in fact this song really not suit her voice dont take wind as ascuse dont care how big the wind if the song suit for a people sure a very good song will came out .
Iagree. Not much emotion when singing this very emotional song. She didn't quite catch the tempo either at the start of the song. Finished well though.
13人因為風大點錯
bobby9864 8 months ago
还是张靓颖唱的好, 当然梁的声音也是相当的棒
liguow 11 months ago
一開始的時候拍子是快了點的，但是之後已經okay。
她本身獨特的顫音就已經足夠唱這首歌了。
wilsonchristine 1 year ago
呼吸是她的缺点...
woesxela 1 year ago
@solekavin 絕對同意你的意見，離實力派好遙遠。
sifng 1 year ago
@sifng 原來你對歌手的標準那麼嚴苛
連梁靜茹都不在你的實力派範圍內
可能這世上你認為的實力派少之又少摟
zxc123qaz456123 2 months ago
good
nok0403 1 year ago
感情丰富的演绎！赞！
6541Lee 1 year ago
静茹的声音真的好好听！
emilyve56 1 year ago
只不過大風而已.
sunny4c12 1 year ago 4
un petit coucou à tous!!!!
je ne la connais pas mais elle a une trés belle voix!!
et je crois vu la vidéo que nca doit etre une celébrité dans votre pays !!
je comprends pourquoi bellllllle voixxxx
bravo
trupinette 1 year ago 2
很不錯呀,沒有比楊和蕭差的說
bakchoikin 1 year ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
她把每段歌词最后一个字的尾音拉得太长,这样就变得太抒情了. 这首歌描述的是悲情,不是抒情. 梁静茹真的不了解这首歌.
grantliu 2 years ago
靜茹唱得好好!!!好有感情
wakaka349 2 years ago 3
我覺得唱得頗有感情
lovesongprinceandy 2 years ago 4
好好聽~~~^^
asuranchan 2 years ago 8
风那么大,还唱那么好.相当有实力了啊
zheng901227 2 years ago 8
its the enviroment la, sing this song so not right
H4z3Ls0h 2 years ago 6
明明就不錯呀 我還以為有唱錯還是搶拍...
sunhome1220 2 years ago 4
Malaysian Rock !
DBWednes 2 years ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
意見那麼多 阿不然你來唱
billyz7094 2 years ago 32
This has been flagged as spam show
她在唱回忆过去的时候，忆唱得好用力喔。有失水准。而且没有很伤痛的感觉。是风让她分了心吗?
peacelia12 2 years ago
another malaysian!
manishmer 2 years ago 10
我覺得幾好聽
ShadowN219 2 years ago 11
不錯的說!抖(震)音 是她的強項耶 我覺得
DaBusUncle 2 years ago 25
@DaBusUncle 纠正一下是颤音；我最喜欢梁静的颤音，尤其是在可惜不是你里，太帅了！
speedylovesjoanna 1 year ago
@DaBusUncle 纠正一下，是颤音。我最喜欢梁静茹的颤音了，尤其是在可惜不是你里，简直就太帅了！
speedylovesjoanna 1 year ago
風太大也是有影響拉
還有她歌因該不熟= =+..
yaklon 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
She just sing it like reading script. Cant feel the soul of this song from her. Sad....
alchemy2004 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
还未听梁静茹唱现场之前，很多人都说她的实力很好，可是听了这首歌可以用大失所望四字形容，这个就是所谓的实力很好吗？虽然没有唱很差，可是还不到实力唱将咯，纯粹个人意见。
solekavin 3 years ago
靜茹只是對這首歌不太熟已而
yicecsze 2 years ago 17
不錯聽 可是我覺得可能對歌不太熟耶....
一開始有搶拍 有些地方拍子也不對
fo6409 3 years ago
唱功不错！
13605323450 3 years ago 5
好听耶！
CFSO5607 3 years ago 3
This kind of song requires a deeper woman's voice to bring out the feelings which the song expresses.
michikochee 3 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
I can see her cleavage.. :P
woozley18 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
hai.. I really like her, but must agree this song really don't suit her vocal. and she din't put in much emotion.
张靓颖 and wan fang is still the best. just my personal opinion. :)
siangal07 4 years ago 21
in fact this song really not suit her voice dont take wind as ascuse dont care how big the wind if the song suit for a people sure a very good song will came out .
SAA6153U 4 years ago 5
u can sing but this song doesn;t suites her voice... NO FEEL!!!
wydywong 4 years ago 5
the wind blew onto her face..how to sing well..mouth also cannot open though,but,quite ok..never gone too far away
ykhiny 4 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
声音很普同,唱的蛮差的
nightsucks 4 years ago
就是感情不够啊！
ericvoo 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
agree
ckokt 4 years ago
distracting wind
DoomGuy321 4 years ago 6
standing that high with wind blowing at face, i do not think you wanna sing at all.
yoyofish 4 years ago 8
Iagree. Not much emotion when singing this very emotional song. She didn't quite catch the tempo either at the start of the song. Finished well though.
cutieco2 4 years ago 5
ooo not bad but no emotions much
blablayou 4 years ago
謝謝分享~
viruslib 4 years ago 4