Left hand is not as lively as the right hand. tempo is at a decent lvl now. There are a lot of tones that are stopped abruptly. You should play the notes fully out. When the right hand plays it should be connected to the left hand. Last note of the right hand(the seventh note) still lingers around the first three notes of the left hand. IT makes it sound much more pleasing to the ear. So your tempo overall is fine, but looking into the details I think you are playing on "stolen time".Interesting
Hmmmmmmm not that bad,but make sure you bring out the dynamics I know because right now I am sitting on my piano bench and having the music sheet in front of me and I am 10 years old but any way BRAVO!!!!!!!! WONERFUL!!!
mmmhm...its good in general... but u have to watch out of stickin ur 5th finger on ur left hand down...when u have 8ths in left hand...second note shouldnt be that long and that loud....and whenever u have notes with articulation dots (staccato) in bach - dont play it like a real staccato cause its Bach man....cheers
Good job! How ever some mishaps. I do not h ave my book right now so i cannot be specific. When your hands cross over in the 2nd and 4th page, make sure your hands sing, don't be so harsh. Also, your right hand should not dominate. the hands should talk to each other. I believe one of your trills were a tad to long and you rhythm was slightly off near the end. Good job and practice hard!
The tempo is very steady (seems like your hard work has paid off). But more dynamics is required to make the piece more intriguing (I know you are aware of that). At 2:00, loved the fact that you didn't rush through the trill and took your time, it would sound horrible if you didn't slow down there. Like The Lark, you have executed your scale passages and trills perfectly, with the correct articulation!
I've never heard it that speed (I know that Glenn Gould plays it faster!) but I really, REALLY like it. Too bad you didn't do the repeats, though. That would give you a chance to vary the intensity a little. Well done!
LOVE the tempo; this really makes it exciting for me - and it's really rock steady now as well! And the way you drop on those trills is really impressive. What a great video.
Left hand is not as lively as the right hand. tempo is at a decent lvl now. There are a lot of tones that are stopped abruptly. You should play the notes fully out. When the right hand plays it should be connected to the left hand. Last note of the right hand(the seventh note) still lingers around the first three notes of the left hand. IT makes it sound much more pleasing to the ear. So your tempo overall is fine, but looking into the details I think you are playing on "stolen time".Interesting
Ianthe22 7 months ago
dude no sped up the video much
REAVENTSNIPER321 7 months ago
wonderfull..keep it up!!love it
13pianomaniac 9 months ago
Hmmmmmmm not that bad,but make sure you bring out the dynamics I know because right now I am sitting on my piano bench and having the music sheet in front of me and I am 10 years old but any way BRAVO!!!!!!!! WONERFUL!!!
meimeichao 9 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Bien mais des erreurs d'interprétation, il faut beaucoup plus lié les notes :s
manu974aimwill 1 year ago
very cool!
bjohnson671 1 year ago 6
Great job!
I wish you the best!
Your discipline and musicality deserves it !!!
Keep going with this good work :)
SalHernor 1 year ago 11
you're amazing!
sarooshki 2 years ago 14
mmmhm...its good in general... but u have to watch out of stickin ur 5th finger on ur left hand down...when u have 8ths in left hand...second note shouldnt be that long and that loud....and whenever u have notes with articulation dots (staccato) in bach - dont play it like a real staccato cause its Bach man....cheers
filip91kv 2 years ago
you are an idiot
bobthetrooper7 2 years ago
why am i an idiot??!!
filip91kv 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
pesimo esta mal tocado y muy rapido. me das asco!!!!!!!!!
chuapino94 2 years ago
Very well-done. Congratulations.
SandyWalters 2 years ago 22
Absolutely dazzling playing young man! Keep up the great work.
JaneAustin57 2 years ago 16
Good job! How ever some mishaps. I do not h ave my book right now so i cannot be specific. When your hands cross over in the 2nd and 4th page, make sure your hands sing, don't be so harsh. Also, your right hand should not dominate. the hands should talk to each other. I believe one of your trills were a tad to long and you rhythm was slightly off near the end. Good job and practice hard!
animatedpheonix 2 years ago
Outstanding job! I wish you had also recorded the repeats; that way, you can really be quite effective with dynamics.
TimK999 2 years ago 15
Good job !
indigoblue555 2 years ago 8
Another splendid performance Josh!
The tempo is very steady (seems like your hard work has paid off). But more dynamics is required to make the piece more intriguing (I know you are aware of that). At 2:00, loved the fact that you didn't rush through the trill and took your time, it would sound horrible if you didn't slow down there. Like The Lark, you have executed your scale passages and trills perfectly, with the correct articulation!
Great job my friend,
Tony
tonyyezj 2 years ago 5
Oh and, I may start learning this piece now I got the new grade 10 Repertoire. But the History/Harmony stuff is keeping me busy.
Five stars for you by the way :)
tonyyezj 2 years ago
INCREDIBLE playing!
pianowatt 2 years ago 11
I've never heard it that speed (I know that Glenn Gould plays it faster!) but I really, REALLY like it. Too bad you didn't do the repeats, though. That would give you a chance to vary the intensity a little. Well done!
ra4419 2 years ago 3
This is so exciting to watch and listen to; a wonderful performance of this Bach fantasia.
AvrilP43 2 years ago 6
WOW! Amazing playing and interpretation.
AvaMac55 2 years ago 5
This absolutely sizzles! Love it!
kallen1999 2 years ago 13
Absolutely super playing! Intense and wonderfully gratifying.
MikeFaw22 2 years ago 10
A powerful, moving Bach Fantasia! Excellent.
atesla199 2 years ago 10
HOLY MAC! Didn't know that the ivory could be tickled so quickly! Great job Josh!
jencrothers 2 years ago 7
LOVE the tempo; this really makes it exciting for me - and it's really rock steady now as well! And the way you drop on those trills is really impressive. What a great video.
GregAnthus 2 years ago 13
Good job, Josh! I liked it a lot. It's always a pleasure watching your videos and witnessing your progress. Keep it up, mate!
LutzKranenborg 2 years ago 21
that was absolutely amazing!!! loved the intensity and the speed especially:) wow
josh at the height of his powers!!!
tituscaesar 2 years ago 11
5/5 Again :D
You continue to amaze me Josh, great job.
Xtrem3Poptarts 2 years ago 13