Added: 3 years ago
From: IrishKagura
Views: 27,646
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (130)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • these better be voice overs

  • @shegwa1 and if they're not????

  • Look it up people Salli Richardson played Maza, Jeff Bennett played Brooklyn, Owen, and Magus, Edward Asner played Hudson, Thom Adcox-Hernandez played Lexington, Brigitte Bako played Angela, Kath Soucie played the wierd sisters, Robert Culp played Halcyon Renard, and last Puck was played by Brent Spiner. If u dont believe me u can find it on IMDB.com.

  • it looks great, but I would say Salli Richardson to play Maza...and also just a criticism, its Jonathan FRAKES, not Frankes

  • I don't know who most of those people are, but just from their looks I could see them playin' the parts. Especially Laura as Fox. But it's got me curious - do you think they'd use body paint and some form of rigged wings/tails/etc. for the gargoyles, or the specialised body suit/CGI?

  • @kipral I'd say CGI but " if I was a director" I'm not sure the movie I'd make would be live action or if it'd be like the tv show but w/ the ppl in this vid.

    P.S. this vid is IMO and nothing else

  • Wait, why can't Salli Richardson play Elisa Maza?!! She LOOKS JUST LIKE HER

  • Rosario Dawson as Elisa Maza!

  • while i was watching the series i kept think that michelle rodriguez would make a good elisa, since a strong female with a gun is the charecter she usually plays anyway lol

  • I agree with some choices and I disagree with some choices, but I'm all for coming up with possible casts for live action versions of cartoons (I do that with my parents all of the time), and now that I've seen this video I'll probably consider your thoughts when I'm deciding who I would choose for the parts.

  • @TippytoeZombie thax 4 the constructive criticsim, when it comes 2 this video I don;t get enough of that, only criticsim...... so thax.

  • You do know that Jeri Ryan is white while Elisa is supposed to be half Native American half Black, right?

  • @TippytoeZombie IF I was a director I'm not sure IF I'd make a live action/ CGI or animated movie. IF it was animated then it'd just be Ryan's voice. When I made this vid I wasn't thinking about such a sensitive topic as race, only my beloved childhood char. and the actors/actress that I THINK would have the kind of talent needed 2 play the part. All Gargoyles char. r dynimic, passionate,deep and I was only thinking about who migh have the talent 4 the job. I mean(t) no offence 2 any1.

  • @IrishKagura I will definitely agree that, while not the right race, Jeri Ryan definitely has at least the talent needed.

  • Ok, before you post a video, make sure you info is correct! Elisa Maza is played by Salli Elise Richardson-Whitfield. Right now you will find her playing the role of Allison on SyFy Channel Show: Eureka.

  • @conectmaster gotta remember how old this show is btw too.

  • @conectmaster excuse me but it's not a competition, I made this vid. 4 fun and nothing else. Also in case it's not clear 1) everything in this vid is IMO and 2) I'm entittled 2 my opinion agreed with or not.

  • @IrishKagura While I agree with you having the right to your own opinions, and some of them makes sense. I just don't see a lot of the cast fitting the bill at least not anymore. Honestly I don't see them fitting the bill back in 2008, although it's a great vid. But I do have one question, why cast Jeri Ryan for a role that doesn't fit her at all?

  • @TheDinidan thax 4 ur constructive criticsim. IF I was a director, IF I was making a Gargoyles movie, IF being the underlined word I'm not sure if I'd make the movie live action w/ CGI or have it totaly animated. IF it was animated then it'd just be Ryan's voice. So in that regards she might fit the role. However this "would be" cast is just IMO and IMO Ryan is a dynimic actress and Ellisa is a dynimic char. so in terms of acting I think Ryan has what it would take. but this is just IMO

  • lol how john frakes looks like his cartoon counterpart, i hadn't drawn the connection before. good vid one question, why'd u choose  rhianna song??

  • @whitemoonwolf13 thax and I just thought it fit, 2 be honest I don't really know.....

  • oh and most of u pick I dont agree with them...

  • U know u left someone out... Guess who he is..... I'll give u a hint is importand as Demona and they cant live without each other... give up MACBETH and even though agree the roll of Goliath most be play by a black I dont think it shout be the one who dose his voice cause that mostly what they r good at doing voices not acting perse u know but that is my opinion... anyway i still cant think of a good actor....

  • horrible

  • all i got from this vid is you like startrek and gargoyles.

  • Danny Devito???

  • Comment removed

  • ^^ nice video!

  • You have excellent taste. Of course if David Keith isn't available I think Michael Dorn would be a good alternative.

    Oh just one point you may wish to reexamine Jonathan Frakes name in your video, aside from that this is a great video. I appreciate you making it.

    I look forward to further videos.

    Have a wonderful one!

  • @jaspr1999 THANK U SO MUCH 4 UR KIND WORDS =^.^= I'm glad that u liked the vid, I made a 2nd one

    P.S. ppl keep saying that I spelled his name wrong but when u type in ( what seems 2 be the thought of spelling of his name) google asks "did u mean" and that's the spelling I used as it seemed that it wasn;t a typo/ wrong spelling. If it appers different on the credits of TNG then ok I'm wrong, but I don;t think so.

    AGAIN THAX 4 THE GREAT FEEDBACK ^_^

  • @IrishKagura

    As far as the spelling, I'm just going by two sources: The credits from the show and his autograph I got at a convention. As far as the spell checker on most search engines... Well, they aren't perfect. But the effort you put in is close. It's only a typo and not a big deal. Especially with your talent at producing and editing.

  • @jaspr1999 thank you very much for such a kind and understanding comment, it made me smile( I was having a bad day, so I need one of those) As for that autograph KOOL! I'd love to go to a con some day. ^_^

  • @IrishKagura

    Sorry that you had a bad day, but glad my comment helped. As for autographs, I think you'd enjoy a convention. The folks that go are an interesting mix of people with a common interest. The stars that visit conventions are incredibly sweet... They really are there to show the fans how much they're appreciated. I've got a rather wide selection since I started collecting around '75.

    Have a great one!

  • its funny i showed this to my mom cause my fav cartoon played by her fave actors on star trek

  • I know that it was Brent Spiner ( Data from ST:TNG) who voiced the characters Owen/Puc; but I always though it was Ed Asner who was the voice for Hudson.

  • I'm sorry but i would not agree with like any of that. it was a good and interesting video but no to all those people.

  • Jonathan Frankes as David just fits, looks and personality wise

  • why is it that this guy only likes star trek actors? weeeeaaak!!!!!!

  • @colinsandysand I'm a girl and in the show there was ALOT of ST actors. I wanted 2 have ST actors in my vid just like there was in the show.

  • @colinsandysand

    umm because most of the main voice actors were ST!!!

  • @colinsandysand The only difference is I hate star trek to death. On the other hand I, believe Gargoyles is one of the best things to come out of Disney ever.

  • Lets face it, just grab all the star trek characters to play their respective parts, and fill it in from there.

  • i had a dream last night that there was like a new poster of Gargoyles announcing there is ganna be like a movie in 3D or a new series. Wish it was real though, might be one day.

  • @Artprincess247 I think that, that's a dream all us Gargoyle fans share. However I hope that unlike most movies made 2day that a Gargoyles movie wouldn't sux.

    P.S. thax 4 the comment =^-^=

  • @Artprincess247 yeah, i agree with you, the annimatipn is great, but the plot is just...*shakes head* know what i mean. But maybe making a new serires might help. have you seen the spatacular spider man?At first i thought, "ah, this is ganna suck", but it turned out really good, and they made mary-jane less annoying and such a kool character to love. check it out.

    And your welcome ^.^

  • I literally have heard of only 2 of these people, and why are half the characters played by people from Star Trek?

  • 0:02 :D (Kate Mulgrew!) :0) OK I checked its someone named Sally who plays elsa. BUT A TON of these are accurate. If you want to be in star trek in the 90s be a guest star in this tv show and in Law and Order. Because little guest staring gigs get you in the star trek line up. :)

  • 0:02 :D (Kate Mulgrew!) :0

  • Why didn't you choose Laura San Giacomo as Eliza and Jeri Ryan for Fox? If it's for appearance, they'd fit better....what do you think?

  • @purplewaterdrop I thank u 4 ur constructive criticsim and also asking 4 my thoughts. I agree w/ u. HOWEVER Giacomo voiced Fox in the show and in a live action/ cgi movie she'd have the looks AND the voice. It should be noted that this vid. and all my comments r IMO agreed w/ or not I'm entitled to express IMO.

    P.S. THANK YOU AGIAN.

  • @purplewaterdrop I thought the exact same thing!

  • This is my cast choice! Goliath-Keith David Brooklyn-Chris Evens Hudson-Ian McKellen Broadway-Seth Rogen Lexington-Michael Cera Bronx-Frank Welker Demona-Angelina Jolie David Xanatos-Robert Downey, Jr. or Tim Curry Elisa Maza-Zoe Saldana
  • If people ever notice or even look at the behind the scens on how Disney makes their shows/movies they usually draw the characters to the people that voice them.

  • Actually Sally Richardson played Elisa Maza not Jeri Ryan

  • to all the people who dont seem to like ST actors in a Gargoyles movie, u do realize that many/most of the original voice actors were from ST?

  • how bout ppl who AREN'T form stark trek

  • But Elisa is half black and half native american...

  • It's Jonathan Frakes, not Frankes.

  • Thank u for the constructive criticsim comment but u should know that when I was making this vid. I tried (googled) that way and the spelling came up my way..that's y I spelled it that way. However I thank u again 4 the constructive criticsim.

  • The only problem with your choice for Elisa is that she is suppose to be half black and half native American, her ethnicity is an important part of the show so her being played by a white actress wouldn't seem right

  • true u're right...I just like Jeri Ryan's acting and that's y I picked her......

    Also thank you for leaving a constructive criticsim comment =^_^= thank u.

  • Startrek

  • terrible music.

  • You know that keith david is like 70, right?

  • @Joker0591 50's actually

  • Haha i been thinkin the same thing with the level of CGI they have nowadays it would be no problem to do this

  • Danny Devito he's Hudson..i don't recognize the voice?

  • LOL no Danny Devito wan't Hudson's voice in the tv show. I'm kinda making a bit of a joke and saying that 4 MY movie he'd play Hudson.

  • Didn't the guy you put as Xanatos actually play him?

  • yes ^_^ and unless I'm mistaken Xanatos was created 2 look like the guy who voiced him. The voice, the looks and even the fact that he's from the tv show r the reasons y I picked Jonathan Frankes.

  • Producers sorry misspelled it

  • n/p 4got 2 say that in my other comment ^^!

  • Danny Devito as Hudson hahaha

  • I'm glad that some1 else thought that the idea was kinda funny.

  • Jeri Ryan as Elisa? I must disagree with you there.

  • a movie would suck. my childhood mustn't spoils with crap like a movie of gargoyles

  • the way that movies r made now-a-dayz I'd agree w/ u that it would suck. This reason and the reason that no1/the majorty of viewers would not b able 2 agree on a "good" cast r MAYBE 2 reasons y this show hasn't been made into a movie.ALSO I'm NOT SAYING that no1 would b happy w/ Hollwood's cast picks I'M JUST SAYING that every1 seems 2 have there OWN idea's of what the cast should b and so most would b unhappy w/ the picks. This maybe just me or not b none the less these r MY THOUGHTS

  • while i agree with alot of your picks, i think halcyon renard should be played by ian mckellen, and hudson would be perfectly portrayed by the voice himself ed asner, also i think the perfect elisa would be rosario dawson. Also John Barrowman as owen/puck.

  • LOL I was going 2 have ed "play" Hudson but I thought that Devito would/might b funny. I also was thinking of Sir Ian 4 Halcyon but I thought that he would b better as the Magus.

    Lastly I'd like 2 say THANK U 4 ur kind comment, as I'm sure u're read most of the comments that I've gotten 4 "MY PICKS" on this movie have been less then considerate most less kind. So thax 4 the CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICSIM ( not just criticsim)

  • no problem, but you haven't responded to my pick for owen, also a movie wouldn't be the worst thing, i mean we've come far enough that a well done movie would be great to see, kinda like the way they did with the chipmunks

  • True and agreed w/ a good budget and production team Gargoyles the movie like Titanic/Philadelphia would b a great movie. As 4 Owen I think that my pick "looks the most like him" sorries but I can just see him w/ blond hair and glasses ^^! Also he's the voice 4 Inu Yasha's Sessy or as I call him Stripes ^_^! But John Barrowman doesn't sound 2 bad...

  • OK this is my last thing about borrowman, check him out on the produecers, mel brooks comedy musical starring nathan lane, he plays the german soldier singing springtime for hitler, in this one he is blond, and the way he's done add glasses and he could be owen just my last thoughts, but once again, good casting

  • Ya ur right he won't b 2 bad, I saw a black/white pic of him as he was kinda cute ^^! maybe a new demention 4 owen (ummm) and ur thoughts have been very good. Thax once again 4 being so nice and understanding. (Something I havn't seen 2 much of w/ ppl's coments. So thax)

  • I so watch that movie

  • what is up with all the star trek actors

  • The tv series had alot of actors from Star Trek that did the voices of the characters

  • you left out salli richardson whitfield and she was on star trek ds9

  • Ya just saw that ep and she's the 1 who played Elisa on the Gargoyles tv show, I didn't want 2 have ALL the org. cast members from the show 4 my vid. so I left her out.

  • YES

  • worst cast ideas.... ever... for one you can't put that many startrek cast members in there they'd never agree to it, plus they are too old to play the roles. Danny divito is unregistered migit and why would they spend money and time making him bigger when they could find a better role for Hudsun. Perhaps a thinner Brendan Gleeson would play it better. It would be CG anyway and Divito doesn't exactly have a Scottish accent.

  • Uhh, I sort of Agree with you. I mean, the first few were the voice actors to the character counterparts, but some (like Maza's prospective actor) were WAY off. The voice actor for that character actually looks the part. Patrick Stewart is good in anything, so ok. As for the rest, well, it's a matter of taste.

  • i agree, for a different yet somewhat similar view, look at my vid, i just made it a video response, who know's, if we are lucky, somebody big might eventually see it, but only if it gets enough views, so please help me out.

  • Ah no problem. I'll check it out right now.

  • Dear Douche bag, his name is Frakes, Jonathan Frakes. There is no fucking 'n' in Frakes, it's surprising how you put so much time and effort into making such a useless video and managed to misspell his name. The fact that you seem to know a little bit about TNG makes it even more pathetic. In the future I recommend a simple task like goggling or going on on Wikipedia to avoid looking like a complete fucking retard. Oh also I like the pic of Gates McFadden.

    Your pal,

    guywhocanread

  • 1st nice language -_-## and 2nd I goggle his name w/ and w/ out the n and guess which 1 was right? (watch the vid 2 find out) Some1 ALREADY POINTED this out 2 me. I DID GOGGLE IT W/ HIS SUGGESTED SPELLING AND IT CAME UP SAYING: DID U MEAN.... AND IT WAS MY SPELLING THAT WAS RIGHT!!!!!!!!!!

    P.S. thax 4 taking the time 2 not leave a CONTRIVE CRITICSIM like comment!

  • your the douche bag. douche bag

  • big-nut...hmm, sounds like you're overcompensating for something...hmm

    Aside from the obvious, you're the douche bag here. He got the name wrong. So what? It's a simple error. There's two types of criticism; constructive and destructive. Yours was most definitely the latter, not the former. In the future make sure to check your asinine comments at the door.

    P.S: Oh, & if you're going to comment on MY name, just note that it's my ACTUAL name, both First AND last. So yeah, good luck there.

  • I wonder who could play that main evil viking and the human that betrays the gargoyes in scotland.

  • boy u must've spent alot of time looking at my vid's! NOT 'cause I've made a 2nd "MY chooses" "cast movie" and did u read the decription? if so then u'd u know y I have Titania&Oberon in this. Also another reason 4 the char.'s that I put in this movie is being random. As 4 Golith The guy that I'D have play him is in my opinion the only 1 who could play him. Just as THIS and all the ppl in THIS VID r MY opinion2 who I'D want 2 play these ppl. if urs r diff. then fine but these r MINE.

  • You don't need the old man in the wheelchair, Oberron or Titana. Too many characters for the first film. Maybe if there was a sequel or a third movie. Same with Angela. Not till a third film and your Angela is too old. She is 17 or 18 in human years. Maza is suppose to be part Native American and part African american. So your choice does not work. Try maybe Jennifer lopez or Rorsario Dawson. Someone said the Angel Actor as Xantos which could cork.

  • Milo Ventimiglia should play brooklyn. I heard someone say Frankie Munz as Lex and that could work, Josh Peck, from Drake and Josh could work as Broadway except he has lot alot of weight lately. I think he would need a false stomach now. Your Goliath sucks!!! Adrian Paul from Highlander or Ron Perlman from Hellboy should play him.

  • The midsummer night dream sharacters do not have to be in the first gargoyle film.

  • i really like ur casting, i'm a lil skeptical about a few but over all i like it, esspecially ur pick for brooklynn XD

  • THAX ^______^ and that's y I picked him (hehehehe)

  • First off I would like to say that the video is just one persons opinion and if IrishKagura feels that these people would be their cast for the movie that they are making then so be it. They took the time to make the video, to share it with everyone. And for that all the more power to you.

    With that said I think in the future IrishKagura you should put at the beginning of your movies " This is my opinion of who would be play the following people in my movie ......."

  • Thax 4 ur support. However I must say that I thought that it was clear that the "cast members" were in my opinion. Still it's an idea and I thax u 4 it and ur constrive critticism

  • Sbes que vato, way to show support. But if you ask me, this was way into the true vein of Gargoyles, with some of the voice actors reprising their roles, and a majority of them being from Star Trek, I agree with the both of you. Be sure to keep an eye out for my choices, hope it gets the same support.

  • That guy sucks you chose to play oberon aswell.He should be played by jason issacs

  • Terrible choice for Hudson aswell.Hudson should be played by Irish actor Brendan Gleeson

  • @fortheir45michael He isnt old enough

  • Oh my god this cast sucks man.Seriously.

    How can you have Goliath played by some Black guy?

    Lady titania should be played by some known actor not the stupid voice actor.She should be played by Kate blanchett or tilda swintion.

    Broadway should be played by comedian peter kay

    and rosario dawson should play elisa maza

  • As for Goliath.He should be played by Ron Perlman

  • that could work. I was think Adrian Paul from Highlander because he has the accent and the look of Goliath.

  • @fortheir45michael Ahh man that would be cool but everytime i see him i think of hellboy

  • @fortheir45michael Ron Perlman wouldn't be my choice, but he definitely could do it. I'd have him play Coldstone maybe.

  • say what u want about MY cast picks but at least ppl know who they r! I don't know who the hell those ppl r that u mentioned! I picked the voice actor that played Goliath 'cause he's the ONLY 1 who could play him. Also if U don't like who I PICKED then y don't U make UR OWN vid??????? u know instead of criticizing others ( minus the constrive!)

  • I agree with cdowg187 the black guy as you call him is Keith David the man that voiced Goliath in the cartoon.

  • lol, @fortheir45michael.You're such a fucking n00b.

    That "Black guy" is Keith David. That is the man who actually voiced Goliath and he is one of the only people that comes to mind when I think of Goliath ever being portrayed as a real person. There are a few others but most of them are also black.

    Let's face it. They have voices and overall personality traits that fit Goliath WAY more than most of us whites do. You are a prime example of that, lol.

  • Are these people the ACTUAL people who play as these charactyers?

  • Some of them, not all but some. ie- Kate Mulgrue,she was the voice behind Lady Titania. Others like Richard Grieco, r my own idea. So it depends on the char. I may've used the actual voice actress/actor or not.

  • Keith David is the ONLY guy who should be Goliath's voice. But what about The Pack though?!

  • Ya I agree, that's y I'd have him for my movie,over all better suted or NOT! Also I'm working on a movie w/ for who I'd have play the Pack,McBeth and a few others. I'm still working on it and all but I'll have it posted soon.....

    P.S. THAX for the comment ^_^

  • Nice, my favorite episodes were with The Pack. I was gonna write a lame fan story giving them a much bigger role. Like Dog The Bounty Hunter but with a former special ops group.

  • I'm not fond of Dog the Bounty Hunter but u're idea sounds really good, I;d write that story. I've even got a few idea's for fan fic's. Anywayz......stick around 'cause in a week or two my vid'll be done ^____^

  • Interesting video, but I'm afraid you spelled Johnathon Frakes wrong.

  • did I? 'casue I goggled my spelling and it came up, I also goggled ur spelling and it came up did u mean? So I think I spelled it right. But thax for the comment ^_^

  • man how uve never heard of aishwarya rai she was shosen this year as the most beautiul women on earth and she was in the last legion check her u really should know her

  • well I'll goggle her name but I still don;t know her. sorries but her name means nothing to me.(shrugs)

  • yeah he is right the girl that should be elisa fit demona more and aishwarya is an indian actress that was miss world and she was in several hollywood movie and she can be a very fine elisa

  • Ok I don;t know what u're seeing w/ the Jeri Rayn should be Demona thing. ???.??? But annywayyys I don;t know who aushwarya is, NEVER heard of her but if u've seen Relic Hunter then the woman who plays Sydny Fox could play Elisa. However Jeri has top notch acting skills,so she has always and always will have my vote for Elisa.

  • thats a awsome vid im a huge Brooklyn fan and i have to say the guy who you chose for him is HOT! lol if im correct the name of the actual guy who does his voice has a different name right? but other then that i loved your vid its awsome id give it a 10 if i could but a 5 will have to do...may i ask the name of the song and who sings it? thnx =^.^=

  • ^-^ ya he is HOT HOT HOT, I thought so too,^_^

    Yes it is a diff. guy but the guy that I chose is a member of the Gargoyles tv show cast. So he had a role on the show, I gave him a more major and (I think) befiting role. THAX for the rating and taking the time to leave me such a great comment.

    The song is disturbia by Rihanna ^____^

  • in my dream Gargoyles movie, Sean Connery would have to play Macbeth.

    I do not agree about Angela for example, because the woman looks too old. Looks like she could be the mother of Goliath, not the daughter. also this Jeri Ryans looks more like Demona than Elisa but other than that I really liked your choices.

  • Also Keath David played Golith in the show and so I thought that he should also play him in the movie. I took some of the cast members and used them or I gave them new roles.

  • whos demona

    and i didnt like some of the cast like goliath i think the rock should be goliath as for elisa i guess aishawarya rai would be the best she have a fine beauty and maybe michelle pfeier would be a good demona

    but the idea is wicked i like it

  • How could u not know who Demona is???? and some of ur suggestions for cast members r ppl that I've been thinking of to play The Pack. I'm working on a Pack vid. and who could play them. The Rock was someone that I was thinking of. And who the HELL is aishawarya???

  • ummm.......

  • Great idea and the music fits perfectly! (**,)

  • ^_^ thax ^_^

  • you know how too pick them especailly Fox I was surprised to see such a perfect match, but Elisa I know their was someone better 4 her but I foget who it is

  • Thax for saying so and would u belive that the woman who plays FOx in the show would be who I'd pick to play her in my moive? Like I said in the info. I took real cast members and included them/changed who they played.

  • Maybe Sydni Fox from that show Relic Hunter? Maybe she'd be good for Elisa or Michel Perfiure maybe.

  • Sweet Cast.

  • Thax for the comment ^_^

  • do you think Gerad Butler or Russel Crow could play Goilath.

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more