Niddar aka Giddar Nang apologising in Hazur Sahib

[singhguvi]

@londonpind where do u live I'll come and talk to you about SikhI .......

[dukepanthermako]

@Ranjeet1469Singh is widely known that the 10th Guru did hunt animals. Its not known if the 10th Guru took phang but his Akali warrior's did. The Akali's were known during the 1800's during Ranjit Singh's time in doing jatka..and they ate meat in times of war. And when it comes to starvation a sikh is allowed to eat anything to survive, when the first Sikh Holocost happened in 1700's, the Sikhs ate meat when they hid in jungles. However a Sikh can only eat meat as a last resort.

[anonymusneo]

@dukepanthermako my grand maa told me that i remember that one 

[singhakabuttar]

@Ranjeet1469Singh you may be a gursikh, your grandfather may be also, that does not give you the right to interpretate what is and what is not written in the Gurbani, also the gurbani is not written by one person, it has verses in it from many sources, so like i said not all the gurus ate meat, drank alcohol, some did some didnt, the Gurbani may not have even been complete, at that time, by the time of completion the gurus( at least some of them may have passed on!

[singhakabuttar]

@Ranjeet1469Singh hunted to release trapped souls?????? strength came from bani???????????? wake up veerji, sikhism is about realism, not hocus pocus rubbish! why did they train swordsmanship? to kill the enemy, enemy is human, so killing was involved, we are not allowed halal meat! thats all, we can have chatka da meat! at least you admit that they consumed bhang! you cant just twist the truth around to suit yourself! and since when does the Sri Guru Granth Sahib become SGGS, show some respect

[singhakabuttar]

@Ranjeet1469Singh MR Ranjit singh, it is a well known fact that Guru Gobind Singh Ji played shikaar(the hunting of animals), it is also known that before going into battle, the gurus did consume some alcohol/pang, they also ate meat, maybe not all of them but some of them did, you can not justify the cause of sikhi by lying, facts are facts, there is no point in adjusting the truth to suit ourselves, when the gurus were fighting against the moghuls, killing took place, humans are also animals.

[singhakabuttar]

@Ranjeet1469Singh APPARENTLY???? lol, if its only apparently VEERJI? why are you getting yourself all wound up? go about your business, if you think eating meat/ drinking is wrong, dont do it, you dont have to consume ganja or sleep around, just cause he APPARENTLY tells people to. just chill out bro!

[singhakabuttar]

@Ranjeet1469Singh its impossible to infiltrate/ruin sikhism, sikhism means to have a pure heart, with a pure heart comes many great things, so dont worry about it, live a happy life, be good to yourself and kind to others, and your sikhi will flourish!

[singhakabuttar]

this is not fair, no one let niddar singh have his say, it was a forced so called apology, and since then niddar singh has gained more respect from the ,martial art he teaches

[tiwanasonyamandeep09]

bai band kar ess no jhagga chakan nal apna hi dhidd nanga hunda

[sonyericsson1049]

Sant Ji, ---Gurudwara Gyaan Godrhi in Hardwar at Har ki pauri was demolished in 1984 riots. UP administration had made a complex of 60 (proximate) shops. Baba ji,- who will liberate this Historical Gurudwara from Govt. shops..? From where the Khalsa would come to take care ( Seva Sambhal) of ruined Gaaurudwara...? Why do we ardass every day many times that-- " Panth to vichhorhe hoye Gurudwarian di seva Sambhal khalsa ji nu bakhsho ji..."..Sant ji, is that khasa is differant from today's.?

[JoedhSingh]

People are stupid.

Ever heard of Sehajdhari's? No well find out before spouting rubbish here.

Niddar Singh is a good man that teaches Singh's to fight and stand up for themselves, which is more than I can say for most of the little farts I see looking all yellow anaemic and skinny in Gurudwaras!!

[orkiutboy]

The only thing he wrote in book is that current jathedar of sri hazur sahib is not strong enough to keep the puratan mareyada of takht sahib alive such as sukhnidhan degh mareyada jhatka mareyada and parkash of sri dasam granth alive keeping in view the ongoing endless pressure from sikhs with different mind set ... this is the only controversial stuff in his book ... jathedar sahib is seen after guru sahib by the local people which raised voice and hence he was made to apologise

[84WAKEUP]

why do nihand do jhatka n why is dasam granth seperate 4rom guru granth sahib ji maharaj n how come dasam granth is not at harimandir sahi plz i need to know paji

[SahijApple93]

The Guru Granth Sahib ji is supposed to be seperate because Guru Gobind Singh Ji left it like that. They did not wish that it be included with the bani of Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. It is not supposed to be used the way do at Hazur Sahib as It is not what we bow down to. We only bow down to Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Also most of the things written in the dasam granth has questionable content. It has many sexual themes and most Sihks dont believe Guru Gobind Singh Ji could say that.

[SardarDholi]

Fateh veere.I've seen this video before but I haven't got a clue why his book is so controversial.I haven't got around to reading the book yet though it's lying in my bedroom. can someone please tell me why it is so controversial.

Rabh rakha

[WakeUpSikhs]

@SardarDholi hes basically said its ok to drink and its ok for girls to cut there hair - in his book hes wrote so many things which are agaisnt what sikhs actually believe in - its against what guru maharaaj teaches us - so there for he is misleading the sikh panth - which is why singhs have put a step foward to speak up and let him no hes wrongm his book that he has wrote is wrong and there for he is to apologise and ask maafi from guru ji which he has done in this video.

[SardarDholi]

Damn...thats messed up. I've seen him make the apology to the Takht Sri Hazur Sahib Sangat, but has he actually changed anything in the book? Thanks for replying yaara.

Rabh Rakha

[londonpind]

@WakeUpSikhs

sat sri akal bai ji. i live here in london, uk and before watching this video i was completely unaware of the matter but what u have wrote in ur comments is practically true. sikhs here in uk follows a completly different path and i personally know few other nihangs like who preaches things like " its ok to drink or smoke" etc.

what i wanna say is that the shromni gurudwara committee should step forward and stop these kind of false preachings in uk and anywhere else in world.

[KillinDaWelfareMCs]

@londonpind the panth is a farce now. With their magical underwear and cerimonial daggers.

[londonpind]

@KillinDaWelfareMCs so tru man. they r just forgetting the original message of sikhism and becoming more of posers.

[mardanafuckednanak]

niddar koi giddar nahin, nidddar guru han

[harry8206]

hey parminder.....its no where written in sri guru granth sahib ji......tht we cant have sex........think about ur past life.....and ask urself ...r u a good guy....or bad guy.......loki niki jayu gal nu ami chak laende.......ehna nu puchhe koi.....tuhaade palle ki aa.....

[bb2nv]

kidha yeh we can onli have sex with our marital partners and that too onli to have kids not just for fun. if it's jus for fun it would be kaam (lust) and if it's not clearly stated in the Guru Granth Sahib Ji then look at the gurus lives, they never preached about havin sex jus for the fun of it

[parminder1324]

niddar is a mother fuckin bullshit nihaang. he tells sikh's that they can drink, smoke, have sex and he thinks he's all that. tell me where that is allowed in guru granth sahib ji that sikh's are allowed to do that. niddar is a great warrior but he's mentally retarded on the inside. like y the hell would he tell us sikh's to go smoke and shit. at the end of the day, he's a good guy that does stupid things or a bad guy that does good thing. its up to u to decide

[harvinder1]

fuck uuu

[harvinder1]

if we cant have sex then shoot me now i dont want to live

[taksalipride]

lol u nob, thats funny

[mardanafuckednanak]

jai ho niddar di , niddar sacha nihang han

[uclajatt11]

Looks like the Sikh Inquisition to me. How is this scene different from what Galileo had to go through 400 years ago. Legitimate scholars are being repressed while the illiterate run amok claiming blasphemy. We should encourage scholarship and scholarly discourse instead of scaring any future scholars of dire consequences.

[godsoldier]

I agree, but I would not put Niddar Singh up with the likes of Galileo.

[harvinder1]

i would

[tjpannu123]

I am the original poster of the Galileo comment. I was alluding to an incident in Galileo's life when faced the Spanish inquisition to answer questions about his latest scientific work that supported the heliocentric theory of Copernicus.He was threatened with torture. The video reminded me of that scene. I agree with you any other parallel between Niddar Singh and Galileo cannot be drawn, for one was a scientist who changed the world, while the other is a budding scholar of Sikh history.

[bitsingh]

My message for all the sikhs here supporting

NIDDAR the GIDDAR, Its common sense that - 1. if he hadnt made the mistake then why is he appologizing .2. If Niddar is a true Sikh then He should not fear to a group of sikhs. Coz a Sikh has a Power of SAVA LAKH. 3. Sikhs of Hazoor saheb may b illeterate according to u coz they r literate in GURU MAHARAJ's BANI , I bet. 4. V the Dakhni Sikhs who were their with GURU MAHARAAJ and stayed with him till his last time r true followers ... rest ran away

[mudakk2009]

What is fear? Where you see fear? What was he to chop all those hot excited Sikhs? "I do not think this is better.

[mardanafuckednanak]

teri maa di lund kuteyah, nidddar uk akeh teri bund mardu salleah

[harvinder1]

fuduuuu say it to his face and watch how he batters fuking cunt

[netaddicted]

when the guy is coperating to appolozise then why everybody is messing up the scene.

[JoedhSingh]

Niddar is a better Sikh than most of the ppl who post here.

This show has been instigated by morons from AKJ, DDT, and other stoopid Sikh cults.

Read the book you morons before making comments. He criticised retards who demolished building built by Guru Gobinds own Sikhs. These building were knocked down in the name of progress. Niddar Singh was 100% correct to tell them off.

[MixingLaboratory]

100% CORRECT.

[SpinnerSingh]

He was forced to apologize because he said shit towards the Jathedar at Huzor Sahib saying hes doing dumb shit...so they took him and made him apologize for that. Read the book before you become engrossed in rumors

[SpinnerSingh]

People don't even know what happened here....No one here has READ the BOOK. From people inside Nidar Singhs Circle they say its bullshit that they said it was okay for woman to cut their kes its a rumor apparently readthe facts before you guy by exactly what people said.

[Gavriel0]

apparently nidar singh ji drinks alot when nervous

[Ghettobunda]

what book did you read that from?!

None?

i thought so

[Gavriel0]

I didnt mean alcohol, i mean from his cup in the video. Why so defensive?

[RaethanaRana]

man that niddar guy would probably bitch slap ALL of these "khalsa ji's" in the video....fucking up a perfectly good faith man..these pussy ass faggots are!

[khalistaniSoorma]

He apologized because he was wrong. You prove what he said was right, then and only then, you have the right to comment on wrong as right. What gives him the right to write against sikh panth, what gives him the right to write that sikh women can CUT HAIR, and COMSURE ALCOHOL? He did all that, and then apologized. He had to. He had no other option. And remember, you "cannot" bitch slap khalsa, it never happened and will never happen. Why, because, KHALSA AKAL PURAKH KI FAUJ.

[RaethanaRana]

I didnt even know what he wrote and find it so hard to digest that he actually wrote that sikh women could do that??? what the fuck was his basis of proof for this??? weired fucker

[KhalsaSoulja]

I also came across a webpage that said Niddar wrote in his book women can cut their hair and drink alcohol.

However would you be so kind as to inform me what page number this is written on.

[godsoldier]

But will he change the statements in the book?

[payneet]

What a dumb reply. Find out wat sikhi is before you start taling what is acceptable and unacceptble in Sikhism.

[RaethanaRana]

"payneet" ? ...where did i "tell" what was acceptable and unacceptable in sikhism?...fucking asshole stfu

[guptuser]

It's funny I don't think people know what they are talking about. You can see from what is going on that the people around causing the commotion are uneducated. There is no point arguing with fools, even Bani states this! I suggest that the book is read before anyone makes assumptions about what they think they know. Niddar Singh & Parmjit Singh has being carrying out 10 years of research, we should all see that facts before making a opinion.

[anonymusneo]

@guptuser i have been to nidar singhs site and on his flickr account there are pics of goats being killed by sikhs , we are never taught to do that ,

[relativity17]

hahaha, he saying he doesnt want anyone to film him apologising, but all the chardi kala singhs bust up his ass and say shut up u nob, ur the one apologising, dont tell us wot to do!!!! hahaha lolllz! Akaaal!

[singhakabuttar]

@relativity17 theres nothing of this nature happening at all, u have a wild imagination pal!