超級星光大道 第二季 20080118 總決賽 梁文音 Candyman

[kkes306010806]

很好聽，可是英文發音阿

[as2009boa]

幹嘛跟原唱比啊?文音當然不可能唱得贏克莉絲汀啊~克莉絲汀是世­界級的歌手耶!!文音如果能唱贏他~那還在台灣幹嘛~?一般人能­把克莉絲汀的個唱到這樣就算不錯了~就好像林宜融大家說他跳得沒­寶兒好一樣~他怎麼可能跳得比寶兒好??寶兒是真的非常能跳耶~­他剛學跳舞如果就能跳得比寶兒好~那幹嘛還唱歌~跳舞就好啦!!­相對的~我覺得有些支持他們的人也不可以說他們做得比原唱好..­...因為明明就沒有.......

[rabuchu]

她的領口怎麼了 -__-

[star3121001]

有點像趕火車?

[1116MrShow]

@star3121001 难道唱快歌要慢1拍吗？

[lomfgbbq]

Chinese accent and English songs just doesn't match

[osawa1008]

@lomfgbbq Check your grammar...

[aaaaa50601]

樓下那位也太沒音樂能力了吧

那不就狂走音

在藍調音階李

那都是正常的音好嗎

這樣評論只會讓人看見你都沒有深度

超弱

[iamplutolin]

狂走音= =

[k060500376]

表演內容100分

歌唱實力100分

人美聲優 

這首值滿分!!!!

[scission1985]

this is way better than the champion imo...

[roy5347]

如果是唱華文會討好點,至少要選抒情歌曲....OK

[chuehliao]

看了就流口水的表演

看幾次反應都一樣

話說：觀眾怎麼沒有興奮感動到起立鼓掌啊??

可能是現場氣氛還是太緊張了吧！

[f2546806y]

快3張cd!!

[f2546806y]

好好聽!!

[cherieyeung23]

第3張ep 錄製中......請多多支持!!

我都好喜歡文音唱這首...

好活潑丫!!! ｉ love you

[jena0616]

超好聽

[2931977012]

......

Christina Aguilera 唱的比較好

[TheCariDee]

@2931977012

Xtina名列MTV「音樂界22位絕佳優嗓(前五名)」、滾石­雜誌「史上百位偉大歌手」

如果梁文音唱得比他好你也該佩服他

[heifetzso]

@TheCariDee

雖然我也覺得xtina 比較好,但名氣跟一隻歌誰唱得比較好好像沒有甚麼關係

[TheCariDee]

@heifetzso

MTV的絕佳優嗓跟滾石的百位偉大歌手是依"實力"選擇不是"名­氣"

[po91123]

為什麼文音在節目曝光率這麼低

除了星一幾個人之外

之後星二以後的 就梁文音粉絲最多阿= =

真不懂公司在想些什麼...

趕快發第3張=ˇ=

[生平買第一張專輯就是文音了]



[oof15]

天呀唱的實在太棒了

[iammonkeychi]

文音好正啊!!!

正到翻XD

[xiaoyu1024]

笑起来真好看！

[AI913]

好sexy ar~~

[falachun]

動靜皆宜

勵害勵害

[zengxingfen]

喜歡聽她的歌了~

[lungpig]

=v=當然是文音唱得比較好

[din3786]

星光6的candyman 跟 星光2的candyman差別怎麼這麼大阿

[roger3793]

是有段差距

但拿馬小姐和她比有點不公平吧

這首歌我聽了四個參賽者唱過

還是她唱的最好

環球很奇怪

明明她是極有舞台魅力的歌手

為何要她走如此狹隘的路線呢

[hkp72302]

she's really so pretty and wonderful! Two thumbs up!

[seasky21]

好好聽~~~

[gi1234g]

奇怪第二屆評審是怎麼回事?

死都不給25分

[chongb]

I think season 1 and season 2 's singers were very very good, that's y the judges did not need to give overrated full marks to boost up the tv rating..

[s7a9m8m1y]

他們的耳朵被第一屆養大了，在第三屆才比較降低標準。

[momobear1129]

而且他演唱這首歌的時候

前面還有播成長使

還可以表演的那麼好

文音真厲害ˊˇˋb

[s100134]

這樣也輸掉冠軍, 怎能不肚爛

[mapleally]

文音唱歌實在太棒了!

超好聽的啦!

[loveIcandy]

虽然比原唱差了很多，但是现场这样已经很惊人了

[yvette74731]

星光班如果要開個人演唱會,只有三個夠看:

1.林芯儀 2葉瑋庭 3梁文音

[johboy2418]

How much she score for this song?

[TFforum]

24 out of 25

[vivaschan123]

it is non-sense to judge her performance with a great american idol's standard. i watched x`tina performacne n i would say hers is reli sophisticated n rock, but this doesnt mean wenyin performance sucks. even if we show our best card like jacky cheung to sing this song, u would still think he sucks coz deep in our blood, our gene, we are diff from americans. the best song in usa is r&b while in asia its soft love song. so dont just criticise for criticising

[onlymes]

she did ruin the song... not only talking about her oral eng, but also her expression of the lyrics. =.=' she really doesnt understand the meaning of the song...thats why she expressed it in a wrong way. *sigh*

[highwin26]

你很行你去唱唱看吧...

[siqi246]

Precisely. I bet you don't even have the guts to do so!!!

[dkniche]

Wow! I love the last part when the dancer carry her up and swing her around. That guy is damn lucky man!

[dkniche]

Wow! I love the last part when the dancer carry her up and swing her around. That guy is damn lucky man!

[binbinice]

cherry代指處女膜

pop有擠破之意

所以makes my cherry pop意指....

但這又如何

歌難道在強調這些嗎

Lady Marmelade講白話還比這更露骨

但人家還不是唱的很有味道

不是歌詞寫怎樣歌就要唱成怎樣吧

[perfectshiningstar]

The bst performance ever! I love it! Rachel is the best!

[Lamerstu]

I still think it was a big mistake to make her second. A lot of people were mad and didn't want to watch the 3rd season because of that. She deserves it.

[ahwen214]

she's awesome!!!

she really workhard, she should be the champion...

[gary0319]

ahhh....

梁文音 i love u....

ur voice ur face all so beautiful and cute

[overseaconanfan]

a real jaw dropping performance.. *roll eyes* wat was 1:06 about??

[startingsprinter]

what happened at 1:06??

[AMUSE154]

文音真的是在星光最代表性的女生歌手!!!

[sl414]

This performance derserves the championship

[roger3793]

最近看到三班表演

再回頭看她的影片

真有說不出的懷念

[SodanMK]

every time i see 文音 works so hard.

i just want to cry

and ...

even you were not the champion

in my heart, you are the winner !!

[sl414]

tres bien

[junhao405]

Her english is very good le. Wen Yiin is more sexy and cute. Perfect singing! WenYin Rocks!

[shanb1028]

i cann0t agree anym0re !!

[HayleyStitchLover]

i dont hear any accents that bad you know.

this is totally fantastic for someone of native in taiwan..

[kattyty]

Absolutely stunning performance!! even her eyes were acting very well!!

[darkness3899]

if you can get christina to sing chinese song thats as great as wenyn singing english song, tell perhaps you can comment on wenyin's performance. idiots like you who can only bluntly criticize w/o thinking. god knows if you're just jealous that you cant do anywhere close to wenyin :)

[dummylolo]

does the accent that u guys emphasized really that important?

its a singing competition in Taiwan, come on!

plz dont ask for a native english speaker in Taiwan...thats hard to find one out of hundred over there

and ...she didnt make any big pronounciational mistakes, right??

I do think WenYin performed very well in this song!

[mickeyminnie80]

she is better than u lol!idiot n gaby

[kayelimcs]

for sure,

she is going to the "professional" singing competition, but i'm not.

so, please show us the sort of "professional" talent

[devashenhu]

wonder why ppl always criticize her english... the competition is about singing not english... duh?

[gaskay9265]

but she sing the best in chinese..dont u think so...i think she is a very good singer...just not ok in choosing the song best for her..

[mi036]

this song is hard to sing..she did pretty good..

[complicatedd]

her english isnt bad at all!!

[tfnylove]

omg 当她尖叫她的声音很高

i lovee it!

好运梁文音

[lzbin]

for me i still think christina sang better..

but,

shes really very very good for a chinese to sing till this well...

love her so much~~ gambate~

waiting for her album~

[roger3793]

很不錯的一首歌

[bluegating]

超好看的 我好喜歡那種甜美兼具歌藝的歌手 最近看了超級偶像的舞台魅力賽 之前認為裡面很多人都唱的很好 但唱了動感的歌 包括有人唱了跟葉瑋庭一樣的Crazy in love 就明顯聽出實力差距 會唱歌的人很多 但動靜皆宜的人真的不多 梁文音是我認為近期內不可多得的一位歌者 大家認為呢

[ellise1973]

滿同意你說的

我也很看好她

[heifetzso]

to me ,she performed this song better than original singer

[startingsprinter]

looks better!!!

[blkoolkat]

im am going to shot myself.

[ellise1973]

真的很不錯

很有才華的女孩

她如果無法發片的話

是台灣唱片界的損失

近年來很難找到外型甜美 唱功佳及舞蹈能力皆強的新人

不是缺這就是缺那個

她幾乎是這幾項全俱備了

我非常看好她的未來

[niurouwan]

and she is young!

[gaga83425]

She did very well in this competition!!She sure gonna be a good singer!!!

[gaga83425]

She did very well in this competition!!She sure gonna be a good singer!!!

[DomotoCat]

新加坡人講英文也有新加坡腔，

新加坡腔也不是屬於高級的那種腔調

[vicky114608]

說真的我很看好她

她應該有潛力成為台灣的天后

[uuDesu]

yhjkl剛剛看了你其他留言，你只有一昧的批評，這就是你所謂­的"表演者應該面對的事實"?外國客戶阿...不是只有洋人才叫­做外國客戶，泰國的客戶也是外國客戶，他的英文當然也可以是零零­散散。所以不要真的以為你的華文很好了在這跟我嗆你的華文有多好­OK?還有阿，什麼叫做stupid Taiwanese，好歹你也是生活在有水準的國家，麻煩拿出你­的水準。

[uuDesu]

我相信他們會接受你的道歉，況且我不是來跟你吵架的。就到這裡為­止了，我不在回了。

[uuDesu]

噢對了，還有那些說她英文很爛的，你們要不要說說中文給我們聽聽­?照照鏡子吧你們這些臭嘴!

[yhjkl]

喂臭嘴，今年几岁啊？你的心胸太狭窄了吧？我觉得你比那些给于负­面意见的人更加丢脸耶~

[uuDesu]

疑，我也可否你幾歲阿?心胸狹窄的是你吧?想必你是新加坡來的吧­，你用華文回我沒有比較厲害，要用英文寫論文當然沒問題，問題是­你的發音能比那些華語國家標準嗎?相對的，我們華語國家的人講英­文當然沒比英語國家標準。等你理解了我所謂的"英文差"在來re­ply我的文，謝謝。抱不平不代表心胸狹窄，心胸狹窄的是你們這­些批評別人的人跟不能接受別人的批評的人!So what? SO LEARN UR MANDARIN!!

[yhjkl]

我是说过她的英文差啊，so what? 现在还用华语文字来回你呢。

[KitL2686]

This shows you're english is no better than 梁文音. Your grammar aint perfect either. Must you be so harsh. She's a great singer. Even if she didnt sound perfect performing this song doesnt change the fact she's a really great singer.

[uuDesu]

真是搞不懂那些給批評的人，雖然評論是客觀的，但是她沒受過專業­的訓練就可以唱成這樣，反觀你們這些人，能唱的多好?多能跳?她­當然不能跟一個出道這麼久的天后比，基本的讚美跟支持都跑哪了?­不高興自己錄一段上來給我們評論吧!!丟臉!

[NiihRoxx]

Love It!

[snuggalisious]

WOW shes bad major brain hermridage

[liteng20]

ok...she quite ok!not so well but at least she have do her best !i think she wont be the best but at least she have done her job completely!: )pretty good

[loonylulu1015]

nightmare

[loonylulu1015]

she sounds horrible as for her english....headache

[loonylulu1015]

she just ruined a great song, and she's giving me a headache

[andreitalz87]

que asssssssco, Dios y christina aguilera perdonden esto!

[sp2001621]

I really think so, chrisina is much better!!

[collyen]

shut your fucking mouth!!!! you only know how to criticise, i guess you felt better when you do that huh? she has done her job and she did great at least. what the fuck have you got and just keep criticising people. Also for those who listen to this and got headache one, just stop listen to this video clip, go to bed and sleep tight!!! beware the ghost crawl to your bed. p.s. wen ying gambade!!!!

[dog0989244057]

唱得真好!!

罵人的請自己來唱跳阿

唱的比他好再來說吧

唉  . .

[woehn]

plz stop compare this lady with christina aguilera.... she is totally nothing can compare with christina aguilera

[ellise1973]

少裝洋人了

爛貨一個

[ellise1973]

唱的真好

我前天播給一個外國客戶看

他豎起大姆指說

The girl is very sweet and song very prefect

[KitL2686]

Sad to say your english isnt that great either.

I know you got your own opinions but dont talk like you're so darn right. Most chinese educated cant help it if their english isnt perfect. Just like how a foreigner cant pronounce chinese very well.

[sixdegallo]

that's nice but no one people sing like my adorable christina aguilera

[Swedyn]

Who is the girl that's singing?

[denisito1982]

WOW THIS SUCKS!!

[jadorebabyjane]

she was really good considering that this song is sang by christina aguilera, and she could reach the high note pretty well also!

but i'm still loving christina's candyman :P

[chloe818]

lol

[harryjarman90]

bloody awful

[youryoury]

totally

[carlsson86]

very cute. she's not a great singer but shes very comfortable with the song. very confident. is it a competition or what? if its not, then ok. if it is, then she wont win (for vocal quality).lol

[mamijassy]

lol at 0:30 xD she's so sweet

[rain665403]

喔~~~~好厲害喔

[funliung]

唱功我想不必評論了

如果那次跟Alisa PK用這首歌就很難說了

硬要挑缺點就是舞步有兩個部分稍稍差了點

一個是從前台走回來的地方節奏有點不對

另一個是在SHAKE的部分 動作不夠開

其他我找不到任何缺點

[tcn1280]

哈,跟Alisa那次,我比較同意張宇的說法,一次的驚艷,如果­口袋沒有東西,那下次一比賽壓力一來就少了驚艷,而主場優勢就會­回來,不過,看了一些早在百人淘汰賽,轉戰內地,表示這個節目是­成功的,不是嗎?輸不一定是輸.

[roger3793]

她外型比Alisa 甜美

[SAIDON92]

go home please

i can't even understand wt she singing

christina is 1000 ways better

[yhjkl]

make sense

[woehn]

roger3793 (3 days ago) Please please please........ i admit that this girl quite not bad in singing BUT if compare with x`tina,.... there is TOTALLY nothing.... because this girl still sound like a `litle girl`... can`t compare with x`tina at all.... PLS PLS PLS PLS ...... there is obviously christina aguilera fantastic, awesome....!!!! those who know about music surely will knew that girls singing SUCK compare with christina aguilera........ NOTHING can compare~~~!!!!

[ki55miass]

all female chinese people sound like little girls, that's why everyone loves their accent

:D

[yhjkl]

AGREED!

[wya0623]

This is the best performance in star boulevard 2.

I always thought she'd be the champion.

However,she will be another super star in the future.

[SAIDON92]

this is THE BEST ?

omg

[teamilker]

I think she deserves that high grades.

[F1ameAlchemist]

I really wished someone'd correct her horrible English! She was good with all the high notes and the Oooohnyeaaaahs, but the rest was terrible. Some people have less limit to their pitch, so even though some people sing really high it doesn't mean that they're good, they're just lucky to have a nice voice. I like Wen Ying's voice, but not the way she performed this song.

[supiero]

can u imagine an english speaker singing a chinese song? haha their chinese may also be very terrible even for those who know chinese.

dun you think so?

[F1ameAlchemist]

I agree, but I don't see any foreigners picking Chinese song for a competition because that'd be a stupid choice. My point is, like most Taiwanese people think it's soo cool when someone speaks English, (or sings, or w/e), that they are too blind to know whether the person's English is right or wrong. If I'm not mistaken, Wen Ying missed words in the lyrics.

[sunnystone111]

Absolutely Fantastic!!!!!!!

[roger3793]

常久以來我一直看好梁文音的原因是她既可唱需要力度的歌(如失戀­無罪與candyman)，也可唱細膩深情的歌，高低音都夠水準­， 聲音甜美而不失力度，這樣的人才若被埋沒那實在太可惜了

[roger3793]

常久以來我一直看梁文音的原因是她既可唱需要力度的歌(如失戀無­罪與candyman)，也可唱細膩深情的歌，高低音都夠水準，­聲音甜美而不失力度，這樣的人才若被埋沒那實在太可惜了

[roger3793]

Christina Aguilera 版本我有聽過(網路上)

力度是Christina Aguilera 勝過

但是她聲音太粗了

沒辦法把 Candyman這首甜美俏皮味道唱出來

而梁文音這點則做到

她這首其實已經可以和原唱相抗衡了(原唱者可是動感天后)

[yhjkl]

I dont think so.

[19Eric94]

whos this buy! I love this song its i malcom in the middle:P pls reply

[sofizkoowl]

wats up with all the little boxes

[limlayfang]

举脚赞成！！他没拿冠军我的心都碎了=.=

梁文音，你给我听好！你是我们心目中永远的冠军，

期待你的个人专辑！各位唱片制作人，快把文音签下来吧！

[jason6243]

不需要再說什麼，就是一個字讚。

[jason6243]

我想梁文音在二班的影響力，跟aska有的比

[yangfu911]

梁文音真的好棒！我覺得很可愛...

雖然我沒聽過克莉絲汀唱的版本...

不過我覺得她唱的真的很好！

為什麼王偉忠不多給1分呢？

梁文音是我心目中的冠軍！

[SAIDON92]

because that guy heard the orginal and he thinks this live is shit compare to the christina 's version

[supiero]

i think this is already a great performance for juz a newbie

[yhjkl]

Christina's LIVE is splendid too, and of course her MV too

[StrawberryKio]

she might be considered good...if you haven't heard christina aguilera's version.

no offense to the girl she was pretty cute but the only good part about this song was her belt at the end

[thomasctteng]

very cute!

[vickysky]

梁文音加油,由始至終妳是星光二班最棒的!!!

[allenlee0730]

incredibly wonderful performance~~ do forget this is a live show!!

[lowenyin]

如果您也覺得文音是第一名

請到Yahoo奇摩"全民快投"裡，投票給您心中真正的星光二班­冠軍~~梁文音~

這個活動不用半毛錢，希望大家不吝表達您的心意~

[kangolfox]

soooo cute. :P

[ki55miass]

wow, she is amazing

[superhotnick]

she sings well!

dun critcise her u nobody!

[thk1977]

She is not the winner.

[lincypoo]

but i think she's the winner in most audience's mind.

[clifflin3]

how did she butchered the song?? i thoguth she was quite good, probably her best performance in the seasons lol

or r u comparing a live performance to mv?

[WazzerAlvin]

Obviously she butchered the song. The belt in the end was good, but for the rest it was dreadfully awful... Whether compared to a live performance or to a music video, she should not have chosen this song.