@MorningDitties It was a reasonable question that @Themusicanddrama asked, no need to accuse them of having no harmonic appreciation! It's a grating sound, classically the reverse of 'beautiful'.
@banterflaws Thank you, seeing as I am predominantly a jazz musician (even though they weren't to know) I felt that was quite harsh to be accused so suddenly. Oh well, as I replied to them- it's just another artist's interpretation. I wouldn't have put that harmony in this particular piece, but nonetheless in other pieces it would have been an inspiring harmony!
@TheMusicanddrama Dim (Maj9) resolving to a Maj7(9). It's like playing a dom7b9 with the b9 as the root up to a major7 a semitone up. If you can't hear why that's beautiful you need to improve your appreciation of harmony..
This is quite a harsh comment seeing as you aren't aware of my musical background. Being a jazz musician I have a solid appreciation and love for harmony. It just felt (to me) that with the mood of the piece, it didn't quite fit. Being the only phrase like that in the piece (excuse my non-terminological language), made it feel that it was by accident as there weren't other sections that included such a dissonant harmony. I am a huge fan, it's just another artists interpretation
@Dinkyswingle Haha that's true! Are you doing any more ditties soon? I recommended to my choir, jazz band and acapella group that they should watch you guys, and they love you!
@Dinkyswingle ......The world deseves to sing like this too! I wrote to Santa and asked him to let the Swingles publish the arrangement for us Normalos ;-) I wonder if he'll grant my wish?
You are great guys hugs from Colombia ! Merry Christmas .
ABIATAR37 2 months ago
:07 that would be a good picture!
amybellman300 2 months ago
I love Lucy's hat!
huangweiyin 3 months ago
@MorningDitties It was a reasonable question that @Themusicanddrama asked, no need to accuse them of having no harmonic appreciation! It's a grating sound, classically the reverse of 'beautiful'.
banterflaws 5 months ago
@banterflaws Thank you, seeing as I am predominantly a jazz musician (even though they weren't to know) I felt that was quite harsh to be accused so suddenly. Oh well, as I replied to them- it's just another artist's interpretation. I wouldn't have put that harmony in this particular piece, but nonetheless in other pieces it would have been an inspiring harmony!
TheMusicanddrama 4 months ago
Oh by the way, are the notes supposed to clash that that on 1.47?? :/
TheMusicanddrama 6 months ago
@TheMusicanddrama Yup :-)
Dinkyswingle 6 months ago
@TheMusicanddrama Dim (Maj9) resolving to a Maj7(9). It's like playing a dom7b9 with the b9 as the root up to a major7 a semitone up. If you can't hear why that's beautiful you need to improve your appreciation of harmony..
MorningDitties 5 months ago
This is quite a harsh comment seeing as you aren't aware of my musical background. Being a jazz musician I have a solid appreciation and love for harmony. It just felt (to me) that with the mood of the piece, it didn't quite fit. Being the only phrase like that in the piece (excuse my non-terminological language), made it feel that it was by accident as there weren't other sections that included such a dissonant harmony. I am a huge fan, it's just another artists interpretation
TheMusicanddrama 4 months ago
Is it bad that we're in July yet I can't stop watching this video?!
So, so, so beautiful!
TheMusicanddrama 7 months ago
@TheMusicanddrama Ha ha. But in the summer we're not sick of all the christmas music yet, right?! ;-)
Dinkyswingle 6 months ago
@Dinkyswingle Haha that's true! Are you doing any more ditties soon? I recommended to my choir, jazz band and acapella group that they should watch you guys, and they love you!
TheMusicanddrama 4 months ago
@TheMusicanddrama Cool! Thanks! :-) I think it's definitely time for another ditty....let me think... x x x
Dinkyswingle 3 months ago
You are not human, this is AMAZING. I want it to be christmas again just because of this video.
peterhollens 10 months ago 3
:) (long, contented sigh.........)
ebtrumpet 1 year ago
@Dinkyswingle: I missed this one at Christmas, but that's ok, cuz you're keeping Christmas alive for me into the New Year. Woo-hoo!
dyzmom 1 year ago
Great, thanks!!
harmonieus 1 year ago
Great, thanks!!
harmonieus 1 year ago
How do you do that, to keep your own sound??????? crazy, that what you did in the subway, thattt is good!! go on!!
harmonieus 1 year ago
Finally felt Christmas is here when I saw this vid today! Very beautiful! :)
jts201 1 year ago
@jts201 Oh yay! :-)
Dinkyswingle 1 year ago
brilliant
theviker 1 year ago
YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS! so great. tekay
nilla4me 1 year ago
Wonderful!
billcmartin 1 year ago
absolutely stunning. you're are all so talented. got me feeling all festive :) lucy is my fave, she's a hottie!
timmybunting 1 year ago
I am so glad to hear the first time Oli singing with the group. Please come back soon to Brazil!
danilodemori 1 year ago
This is most awesome! Love it!! Going on my facebook!
vanceperry 1 year ago
Very nice arrangement and beautiful singing...Thanks for sharing, JB. =)
jbcraipeau 1 year ago
oh, dears...
made my day too!
love you!
Danilo
danilodemori 1 year ago
Love it!
melodytarn 1 year ago
So glad! We'll try and do another one before Christmas :-)
Dinkyswingle 1 year ago
@Dinkyswingle ......The world deseves to sing like this too! I wrote to Santa and asked him to let the Swingles publish the arrangement for us Normalos ;-) I wonder if he'll grant my wish?
debros65 1 year ago
@debros65 Ha ha. I dunno, I heard Santa's pretty mean...but if you emailed music @ swinglesingers . com they might be able to help you! ;-)
Dinkyswingle 1 year ago
@Dinkyswingle Bless you Sweetheart! I'll donate the Liptons or PGTips for the next Ditty! ;-)
debros65 1 year ago
@debros65 Sweet. It's a deal!
Dinkyswingle 1 year ago
@Dinkyswingle Santa WAS mean... he didn't even answer my mail :(((
debros65 1 year ago
@debros65 PS what's your name so I know who to reference? x
Dinkyswingle 1 year ago
YES!
steveeeeelj 1 year ago
This made my day. :D
bobchuseby 1 year ago