Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (282)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • ummmmmm, Shania's = the best. 

  • As an Alainer, I was terrified after this performance. I didn't think she deserved the criticism, she sounded great (IMO).

  • you know what haters, Lauren Alaina is an extremely talented girl who deserves everything she's got/getting, SHE'S A 16 YEAR OLD GIRL, of course she isnt as mature as some of the others !! Haley has had 5 more years to mature, but Lala still beat her, and its up to you voters anyway, so dont come on to a LAUREN ALAINA video and hate on her :/

  • Sibohan Magnus did great last year and she did horrible this year. Ruinned the song! But her other performances are wonderful anyway...

  • she makes this song perfect^_^

  • Has the voice but needs schooling.

  • @Darkle2010 dude ur just jealous because you cant sing as good as the person that didnt even make it to hollywood so you can stfu i agree not he best performance but she did it justice have you even hurd the original verison

  • @Darkle2010 you obviously dont know talent

  • Suck it all of you douche bags that hated on her! This just proves that karmas a bitch! she did nothing wrong and made it as far as she goes but the runner-up always goes farther than the acctual winner does (in most cases)

  • @Darkle2010 Haha its funny that Lauren made it farther than everyone else but scotty...so stop talkin bad about her...asshole...Get the hell off this channel you troll. GET A LIFE

  • Siobhan's performance is a lot better

  • New channel for America's Got Talent - AmericasGotTalent11 - Go subscribe!

  • @AmericanIdol2011TV  haha wats with the description??? lol

  • I love how when Lauren rolls her eyes it's no big deal, but when Haley does it she's a bitch. Kind of a double standard, dontcha think???

  • @CrazySabertooth Haley just stood up for herself. She got critized (or however you spell it) every performance. And Lauren just pouted when she got SOME constuctive critisism

  • @CallieAnn111 That's true, which makes the whole situation even more ridiculous. I'd also like to point out that, for some reason, this is the ONLY criticism Lauren got throughout the whole competition! I suppose we should keep in mind that Lauren's younger.  The people who called haley a bitch were just looking to hate on her, because they're girls who are insecure, and Haley is sexy and confident. That's why so many of them like Lauren so much, they can relate to her insecurity.

  • @CrazySabertooth Wow! That is soo true!

  • @CallieAnn111 I think that she's just so young and sweet most of the time, they didn't feel they could fairly critique her without feeling like complete douches.

  • @CrazySabertooth Yepp!

  • @Darkle2010 Yes they are really good. They're Destinee and Paris Monroe.

  • Everyone takes this so seriously. Lauren and Haley can have whatever expression they want, you want them to be happy all the time?

  • Gorda campesina ... aburridisima!!!!!!!! 

  • LOVE HER !!!

  • I don't understand why everyone thinks this was horrible. Yes, Siobhan did it better, but I thought Lauren sang it pretty well too.

  • This video isn't "HD". Pretty bad quality.

  • @playnicewithme it's HQ not HD theres a difference...

  • I don't think it looks like she's rolling her eyes....

  • Why is everyone saying Siobhan sang this better? Last time i checked Lauren made it to the top 2, and Siobhan made it to 6th place. Pus, you never even hear from that girl anymore, and you will hear from Lauren years from now. I can guarantee that.

  • Yeah she doesnt sound perferct but this song is ok

  • Siobhan Magnus sang this way better.

  • i dont see anything bad rolling her eyes. its just normal. maybe she was just disappointed that she couldve picked the a better song.

  • @MegaMeowable that's so rude and disrespectful and do not judge on the weight of a person this is a TALENT COMPETITION.

  • HD???pshaa...i get better vid from a fisher price cam

  • 2:07 to 2:10 her eyeroll.....so please no more calling Haley a brat. This girl is one here.

  • @FloridaSPHB YES! She is a brat because she shouldn't be rolling her eyes like that, it's an honor that she getting advice from Steven. Haley is badass and beautiful and handles it better.

  • @Sway2105 In my opinion Haley is a brat and i can't stand her.. she would act like she didn't even need constructive criticism from the judges and she would catch an attitude when they did give it.. im glad she didn't make it to the final two..

  • @CourtneyDanielle9392 i totally agree with u.... haley shouldnt of acted like tht towards randy. im glad she tripped LOL

  • @Sway2105 wait..... thats fiunny... did you say haley handles criticism better than Lauren??? seriously???? you're fucking hilarious.

  • @dubsetcatz914 Yes I said it, it's my opinion just like you have yours. . .And i'm very glad i amuse you. hahaha. .

  • @FloridaSPHB you're hilarious. idk if you ever watched ANY OTHER EPISODE OF THIS SHOW. lauren might've rolled her eyes here but im pretty sure this is the only place she did. and she deserved to. this was fantastic. Haley's done bad and been pissed off at the judges WHILE talking back at them when they were critiquing her. GET YOUR EYES CHECKED. immediately.

  • I miss this episode if I didnt already think she was good then this would have made her better

  • lauren rocks

  • scotty should win..

  • NOT SO SPECIAL

  • Pfft, nothing special at all. Can someone please remind me why Haley got voted off instead of her?

  • HQ my ass.

  • I don't understand why this performance got such bad reviews. It's much better than most of her current opponent's performances.

  • @Bellizzi804 I totally agree. I thought this performance was really good.

  • she isn't fat at all she is a healthy girl who isn't aneroxic like most girls. Proud she is normal and not with a eating disorder.. its people like u who make girls have eating problems.

  • SHE DESERVES TO WIN

    MUCH BETTER VOICE

    VOTE NONSTOP!!!!!!!!!

  • She's another cookie-cutter, sorry. AI alumna Carrie Underwood and the evergreen LeAnn Rimes and other female singers win hands down in this department.

  • HQ???

  • she's good but i still hope scotty wins

  • @rockty429 Don't try to act like you know her. She doesn't come off fake at all. If you don't like her, don't come on her videos & spread your negativity . You're the one being childish.

  • I don't think she was being rude or spoiled. I think she was upset at herself because Steven normally givs her 100% positive feedback and love, butthis time she didn't quite get it.

    For those that thinks that she can't sing, i'd like to see you get up there and perform...

    For a 16 year old she i Awsome and when she sings with Scotty McCreery its

    perfection.

  • @jennwynhoff she's a brat and she's fake. she has been trying to act all sweet but she's really childish. this video is where it all went wrong. the judges tell her she sucked and she can't take it. they then become scared to tell her she sucks later on. no wonder she isn't rolling her eyes now they always say she is good because they are scared of hurting a 16 year olds feelings. lauren should have left weeks ago

  • She is A little Carrie Underwood. If you know what I am saying.

    If she can't sing then apparently the TOP THREE means nothing to you.

  • SHES AMAZING

    I <3 LAUREN ALAINA

  • She does not do this song very well.

  • OMG......what a RUDE eyeroll that was! She acted like a spoiled 10 year old!!

    YOU should have been the one gone this week....NOT JAMES!!!!

    LAUREN is a spoled brat and can't take any criticism or she starts crying.

    Go home and get some voice lessons because your voice is just not good.

  • @FloridaSPHB clearly you dont know the definition of amazing music so i suggest you go look it up

    If you dont like her why look her up? I wanna know

  • @LoganIsMine100

    I'm a music major so don't tell me I don't know anything about music.

    Lauren doesn't have any breath control....at all.

    She needs to go away and come back in 5 years.

    She's too young and immature.

  • @FloridaSPHB but u dont hav 2 b so mean

  • @FloridaSPHB but u dont hav 2 b so mean shes 16 years old

  • @FloridaSPHB thats because she's 16... good god i hope you never have children the verbal abuse just because ther body hasnt mature yet wow horrible.

  • Check it Lauren you need to go away because everything you do is for the wrong reason and stop using our town as a way to get publicity we hate you love Anthony Lumpkin argue with me on twitter @DARKSCENE18 beyotch!

  • REAL men don't like toothpick girls. Those skin and bones chicks are sickly to us REAL MEN. Oh yea we don't get botoxed or manicures or wear fancy girly close!!!

  • Honestly I didn't think this was bad at all I don't understand why the judges didn't like it. Lauren & Scotty in the finally!!!

  • i love lauren so much she is so amazing i love every song she sang some were better then others but she is so talented and is so beautiful

  • take it all the way to the top alaina, you got it girl take this competitin home you truly deserve it.

  • Lauren sings like a professional 25 or 30 year old at age 15. Saying simply that she sucks, makes be hunger for more of your Juliard level of musical knowledge and experience. LOL

  • she sucks

  • @tinleyparkmom she hit every note and was sung it perfectly lol so technically she dosnt suck at all

  • she is the best

  • Vote James & Hailey

  • @swtgrl85 You didn't even spell Haley's name right...

  • she sounds really good

  • Siobhan's version is soooo gooood!

  • I FUCKIN LOVE YOU LAUREN !!! <3 <3 <3 <3

  • A bunch of DUMBASS people who dont have a clue what Beautiful is... Lauren you great and YOU DONT need to change. End of story. <3

  • She just need to lose some weight and she's gonna be PERFECT. Not that it really matters though, everybody loves her for being herself. Maybe she's already perfect afterall!

  • @rockskater012 Not true

  • try to listen to Siobhan Magnus version,.. She sang it very good,..

  • wooww,.. shes great,.. shes a good singer, she sang the song way better than shania. However, Siobhan Magnus "Any man of mine" was the best and perfect rendition of the song. Only Siobhan can nail the song...

  • ******Make sure we all vote for her as many times as possible!!! VOTE VOTE VOTE! She really is the whole package! She NEEDS to win!!!******

  • no that was terrible

  • boring...

  • good show...  loooool ..but...

  • they need to be REAL judges and not sugarcoat and be apologetic when they saw she was so affected by one little comment that steven made. and she just needs to be able to take the criticism cuz this wasn't a good performance. she still has a LONG way to go.

  • DON'T INSULT PROBABLY THE BEST SINGER TO COME OUT OF IDOL.SHE'S NOT IN THE SAME CLASS AS HER.HER VOICE,LOOK,PERSONALITY,WHATEVE­R, DOESN'T HOLD A CANDLE TO HER.THAT WOMAN IS CARRIE UNDERWOOD.VOICE OF AN ANGEL.LOOK OF A GODDESS.PERSONIFICATION OF BEAUTY AND TALENT.

  • oscena

  • ome she gonna win i know it i love her she raping miley with her own song

  • *** DONT FORGET TO VOTE FOR HER! SHES AMAZING! VOTE VOTE VOTE! :D***

  • she looks like carrie underwood and sings like her so that make her a winner

  • @julien19922010 I think she's better than Carrie Underwood!

  • @julien19922010 They are both white women. That's where the similarities end.

  • she is gorgeous.

  • She's the winner in my book.

  • shes not fat i bet she is skinnier then all of u combined thumbs up if u agree

  • LOVE HERRRRRRRRRRRR SO MUCH!!! she's amazing!!!!!!!!! in every single way!!!!

  • SHE IS BETTER THEN SHANIA TWAIN !!!!!!!

  • @depelated  NO! JAMES IS GONNA WIN!! AND SCOTTY'S GONNA BE 2nd or 3rd !!!

  • @depelated Bahahahahahahaha!! This is hilarious!! The two you said would go home sooner are the very ones that are in the finals!!! Baahahahahahaha......The two that can actually sing.....no offense to a couple of the other ones cause they could sing too but these two were my favorites......

  • @GreenEyedHeather03

    True...no offense or anything...but this goes to show that Idol votes are dominated by hormonal teenagers who just want to see the best looking person win. It explains why Scott and James made it into the top 4, they were the best looking of the bunch (James has a pretty good voice too). But you cant deny, Jacob Lusk, Casey Abrams, and Pia Toscano were, by far, the best vocalists of them all (they had much more range, better pitch, and were much more unique).

  • @depelated No offense taken! Just thought it was funny...no offense 2 you either! We've all got opinions. I cant say the votes are only from little girls/little guys who r just lookin 4 a pretty face/cute guy to vote for. I know ALOT of people who are either in there 20's or married that vote there butts off 4 the person they like the most. This is opinion votes & whoever gets the most votes gets to stay....To be honest I NEVER liked Pia or Casey. James was great but I didnt vote 4 him.... :)

  • @AmericanIdol2011TV your so rude she's not even big at all she pretty and its better than bein stick ass skinny.

  • @TheAlpinestars007 How am I being rude? Lauren's the most beautiful girl on the show, and some asshole made a fat joke about her.

  • @AmericanIdol2011TV I think he meant for that to go to the other dude :P

  • @AmericanIdol2011TV I think she was calling the other person rude. not you :)

  • @TheAlpinestars007 no i wasnt talking to you i was talking to the guy that mad the comment about her bein fat.

  • @TheAlpinestars007 i'm agree with you and it's not her appeance that we judges but her voice and she have a beautiful voice (sorry if you don't understand)

  • @RTT8001 She has curves in all the right places...so fuck off you jealous punk-ass motherfucker...RUDE RUDE RUDE.

  • @RTT8001- u need to shutup @RTT8001, nobody wants ur stupid opinions if there not true and if there dumb, so get a life and shut up.!! ur such a jackass!! ur a piece of shit and have nothing better to do! ur gonna grow up get fat and wish u never said what u said.! stupid son of a BI***

  • @RTT8001 WOW UR SO RUDE.... u should be ashamed of yourself

  • @RTT8001 Whats up with you guys thinking shes fat shes not fat at all i've seen fatter people than that

  • Do you think when she said "I didn't want to do a ballad because that's what eveybody does" that was a dig a Pia Toscano? I get the impression this girl is a brat and needs to learn to handle rejection or she'll never make it in the music business. She has a really great voice, I don't really know what happened on this song? It sounded like she wasn't breathing

  • Shes good and I thought she would win,but now I just don't see it.This performance was absolutely one of the worst ever on idol when they went to the top singers as she will have to be careful with the song choice.

  • shes good,but in her audition she seemed more pop/r&b not country,i mean she obviously has a southern accent but just becuase your from the south doesnt mean your a country.its a bit annoying that america seems to love the country singers.ugh

  • damn shes hot!!

  • Nice girl but lame singer.. She needs to control her weight too.By the time she's 30 she could be 250 pounds.

    Go Stefano, Pia and Jacob !!! The real singers.

  • @RTT8001 what are you talking about???? im honestly not understanding any of these comments... she isn't heavy at all. she's stunning and fit looking.

  • Since the beggining she was so overrated because is a teenager, but come on! guys, Lauren is the weakest female contestant of this season. Haley & Pia are much better. It´s time she goes home.

  • Who will win American Idol on 06 Apr.2011

    Scotty McCreery,James Durbin, Pia Toscano, Lauren Alaina, Casey Abrams, Jacob Lusk, Paul McDonald

  • I love this song, and I love Lauren! Her and Haley are my favorite girls! 

  • I loved her performance! I love all her performances!

  • this is in high quality?

  • I love her! And don't hate on her wardrobe. She is modest and doesn't have to flaunt her natural beauty. And as we all know, she is like 15. I respect her for that.

  • REALLY good..!!

  • Wow! This is one of her best performances!

  • love this..:D

  • chick singer, fast forward

  • she's really good, but there's nothing exactly unique about her voice.

  • haha!! love the face at 3:45!

  • she has everything to succeed ,that's what i call a perfect woman,,gorgeous excellent singer and beautiful body,,i want a woman like her,,muah.

  • hey.. umm... american idol 2011tv, carrasco30g,alxtourv!! yall need to shut ur effin mouth and get a life, stop bieng jelous..mmk! nobody wants ur dumb responses if there going to be stupid like ur life..! okay..! thanks.. buh bye.!!! :)

  • me encanta esta mujer y soo sexy

  • dammmmm i love her, lauren and pia is my fav.!!

  • is time to go baby...you sucked in this SONG..>TRASHHH..GO HOME....

  • I'm not a big fan of kids/teens doing grown up songs. Her voice rocks though.

  • She's amazing! And she broke the curse with this song! haha

  • SHE'S MY FAVORITE!!! ♥ lAUREN aLAINA ♥

  • AEROSMITH KISSASSER

  • THAT HAIR FLIP WAS WEAK

  • this song sent siobhan home dudes

  • PLEASE WIN LAUREN! :)

  • she sucks i like jacob and james i think they can sing casey and naima are ok and if all else paul is decent

  • @Rashi3Rashi for me Lauren Alaina will be a superstar because the fact that she is just only 15 years old. She is also the fusion of AI alumni and top recording artists Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood. who had million album sales. I think if Simon Cowell still be one of the 3 judges, her favorite is Alaina and judge others badly like the early previous seasons.

  • Siobhan magnus did it better

  • @tanujlamech Siobhan sings off keys on low notes. but she has incredible range

  • 3:26 Steven is tired of her crap hahaha