Added: 10 months ago
From: collettebeveridgex3
Views: 231,279
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (211)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I wish it wasn't autotuned man, Gwyneth Paltrow can legitimately sing, she doesn't need the computer's help. Glee would probably quantize and autotune Adele herself if she was on the show.

  • Comment removed

  • i like her version!

  • well, i adore adele, she is a queen !!! but i like this song with gwyneth, she sings it with more passion ....

  • Where's the "stick to acting and making babies with Chris Martin" button? I must be missing it, thought it was right at the top... hmm.

  • It's a very good pop version but it lacks that Adele's soulfuness as it's sung at faster tempo. Well this is my opinion anyway lol

  • i <3 her! and her songs!

  • I love how this video is not moving.

  • @JoeyTalle haha xD

  • Gr8 attempt, but it lacks the emotion and depth that's in Adele's voice.

  • good attempt. soul is missing though...

  • I love it but this is my song that I escape to

  • Wow. I was very surprised. Gwyneth Paltrow does so wonderful in this cover. Amazing.

  • Adele is better

  • @roxanapreda I agree with you in several ways. I love Paltrow's voice. It is original...soft and sweet. The orchestration is PERFECT around the song. You can really feel the pain of the song, yet it is sung so beautifully. I've loved Paltrow's voice since "DUETS" and I'm so happy she's pursuing a career in music. Her acting is superb, too, so she really can't do wrong in my eyes. I love Adele...nothing against her. However, when it comes down to it, I like listening to the Glee version more.

  • Its much better than adèle

  • @x103femke oh don't even go there! not saying this is bad, but it is def. autotuned and nobody will EVER beat adele at singing her own songs! just saying:P

  • @mslisa6824 Actually it's NOT autotuned. Gwyneth sang this live with the cast of Glee on the X Factor and she sounded just as good if not better Live. Of course Adele sang it better. SHE MADE IT. Adele made the song to fit her voice perfectly. That's why if ANYONE covers a song it's never ever eveerrr better than the original. So i agree with you on giving ur pinion that Adele is better. But don't accuse someone of being autotuned if u have no proof. It sounds really mean. Thanks :)

  • I really like her voice color! She did a great job. I don't like Adele's voice color that much at all. Great performance Gwyneth!

  • Pretty, but Adele will always be the best at singing *her* song.

  • omg she ruins it..!why do voiceless people sing?her job is to act and hell shes good at it so she should stick to it

  • Listen haters, if you're gonna hate on Gywneth's voice, you better be able to back it up. I'd like to see you pussies record yourself singing this.

  • Loved it it's WAY better than Adele

  • @LuluLust97

    ridiculas remark

  • if she makes an album she should put this song on it :)

  • This is much better than adele

  • this episode is rerunning next week can't wait! :)

  • GLEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE­EEEEEE <3

  • It hurts my feelings that this song was on Glee. Fucking hate that show... but Gwen did a nice job with this song <3

  • Surprising REALLY good, I love this version :D x

  • i wish gwen will still be seen on season 3 .. i love her singing so much

  • Indeed- when the gayly Glee's do a song- the artists get MAJOR airtime and recognition. Dont hate! and even more than that- when people cover them on the internet, it only creates more of a buzz. People are allowed to like what they want.

    The beauty of Adele though- is she wrote it!!! :-P

  • I love her version. She did Adele proud

    

  • i cry every time i hear her sing this it's just so beautiful i heard this before i heard the original. it's especially sad when they broke up.

  • This is really beautiful.

    To be honest i wasnt big on gweneths singing in Glee until i heard song. Shes very talented.

    LOVE glee!! Its made me love so many songs, even songs i used to dislike <3

  • Love this song of Adele's. Gywneth is a fave of mine. Love her as an actress and a singer too!

  • I never saw Glee but I caught this performance when she sang it while I was doing zapping on the TV and I gotta say she left me speechless. Not only the song is beautiful but she rocked it !!!

  • i lov this song and also is better than Adle's xDDD i lovee Glee !!!!!!! xD

  • Adele sings this brilliantly credit to her indeed, but i don't know - theres something about Gwyneth's voice - maybe the tone? that makes me like this version a lot more. Beautiful cover :)

  • @TheDawbb

    I agree, this is the better version.

  • Correct me if im wrong but didnt she sing this on glee ?

  • @Jodyisere yes, she did. the picture is from her movie Country Strong, and I originally put this video up for my friend so she could download the song, and this is the only picture i had. xD

  • Comment removed

  • Gwyneth did such a fantastic job with this!

  • LOVE THIS SONG !

  • @iLoveYoohS2x3 what does Gwyneth being skinnier have anything to do with the song? I'm glad that there's finally a great singer who doesn't look like she hasn't eaten in weeks, Adele's an exemple for erveryone. I like both versions, and I don't mind that you like this one better, but that 'skinnier' part really bugged me, just wanted to say that..

  • @iLoveYoohS2x3 Yes, I agree with Kaats. What does being skinnier have to do with anything? You pass judgement so easily when you just claimed that you never knew about Adele before Glee. Adele is gorgeous and amazing just the way she is. She may be a bit bigger than any of the other cookie-cutter singers, but her voice is original and beautiful.

  • @iLoveYoohS2x3 I agree with Kaats and Princess. I love both versions bu twhat the hell does her being skinnier do with shit? You just sound like an arrogant bitch. ;)

  • @LindsMandy

    oh my badd :)

    that comment wasn't from me.

    my friend was commenting that day.

  • @iLoveYoohS2x3 Ayee :) It's all good. :)))

  • gwenyth does it better

  • amazing.

  • @PoisonIvyDancer I don't think Glee picked this song for you to hate on Adele. What a bizarre thing to say.

  • I bet ADELE loves this. She loves Glee.

  • she sounds great and all yew haters... f*** off... shes fantastic...not like yew could do ANY better:D

  • this is good, but not as good as the origional...

    WHY? BECAUSEEEEEE: Gwyneth Paltrow is missing that raspiness that adele has, and THAT is the secret ingredient. Anyone can cover it, but it'll NEVER be as good as the way adele does it :D

  • Sweet!

  • loveee<3 

  • i don't hate adele but i think this version is better

  • @Weasles14

    you dont deserve ears

    Adele is the best vocalist since Nina Simone

  • @Grange34

    that's just my opinion, it's just my taste in music. i like adele i'm a fan of hers. I just prefer this version of the song.

  • it's like a respectful testament to Adele from an older woman - older than Adele, I mean - who gets how great the song is...she brings it to the Glee audience. they may check Adele out!

  • stop bitching. no one compares to Adele, but Gwyneth did better than most of you could ever imagine.

  • she ruined the song

  • I like Gwyneth's version more!

  • i just really like both versions. that's possible, right?

  • Both Gwyneth and Adele have amazing voices and I'm glad that it was Gwyneth Paltrow who covered it. Good choice, Glee

  • she is excellent. and adele has another kind of voice. so you has not the right to judge them. it's a cover. a cover is made to sing with your own voice...

  • This is a boring copy. The song and the way she sings it... it's just Turning Tables with Gywneth Paltrow's voice. She doesn't make this song hers, she just copies it exactly as she hears it. And on top of that, she has about a tenth of the emotion Adele has. Not impressed.

  • I think when compared to Adele, it's a no win but covers are always difficult. I can hear emotion and I certainly saw it on GLEE. with the context. God I sound like a Nerd!

  • i cry wen i hear this :')

  • SOOOOOO GOOOOOOOOD. Gwyneth's singing doesn't always impress me. She's good but not GREAT, you know? However, watching her PERFORM this song... This was so so good!!!

  • i never expected gywneth to be able to sing and when she was on country strong i was like OMG! haha this is actually pretty good! but i like adeles a little bit better! sry...

  • Love this and its more raw and true to her voice - she honours adele by using the same melodies but hitting notes in her comfort range and covering it at all - that is major respect to an artist. I love both adele and gwyneth's version as they both are awesome!

  • @PoisonIvyDancer Gwenth Is amazing she has the same emotion as adele. But personally i think adele sings this bettter. Adele just haves the voice that suits this song. But Gwenth is defiantyl in 2nd place. This cover is amazing.

  • I wish that she had done something besides copying Adele's melody EXACTLY, with every single riff intact. If you're going to cover a song, you should add your own twist to it; otherwise, you're asking for people to compare the two, and nothing more.

  • Love Gwyneth's Voice!!!!!! Shes AWESOME!

  • Just commenting on this, because I don't know how to work youtube. I put this up for my friend. I love Gwyneth and her voice. Stop writing about how bad you think she sounds. I love it.

  • @collettebeveridgex3 Me too love this song listen to Emilie de Villecourts cover it's good too she's just sittng there in a room belting out this song AMAZING !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @sallybeth92 i will look at hers just now :)

  • i had no idea that Gwyneth could sing....she has a beautiful voice!!

  • @pricelessangie Better pushing her voice to reach the note than using auto-tune.

  • yeahhhhhhhh royyyyyy x

  • If Gwyneth Paltrow wants to convince the world that she is a talented singer, this is a really BAD choice of song to go with - her vocals are soooo limited in comparison with Adele's.

  • @gandynator she is just singing what people ask for... holly holliday is a CHARACTER, she's just doing her job

  • excellent song!!

  • better than adele :')

  • im soo biast when it comes to adele (im a huge fan) gwyenth paltrow did a good job covering her but no one does it like adele

  • anyone else think gwyneth is forcing her voice too much on the high notes?

  • Very good!

    (Subtext: but not as good as ADELE....)

  • This is an excellent cover, but Adele adds that special uniqueness to the vocals. But, really that's the only difference in the two.

  • i love this, and i love Gwyneth so much! :) i think she has an excellent voice,i don't really like Adelle but this is Adelle's song so of course she'd sing it best! i didn't really think Adelle was a neglected artist?

  • @muusicManiac maybe a little underappreciated before her 21 album

  • LOVE.IT

  • I like this better than the original, I think her voice has real heart behind it, I love Gwyneth!

  • oh my :) gooood cover <3

  • What a great cover! She sounds almost country.

  • I was impressed with Gwyneth's version of this. We ALL need to remember, that this is Adele's song. She wrote it, and OF COURSE she will sing it the best! She put her heart and soul into writing it. But, Gwyneth did just fine! I would LOVE to hear more from Gwyneth! She has the PASSION to be a great singer!

  • Actually I like this - Paltrow's voice is an unexpected gift, it was a surprise to everyone who's followed her work. It is simpler than Adele's, less nitty-gritty, but no less sincere and impressive. It got to me from the start. The orchestration around her is even better than in the original song. For me Paltrow's version stands on its own, next to the original and I will listen to both in the future. Two women, two voices, two sensibilities - you don't need to choose.

  • @roxanapreda i first heard this song from gwyneth on glee but i know it's adele's. it depends on what voice u like. I like "bright" souring voices so i like this. I like Adele's when it is pitched higher. I heard Someone like u here on youtube thinking that it was the orig version then i heard it on radio and it sounded deeper which i did not fancy much

  • @roxanapreda two women, two voices, one is auto-tuned.

  • Comment removed

  • Adele isn't a neglected artist!

  • She got the words wrong, which surprises me that Glee didn't do their basic homework to at least get the words right. Sad but it was ok, nothing compared to Adele. She is truly an under appreciated artist!!

  • I don't think it's THAT bad , but there are better singers . She doesn't have a great voice , but I actually liked this . She put in the emotion & her voice soundede ohhk (:

  • I think she did good :) I don't think it beats the original, but she did a good job and she has the voice :D

  • Amazeballs! :)

  • WOW, she ruined this song.

    

  • WOW, she ruined this song.

  • I guess this isn't as bad as Forget You, but it still sounds so very kareoke. I wish Gwyneth would stick to acting, and even then...

  • so I listened to Adele's version, and guys, I have to say I like Gwyneth's version more :) I guess it the softness of her voice. It's just too wonderful but it also has the passion!

  • She did a good job considering her voice isn't that great and compared to Adele, I think she did a good job.

  • I will have to listen do Adele, but maybe thanks to not knowing the original, I can appreciate Gwyneth's voice even more. I think she is a fabulous singer! totally would buy her album :)

  • her voice sounds like kurt in glee

  • Way better than Adele!

  • @TheBellelaufer You must be deaf.. seriously.

  • Nos as great as Adele... it seems like Gwyneth is trying so hard while Adele just opens her mouth and sings naturally effortlessly

  • I agree with everyone else.. Adele clearly sings it better HOWEVER. Keep in mind that the visual accompaniment with the song amplify'sthe emotion that everyone feels when listening to a song.

  • @mnthol agreed :)

  • i love this song... i can realy relate... definately

  • i listen to this so much

  • I think it's even better the Adele's !

    Glee guys are geniuses !!

  • I personally like this version, perhaps better than the original. But even you don't, if you are an Adele fan you should be happy that this cover happened; Glee has a large fanbase, and a lot of those people have been introduced to Adele where they might not have known about her before. That means more popularity and more money for Adele, how is positive attention ever going to hurt a singer? This can only help her career.

  • @Pensulliwen How can someone not have heard of Adele? She's pretty big. But mainly Adele has some of the best pipes (if not THE best) today. I don't think Gwyneth did a bad job. But come on, better than Adele? Gwyneth sounds nice.  But nice is just pathetic compared to the power, beauty, strength and raw emotion that come from Adele.

  • If U Just Come Here To Complain..Don't Come Here At All? This Woman Is My Biggest Hero And She Rocks This Song!?

  • I don't like this version. She did okay but no one could beat Adele with this song... :p

  • i think there both good (glee version and original) :D

  • she rocked!

  • i love gwyneth and i lovvvvvvveeeeeee this song... by adele. i think gwyneth butchered this song. i love her voice but just not for this song, and when i listen to this i cringe

  • i can't believe she left again to go away to teach french. maybe will and emma will get together<3 iloveglee. ps. i know a website where you can watch free movies and tv shows :) thats where i watch it.X

  • @ChocolateMonster001 What is the website called? ;D

  • I actually like Gwyneth's version a lot better than Adele's. I love Adele's voice but I think Gwyneth's voice sounds better with the orchestra and piano than Adele.

  • @Cassidy122990 i definitely i love the sound of the orchestra and piano with her voice better!

  • @Cassidy122990 NO just NO :Lx

  • @Cassidy122990 i think adele's version is better because she has that raspiness quality in her voice, and it adds "umph" to the song. Gwyneth Paltrow did an amazing job, but nothing beats the origional...... and if it does then it doesnt last ._.

  • @KimifferXD

    LOL i know i did thumbs down but i meant to do thumbs UPPP :)

  • @Cassidy122990

    I agree. Absolutely.

  • Let me get this out there... I love Glee, I love Gwyneth, and i always will. However... no matter how great Gwyneth did with this song, no one holds a candle to Adele. Her voice just doesn't compare to Adele; actually, her performance on Glee makes me want to listen to the Adele version... which I guess is a good thing, and is why Adele would allow her song to be featured on Glee. Absolutely great job Gwyenth!! It sounded super lovely on Glee and I'm glad the song is getting out there.

  • There is no autotune in this performance. Gwyneth killed it!

  • one of my new favorite songs...:) she can evoke a lot of sadness like adele...im glad adele is getting so much attention she deserves it all and more!

  • not bad

  • everythings touched by gwyneth become gold.

  • this song makes me cry everyyyy single time i listen to it.

  • I like Adele's version much better but,that's just my opinion!

  • @TeeJaye46

    Your opinion stinks, Adele wrote the song you twonk.

  • @boomchilds well, "twonk", just because she wrote it doesn't mean she sings it better...and again, it's just my opinion.

  • Can Gwyneth sing? Yeah, I'll give her that. But Adele conveys such emotion, you can't ignore it. There's a huge difference between singing and conveying emotion. In rare instances an artist can do both. Gwyneth is missing the pain that Adele conveys so well.

  • I hope Adele will now get the credit and attention she gets from us in Britain and surrounding European countries. I love her so much, and this got her into the attention of millions of Americans

  • @TheFeJaPiDi  Oh boo, she has a huge following in the US; it's just largely underground. I downloaded her album the day 19 came out and have been a fan ever since.

  • @chopsueybrandy We're both fans, don't be like that, c'mon, it was meant as a good luck wish because she's not widely known. I know several people in America and they had never heard of her and neither had their friends.

  • @TheFeJaPiDi Don't be like what? My comment was in no way negative. Just saying that she has a huge following already, it's just underground.

  • @chopsueybrandy you started with "oh boo", that sets a negative tone to your whole message :P.

  • @TheFeJaPiDi Ah, gotcha. No, no. I meant "boo" as in person (Like Usher's "My Boo").

  • @chopsueybrandy ahh, I thought that was Chris Brown? XD But I never heard that "boo" in Europe before :S :P 

  • @TheFeJaPiDi Do you even know that she is already very populair and succesfull in America??

  • @michaeldeboer I know she's popular and successful (that's with one L and two S's), but she's not as widely known as she is in Western Europe and it was just a good luck wish for her to become widely known and credited all over the world, because she deserves it.

  • @TheFeJaPiDi

    I'm sorry I don't live in a country where we speak and write English all the time. I make mistakes. ;-)

    Ofcourse she deserves it. She is my favourite singer. But she is already performing on all sorts of shows in America and winning Grammy's. I don't think this will get her more attention in America than one of her own performances.

  • @michaeldeboer When I look at your name, I can guess you're Dutch, and English is the second or third language of almost every Dutch citizen :P But I know not everyone's spelling is as good as mine, since I'm in collage. But Glee is famous and watched by almost everyone in America and also in a lot of foreign countries where they haven't heard of Adele, so I think more people will hear from her and can relate themselves to her music. :D That's the only thing I meant to say.

  • @TheFeJaPiDi Yes I understand you but I was never negative about your comment if you thought that. Not at all. I understand what you mean.

    And btw......It's College.......not Collage......... haha :-D

  • I really like how she did it, 'cause it's hard to cover Adele, but she's done a pretty good job. As I said it's hard to cover her, Adele's original version has more feeling in it, but Gwyneth did a very good job :D

  • I like this version much better than Adele's. This is unbelievably good!