The Saturdays - If This Is Love (The Nokia Green Room Live)

[Kelmurf313]

o frankie.... please stop... my ears.... are burning!

[wtda0frutlkinbout]

dey didnt sing the whole song y?

[adriancn1]

a ver cual canta peor

[Irene95pap]

@adriancn1 este directo es muy malo.. pero te recomiendo q veas algun otro directo de ellas porq la verdad esq no lo suelen hacer nada mal, ademas es una cancion dificil..

[aggzieMCR]

they all suck here. :/

[mike214203]

I don't think this is the worst performance ever. I quite enjoyed it. I really like the fact that they didn't mime as well, even if it wasn't perfect the whole time.

[JillValentineFE]

excuse meeeee? Rochelle is actually the worst one and Mollie did pretty well >.>

[thlcfc]

This is the only bad live performance they have ever done and it was there first ever! It is pretty awful and i said they wouldnt get anywhere at the time but since then there performances have improved so much its clearly down to nerves

[TheAfyk]

total aweful live they are

they cant sing 

[AliiVolkova]

frankie´s voice sounds weird, but in others performance she sings incredible, so maybe she had some problem that day with her voice..

[LadyGagacy424]

though this is a bit weird lol but i think Vanessa sings the best she has a big lung! :-D

[alexm921]

Vanessa is amazing, and i have seen them live and they are all amazing. I have even seem them sing in a moving car so they can sing individually!!!!

[letshavethesalt91]

Epic fail on all singing and dancing parts, Can frankie hit high note? no no can she hit ANY note?

p.s. im sure she is a lovely person.

sorry frankie :) x

[ceaddwyk]

Did you really just say that Mollie can sing? In this video she clearly can not.. and neither can Frankie... but two best are Vanessa and Rochelle and then Una, and Mollie and Frankie are kinda tied for last...

[aajjlovemcfly]

vanessa is the best singer, only thing i agree in.

but you can't say that frankie and mollie are bad singers! it's not that easy to sing while you're dancing. keep that in mind

[ceaddwyk]

These dance moves aren't even that hard.. and I know about dancing and singing..

[aajjlovemcfly]

then add that this was their first tv performance. if you know about singing and dancing you probably know its really hard to sing when you're really nervous.

not saying this i her best vocal performance, but she can sing.

[Punkprynces95]

omg i never realized how much frankie suckz until now! she sounds like shes dieing or somethin. vanessa and mollie r the only 2 that can sing really well in this band!

[MissSiriusRose]

So this is their first ever t.v. performance? If so it's good... the performance is 'exciting' and fun. Vocals are really bad though... but it's good for a debute.

[SugaFan90]

Thank god they got better, that's all I'm saying!

[rosasymariposas]

if im honest i don't think this video showcases their vocal talent. in the particular vid it's really hard for them because they've got a dance routine, making it a LOT harder to control their voices. thought una did a good job, mollie was pretty ok..vanessa, rochelle ok too..frankie struggled the most i think..but all in all, kudos as it was hard for them and they've done great live performances apart from this!

[phototgenicposer]

Frankie had the hardest part though

[Fbinitie]

@phototgenicposer Rochelle had the hardest part

[mofoexpo]

lol, not the greatest performances...but they have got better...you cant deny it :P

[betomi]

it wasn't awful considering it was their first one

[Englishdosser86]

She's too hot to get rid of.

[kitten123lil]

♥Moluna♥

love all of them though

[fbayona21]

Ya no I agree too. I'm a fan of the rochelle and vanessa. I like Una too. Frankie and Mollie seem really nice, but if weren't there I wouldn't mind.

[jhits4life14]

Frankie is the best!

[str4nded]

She's just screaming in this video though

[Al3xJordanSaid3]

Vanessa&Rochelle The best.

[girlsaloudfan121]

OMG FRANKIE AND ROCHELLE shutup your hurting my ears

Vanessa is the only one tht can sing

[girlsaloudfan121]

oh and unas orite too

[Back2Bay6]

Vanessa sings damn horrible here. But they're all good normally, even when they're not lipsyncing

[drewbilation]

Rochelle sounds the best of any of them on this video!

[gojumpoffacliff13]

lol, i found your comment amusing cause the two you named are the two who used to be in a semi-succesful band lol, but i agree with you! lol, jus had to laugh at that :)

[prettypinkpanther123]

they cant hear each other and they is supper nackered

[littlemissdaydreamer]

if u think ther rubbish live check out ishues and chasing lights when they were on mtv cause its awsome

[prettypinkpanther123]

They sound bad cus they is trying 2 dance but they r gd cus listen to issues!!

[sohott101]

THEY SOUND TERRIBLE LIVE

[girlsaloudfan121]

none of them bar vanessa can sing ESPECIALLY frankie and mollie

[annadream00]

For al those people who say that these girls can't sing live, search 'The Saturdays - Issues (Nokia Green Room)'

[aze1022]

i think that they may not be able to hear eachother. but they tried their best

[julie22macy]

i thought they were actually really good live!!!

[Staarrgiirrll]

I thought they were really good actually, one of the better girl groups I've heard live !

[HayleyHula]

there only singing bad cos there dancing and there trying to make themselves sing louder

[Roxas3143]

OMG they are terrible live. Shows what voice enhancers does!

[gazza222222222222222]

oo dear! they orr soo shitt :L its funny im mean the one in the green dress pahahahah shee iss rubish :L

[veeramootoo]

una is the worst

[ThePurestBlood]

shit

[5h4d0wc4t]

They are really good in my opinion.

ALL YOU PEOPLE WHO SAY THEIR CRAP

WATCH THE 'ISSUES' VIDEO

[lucyblackz]

You had Blur Vs Oasis

Now its....

City Girls Vs The Saturdays.

Battle of the new girl groups.

WHOSE SIDE ARE YOU ON???

[crouchleics]

they are so poor live because they are used to miming everywhere!

[george0506]

they can sing!!!

[Steman000]

shit shit shit shit shit shit shit

fully shit

frankie is da worst sounds like she has to really scream it lol

molly wtf?

[CataFee89]

i love this song and you have to remember this is their first live gig you know give them a little slack.. there were bits where the gave effort and then when they didnt!

Vanessa though has got one hell of a voice (pink dress)

[Xcarakom]

haha, terrible

[RachelMoo1234]

All talentless wannabes

[djpdance]

just a bunch of wannabees

[fialane13]

I LOVE THE SATURDAYSS. WOHOO! To all them people that think they are bad they are doing the right thing and they will be big. so haa x

[potterboi250]

hey now people. This is their first time singing live they might have be nervous during their performance, that's why their voice are kinda.. out of tune. But hey, they are still good in what they do. Listen to the music video. They're awsome..

[nicolaristhebest]

the one in the pink is the only good one the one in orange is average

[DaAsianWitnSoul]

at least they r not miming dis time.

[xSteviEJeebiEx]

The fallen angel girl was the worst one

[xxsammiexx91]

her in the blue is bad :S

[danyeal2]

they sound better than Girls Aloud... but this was awful...

[homophob17]

the point of being a group is actually singing 2gether and harmonizing, they can't even do that, danity kane might not be the best group vocally but at least they know how to harmonize.

[alexb2712]

this song is fuckin well hard 2 sing dowt it tht u guys dissin them could sing any better luv them luv the song

[xcoolxlooserx]

Listen guys, yeah, this wasn't that good a performance . But we all know they can sing and plus this is a seriously hard song to sing!

[vashtismith12]

i like them.

[pandrosito]

hahahaha holly crap they're really suck !

i can't believe that i like their song...

[charlotte2tone]

what the fook is this

[TevoRevo]

at least they ARE singing

[chelseajenks]

Amazing For begginers

[jeffthehighflyer]

The Saturdays are awsum ... frankie is so hot

[chelseajenks]

Yeh Rochelle is amazing

[nicolaristhebest]

omg they are so bad when i heard them at girls aloud i thought una and vanessa were great and vanessa still is but there all crap now except vanessa

[Gills22]

at least their singing live, i rather hear them live then lip sinking. it wasnt awful but they have tons of time 2 improve n the song rocks. plus we all no they can sing just gotta work on th elive part

[emzybrad]

:O :O

im sorry but this is truly awful!!

the only one that can sing out of the 5 is rochelle...and im being honest

i didnt expect them to be this bad :/

[PrincessMeg7]

Omg, they are actually singing live for once! Loose Women and GMTV was mimed, badely!

[lebyuk]

they dont sound to bad its jsut moreee singing together they need practice on coz u can tell there trying to out sing each other

[deviouswun]

I now see why they lip sync!

This is bad, just shows that you don't need to have talent to be a singer. As long as your pretty then your good to go, BUT I will say Issues live is great!!

[carltinio]

Omg So This Is Why They Lip Synced On GMTV & Loose Women xD

But no matter they'll improve,, remember rihanna wasn't good at singing live at 1st.

Good song to =]

[noangel07]

good song but poor singing

[jimrave75]

i lovr rochelle , how good.

[Resi12]

that one in the yellow one annoys me so much you can tell she thinks shes the shit get over yourself love

[charlotte2tone]

i agree.

[blankedidentity]

I saw them live at girls aloud and they much better than here, so guess they just having an off day

[samswan1990]

Wow frankie screams when she sings, stupid cow

[BriCampo]

Wow, they are absolutely awful live.

[thesaturdaysmedia]

I won't deny that it wasn't the greatest performance in the world :p But check out their performance of Issues at the Nokia Green Room - can definitely sing.

[adamjennings5]

am i the only one that thinks this performance was awesome? can someone explain to me why this is bad? im getting confused now :(

[xlilxnicolexgx]

adam their not gd singin live

[emmanuelh6198]

Issues is definitely amazing. I think this song is just in an odd key for all of them but Rochelle

[ijason2]

I think they should sing live in the verses and mimed to the chorus so they'd have more energy and breath...

[adamjennings5]

absolutely amaaaziing!!! thanks sooo much for uploading , Jay XD

[sclubunitedrocked]

gr8!