlnight]

omfg

[pedrodalmo]

esse cara da bateria é muito bom!!!

[cfvbankrobber]

Two channel ? Ya sure but the music touches the soul in so many levels ; Cant wait to get my Big system on line to hear and feel this wonderful music.

[tamster5e]

one of the best discs ever it will show you what a two speaker sound system can do

[codern]

does nothing for me...i want some DSOTM

[jetfighters20fr]

you suck

[anderleyfilho]

when and where was this concert ? [2]

[tamirtiko]

when and where was this concert ?

[DavelovesRealMusic]

Any doctors in MANHATTAN want to SAVE ME? No money..and I have autonomic dysfunction...HELP....

[DavelovesRealMusic]

How many other songwriters use words like Tigres and Euphredites and make it work !

[GABRIEL3847]

really music, timeless

fuwera del tiempo...de todos los tiempos

[Buckienz]

and a 67 year old guys shows the young ones how to rock and enjoy it

[olybears077]

@Buckienz Not just how to rock and enjoy it, friend. This lyricist shows the young the crippling flaws of our society. All of our awful wrongs. Pointing to the cracks in our wall of ignorance, as it were.

[anderleyfilho]

i wanna this dvd =S

[TheFff06]

@anderleyfilho i have :D

[TolbaAuditore]

A GENIUS WILL REMAINS A GENIUS.....

[alexmortland]

Homey on bass is giving 110% on those octave jumps, you know it! That's fucker's CONCENTRATING.

[jancsipl]

Never before and never later -this music is now and only once

[ilupir77]

Wow. Amazing. I'm quite new to Pink Floyd and Roger Waters, but now I definitely want to hear more. Great atmosphere, great music.

[inesescalante]

que buen comentario

[atheer2002]

it must be a miracle…

[MrConeman]

"A doctor in manhattan saved a dying man for free...it's a miracle"

I love Roger Waters.

[blusero67]

MARAVILLOSO

[Paulitinho1]

roger hoje pavilhao atlantico vou la estar simply the best

[talibe801]

Roger is amazing live,and i´m going to see him playing live tonite in lisbon.

one of the best composers ever in all history of music.

[beatom36]

no words

[anamgify]

Another hopeless (we don´t need ANOTHER BRICK to separate Us) we need another MIRACLE now for JAPAN all my love for them too

[86286286]

i love it.:((( remember me my love..its a miracle....farzad i love uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu:):*

[86286286]

i love it.:((( remember me my love..its a miracle....farzad i love uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu:)

[puretemptation]

a walking genius!

[ishmail68]

@twixxxer: you are a geniuos!

[twixxxer]

@ishmail68 haha thanks. I understand you're saying that due to my comment, not the music of mine, are you? ;))

[ishmail68]

@twixxxer right.

[ishmail68]

twixxxer you are a geniuos!

[wooly1950]

Roger is the man, he says it as it really is, his music will go on for and ever and ever, the piano lid won't break his fucking fingers !!!!

Ian Wooly Melbourne

[BartsMyName]

Does anybody know if the concert is on DVD? If so then what is the name of it?

[twixxxer]

@BartsMyName "In the Flesh - live"

[cat17plc]

@BartsMyName roger waters in the flesh 2h 50m of real music

[twixxxer]

Andrew Lloyd-Webber has visited this site for 22 times, I see.

[countvonjustin]

@twixxxer Best youtube comment ever. Too bad we're the geeks geeky enough to get it.

[twixxxer]

@countvonjustin yep, the answer is in the lyrics

[ishmail68]

@twixxxer unfortuantely now they are 23: Andrew Lloyd-Webber has come back once again.

[McDonaldsInTibet]

@twixxxer Fuck the Webber, who the fuck is him in comparison to Waters)

[DavelovesRealMusic]

@twixxxer 23x now LOL....You know why he mentions that pretentious prick..he stole Waters music,

[AGSystem27]

@twixxxer Andrew Lloyd Webber has problem with Roger?

[engenheiro1986edu]

o brasil te ama!!!!!!

[Tomlehue]

Roger waters is Roger Waters i have 2 say no more

[vicens1942]

fantástico vídeo,maravillosa interpretacion de una no menos maravillosa canción del album Amused To Death,obra maestra de ROGER WATERS,creo sinceramente que es lo mejors del ex de pink floyd

[Symphonidisorder]

beautiful!

[Logicamweb]

ti amo !

[madfrog1962]

roger by far far is the greatest sonwriter of rock history,

just like british can do,

pink floyd without roger still an ordinary rock band.

[markripley1]

It's a Miracle all love 2 Roger Waters

pll dont get this song at all it's as good as it gets.

[Cbarns88]

If you dislike this song, you completely missed the boat of understanding what real music is

also, astridjuh, bands change, this still is real music

[DrownInGrace88]

Its a Miracle !!! How many Fuckin Jerks Dont like this song and compare this to the floyd ,......this is Roger Waters ...stop saying how much better it coulda been if gilmour was playing a solo on this song ,,,, (not that it wouldnt be cool ) but Roger is at a Different level than David and David is at a different level too both are freakin amazing but ...now with that said this is real music ,,,,Roger ...thank you for the wonderful songs america loves you ....i l

[Stuilove]

@DrownInGrace88 well said.

[Stopzilla77]

A Great Song

[ICHIKHRA]

tvinshi dzvreba es simgera umagresiaaaaaaaaaaaa.... gazarda ra itokshi rogerA chvenma gia suramelashvilma:D:D:D:D:D

[PFforever1]

My ten year old son and I saw Roger in San Jose on December 8th. Music, like a fine bottle of cabernet sauvignon, ages ever so well with time. Needless to say, the 30 year wait was well worth it as tears formed in my eyes during several heartfelt songs. If you have the chance to see the production, do yourself a favor and take it in. In closing, my son looked up at me after "Comfortably Numb" and said "Dad, now I know why you love music so much." Enough said.

[bendesmond66]

@PFforever1 i was at that show too, i know man...life changing i was speechless after that show it was just so mind blowing

[magaha63]

@PFforever1 all can say is wow what a special moment in time 

[inesescalante]

@PFforever1 que buen comentario, entendió la esencia 

[TheFff06]

@PFforever1 I went to see his concert in Lisbon (Portugal) because of the new tour "the wall - live. " I went with my parents and when I saw him come on stage, I cried because if it wasn't my father giving me this brilliant and magnificent gift for Christmas, I would never have had the opportunity to see my biggest idol. I owe him forever because of it.

[PFforever1]

@TheFff06 Great post! Thanks so much for sharing...and give that father of yours a great big hug!!!

[serrapereira]

@PFforever1 I see in Lisbon. Completely subscribe

[guitarfreaky1996]

@PFforever1 P&L

[manchestercitizen]

Roger Waters is a prophet...

[MrGuitarXX]

im new to youtube. please check my shit out.

[JustAagje]

I will see and hear Roger Waters on May 27 th this year at the sportpaleis Antwerp (Belgium).!!

YES !!

[scarletttango]

@JustAagje I will be there too! Looking forward to it, although that's an understatement...

[khruschov]

It's a Miracle...! Great Waters!

[OmManePedmeOm]

Des draps bleu marine.... et cette chanson... Wahouuu !!

[stookiebhoy]

The only thing missing is a beautifully understated guitar solo at 3:10 from David Gilmour.

[Larrs81]

This music is a miracle.

I have this song on CD, but this live version is unbelievable beautiful.

[mrllapjani]

can anyone tell me why do i see the same people with David and Roger

[cjsoberanis]

ROGER WATERS LO MEJOR DESPUES DE DIOS

[angspec003]

Roger is the best ever , a musical mastermind.

[SuperRedfighter]

GREAT

[DonSudia]

Isn't he awesome! His backup singers are pretty incredible too.

[clrmsm]

mitico roger.............te sei i pink floyd

[hzuiga]

The Lord said Peter I can see your house from here..

[TheGraywolf661]

Hi

One word

FANTASTIC..

.Good old Roger,Great music as always /and lyric that only he can do it.

Thanks for share

regards

Hans

[ksvideos]

7:25 beautiful!!!!

[angelstarzification]

OMGG Roger Waters you are THE most amazing person on this planet, you have guts, you have foresight, your intuitive, Oh My Good God, I have always seen your Wisdom, but you are truely the modern day profit. Loving you and your music forever amen :) xxxxxx

[panic821]

one of the best solos ever. this guy does justice to Jeff Beck .

[Mariois101]

Where's the Lloyd weber part

[panic821]

@Mariois101

its there....at the 5:40 mark.

[col2968]

je trouve cette chanson magnifique,,j aime et si vrai,

[col2968]

je trouve cette chanson magnifique,,j adore

[AGSystem27]

7:32 who is the guitarrist?

[BERNIE6164]

Manchester in may...oh yes

[CrayolaCowboy]

Waters? the consummate great writer, and with Gilmour, he is simply better.

[kolargol111]

King Roger !

[dinkeldal]

meesterlijk de rillingen nemen bezit van mijn lichaam

[astridjuh12]

Pink floyd might be old, but listening to music from the 21st century just hurt my ears, back then they knew how to make REAL music . <3

going to see Roger Waters in concert this year, i can't wait ;)

[honkydudeman]

@astridjuh12 but the EARTH IS OLD???GOD IS OLD ??? pink floyds music will be old when we have a safe secure planet to live in ???and thats NEVER ,,,,,,AMEN

[LaurindoFernando]

Brutal.

[pouriasar]

I love your gestures man, I'm really love you.

[riccowcm]

that guitar solo is what i'm gonna hear when i'm going to heaven

what a amazing heavenly sound

b. u.

[Polterguist]

Seems like he liked the Lloyd Webber part the best. Great song.

[GTMcArthur]

Até arrepia ouvir esta melodia.

[mynamemeanssun]

El grandioso a La Supremente! Need eye say more?

[taterbowie]

Excelente, simplemente!

[gozaderadrfunk]

It's a Festivus Miracle!

[pinkhakimfloyd]

HE IS THE GENIUS

[gmorais2]

perfect

[raisinsec1]

Magnifique!!

[oddbtve]

@uh0oo  It's Andy Fairweather Low you ignorant fool.

[oddbtve]

@uh0oo It's Andy Fairweather Low you ignorant fool.

[uh0oo]

@uh0oo I know who he is, and he sucks, and so does old man Roger. He needs to get with the times man. Todays music isnt for Roger, and his fans move aside, because Lady GaGa is incharge bitch.

[northvilletunnels]

@uh0oo Some people don't have to appeal to the lowest common denominator. I doubt Roger cares if people like Lady Gaga. Those people are mindless stool samples.

[germanicopazuzu]

In The Flesh ?, TDSOM, and now, coming up next, The Wall, next saturday in México City.....................never­ is enough for more Roger Waters.

19 retards don´t believe in Miracles.........

[Pedro122ish]

espero bem estar em Lisboa daqui a uns três meses a ver este grande senhor :D

[schmittelt]

I saw him during this tour. The best seats I ever had at a concert, right next to the oil slide guy. (who asked me for a light for his cigarette so he could blow smoke infront of the projector...my fire, my smoke, I was part of the show! : D ) Anyway, I'm from Pittsburgh, PA though I've since moved away. I always remember the cheers that went up during the line "They had sex in Pennsylvania."

[fhurvhur]

19 disliked retards or music illiterates, or kids, and growing.

[sdsfgsffdgdsfg]

19 people don't belive in miracles

[031471emi]

you the bests ROGER

[pinkfloyd426]

Fantastic!!!! Roger is the Man

[florinovich]

Great Song! Thank You!

[onthewinglets]

Saw this tour in Toronto in 99' and it was a miracle. Thanks Roger for always coming to Toronto for your shows. And thanks for opening the Wall Live in Toronto.

All 3 nights were a miracle.

OTW

[padypower]

u r a godddddddddddddddddddddddddddd­dddddddddddddddddd,, u r the miracle

[betukoso]

careful with that axe eugene

[LittleG3o]

greaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa­aaaaaaaaat

[bartje21]

the end brings me to tears...awesome song, awesome album

[pirolitoami]

quelle douce melodie,tt simplement envoutante!!!!!!!!

roger,pink floyd forever

[mraberav]

great

[mraberav]

awsome

[Bassjunkie1985]

I just love the line ", and the piano lid comes down, pffff, and breaks his fuckin fingers!" just pure poetry, based on raw content!

[vederchi]

What a beautiful peice of music.

[Sconz32]

This is art. Lots of people can write pretty songs (like Dave Gilmour for instance) but only a few can produce art.

[ShoTgUn851112]

Brillant song, but how good is Snowy White's bit in the end?!!?!?! oh my god..

[endurozan]

Mr. Floyd