Led Zeppelin-What Is And What Should Never Be

[slick3xexx]

Nice video, ignore all of these idiots.

[buddhak0n]

I liked it... a little artsy film schoolish but kewl nonetheless.

The Music obviously drove you which with Zeppelin is awesome.

[jetskirydr]

Excellent timing on your part ... maybe a player yourself ... nicely interpreted.

Jetskirydr

[fanofthemusic1090]

Best song from their second album.

[okandah]

bro, their whole 2nd album is amazing. there isnt a best song in that album

[cartmenlovers]

best song evr!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[mikewolf123]

shouldnt this song be play with white summer........its still really good but its missing an important solo

[yoitsquintero23]

hey cdogg it doesnt matter who plays the fastest its about the melodies and riffs they come up with thats what makes them the best and that is why hendrix is the best

[mopodreamer]

Hi, how are you? Very good job!! Did you use Proshow? It's very good but of course as like everything we all do, it can be improved. Just check out Recording Star, VITTO's Video/Slide Show: My Guitar Can Sing. You'll learn some cool tricks as I did. Good luck keep up the excellent work!1

[AaronWallace]

Guys, let's not stray from the topic at hand, which is the fact that Proferic is a fucking douche who's just mad cause daddy makes him dance on his lap rofl.

[coolhandossig]

i agree to that and yeah dude ur mad good but if hendrix was still alive i guarantee you he'd be better...improvise like he did and ill be impressed and make ur own songs

[EckoSmash]

You take a dip and try to play the axe.

[nonotreals]

i personally love zeppelin and think page is awesome, but this is not opinion it is fact: The Beatles were much more influencial than led zep and they also were much better songs writers. Also i prefer clapton personally just because i think page can be pretty sloppy at times

[schwisgarth]

the beatles was more influential to bands in the seventies but led zep was more influential to bands of the eighties even still i would say one of the most influential people of all time is chuck berry that was ALL of the guitar greats favorite guitarist

[pvtjoke]

lol) I'm sixteen to) But, you know, Hendrix is goddamn alien guitar god! First song that I heard was Jimi Hendrix - Bold As Love. And you know, it is real guitar and real rock, and Vai and Satriani is only technique, it fun to see but it boringly to listen.

p.s. Sorry for my bad english, I don't know it too well (

p.p.s Led Zep rules!

[fenderbass8]

you are a genius

[vamprandom]

na Jimmy was better than Eric

cos in 87-88 ish there was a reunion concert for the Yardbirds, so Chris Dreja, Jeff Beck, Eric and Jimmy, all on stage, Jimmy went on before Eric, and after Jimmy's solo, the croud was so worn out cos Jimmy was so good Clapton refused to go on

also i think Ginger Baker came close to Bonham, ever heard any of the stuff he did with Steely Dan? amazing (im saying this a complete Bonham worshipper)

[proferic]

That didn't happen. Clapton never has refused to follow Page. Even Page has acknowledged that Clapton is better. As ted Nugent has aptly put it, "Jummy Fumble-Fingers Page."

[ClaptonsGod]

Cream was liek early Led Zeppelin but they were way more psychadelic i do think clapton is the greatest of all time but Zeppelin had the better songs, and no way baker was a better drummer than bonham, keith moon maybe but not baker, guitar wise its to close to call and bass not even close Derek and the Dominoes was better than Cream.

[ClaptonsGod]

Also everyone at that time riped music off from black blues musician or country artists even the fucking beatles you say that liek Jimmy Page never wrote played or produced his own songs Beatle were a piece of shit band 90% of there music is garbage and dated they are the 1960s equivilant of the Back Street Boys. Also when people used to have arguments over who was better the Beatles or the Monkeys i think it kills ur argument right there a poppy fag band and one who didnt play there instruments

[proferic]

You are delusional. An inmate of your own Zeppelin asylum. Clapton played on only one Beatles song, as an unpaid, uncredited guest. Have to agree with you on Ringo. Not bad, but certainly no Bonham.

[ClaptonsGod]

Yea man theres no way you can say that The Beatles were more talented musicly than Zeppelin like Zeppelin had the greatest collection of artists in 1 band.

[proferic]

No . . . that goes to Cream!! Better musicians without a doubt. Better guitar (by a mile, better bassplayer and better drummer.

[luzick]

lol... what are you creterias? You cani't be a musician and say that, sorry. You don't know what you are talking about.

[AaronWallace]

If you really believe that Eric Clapton is more talented in any way than Jimmy Page, you clearly know absolutely nothing about guitar.

[proferic]

Shhhh!! Don't tell anyone at the Berklee School of Music, where I got my degree in guitar,l don't tell any of my students, and . . for sure. . . don't tell any of the session players here in L.A. where I make my living. It'll be our secret, OK? Oh, yeah, before I forget, Clapton was and is better than Page. Even Page acknowledged this.

[AaronWallace]

Yea, sure man, whatever you say bahaha.

[queenforever]

LOL! It's okay

[ClaptonsGod]

Your gonna sit there and tell me with a straight face a Beatles album is better than Led Zeppelin, you must be smoking some bad stuff, also like my hippie english techer told me Zeppelin 1 was big but everyone and i mean everyone bought Zeppelin 2.

[proferic]

Dude!! With a straight face . . . THE BEATLES WERE BETTER!!!

[ClaptonsGod]

The Beatles are the most over glorified over played little girl teen bopper band like they wish they had 1 1000th the talent Zeppelin did.

[proferic]

Even Calpton thought the Beatles were good. Jimmy Page is the over-glorified, rip-stealing thief on the planet. Certainly not on a par with Clapton or Beck. Lennon and McCartney were better writers than Page (as was Harrison), and Mccartney blew John Paul Jones out of the water. Zeppelin was the most over glorified over played 14 year old head-banging little boy band, who had hardly 1/1000th the talent of the Beatles.

[ClaptonsGod]

Zeppelin was bigger and better than anyone, they influenced more musicans than the Beatles noone says hey guys lets make music liek the Beatles, lets go bust out some Octopuses garden or Yellow submarine they played bs rock n roll and there songs are on my sisters baby records, youd never see whole lotta love on somthin like that. Ringo star cant play drums worth shit, george harrison had to get clapton to play his songs and john paul jones can rip better than Mccartney.

[AaronWallace]

Even Clapton, like he's some kind of fucking hero. I have two words for you, Steve, Vai.

[proferic]

As a writer once put it, Clapton not only wrote the book on rock guitar playing in the 60's, he invented the language that went into the book. All Page did was steal other people's riffs. My dog can play better than Page.

[AaronWallace]

And Fuck that writer. If Clapton is a guitar god, then why are all his riffs so goddamn simple?

I'll admit "Tears In Heaven" is quite a masterpiece, but it does not promote him to guitar god status.

Steve Vai, Yngwie Malmsteen, Paul Gilbert, Satriani, Petrucci, Page, IommI, Laiho, Trower. All guitar gods, Clapton? Brush him off your shoulder.

[proferic]

What are you fucking 12?? You obviously have no historical perspective of Clapton's influence on popular music. Judging from the names you've listed, you've obviously confused speed with technique. They are mutually exclusive (I know those are big words for you, perhaps next time I'll keep it simple for you and use single syllable words). You've got no real grasp on guitar. In fact, it sounds like the only think you've got a grasp on is your dick.

[AaronWallace]

I'm sixteen, and I admit he DID have quite an influence on some music, but so did Hendrix, and Hendrix sucks too. Take away Clapton's over-rated status, and just look at him for raw talent, he ain't shit.

I don't know why you're giving me all this shit about big words you're the motherfucker who can't count to three, or use contractions correctly.

I cannot believe you can sit there and tell me that Steve Vai, Joe Satriani or Malmsteen are lacking in technique.

[proferic]

Oh, 16!! *lol* Excuse me!! You don't know shit. Your'e a fucking little kid. I thought I was dealing with someone who knew what they were talking about. Even Vai, Malmsteen and Satriani have respect for Clapton. But, your'e too stupid to understand that.

[AaronWallace]

Say what you want about what you think I "Know" but I guarantee I'm a better guitar player than you, degree or no, it really doesn't make a difference. Yet of course, you'll be able to play some 'REAL' cool Clapton-style hammer-ons, so you must be better. I won't respect any of your opinions until you can out-shred or out-write me. Fuck your degree.

I know alot more than you credit me for, ask me a music theory question.

[cdogg710]

Out of Satch, Malmsteen, and Vai, Vai plays has the most technique and your saying that Claptons riffs are easy while Pages are pretty simple also but they're awesome and besides Malmsteen is a robot who just sweep picks and goes at like 14 notes per second

[coolhandossig]

woah woah woah woah you never EVER bash hendrix. you cant play half as good as him you little shit he did stuff with his guitar you only have wet dreams about doing with urs..that is if you even play.

[AaronWallace]

Check my vids, I can fucking rape Hendrix. Sry.

[schwisgarth]

i dont hear anything special about your guitar playing hendrix came out in the sixties and there isnt a hole lot of people who can reproduce his sound or style, when you can bring something new to the table please let me know til then shut up and realize hendrix was the shit

[proferic]

And I have two words for you: Your'e a Moron.

[AaronWallace]

Lmao, that's three words you stupid fuck.

[coolhandossig]

woah woah woah did you really just compare McCartney to JPJ? Have you ever listened to the Lemon song or WIAWSNB seriously? His bass is phenomenal. And Page invented most of his own riffs u dumb shit people stole off of him.

[proferic]

Well, take "Dazed and Confused". Page blatantly just stole that entire song. It was creditied to him on either the first or second album, and he never wrote it.

As far as McCartney re JPJ, historians of the rock era commonly refer to James Jamerson, Jack Bruce, McCartney, and Jaco Pastorius as the four most influential bassists. JPJ was certainly top 25, but he was never in the upper echelon of players.

[MY599FERRARI]

Jaco.........for sure, the guy was incredible .

[coolhandossig]

...who did he steal that entire song from?

[proferic]

He stole it from a British folksinger by the name of Jake Holmes, from the album, The Underground Sound of Jake Holmes. He lifted the entire song off the album and took it as his own.

[coolhandossig]

so every single note that he played, every effect and every noise is exactly like that original song?

[zeppelin511]

where are you getting your ideas. page didnt steal the WHOLE song you dillweed. he took the very first baseline part. and he baught it. did not steal it. learn your facts.

[proferic]

I know my facts. He lifted the songs. And got sued for it and lost.Oh yeah, it's spelled "bought". Learn to spell, dope.

[ledzep147]

The fact that you dont even know whether dazed and confused was on the first or second album shows you dont know what the fuck you're on about. Now piss off!

[proferic]

Whether it's on the first or second album or even the last isn't the issue, moron. It's the fact that Pagey stole it!! You need to take a logic class if and when they ever let you into college.

[schwisgarth]

i agree jpj was (is) the shit bad ass bassist like the les claypool of the seventies and he could play the piano really good as well

[coolhandossig]

yeah dude my dad told me if you didnt have zeppelin 2 there was something seriously wrong with you

[cetlahi]

I don't care what anyone says... the vid is great! Thanks.

[coolerjohn]

I think it is a good video... It is the editors feelings towards the song... Who's to say whether this editor portrayed the song correctly or not? People who are dogging on this editor's style are irritating, stupid, and wrong. You others are not Led Zeppelin, nor did you write the song, so stop acting like you know how things are supposed to be done.

[coolhandossig]

the problem is that this is not feelings. This is just a literal interpretation. The only part he got close to right was during the beginning of the solo. There were no words, just what is nice to think about at the time. that is how u should interpret the wholse song, not by the words.

[Bajocholo]

r u a fuckin freak/im a37 yr old mother and this is full of emotion/mostly brings back memories /u need more feelings than this go to the bathroom and jiggle your shit around

[coolhandossig]

ur an old hag and i hope i never meet you in real life, you sound dirty and ugly and hick like

[Bajocholo]

1st of all who the fuck are you to come at me talkin shit like your'e somebody? shut ya lil mouth when grown people is talkin. you sound like your'e still livin in your mom's basement jackin off to porn like a sad little wanker.

[coolhandossig]

hahah you are an illiterate hick! "shut ya lil mouth when grown people IS talkin." hahah learn english first you dumb twatwaffle. I am talking shit because...well...i am somebody, i dont live in a trailor like you probably do.

[Bajocholo]

seriously what kind of comeback is twatwaffle

coem back with shti even worth a comeback from me u lil bitch

[coolhandossig]

i also called you an illiterate hick and that you are nobody compared to me. maybe if you could read past the 2nd grade level then you would be able to comeback to that too. And rhymezee ur calling me a loser? ur a fucking retard. do you go to one of those special schools where they give you your own drool buckets?

[Bajocholo]

if any1 is a fuckin hick it's ur pethetic ass

you wanna compare urself to me? hahaha i actually laughed when u thought u were better than me

[coolhandossig]

yes definitely im from new jersey that qualifies me for hick status...you fuckin retard. and i am better than you...alot better.

[Bajocholo]

ok keep thinkin that if it helps you sleep at night

[rhymezee2k6]

''Forever E-Thuggin on the quest to get G's, Runnin from enemy'z..''

[rhymezee2k6]

lol this guy is a LOSER

You hear me 'coolhandossig'?

L-O-S-E-R

LOL

[embitteredshurpa]

this vid production is what is and should never have have been.. please never make another one

[buntaeve]

great i loved it

[ClaptonsGod]

Crappy video and yes Zeppelin 2 is the greatest album ever pivitol and so influential and back to front eveyr song is a hit.

[rockonskater]

idk, id have to say the greatest album ever would be abbey road, and the best zeppelin album being houses of the holy

[coolhandossig]

this is an attempt at murder to this song. Had it been a lesser song, it would have died from such a brutal attack. Your not supposed to take it literally. You can't just have pictures explain it either.  No video can explain this song. It's just soul and feeling that you need to feel to get a good vibe from.

[Carouselambra]

Right on... freakin stupid pictures for every line - goes against everyting Zeppelin stands for.

[bbigtn]

Overall I liked the vid but I needed the song.

[daconor91]

personally i think led zeppelin II is the best album ever made

[friendstacy]

you missed the whole point of the song...

[salad911]

whats the point of the song?

[hunnybunnygem]

this is bad. you just did a literal translation of the song, word for word.

[salad911]

yep sure did

[rockismymusic]

right on man...or girl....whichever right on!

[salad911]

i be a man

[shunammite]

You're a GENIUS - the pictures show how much you understand and appreciate the song!!! THANK YOU!!!

[salad911]

I'm not a genius well maybe yeah lol :) and yeah i like this song a lot and your welcome

[salad911]

Thanks

[TheBernardo92]

Great pictures.