Judy had style that no Woman in show business has come close to.The curtain was there for a reason not to see.But the press the world pulled it back and seen how hard it was to be Judy Garland.She did a Great job in giving the world JOY so lets remember that!!! Loving you still Barb...
My God (!) this is simply the best version of "Smile" which has ever been done. This is the defining Judy - she didn't just make you feel "sympathy" for her - she made you feel what she felt (empathy!) Very few singers have ever approached this realm - Judy not only "lived" there, but she invented this heaven-space. Right here on planet earth!
This is a great old song. I've listened to it by other singers then I found this. Sheeesh! Ms Garland will always really be in a class all by herself.
You know, her life was so messed up, I wonder if she sang this to herself. It almost hurts, listening to her sing this. I never met her, I still miss her.
What is so poignant about this song is how it defines Judy's life. Put on a brave face... and go out there and deal with it. And yet... we know what happened.
Sublime sadness can be as fulfilling, in its own way, as supreme happiness.
I think Judy did good with her life. I can only hope that she realized that.
I wanted to write how much I miss Judy. There is not her near equal on this planet today. I met her twice early 60's, I was 16. Then I saw the comment from a 15 year old and somehow I was stunned but consoled. TY
@globalman blessed moments.... i LOVE judy since i m a young girl. even now i can understand how hard her live was.but in my younger days i just felt her emotion.. and this is what music should be...... i also miss her ..... my whole live
Shirley Bassey idolized Judy Garland when growing up, and when she became a music industry celebrity in her own right, she and Judy became friends. Click on attached 'You Made Me Love You' Video Response for Shirley's tribute to Judy. These three Judy songs were recorded by Bassey in 1979.
incredible..at this moment she must of known why she was put here on earth..thank you Judy for your amazing talent, I imagine you sing with the angels regularly..
The VOICE.. still.. RINGS.. out.. and it.. brings back... A SMILE.. even though that saddness that she left us.. ! BUT SHE LIVES ON.. in what she left behind for us.
It seems to me that judy Garland sings the most uplifting songs ever. This, Somewhere Over The Rainbow, and Have yourself A Merry Little Christmas. Her songs could cure the world of depression if played enough.
@ticklertim1 No the lyrics where written by John Turner and Geoffrey Parsons in 1954. The original was an instrumental piece that Chaplin wrote for his film Modern times in 1936.
JUDY, ma préférence ... Je t'ai dans mon coeur et dans mes pensées .. à chaque fois que j'écoute ta voix ... tu me fais tellement vibrer - tu étais la vie même ... quel talent ... quelle émotion .... MERCI
What an incredibly unique, special and personal vocal ability. Judy was an entertainer like no other with a voice with so many different qualities that just grabbed our hearts and brought us to tears or amazement. She really hit home with this song. Judy has matched Michael Jackson's version of this song and anyone else for that matter. You can hear about her tragic life through this song and her rare "Somewhere over the Rainbow" that she sang on only two TV specials dressed as a sad clown.
Most comments talk about how deeply Judy dug into her emotions and how much of herself she gave. I'm not sure that I believe that... I don't think that she had to go within herself to convey the magic that we all feel from her. She simply had a gift that no other performer had or will have to penetrate the souls of all who experience her. I believe it is US more than herself that Judy is digging so deeply into... That is why in any of her performances she has us in the palm of her hand.
When it comes to smiling, Judy wanted it every bit as much as the very most deserving smile seekers. The depth of feeling demonstrated also in wanting to pull the struggling believers through. . . . . you can really feel in this performance her wanting to tell and show the whole world that it really is possible no matter what. . . to smile! :)
Who could draw on more of themselves to produce such an emotive performance of this piece? Connecting deep within to pull the very best out without crossing a very finite line into tears.
Only a true talent with extraordinary persona could achieve this and offer up to us such a special gift for us to treasure.
That's what makes Judy Garland stand out from the vast amounts of singers out there and especially with today's singers. They need to look at Judy Garland's career (both in the studio & live performances) and see how the master did it. Judy Garland truly was a singer and she put more than 100% of herself into the songs that she sung. She didn't need to do any choreographed dance routines or dress provocatively--all she needed was a microphone and the magic begins.
hey thanks for that. i have never heard judy sing that song before. and to see it with video also brought me to tears. she is amazing. even if she is on pills or something chemical. still the honesty of her is amazing
The story of Judy Garland's life is a devastating one. Hooked on drugs from a young age and dieing because of all of that. I feel like this song is a good sum up of her life. makes me so sad.
I don't know much about her and I stumbed on this by accident. My God! She kicks ass. This is beyond crooning. Its art. She's so beautiful, graceful, and every gesture pulled me in. Where the hell have I been. Wow!!!!!!!!
somebody borns special.she was s dream.she was carrying the great art talents.Also that brought end of her.The artest sick.To be diffrent.wow judy ı wish ı would catch you.BİG LOVES WİTh you from turkey..
The amount of emotion in hër sounds is amazing. Happiness and Sadness combined to one briliant piece. It talks about life and death. About endless effort and about our obligation to carry our problems and struggles alone... And still we should smile! And still we should enjoy life! Perfection...
The song's title is "Smile", ironically though, it's the one song that can bring me to tears whenever I listen to it. It's such an overwhelming feeling.
By the way, those 5 people who 'Disliked' this performance of the song clearly know nothing of music.
ah....Judy......I hope you have the most wonderful nest in heaven....thankyou for all the beautiful moments you have provided we earthlings.....I hope you finally realize what you meant to us...
to my mom and day......your times were the best times....miss you always...L.
This is a bittersweet song that so perfectly fits Judy's life story that you know Judy is singing it straight from the heart. Even though Judy seemed to struggle for happiness in her personal life, she loved performing and her audience loved her for performing. No one could sing a song with more emotion than Judy.
It hurts to watch this because the emotions are real--nobody current can get even near this level of honest artistry. The current crop doesn't have a clue....
GigantaHeart nice to hear and right on key I am 53 and the junk is hard to listen to and call it music.Where is Alica Keys Jennifer Hudson they are the Ladies of there time!!! NO one beats Judy tho!! PEACE Barb ...
Judy found the soul of every song she sang...and poured that soul out for us all to share with her. Her voice, her face, her expression created every song new for us to love all over again.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
did she get drunk and beat the hell out of her daughter like Mommy dearest Joan Crawford? or was she so drugged out on pills that little liza had to watch her unconscious in the bed for days at a time? is that why Liza turned out to be a drunk like she is?
I just want to say that I have been looking for a song to sort of represent me when I am gone, which I hope will be shortly , and the best I have known is of this Lady who I think is the greatest Diva of all, not like all the mentioned Divas, but the one who realy gets to your hearts. I think she should have been awarded the Diva of mankind if it existed. Let She rest in Peace.
I just want to say that I have been looking for a song to sort of represent me when I am gone, which I hope will be shortly , and the best I have known is of this Lady who I think is the greatest Diva of all, not like all the mentioned Divas, but the one who realy gets to your hearts. I think she should have been awarded the Diva of mankind if it existed. Let She rest in Peace.
Artist of the old days... I love this song both by her and Nat King Cole. Still I think there r 1 difference between nowadays and the old days: The GREAT artist of the good old day don't need to be good looking whatsoever to be GREAT, like Nat KIng Cole or Louis Armstrong, they aren't handsome but GREAT compare to many singers today...
@moroney1 I said many not all... Modern music with its growth in all branches is inevitable, the artists tend to attract people by any mean necessary... Like at my place, it's quite hard to find someone eager to learn one thing a two about the artists of the old age while many are influenced by the current of K-Pop, where their look is more appreciated than their voice (sorry K-Pop fan). This makes me quite sad because the most important thing to an artist beside their voice is their SOUL.
@GigantaHeart You're completely right. Music has gone down hill. I mean I still like modern music, but I turn the other way when it comes to Lady GooGoo who by the way is hardly a lady. And she cannot sing to save herself. I'm 28 and absolutely feel Judy Garland even now as she sings as though she's singing to me. That's how she wanted it to be too. She wants you to feel your own feelings. And boy does it work. Wonderful voice and wonderful singer.
Judy sang in her own magical way.She knew how to approach a song and put her every emotion into it. You cannot compare her with anyone. Lady Gaga is a totally different singer who will not have long lasting appeal that Judy Garland does. Judy was a living legend and all she needed was a mic and a Orchestra. She doesn't need get ups or all those distractions that todays singers use because if the singers today got rid of all their gimmicks they would be booed off stage.
You are right, I agree with everything that you said. Judy Garland has TRUE talent, unlike these "so-called" singers that are out here today. And also Judy Garland's music will always have more longeity because her music is timeless. There will never be another Judy Garland . . . .she may be often imitated but never duplicated. I also hate the fact that so many singers today rely things like choreographed dances and I wish it was more about the music.
@RUSTYBOY1122 WTF? those two women are totally different. you cant compare the two. different time periods,style, and voices. all of these come into factor while choosing who's better. their simply can be no "better" singer. im not saying that gaga isn't talented, but i really hate it when people make non- thought out choices.They are BOTH great in their OWN ways. thank you.
@RUSTYBOY1122 lady gaga is nothing without her costumes and other myriad of gimmicks. same with katy perry, madonna, and countless others. imo, all the really great singers need is their voice and a piano or orchestra behind them.
gives me goosebumps and a lump in the throst EVERY time! Esp. when she sing about hiding every trace of sdness and her face gets that knowing and very sad smirk. awww poor Judy. Still No one did it better
Through all of her inner turmoil Judy was the ultimate lady. A legend to everyone but to a fifteen year old she was a friend who cared about what I thought. I spent an hour with her in 1953 in Birmingham,England backstage after one of her shows. All the time she kept asking me questions about what I wanted to do in life. None of it was about her. Bless you Judy.
@ericlovesjudy and we were lucky enough to exist in a time when this magic was created! How sad a place the world would be without Judy Garland singing to us!
There are certain artists who were never before and never again. There is only one and the best efforts, few as they may be because these people can never be re-created, always fail. Judy Garland is one of them. More remarkable is she sings like someone from heaven, dances expertly with no choreography, acts in drama, comedy, musical, and TV, and she looks as if it comes very easy and that she worked and waited her whole life for any one performance.
judy was one of the greats singing with great feeling she could sing any of the great stars of her time off the stage its very sad she is gone and that would not say it all for judy
judy was one of the greats singing with great feeling she could sing any of the great stars of her time off the stage its very sad she is gone and that dosent cover it
I didn't realized that she was truly a gem....
unpinoy 5 days ago
Judy had style that no Woman in show business has come close to.The curtain was there for a reason not to see.But the press the world pulled it back and seen how hard it was to be Judy Garland.She did a Great job in giving the world JOY so lets remember that!!! Loving you still Barb...
pusspleaser134 5 days ago 2
Thumbs up if you think that this might be the most heart-wrenching song on YouTube.
bjbinmke 1 week ago 2
I love judy garland!!!!!
LoveDrawingxP 1 week ago
My God (!) this is simply the best version of "Smile" which has ever been done. This is the defining Judy - she didn't just make you feel "sympathy" for her - she made you feel what she felt (empathy!) Very few singers have ever approached this realm - Judy not only "lived" there, but she invented this heaven-space. Right here on planet earth!
etienne818 2 weeks ago 5
@etienne818
well said.
annielouism 2 days ago
Breathtaking!
Whow!
Ullarobinlilly 3 weeks ago
No one but no one sings this like Judy!
TheBlandina131 1 month ago
This is a great old song. I've listened to it by other singers then I found this. Sheeesh! Ms Garland will always really be in a class all by herself.
euqip 1 month ago 2
she was undoutbly one of the best entertainers of all time!........
TC6759 1 month ago
Beautiful
veeerooniicaaa 1 month ago
You know, her life was so messed up, I wonder if she sang this to herself. It almost hurts, listening to her sing this. I never met her, I still miss her.
bjbinmke 2 months ago 4
That was Beautiful.
alydez2 2 months ago
holy shit.
Yankees22013 2 months ago 4
To all the broken hearts...
ramgaresao 2 months ago 3
What is so poignant about this song is how it defines Judy's life. Put on a brave face... and go out there and deal with it. And yet... we know what happened.
Sublime sadness can be as fulfilling, in its own way, as supreme happiness.
I think Judy did good with her life. I can only hope that she realized that.
sbergman27 3 months ago 14
a true legend. she will forever remain in our hearts. beautiful inside and out, an undeniable talent.
vangoghlicious 3 months ago 4
I wanted to write how much I miss Judy. There is not her near equal on this planet today. I met her twice early 60's, I was 16. Then I saw the comment from a 15 year old and somehow I was stunned but consoled. TY
globalman 3 months ago 5
@globalman blessed moments.... i LOVE judy since i m a young girl. even now i can understand how hard her live was.but in my younger days i just felt her emotion.. and this is what music should be...... i also miss her ..... my whole live
odysseetheater 1 month ago 2
I'm 15...and I miss Judy Garland so much!
whatsername124 4 months ago 7
Shirley Bassey idolized Judy Garland when growing up, and when she became a music industry celebrity in her own right, she and Judy became friends. Click on attached 'You Made Me Love You' Video Response for Shirley's tribute to Judy. These three Judy songs were recorded by Bassey in 1979.
sas9023055 4 months ago
For me, the best version ever.
Daninha86 4 months ago 2
incredible..at this moment she must of known why she was put here on earth..thank you Judy for your amazing talent, I imagine you sing with the angels regularly..
sbarrette78 4 months ago 2
is there a "i smiled while listening to Judy"-button?
happycat85 4 months ago 2
The VOICE.. still.. RINGS.. out.. and it.. brings back... A SMILE.. even though that saddness that she left us.. ! BUT SHE LIVES ON.. in what she left behind for us.
eireman 4 months ago 2
Judy is still the best and still timeless. No performer has ever equaled her.
dannyroy100 4 months ago
wonderful.
60Bluesy 4 months ago
Sunday night at the palladium, and Ed Sullivan aired it
joeyjosephs 4 months ago
I know this was in London. Does anyone know the venue?
zyxquark 4 months ago
6 people don't smile
caiomoloko 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@caiomoloko .. they must be very very sad...
odysseetheater 4 months ago
BREATHTAKING....
jacksonbrownepuppy 4 months ago
@jacksonbrownepuppy Yes, still, everytime without fail! Judy is my Queen!
JosienTess2 4 months ago
@JosienTess2 yes, I feel the same way... she will always be #1 to me...
jacksonbrownepuppy 4 months ago
judy, i hope youre finally happy somewhere. god bless you, darling. <3
ThePhantom4ever 4 months ago 3
Indeed a classic.
Jme1095 5 months ago
timeless.
andiimayleangray67 5 months ago
Judy Garland was a very sad person herself in real life. I didn't know that until I saw some commentaries about her.
MegaLWordFan 5 months ago
It seems to me that judy Garland sings the most uplifting songs ever. This, Somewhere Over The Rainbow, and Have yourself A Merry Little Christmas. Her songs could cure the world of depression if played enough.
mysteryMusician13 5 months ago
Beautiful...
GazTheSoundGuy 5 months ago
(N)agyszerű! :)
icasizsiv 5 months ago
Simply stunning...
kirstenrubberducky 5 months ago
Holy smoke. That's a performance!
naniwadog 5 months ago
why is that even the the song says smile it makes me feel sad?
sonofsilence 5 months ago
God, she just kills me with this song
celtica99 5 months ago 2
@MarytheNight126 have you heard Michael Jackson's version? Its also incredible
aishaxoxobela 5 months ago
<3
CelineElla123 6 months ago
awesome !!!......the words were written by Charlie Chaplin....Judy...the one and only!
ticklertim1 6 months ago 3
@ticklertim1 No the lyrics where written by John Turner and Geoffrey Parsons in 1954. The original was an instrumental piece that Chaplin wrote for his film Modern times in 1936.
Stravinsky91 6 months ago
I have heard (read?) that this was Judy's fav song... meebee I/m wrong!
spikereward1 6 months ago 2
one of the best versions of this song i've ever heard, so beautiful :')
angelgeorgiamae 6 months ago
Whatever thing disliked this must have no soul. This is beautiful.
Conqueredd1 6 months ago 3
Wow, this beyooooond amazing
BanginDRCuT 6 months ago
JUDY, ma préférence ... Je t'ai dans mon coeur et dans mes pensées .. à chaque fois que j'écoute ta voix ... tu me fais tellement vibrer - tu étais la vie même ... quel talent ... quelle émotion .... MERCI
aroukalyne 7 months ago
Wow! This made me cry...
manilenyongmakoy 7 months ago 4
What an incredibly unique, special and personal vocal ability. Judy was an entertainer like no other with a voice with so many different qualities that just grabbed our hearts and brought us to tears or amazement. She really hit home with this song. Judy has matched Michael Jackson's version of this song and anyone else for that matter. You can hear about her tragic life through this song and her rare "Somewhere over the Rainbow" that she sang on only two TV specials dressed as a sad clown.
HandwhistlerBen 7 months ago 2
Such a beautiful rendition and sucha tragic tale.
yoursandygray 7 months ago
Most comments talk about how deeply Judy dug into her emotions and how much of herself she gave. I'm not sure that I believe that... I don't think that she had to go within herself to convey the magic that we all feel from her. She simply had a gift that no other performer had or will have to penetrate the souls of all who experience her. I believe it is US more than herself that Judy is digging so deeply into... That is why in any of her performances she has us in the palm of her hand.
cda345 7 months ago 2
Judy never held back she put every ounce of her soul into each song ,may she should have kept some back for herself,
MrDACooling 7 months ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
When it comes to smiling, Judy wanted it every bit as much as the very most deserving smile seekers. The depth of feeling demonstrated also in wanting to pull the struggling believers through. . . . . you can really feel in this performance her wanting to tell and show the whole world that it really is possible no matter what. . . to smile! :)
runningwithoutmymeds 7 months ago
Who could draw on more of themselves to produce such an emotive performance of this piece? Connecting deep within to pull the very best out without crossing a very finite line into tears.
Only a true talent with extraordinary persona could achieve this and offer up to us such a special gift for us to treasure.
runningwithoutmymeds 7 months ago 2
@runningwithoutmymeds
That's what makes Judy Garland stand out from the vast amounts of singers out there and especially with today's singers. They need to look at Judy Garland's career (both in the studio & live performances) and see how the master did it. Judy Garland truly was a singer and she put more than 100% of herself into the songs that she sung. She didn't need to do any choreographed dance routines or dress provocatively--all she needed was a microphone and the magic begins.
MusicLoverBrian1 7 months ago
Comment removed
runningwithoutmymeds 7 months ago
hey thanks for that. i have never heard judy sing that song before. and to see it with video also brought me to tears. she is amazing. even if she is on pills or something chemical. still the honesty of her is amazing
toeknee1965 7 months ago
Happy birthday judy
Scabsxinxmyxnose 7 months ago
6 people are related to the wicked witch of the west.
the1texasmccoy 7 months ago 3
They should not have a like button, they should have a love button for this song. One of my fav songs ever. Also my fav version
71579musiclover 8 months ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
the greatest entertainer of all time!.......love her so much!
TC6759 8 months ago
The story of Judy Garland's life is a devastating one. Hooked on drugs from a young age and dieing because of all of that. I feel like this song is a good sum up of her life. makes me so sad.
hulahoolaXx 8 months ago 2
Awesome ...just awesome! I heard another version on an oldies radio show.
Judy Garland's is the best by far. What a classy lady! Thanks for this sharing this great live performance.
shalimarsgirl 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this is immense, check out my cover on my channel x
mildredsmelodies 8 months ago
i love judy!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
giuligulis 8 months ago
I don't know much about her and I stumbed on this by accident. My God! She kicks ass. This is beyond crooning. Its art. She's so beautiful, graceful, and every gesture pulled me in. Where the hell have I been. Wow!!!!!!!!
avengerspeel 8 months ago 3
somebody borns special.she was s dream.she was carrying the great art talents.Also that brought end of her.The artest sick.To be diffrent.wow judy ı wish ı would catch you.BİG LOVES WİTh you from turkey..
sx1666 8 months ago
A legendary singer, dancer, actress. Talented Judy Garland (^^)y
kitkatrivera 8 months ago
I hit the "like" button, but I feel bad because it should say "love".
supinedream 8 months ago 98
@supinedream you've hit that right ; ))))
beretta8 3 months ago
The amount of emotion in hër sounds is amazing. Happiness and Sadness combined to one briliant piece. It talks about life and death. About endless effort and about our obligation to carry our problems and struggles alone... And still we should smile! And still we should enjoy life! Perfection...
SirDead77 8 months ago 3
i could listen to her forever
silvershields 8 months ago
I was sobbing.. only because this song is my life in a nutshell
Redskittles101 9 months ago
@Redskittles101 ssshhh emo kid - listen to Judy and her voice
silvershields 8 months ago 23
5 people are clearly too miserable to smile.
ClaireSpooky 9 months ago 3
miss garland was a very poor lady!
emre900100 9 months ago
5 people obviously don't appreciate an awesome performer
greenlanternintx 9 months ago
@greenlanternintx They should go listen to justin beiber
71579musiclover 9 months ago
There'll never be another Judy.
IFreakMyselfOut 9 months ago 2
This is the only version of the song that has me in tears. She is remarkable!
000duchess000 9 months ago 4
The song's title is "Smile", ironically though, it's the one song that can bring me to tears whenever I listen to it. It's such an overwhelming feeling.
By the way, those 5 people who 'Disliked' this performance of the song clearly know nothing of music.
Dan3043 9 months ago 4
Oh, Judy, this makes me miss you so much. This has put me in tears. Thank you ever so much for sharing this. We adore you, Judy! *sigh*
JudyGarland38 9 months ago
ah....Judy......I hope you have the most wonderful nest in heaven....thankyou for all the beautiful moments you have provided we earthlings.....I hope you finally realize what you meant to us...
to my mom and day......your times were the best times....miss you always...L.
leelaural 10 months ago 2
@leelaural and she left such beautiful moments for us to relish in until we meet her there!
supinedream 9 months ago
This is a bittersweet song that so perfectly fits Judy's life story that you know Judy is singing it straight from the heart. Even though Judy seemed to struggle for happiness in her personal life, she loved performing and her audience loved her for performing. No one could sing a song with more emotion than Judy.
ronhronh 10 months ago
Ach Juds. wenn du nich wärst! Danke
alixvhessen 10 months ago
i hope i can give my son somthing with this song.its so amazing
30piefke 10 months ago
Such a beautiful song, Charlie Chaplin was a talented man.
Hania454 10 months ago
Wow!
bashbrannigan 10 months ago
Michael Jacksons fav song. I love this song. One of my fav songs also
71579musiclover 10 months ago
5 people smiled
gegx313 10 months ago
This song makes me in the opposite mood... Sad.
I love her!!!
helenajesstarzak 10 months ago
It hurts to watch this because the emotions are real--nobody current can get even near this level of honest artistry. The current crop doesn't have a clue....
terrryc 10 months ago
this is beautiful
nathanielane 10 months ago
laden with emotions! *
simply BEAUTIFUL!!!
farres0031 10 months ago
she bad. 2:33 is too on point just like whitney houston.
TheLeadCreator 10 months ago
I want to cry for her....she always looked so sad in her waning years.
Sweetthang9 10 months ago
Beautiful.
TheKimdunn 10 months ago
Celine could never come close to the emotion that Judy puts into a song..no way near in the same category.
Jimbo8137 10 months ago 2
@Jimbo8137 she was in pain you can feel it, but she still smiled....maybe it was the barbiturates...dunno.
katrastrophy 10 months ago
4 poeple dont have souls
Hippychick25 10 months ago 3
GigantaHeart nice to hear and right on key I am 53 and the junk is hard to listen to and call it music.Where is Alica Keys Jennifer Hudson they are the Ladies of there time!!! NO one beats Judy tho!! PEACE Barb ...
pusspleaser134 11 months ago
Celine didn't come close last night.
Gladman 11 months ago
How sad that a lady with this voice could die the way she did, all alone?.
Brighteyes1ful 11 months ago 3
Four assholes voted......Oh how I love transparency.
TheMikehattan 11 months ago
Nobody can sing it like Judy.
thewzrdofoz 11 months ago
just beautiful.... thank you for posting
jvillan85 11 months ago
I wanted to cry as I listened :' )
beaverdctor 11 months ago 4
a melhor interpretação desta música, sem dúvida, so poderia ser dela: Judy g
Garland
mirocadf 11 months ago
train wreck...
Sleightman3D 11 months ago
Judy found the soul of every song she sang...and poured that soul out for us all to share with her. Her voice, her face, her expression created every song new for us to love all over again.
Operaddict 1 year ago 2
She brought it from the depths. She was a great singer.
BackInsight 1 year ago 2
Everytime I watch this I cry.. Her voice is so moving!! Most wonderful singer & actress ever...I love her.
frenchfriesism 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
did she get drunk and beat the hell out of her daughter like Mommy dearest Joan Crawford? or was she so drugged out on pills that little liza had to watch her unconscious in the bed for days at a time? is that why Liza turned out to be a drunk like she is?
whatigot2say 1 year ago
@whatigot2say really nice compassion there. really nice.
cait72590 1 year ago
@cait72590 I was just asking. found out later that she wasn't mean to her children like Joan Crawford she was too high to be mean.
whatigot2say 1 year ago
Uhhh..... WOW!
PoptartFreak720 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
she sounds like an old drunk.
whatigot2say 1 year ago
@whatigot2say all the more pathos and emotion
TwoMenofMGM 1 year ago
tem hora que da até gosto de escutar musica ,quando é uma musica linda desta e bem cantada tem que dar graça a Deus por não ser surdo.
MrLeeguaianazes 1 year ago
NOW that is selling it with your heart and soul
trerenee1 1 year ago
I just want to say that I have been looking for a song to sort of represent me when I am gone, which I hope will be shortly , and the best I have known is of this Lady who I think is the greatest Diva of all, not like all the mentioned Divas, but the one who realy gets to your hearts. I think she should have been awarded the Diva of mankind if it existed. Let She rest in Peace.
MrJasperscott 1 year ago
I just want to say that I have been looking for a song to sort of represent me when I am gone, which I hope will be shortly , and the best I have known is of this Lady who I think is the greatest Diva of all, not like all the mentioned Divas, but the one who realy gets to your hearts. I think she should have been awarded the Diva of mankind if it existed. Let She rest in Peace.
MrJasperscott 1 year ago
Artist of the old days... I love this song both by her and Nat King Cole. Still I think there r 1 difference between nowadays and the old days: The GREAT artist of the good old day don't need to be good looking whatsoever to be GREAT, like Nat KIng Cole or Louis Armstrong, they aren't handsome but GREAT compare to many singers today...
GigantaHeart 1 year ago
@GigantaHeart stop undermining modern music
moroney1 1 year ago
@moroney1 I said many not all... Modern music with its growth in all branches is inevitable, the artists tend to attract people by any mean necessary... Like at my place, it's quite hard to find someone eager to learn one thing a two about the artists of the old age while many are influenced by the current of K-Pop, where their look is more appreciated than their voice (sorry K-Pop fan). This makes me quite sad because the most important thing to an artist beside their voice is their SOUL.
GigantaHeart 11 months ago
@GigantaHeart You're completely right. Music has gone down hill. I mean I still like modern music, but I turn the other way when it comes to Lady GooGoo who by the way is hardly a lady. And she cannot sing to save herself. I'm 28 and absolutely feel Judy Garland even now as she sings as though she's singing to me. That's how she wanted it to be too. She wants you to feel your own feelings. And boy does it work. Wonderful voice and wonderful singer.
DreamerMaker 11 months ago
stunning....thats the only word
reidsify 1 year ago
I always said if someone came down from another planet and asked "who is Judy Garland" all you would have to do is show them this clip.
Robert4770 1 year ago 4
Brought me to tears.
CarlyIsAGangster 1 year ago 43
@CarlyIsAGangster the best version of this beautiful song
71579musiclover 9 months ago 2
Everytime she sang, she died a little!
Wotan123456789 1 year ago
Judy sang in her own magical way.She knew how to approach a song and put her every emotion into it. You cannot compare her with anyone. Lady Gaga is a totally different singer who will not have long lasting appeal that Judy Garland does. Judy was a living legend and all she needed was a mic and a Orchestra. She doesn't need get ups or all those distractions that todays singers use because if the singers today got rid of all their gimmicks they would be booed off stage.
NFitalianGuy 1 year ago 3
@NFitalianGuy
You are right, I agree with everything that you said. Judy Garland has TRUE talent, unlike these "so-called" singers that are out here today. And also Judy Garland's music will always have more longeity because her music is timeless. There will never be another Judy Garland . . . .she may be often imitated but never duplicated. I also hate the fact that so many singers today rely things like choreographed dances and I wish it was more about the music.
MusicLoverBrian1 1 year ago
@MusicLoverBrian1 ughhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh, stop bloody undermining todays music, its sickening
moroney1 1 year ago
@NFitalianGuy amen!
No1KCfan6 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Lady GAGA is so much better
RUSTYBOY1122 1 year ago
@RUSTYBOY1122 Shut the fuck up, you have no clue what you are talking about, Judy is the greatest female performer in living memory
Gurgi1990 1 year ago
@RUSTYBOY1122 WTF? those two women are totally different. you cant compare the two. different time periods,style, and voices. all of these come into factor while choosing who's better. their simply can be no "better" singer. im not saying that gaga isn't talented, but i really hate it when people make non- thought out choices.They are BOTH great in their OWN ways. thank you.
rgasp12 1 year ago
@RUSTYBOY1122 lady gaga is nothing without her costumes and other myriad of gimmicks. same with katy perry, madonna, and countless others. imo, all the really great singers need is their voice and a piano or orchestra behind them.
No1KCfan6 1 year ago
gives me goosebumps and a lump in the throst EVERY time! Esp. when she sing about hiding every trace of sdness and her face gets that knowing and very sad smirk. awww poor Judy. Still No one did it better
divastyledfw 1 year ago
just class, love it baby Judy xxx
daveybeno 1 year ago
Through all of her inner turmoil Judy was the ultimate lady. A legend to everyone but to a fifteen year old she was a friend who cared about what I thought. I spent an hour with her in 1953 in Birmingham,England backstage after one of her shows. All the time she kept asking me questions about what I wanted to do in life. None of it was about her. Bless you Judy.
02lensman 1 year ago
No he's not, and in any event, you didn't even spell his name correctly. It's "Nat" not "Nate."
bwaysinger88 1 year ago
Nate King Cole is much better
BillyRaff 1 year ago
why do I always have a tear in my eye and a lump in my throat when I hear this song sung by one of the very best......thanx Judy!!
ethan2480 1 year ago 2
Once, every eternity, there's a Judy Garland.
ericlovesjudy 1 year ago 68
@ericlovesjudy and we were lucky enough to exist in a time when this magic was created! How sad a place the world would be without Judy Garland singing to us!
supinedream 9 months ago 2
@supinedream Such a beautiful thing to say and so true!
TheMensch84 9 months ago 3
@supinedream
Thank you.
jurek46pink 8 months ago
amazing!
mtgrey 1 year ago
There are certain artists who were never before and never again. There is only one and the best efforts, few as they may be because these people can never be re-created, always fail. Judy Garland is one of them. More remarkable is she sings like someone from heaven, dances expertly with no choreography, acts in drama, comedy, musical, and TV, and she looks as if it comes very easy and that she worked and waited her whole life for any one performance.
elevado90069 1 year ago
judy was one of the greats singing with great feeling she could sing any of the great stars of her time off the stage its very sad she is gone and that would not say it all for judy
bswann2 1 year ago
judy was one of the greats singing with great feeling she could sing any of the great stars of her time off the stage its very sad she is gone and that dosent cover it
bswann2 1 year ago
the ultimate tear jerker!
Jimbo8137 1 year ago
Judy Garland 4ever. :-D
Jeannekm126 1 year ago
Sing it? She LIVED it! Peace to you Judy where ever you are...always.
gugenheim84 1 year ago 4
The greatest talent that this world has every been blessed with. Period.
mikeyp1230 1 year ago 5
And she didn't like herself???
Love you.
openedto 1 year ago
she is timelessly beautiful and amazingly amazing <3<3
ninskimig123 1 year ago 3
Nothing interesting in my comment. I love you JUDY. You help us face each day.
patriotplus 1 year ago 2
the greatest singer ever
jocmuc1 1 year ago 4
pure magic .......
sookiestackhouse2u 1 year ago 5
Judy's the best. So far ahead of anyone else. I could listen all day.
bobufer 1 year ago 2
the four people who gave this a thumbs down must be musicaly impaired
katfruit81 1 year ago 2
This is my all time favorite Judy Garland performance.....
charleswtriplett 1 year ago
As Deep as it gets.
WhiteWhiteWhite88 1 year ago
With a voice husky with hard living her vocals seems only to take on perfection. You do not listen to Judy you are there! Living what she is singing!
1146beaver 1 year ago 3
the best version of this song i have ever heard...ty for posting this
elvisuk 1 year ago 3
the best performance of this song to date!!!! beautiful judy!!! thank u!!!!!...jb
joebrucato 1 year ago