Carnival of rust acoustic cover

[RabbitWolfpack1]

I think the person starts singing on wrong notes. and he continues the mistake in the song. but yeah guitar is awesme.

[PlainWhiteGuitar]

I thought it was great :) good job!

[Miluiindil]

The guitar boy plays good !

[Markie4400]

well... i liked them! :)

[superlols96]

Dude, what did that guitar ever do to you? Try to relax a bit when you play, and don't strum so hard, cause seriously, you're gonna break a string… by which I mean all if them…

[PlainWhiteGuitar]

@superlols96 I know right?

[TopoPark1990]

Try to breathe more, put more emotion, you do not have to strain your voice ... This way was really out of tune with the guitar, this is my opinions, do not speak in a derogatory manner ... Success!

[Edvainas]

@TopoPark1990 Thanks ;)

[kenpachi1114]

Sounds good but I.kinda feel bad for that guitar 0.o

[BigJasonOne]

and I have exactly the same guitar as this guy... plz be more gentle to it... u are about to destroy it like that! Anyway, after all, the whole thing sucks. I'm sorry

[BigJasonOne]

dude ur voice ruins the guitar melody,...

[muleylax]

too good guitarist

[vicfrohmann]

What the freaking hell was that? Guy on the right, don't blame this beautiful song with this agressive playstyle and don't use the pick, try with your fingers:D Guy on the right...:Well, Is that from a Romeo and Juliette scene?

[Edvainas]

@vicfrohmann You mean the words do not connect with the emotions I portray?

[witchbury]

omg guys! You are absotutely awesome! You're damn good! Guys! I loved your cover!

[trueTruemanMan]

This guy is a tenor, his voice is not that bad, it's just not for songs like this. Marko Saaresto's baritone is much lower, so it sounds better when he hits those low notes.

[llstarlight]

than you u guys are good- u get it right

[ImtheIZ16]

wow awfull singing, dude a tip, im a singer and i just sing songs that are in my tune, im nor saying that you cannot sing, but for real this song it's not for you, and also there is singing schools, because that's a discipline, don't be a piece of crap, thats a extremely good song and you fucked it, really

[RabFr]

Massive LMAO @ 0:52-1:14 freakin hilarious!

[qdude101]

3:03 hes going too fast, the guitar. so the singer has to go faster and it screws up the song

[atreyurockmysocks]

LOL. love it when the cameraman laughs.

[taha258]

poets of the fall wouldn't be proud

[rijurules]

u raped d guitar....m callin d police.. :P

[TopoPark1990]

Very Very very very very very very bad vocal OMG !@!@!

[Edvainas]

@TopoPark1990 After almost 4 years of making this, I wonder what's the constructive critique you can put forward? I would like to get better :)

[MySandrooliveira]

Good guitar. Poor voice.

[rickkkist]

guys you ruined the sweetness of the song...but still its not so fucking bad so keep rocking...

[TheRockClassicfan]

dude the f***ing chords!!!!!!! omfg could you send me the chorus chords plzzzzzz their kicking my butt XD

[k0ctantic]

the guitarist isnt helping the singer at all .... he plays kinda fast at the refrain

[ShaunAndFriends]

Solid performance there, i really enjoyed it :)

[Chii1991]

He's good :D

[AndreaTuccilloBuonoc]

che bello

[elloumon]

TUTORIAL!!! I WANT TUTORIAL!!!!

[CleansWithRag]

Not bad. Not great, but not bad.

A for effort.

[saadsohal]

Good job man. :D

[ie666death]

At first I thought it sucked - didn't sound like the original, but man.... You guys are awesome, just love how you put passion in it, both of you. And for the haters the vocalist didn't have any equipment, so STFU.

Rock on!

[NOXLT]

that was indeed a nice cover

[MissJandi2012]

Dang, nice guitar. He looked like he was really into it at the end. (middle/endish area). Lol, the singer wasn't that bad, but I'm not too fond of the interpretation.

[devpunk93]

I liked the cover. Really nice.

[mannyindaclub]

wow... 2 thumbs up for performing with PASSION!!!

[LaNoireSakura]

Interesting interpretation but... I really dislike this version. I think it's a good thing using the own style if you cover a song.

Music's beauty is expressed by the emotions of the musicians; music is such a fragile thing and in this case you were way too harsh, guys. :/

[Zocsma]

The guitarist guy's actually going crazy in the end : D Anyway great cover guys! :)

[BLAGOVESTAPISCOPO]

he has some problems with trembling of his voice on the higher notes- maybe he's stressed or shy but otherwise he has a lot of potential!

[22YearOldBoy]

You got to give this singer credit. He does have confidence and that ain't so easy to acquire. And you can tell he tried.

[fnatic101]

good lord that poor guitar!!

[iasond]

Very good keep up ! gr8 guitar playin and gr8 voice !

[tukun3104]

very bad i say (the vocals)

[rkellynsm]

my god , stop sing plzzzzzz!!!!!! wat a terrifiant voice --"

[jsjazz3d]

dude is about to break the guitar to hell :D emotional...

[TeRrahiel]

Of course I like POTF's version more but I wouldn't dare to say this is a bad cover. It's different because the singing guy has completely different voice. I must say I like it, anyway:P

[xxAngelxxBabexx]

the singer is actually real good, :)

[Mathemoto]

This guitarplayer is crazy.

[RabFr]

What's up with the crappy fagotty vocals?? Thanks for destroying the song, not.

[Beriol9]

Great, I don't get the complaints about the singer, I think he's really good o.O

[kaarykaary]

please please please tabs for this lovely song!!!!!11

u guys ROCK please give me tabs of this addicting song please@@@@@@@

[kaarykaary]

please please please tabs for this lovely song!!!!!11

u guys ROCK please give me tabs of this addicting song please@@@@@@@

[kaarykaary]

please please please tell me the tab and the chords u guys rock!!!!!!!!!!!

please i love this song and im addicted please tell me the tabs....

<3 love u

[AngeliRoom]

Na, vien už pastangas jau galima pagirti. Nėra tai pati lengviausiai atliekama daina..

[Skeletor7377]

the guitarist needs to chill out a little bit but otherwise very good

[Zieglers666]

well done, guys! very very good! Everyone in my college class listens to techno and hip hop, so I envy these people who listened to this live! Fortunately I'm a musician myself, so I'm teaching them about good music.. haha. Well.. GREAT guitar playing and also a great voice + singing!

[launo97]

singer is good too

[AlexWeno]

well.. I like it.

[6BallerMANN]

thats so bad.the guitar player ist good^^

[LordKoC]

Acoustic is good yeah but the vocal needs to listen to himself sing

[metalanarchist666]

good guitar playing,but the song is played with a capo on the first fret!

the singer has a good base so he can build his voice!!

Good job!

[patcoolboy]

its not bad singers a bit out of tone and guitarist is a bit mental on the guitar other than that its good

[1IlIlIlIlIl1]

Guitarist is a bit iffy and the singer gets a few words wrong. not bad though.

[xfaejaz]

5 star for guitar..

[fishboyandqiqi]

the guitarist is fuking amazing!

[nedelchohristov]

I'm voting 5 stars ONLY for guitar player. He's good. Damn good :)

[RabFr]

What a horrible cover.

[honeyhere0]

good sung, but the giutarist was about to have'en torn the cords...

however, good sung and good played

[Darkmage1293]

WHAT ARE THOSE GODDAMN CHORDS ARGH

[chiffmonkey]

@Darkmage1293 Yeah the chorus chords still elude me :/

[Matthew1BigGuy]

@Darkmage1293

When I play it on piano, I use a:

F, Ab, B, Db, Eb pattern.

For the Chorus;

F, Eb, Db, Ab, Eb, F.

I might put up a tutorial for how to play it on the piano, and you can simply transpose it.

[Booyakaraoke]

The singer is so gay. And his voice sucks big time.

[dojodoss]

your mums gay.. you fuckin faggot, appretiate...

[xXSythenXx]

But does he sing better than you? ^^

[sitzkissen23]

You read from paper you noob ;)

[Cyrious101]

haha ,i was there :D

[Killcupidsaaki17]

the vocalist needs to sing with more support, but i totally understand, my voice does the same thing when I get nervous and I'm a pretty solid singer.

[honeyhere0]

The giutarist's effort and skills are admirable.............

[honeyhere0]

this dude is good ................... xD

[xuby2274]

well needs 2 work more 4 a year i thnk....no sync....vocalist is singing junk.....well nice try

[balloonster123]

Sugrojo tai lb gerai..man patiko..balsas ir geras bet norejos stipresnio..vis vien saunuoliai..^-^

[xxxtheoryxxx]

Oh my dear god, you hit this cool guitar... no comment, learn abouit it LOW....and te vocal,,,, this is not a POTF song on this video.....

[acjmak]

Awesome guitar. Vocal kinda sucked but not all the way.

[justchill2010]

awesome guitar dude...but the singing part i feel is awful except for the fact that the voice is awesome...but where is the tune dude in the singing???

[HeroXofXTime21]

ur gunna break more that the strings...ur gunna snap that guitar in half!!!!!, its a mellow song man so keep it that way.....oh nd for the singing, to hit the high notes u gotta belt that shit from the stomach also doin vibratos every now nd then really didnt make it sound good sry...just a tip

[Steampunkseb]

you nailed the 'dont walk away bit'.

Well done :D

[airhike]

voice is like a 7 out of 10 for the song , and the guitar is right on but dont over play it lol it sounded great though i love the cover

[sameep8]

great work guys :D

[InsertDavve]

Easy on that guitar, nah, Keep rockin'. Nice playing and cool voice.

[misstressbyron]

great cover!

[orehm0dnar]

horrible vocals

[Alfonz01]

NICE! Keep going!

[nickblack1990]

very good guitaring, power play in kinda nice...though, u dont wanna break the strings while on the stage or something :) but hey, thats ur style man, voice is also good....powerful, strong...

[tranglynx]

waw... cool voice.

& guitarist's good :D

[fnatic101]

lol i love the guitarist

[0Shadowdragon]

The cover is amazing. =3

Personally, the voice doesn't fit POTF...

[TheGirl19]

this is growing on me alot but everytime I watch it I'm just waiting for one of those guitar strings to break and flick him in the eye lol

[STAR6INATA]

Damn dudes that is the best cover I`ve ever seen no realy I like it expecialy the guitar dude I just like the way he clows the strings !!!NICE!!! keep on rocking | btw the song is great \\m//

[musicismyfavorite777]

hey guys this is a great cover and the voice doesn't sound bad IMO, alot better than mine lol, keep it up !

rock on POTF rules!

[Edvainas]

Thank you!

[huzargarden]

very very good lads :D guitar guy just killing me hehe I like his style of play ;)

[BurningNocturnes]

Good job. The guitar was slightly sketchy, but emotional, and the voice ruled. Worlds better than PotF's actual acoustic version, which was just dull. Good job.

[ctti]

The guitar is good...although the vocals sound a little too whiny for the song (not that they're lousy, just not very suitable for the song), although it could be due to the poor sound quality. Overall, not bad.

[Gyrki]

this is really wonderful.

thank you!

[superpikappa]

Excellent. I like this like the original ^.^

[Steampunkseb]

That was really good, its a hard song to do but i think you both did it justice.

[abhifloyd85]

hey nice work dudes....

keep it up!!!

[Thyevilhat]

Rust in peace.

[Thyevilhat]

It's incredible what you can acomplish with a simple acoustic guitar. What's even more incredible is how you can butcher a beautiful song with an acoustic guitar. Oh,and with a voice. Not just ANY voice...THAT voice.

BLACK METAL IST KRIEG!!!!! and so is your cover.

Nicely played,btw.Yup,i was being sarcastic.

[BurningIce89]

OMG! man...you're going to "kill" that guitar...take it easy..

the the vocals erm...dude..whatever your name is..u gave me a trauma with this song. U do have a good voice, but u didn't sing this well.

That song i supposed to be a bit more calm...

people..do not try this at home :|

[tbenkert]

Sorry, don't like the vocals and miss the guitarists feeling in the strumming parts...

[utsavdang1]

hey guitarisr enthusiasm and excitement is natural to a music lover.....amazing .....rock on n b wat u are.....

[Ron451991]

Woah, guitarist dude!!!

Calm down!!!!!

why in heavens are you banging your guitar as though its personally offended you???

[MoteseS]

You can also watch my cover of CoR. I'd like to know your opinion too. :)

[Edvainas]

Thanks man (Y)

[MoteseS]

I think you could do it much better if you knew the lyrics for 100% (You sometimes read them, right? :()

The construction of the song is different...

And the guitar-man. I have impression, that he hates his guitar. Yes, in common notes that he plays are right, but... how to say... when I saw him playing for the first time i thought "WTF?"... I think you understand: overemoting. it makes the song cruel in some way...

so, that is my opinion.

[snow6smoke]

What did the guitar do to deserve such treatment?

This is not death metal!

[Nitrous2k]

oy yeah, calm down a little bit...

good playing tho

[yoyomonkey1]

the guitar is played right as far as the notes go but no offence you kinda play it to ...loud and powerful its a soft and calm song..same goes for the singer

[DreamerM]

To all the posters about the singer: no he can't sing LIKE MARKO CAN. There's no one out there except Marko who can sing like Marko can.

So naturally, this guy sounds different. Different is not nessessarily bad: he doesn't have the powerful pipes Marko does but he can bring the ANGST with plenty of raw, rock-star intensity.

Rock is what you make it. It lives or dies by it's attitude. And these guys have got attitude.

[izka19081989]

@DreamerM

I totally agree with U.  No one can't sing like Marko, so people shouldn't grade this guy in such category... I think that he isn't bad at all

[Eyeseen]

Great job..loved it keep going guys..

[mrudul13]

the guitarist is over reactin...d song is soft and calm...not meant 4 hittin d strings so hard...

[Edvainas]

Emo!!!

[remarkdPOTF]

That don't gives him the permission to sing like crap a song, who we all know is a great song...

Sorry... but, i don't care from where are you're from, god damed... if you can't sing - DON'T... you are just ruining the song!!!

[AnticitizenThree]

Well if he couldn't sing then this youtube rating wouldn't be 4 stars :D plius who heard it live says It's pretty damn good so... You should be more polite your'e post should start like IN MY OPINION IT SUCKS :D (couse your opinion is yours only so If you really want someone to care about it stop being a jerk) unless you'r a total redneck then you can keep on writing your I WILL KILL you bullcrap :P

[Rawfall]

@AnticitizenThree he is in fact correct. he can't sing. maybe the majority of people actually think this is good but then again most people just listen to music. they don't create play or sing music. Sorry dude but he just can't sing...

[CleansWithRag]

@remarkdPOTF

First off, your grammar sucks. If you can't use the English language properly, DON'T! I suggest you go back to school and pay attention for once.

Second, he's not *that* bad! He's not great, but not bad. I suppose *you* could do better?

[Edvainas]

The guy lives in latvia. We are fucking neighbours...

[remarkdPOTF]

Okey... i admit... the guitar guy is good, BUT... THE stupid mother fu****cker who can't sing for sh***it cud just shut the fu***ck up...!!!! Oh... when i meet that guy with glasses - i will kill him!!! Such an a**ss hole!!!

[masstrooper72]

what a joke!!! fucking embarrassment!

[snarkthepirate]

I rather like this cover :)

[Edvainas]

C'mon guys, we're not stoping covering this song, so if you want it to sound better, please, share some advices!

[aushryte17]

Hey a lil more practise with guitar and it will be perfect. ;) but the vocal..crap =|

[katwarrior]

easy on the guitar, boy! you need to practice a lot more!

and get a new vocal!

[666hela]

Ed's, you are cool guys!!!

Best wishes from my sister Liberty:*

[TheGirl19]

omg that was shite

[POTFFREAK4LIFE]

OMG!stop it you guys totally embarrased the name of "Poets Of The Fall" omg you guys suck omg me and my friend are way better but im a big fan of POTF and you guys need some serious talent!!

[Edvainas]

heheh, I realy care about singin' and please, if you have some advices, share 'em with me. I will be more than thankfull. DA vocalist ^^

[omgitsjordin]

hahaha the dude cant sing!!! the guitar kicked sum seriouse ass but haha

[sunnyryann]

Fucking vocal u killed the song the guitaring woz more over gud... man go and learn sm vocal first

[SlowStarted]

Good job! But the singing is not especially good.. just my opinion.

[AnticitizenThree]

post what ?? :D

[bilal12e]

whoz playin ..u ?

[AnticitizenThree]

yeah.. and I have the chords and arpegio parts.. If thats what you want....

[bilal12e]

holy ...shitt

yar plz plz plz post the pattren

my id is nevermore_k@live... i,ve got the chords all i need the patttren

[marek2008rm]

Good guitar! it's no many guitar player who make play this song completed.Best wishes!

[troniac]

Great Idea, I like it well done guys! I'd my hair cut about six months ago. *rofl* I've lost 50 centemeters of hairs.

best wishes to all outa there!

[mathvb]

Two words: 1. Haircut! 2. Awsome

[cleopatra7g]

Nice guitaring:)& vocals to0o!!

[MisterTownsend]

pretty good you did your thing.

[EdsFatFred]

I like this band of yours!I'm your number one fan for sure!!!Goooooooooo Ed's!!!YEAH!!!P.S. If the drummer and bassist were here this would totaly have rocked much more yarrr!

[Kuborion]

Yeah, pretty good!

Not as good as original, but hell - no one is! :D

[Edvainas]

You kick ass!!!