I figure this way, you lower the likelihood of damaging them, while keeping them intact enough to replant elsewhere. I have a couple basil seedlings I did this way and though they're smaller than the best looking one, they're still healthy. I wonder if they'll just grow at a slower rate or have they hit a ceiling from competing with the larger one for so long.
I see the rationale with eliminating the "weaker" seedlings in order for the more healthy one to thrive, but I'm with you guys: why waste what looked like two perfectly good seedlings because they're smaller?
Can't you just space them out a bit more within the same cell, so as to avoid the roots of the seedlings from getting tangled?
The reason you thin out the plants is because as they grow, they compete for nutrients in the soil. The goal is to have a single strong, healthy plant, not two or three weak ones with tangled root systems.
"Only the strong shall survive." That is your reinterpretation of "The survival of the fittest." That was a bastardization of Charles Darwin's work by Herbert Spencer. He propagated this belief that lead to Eugenics, that sterilized 60,000 American women. (Hitler also took his views from this thoughts and....)
What Darwin was meaning was natural selection. It is those that are most adaptable that will survive, not the strong, but the adaptable.
They looked the same, why not just let them all grow? Spreed the out. I have watched Expert Village over two years, and it doesn't seem as they are very "expert."
Look for the bamboo video, oh what she did to that poor plant.
I heard the plant screaming out this is so ugly
hypnos315 7 months ago
can't watch >_<'
moonshadow112358 8 months ago
wheres the weed gaytard
arra009 8 months ago
everytime i try to grow tomatoes from sed, they come up grow about 3 inches tall and skinny then fall over and die. What am i doing wrong?
bhauk 9 months ago 2
@bhauk ..soil should be moist at all times when they're babies :)
MELISSA84008 8 months ago
He eliminated a poor baby plant by cutting its head off!!! lol
lilo621 11 months ago
I'm new to gardening. Can you eat the one you cut down?
Z71Ranger 11 months ago
Comment removed
melonpotato 10 months ago
@Z71Ranger lol yes i have ,,,,,,sadly
TennesseeUnderground 10 months ago
DAM!!! what a sacrifice
smallblocksupercharg 1 year ago
I figure this way, you lower the likelihood of damaging them, while keeping them intact enough to replant elsewhere. I have a couple basil seedlings I did this way and though they're smaller than the best looking one, they're still healthy. I wonder if they'll just grow at a slower rate or have they hit a ceiling from competing with the larger one for so long.
jwbail02 1 year ago
I see the rationale with eliminating the "weaker" seedlings in order for the more healthy one to thrive, but I'm with you guys: why waste what looked like two perfectly good seedlings because they're smaller?
Can't you just space them out a bit more within the same cell, so as to avoid the roots of the seedlings from getting tangled?
jwbail02 1 year ago
The reason you thin out the plants is because as they grow, they compete for nutrients in the soil. The goal is to have a single strong, healthy plant, not two or three weak ones with tangled root systems.
chilledfresh 1 year ago
how funny....if you leave them all, the survivor will not thrive. Sadly...
msskimbot 1 year ago
dude you just killed a baby!
sio42 1 year ago 2
"Only the strong shall survive." That is your reinterpretation of "The survival of the fittest." That was a bastardization of Charles Darwin's work by Herbert Spencer. He propagated this belief that lead to Eugenics, that sterilized 60,000 American women. (Hitler also took his views from this thoughts and....)
What Darwin was meaning was natural selection. It is those that are most adaptable that will survive, not the strong, but the adaptable.
Think before you speak, or make a video.
JollyMunkie 2 years ago
They looked the same, why not just let them all grow? Spreed the out. I have watched Expert Village over two years, and it doesn't seem as they are very "expert."
Look for the bamboo video, oh what she did to that poor plant.
JollyMunkie 2 years ago
I'm against plant abortion! Plants are beings too!!!
youlosez 2 years ago 13
LOL
PewPewPwnt 2 years ago 3
@youlosez Human beans, for instance
rutsableich 1 year ago 2
wtf?! the more the merrier
crip23walk23 2 years ago
what if you want to spread them out?? do u pull them out and plant them in another cell?
btw... this video was hard to watch cuz it's murder =(
SeikoPsycho 2 years ago
plant abortion??
bamboorules 2 years ago 19
@bamboorules plant the thinnings and give them a chance! you could end up with twice the plants, or not. but if you don't you deffinitley won't
flupmakintosh 1 year ago
why plant three seedlings if you're just gonna cut the other two?
Whitetiger701 2 years ago 2
Because there's a better chance that at least one of the seeds will germinate; sometimes not all three will.
UraniumWilly 2 years ago 2
thanks
Whitetiger701 2 years ago
to asure the seeds actually do germinate
MyGeranium 2 years ago
What if all plants lok strong? Is it necessary to clip some away?
mypetbirdrocks 2 years ago 2
i usually wait alittle more then i separate them and plant them somewhere else. goood video thought
aggalf1978 2 years ago
Exactly, this way you get maximum out of your purchase, and nothing is wasted.
DeepestSleep 2 years ago
Great tip!! I would have yanked the seedling out and probably killed all the others. I've got a lot to learn about gardening!
RetroLoco1 3 years ago 3