@lamusicahera I agree love Jessye she great. This is strange i first this song in a HAL ROACH STUDIOS production of The Bohemian Girl with believe or not with Laurel and Hardy. Also Fra Diablo. they were comedies but they educated to quality music. ROGHARM
Bartolli is a poor secretary girl?? Maybe you should check her out singing Una Voce Poco Fa on the web. Okay, she makes silly faces, but it's in character. And her voice is among the greatest. Superhartline
@lamusicahera Ah, yes, bring back the "good old days!" Why is it that so many older people look back with rose-colored glasses upon everything from their youth? Norman is indeed a fine singer, but some of those you so casually put down are also quite good. I'm not exactly young myself, but I try to remember that much of what makes events from our youth seem so great was due to the mere fact that we were young then.
Why carp about who's better, Jessye Norman or Joan Sutherland? They're both wonderful. The version in the movie of the Bohemian Girl is vanilla compared to them...
the l & H movie was the bohemanian girl based on balfe seen in 1952 on wcbs-tv as a cutup 15 minute movie. they made swiss miss, fra diablo and babes in toyland. all with classical music and classic singers. but they made a comedy of them. wcbs-tv nyc had to fill in 15 minutes at9:45 am and wcbs-tv just showed any part of the of any l & h movie with no titles. in 1959, one nyc tv station showed them all from beginning to end with titles. anymore questions Ask! ROGHARM
@ruffomaldito AGREE 10,000% ROGHARM i first heard this song at age 7 in 1952 in a laurel and hardy movie. that is how i learned fine music walter woolf and dennis king in the l & h movies. just like alfalfa carl switzer introduced me to bing crosby in the early 1930's. Great performance!!!!!!!!!*****
@rogharm I ´ve always been a l & h fan myself. I think they´re the greatest ever.....so funny that I hardly ever paid attention to accompanying music. So I suspect this song was played (or sung) in a very different style and tempo. Do you happen to remember what movie it was? I´d been fascinated to view it again, to listen to the music. Thanks for your response.
@ruffomaldito the l&h movie was THE BOHEMIAN GIL i am age 65 now 2010 and never forgot it> rosina timpani sang it. they made a comedy of it but they went to jail for kidnapping her, but the gypies stole her if i remember correctly. HAL ROACH STUDIOS introduced to culture and crosby-alfalfa. ms. norman deserves the great applause. fabouls perform. ROGHARM
@rogharm Yeah, yeah, of course I remember the movie. One of my favorites. Old Stan got drunk when filling the bottles.....one of the greatest scenes ever. Thanks for the memories.
I once watched a film about the explorers burke and wills attempting to cross the australian Gibson dessert. This was sung on the soundtrack, does anyone know who the singer was?, I've not seen the film since so can't find out.
Unlike Joan S.. Ms.Norman can be understood.. Her vowels are much better, and as it is an english text.. wow.. we as english speaking people really need to understand the words. My hats off to her.
I saw Jesse Normans performance on television and it sent cold shivers up my spine- itstill does. Since then I have tried to obtain a recording of it, without success. imagine my delight when I saw the link on utube. Thank you for giving me that thrill again - whata wonderful voice!
My vocal instructor told me to look her up, since I'm a soprano and, like Ms. Norman, I don't have that tiny tinkling soprano voice, either. (As my teacher would say, my voice will never be a tiny bird fart of a sound.) =) I've never heard her before tonight, and I'm in awe. She's beautiful and her voice is divine. If I only end up with half that talent, I will be content. She's amazing.
Stunning! Her top notes are divine - ALL of it is divine. And for those of you used to wee 'popera' voices who can't be heard without a microphone - this aria is from the OPERA The Behemian Girl.
Song and artist mismatched, as it is to the voice of Sutherland. It takes a smaller voice and a less mannered delivery. If you can find it, listen to Elizabeth Wheeler on black Victor; or, Olive Kline in a brief snippet on the acoustic Bohemian Girl Gems on Victor 35603.
A tremendous voice -- a bit much - too full and rich - for this rather light song, but I'd love to hear her do Wagner. And I'll bet she sing a sexy and very lusty Carmen.
Renowned British conductor Sir Edward Thomas Downes, CBE, has died at the age of 85, after travelling to the assisted suicide clinic Dignitas with his wife.
He and his 74-year-old wife Joan, who was terminally ill, chose to end their lives at the Swiss clinic, their family said in a statement.
According to the statement, the couple "died peacefully, and under circumstances of their own choosing".
wow i though sumi jo was the best but after hearing norman...boy, was i wrong!lol sumi jo is still a wonderful singer, but i like the richness in norman's voice.
@niallsullivan1948 Jessye Norman is an amazing soprano, and her version of this aria is one of the best for sure.
But Dame Joan Sutherland's version (that you criticised) has got much more subtle coloratura, and as you may know, Joan's efforts on the coloratura sometimes makes her diction less good.
But the fact that they have different styles, doesn't make Joan Sutherland worse than Jessye Norman. Actually, both are "top" performers.
@musicredshoes I agree. Perhaps Jessye´s style is a bit more expressive, while Joan is a bit more technically perfect. On this particular vid, Jessye´s gestures more than fill her role as an actress-singer. It´s like watching "A thousand and one nights."
Superb aria from a truly great singer a lovely melody by Irishman William Balfe a long forgotten composer who is now sadly overlooked so this aria is his legacy. Thank you for posting.
A most beautiful rendition of a haunting aria. I wish Norman had been a more "conventional" singer when she chose her repertoire (aka bread and butter) but who am I to argue with her?
Did you know it is William Balfe's bicentenary this year. Should be able to see The Bohemian Girl somewhere. He is my uncle a few generations back!! :~)
It is just a completely different Bohemian girl from the one interpreted by Joan. Maybe her mother was actually a US lady or she studied a couple of years in NYC...
Anyway, it is called arts...we don't need precision here.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
It might be hard to believe, but this piece has been sung by ...Enya (it has been recorder for one of her albums).
I just adore Jessye Norman, but it is so ridiculous to hear her rendition and voice - obviously TOO powerful, too fervent for this lullaby-like waltz :) Maybe it's just the influence of the somnambulistic version by Enya? ;)
This is an operatic aria; it was written before microphones were invented, and requires a powerful delivery in order to fill the performance space. To compare this performance to one by Enya is to compare apples and oranges.
You said it: take the technology away from Enya and there's very, very little left to carry over three rows of seats in an audience. Take technology away from Norman and still end up with overwhelming music.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Score: SubtlyRough, 1; ejtka, 0.
Watch the Sutherland, it's on youtube, and is a much more endearing and touching (albeit somewhat overly-ornamented) rendition than either this or the Enya. "A powerful delivery" requires nothing more than the proper projection of the tone, which can easily be achieved by a well-trained singer at forte, or piano. It is the latter for which this, yes, lullaby-like waltz calls.
oh my gosh. i've never seen this before. thank you so much for put on this...i can't believe...its so beautyful. brava jessye. again, again and again...
I remember in 1996/7 a colleague showed me this on video. It was from a Royal Variety Society Performance. They thought it tacky but I loved it. He facial expressions, the diction the voice all wonderful. This is not available to buy which is a shame.
This is a really beautiful performance of an excerpt from a vastly underrated opera. The choruses in this work are magnificent. For a really different kind of rendering of this gem, check on YouTube for Ruby Helder, "the girl tenor"! Thanks for this video.
Oops...I wanted to say "a really different kind of rendering of ANOTHER gem from Bohemian Girl." (Another senior moment!) In the way of an afterthought, one wonders how many recall the 1930's Laurel & Hardy movie based on this Balfe opera. That film contained some fine and serious singing.
Thank you for posting this. Over the years, whenever Jessie Norman's name has come up in conversation I have asked if anyone else remembers her performance of this aria. It was at a Royal Gala in Covent garden about 12 years ago. Sadly, it doesn't seem appear on any of her recordings. If anyone has actually found it, please post the details. Superb!
THIS IS ABSOLUTELY ONE OF THE GREATEST PERFORMANCE I HAVE EVER SEEN. Miss Norman you have acheived even greater respect and adoration from me. BRAVA BRAVA BRAVA
A very fine piece with a gripping melody - til now I thought Enya (who sung this spendidly) did compose this, too.....
TheAkelei 3 weeks ago
I had the great good fortune in the 80s to attend one of her recitals.Her voice and precision are incomparable.
Jan96106 4 weeks ago
The voice of an angel....my favorite song--never heard it more tender and sweet. Carolyn in San Antonio, TX
mellorslover 2 months ago
@lamusicahera I agree love Jessye she great. This is strange i first this song in a HAL ROACH STUDIOS production of The Bohemian Girl with believe or not with Laurel and Hardy. Also Fra Diablo. they were comedies but they educated to quality music. ROGHARM
rogharm 2 months ago
Bartolli is a poor secretary girl?? Maybe you should check her out singing Una Voce Poco Fa on the web. Okay, she makes silly faces, but it's in character. And her voice is among the greatest. Superhartline
SuperHartline 2 months ago
Wonderful! Amazing voice and the dress is sweet!
AleksandraPlamenac 4 months ago
Magnificent
Dhbrydon 9 months ago
@lamusicahera Ah, yes, bring back the "good old days!" Why is it that so many older people look back with rose-colored glasses upon everything from their youth? Norman is indeed a fine singer, but some of those you so casually put down are also quite good. I'm not exactly young myself, but I try to remember that much of what makes events from our youth seem so great was due to the mere fact that we were young then.
davehshs 1 year ago
Why carp about who's better, Jessye Norman or Joan Sutherland? They're both wonderful. The version in the movie of the Bohemian Girl is vanilla compared to them...
alshouse 1 year ago
BRAVO !!!
lababoc 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Exquisite . Those top notes. Ah, Mr Balfe!.
lightcrazed 1 year ago
Exquisite . Those top notes. Ah, Mr Balfe!.
lightcrazed 1 year ago
Lovely!
solsticecelt1 1 year ago
good diction and an incredibly powerful voice. she never moved me though for some reason.
ShawDAMAN 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Her singing brilliant ,as always. Her dresser zero,makes her look like a pigeon
lewis1936 1 year ago
Her singing brilliant ,as alwayys. Her dresser zero,makes her look like a pigeon
lewis1936 1 year ago
WOW ... what a great artist can make of a simple song!!! Brava la Diva
AustrianAdrian 1 year ago
Fantastic diction!!
osbornd89 1 year ago
the l & H movie was the bohemanian girl based on balfe seen in 1952 on wcbs-tv as a cutup 15 minute movie. they made swiss miss, fra diablo and babes in toyland. all with classical music and classic singers. but they made a comedy of them. wcbs-tv nyc had to fill in 15 minutes at9:45 am and wcbs-tv just showed any part of the of any l & h movie with no titles. in 1959, one nyc tv station showed them all from beginning to end with titles. anymore questions Ask! ROGHARM
rogharm 1 year ago
she is amazing singing this can someone tell me how to get a copy of this as i have checked her albums and carnt find it .please help BH
iwillliftupmyeyes 1 year ago
Stunning. By far the best version up here
TheGman1004 1 year ago
After replaying it 5 times in my laptop, my only question is: "How can a mortal sing like this?".............Thanks for such a treat!
ruffomaldito 1 year ago
@ruffomaldito AGREE 10,000% ROGHARM i first heard this song at age 7 in 1952 in a laurel and hardy movie. that is how i learned fine music walter woolf and dennis king in the l & h movies. just like alfalfa carl switzer introduced me to bing crosby in the early 1930's. Great performance!!!!!!!!!*****
rogharm 1 year ago
@rogharm I ´ve always been a l & h fan myself. I think they´re the greatest ever.....so funny that I hardly ever paid attention to accompanying music. So I suspect this song was played (or sung) in a very different style and tempo. Do you happen to remember what movie it was? I´d been fascinated to view it again, to listen to the music. Thanks for your response.
ruffomaldito 1 year ago
@ruffomaldito the l&h movie was THE BOHEMIAN GIL i am age 65 now 2010 and never forgot it> rosina timpani sang it. they made a comedy of it but they went to jail for kidnapping her, but the gypies stole her if i remember correctly. HAL ROACH STUDIOS introduced to culture and crosby-alfalfa. ms. norman deserves the great applause. fabouls perform. ROGHARM
rogharm 1 year ago
@rogharm Yeah, yeah, of course I remember the movie. One of my favorites. Old Stan got drunk when filling the bottles.....one of the greatest scenes ever. Thanks for the memories.
ruffomaldito 1 year ago
I once watched a film about the explorers burke and wills attempting to cross the australian Gibson dessert. This was sung on the soundtrack, does anyone know who the singer was?, I've not seen the film since so can't find out.
solsticecelt1 1 year ago
Unlike Joan S.. Ms.Norman can be understood.. Her vowels are much better, and as it is an english text.. wow.. we as english speaking people really need to understand the words. My hats off to her.
kgarmaker123 1 year ago
@kgarmaker123 Jesse is a mezzo, singing in a mezzo range. Joan is a lyric soprano, singing in a much higher range.
stingabe 1 year ago
@stingabe REally? Is that Joan S.. excuse? Pardon moi...
kgarmaker123 1 year ago
Oh I knopw she doesn't need one. Someone else commented that she used on for this performance.
langleywil 1 year ago
I saw Jesse Normans performance on television and it sent cold shivers up my spine- itstill does. Since then I have tried to obtain a recording of it, without success. imagine my delight when I saw the link on utube. Thank you for giving me that thrill again - whata wonderful voice!
fred
freddyzify 2 years ago
Magnificant 1000*****'s, no wonder the applause...thanks
thomascow1 2 years ago
GREAT COMMENT! BRAVO & THANKS :)
I totally AGREE with you!!!!!!!!!!!!
BravaBerganza01 2 years ago
@BravaBerganza01 How true.
The1620 1 year ago
My vocal instructor told me to look her up, since I'm a soprano and, like Ms. Norman, I don't have that tiny tinkling soprano voice, either. (As my teacher would say, my voice will never be a tiny bird fart of a sound.) =) I've never heard her before tonight, and I'm in awe. She's beautiful and her voice is divine. If I only end up with half that talent, I will be content. She's amazing.
nkteinert 2 years ago
Prima, Miss Jessye Norman!
Was für eine Stimme!
Die Beste!
schuttowb 2 years ago
Stunning! Her top notes are divine - ALL of it is divine. And for those of you used to wee 'popera' voices who can't be heard without a microphone - this aria is from the OPERA The Behemian Girl.
shinawillful 2 years ago 4
wonderful excellent, jessye norman sings always outstanding, one of our divas from the XX century
cantanteporsiempre 2 years ago
Marvellous singer and one of my old favourite arias. Unfortunately they just don't belong together. A bit like custard on a dover sole.
anyotherbizniz 2 years ago
You must not forget that she's not singing this piece with a mic right in front of her mouth so she has to project.
Lindow 2 years ago
I didn't see the microphone. Where is it?
langleywil 2 years ago
She does'nt need one.
qklq42 1 year ago
Oh lord!
Is there absolutely nothing this lady cannot sing!
Im such a big fan of her!!
Love you Jessye Norman!!
schef123 2 years ago
What a lovely dress ........ the voice a Rolls Royce when a Volkswagen would do ...... But absolutely charming !
The1620 2 years ago
Song and artist mismatched, as it is to the voice of Sutherland. It takes a smaller voice and a less mannered delivery. If you can find it, listen to Elizabeth Wheeler on black Victor; or, Olive Kline in a brief snippet on the acoustic Bohemian Girl Gems on Victor 35603.
shareddrive 2 years ago
A tremendous voice -- a bit much - too full and rich - for this rather light song, but I'd love to hear her do Wagner. And I'll bet she sing a sexy and very lusty Carmen.
neoceratodus 2 years ago
This brings tears to my eyes - GORGEOUS!
singerjen212 2 years ago 6
R.I.P.
Renowned British conductor Sir Edward Thomas Downes, CBE, has died at the age of 85, after travelling to the assisted suicide clinic Dignitas with his wife.
He and his 74-year-old wife Joan, who was terminally ill, chose to end their lives at the Swiss clinic, their family said in a statement.
According to the statement, the couple "died peacefully, and under circumstances of their own choosing".
eutuve 2 years ago
wow i though sumi jo was the best but after hearing norman...boy, was i wrong!lol sumi jo is still a wonderful singer, but i like the richness in norman's voice.
fruit1020 2 years ago 2
I adore this artist
ugotitbabe000 2 years ago
Brilliant!
maass16 2 years ago
The voice of the century...and a fab song too. Thanks
yeahbyme 2 years ago 2
Brava!!!
MichelleLaJeunes 2 years ago
Ganz schön!!!
Mikirekai 2 years ago
BRAVO!!!
1400deadwood 2 years ago
Comment removed
veggieelf 2 years ago
That was so magical, it took me to another place!!!
watsola 2 years ago
she has the most beautiful smile and presence!!
flouraki 3 years ago
angelic voice.....when I die I want to hear this....!
flouraki 3 years ago 3
Why is Jesse Norman not seen as the greatest opera singer of this era? She surley has earned it
Bahia82 3 years ago 6
She is.
davidmcdowell 2 years ago
Most beautiful interpretation of marble hall I've ever seen.
KakarottoCL 3 years ago 6
Sie ist die Beste!Wunderbar!
Schw. Birgit
schuttowb 3 years ago
She's so good! My favourite singer of the Strauss Four Last Songs.
algernon4444 3 years ago 2
William Balfe? No! Michael Balfe.
BlackMagic1943 3 years ago
Yes, it is Michael William Balfe.
Meyerbeer1 2 years ago
Beautiful!
maryclaude2 3 years ago 2
Superb. It knocks Joan Sutherland's version with the wierd diction into a cocked hat.
niallsullivan1948 3 years ago 7
@niallsullivan1948 Dream on.............!
stingabe 1 year ago
@niallsullivan1948 Jessye Norman is an amazing soprano, and her version of this aria is one of the best for sure.
But Dame Joan Sutherland's version (that you criticised) has got much more subtle coloratura, and as you may know, Joan's efforts on the coloratura sometimes makes her diction less good.
But the fact that they have different styles, doesn't make Joan Sutherland worse than Jessye Norman. Actually, both are "top" performers.
musicredshoes 1 year ago 3
@musicredshoes I agree. Perhaps Jessye´s style is a bit more expressive, while Joan is a bit more technically perfect. On this particular vid, Jessye´s gestures more than fill her role as an actress-singer. It´s like watching "A thousand and one nights."
ruffomaldito 1 year ago
Wonderful, as always from this great singer,emotion without sentimentality or affection. A joy to hear!
savagebear54 3 years ago 2
wow...beautiful, and great diction to boot
brava la norman
xoox
SMMHELDENTENOR 3 years ago
Superb aria from a truly great singer a lovely melody by Irishman William Balfe a long forgotten composer who is now sadly overlooked so this aria is his legacy. Thank you for posting.
richio44 3 years ago 3
A most beautiful rendition of a haunting aria. I wish Norman had been a more "conventional" singer when she chose her repertoire (aka bread and butter) but who am I to argue with her?
lungdoc 3 years ago
Beautiful and elegant aria and voice. Brava!
wolkowy1 3 years ago 4
Very good !!! Congratulations.
nycolas1712 3 years ago 7
She has to be the most powerful female singer EVER!!! and technically the equal of any.
re6356 3 years ago 4
Did you know it is William Balfe's bicentenary this year. Should be able to see The Bohemian Girl somewhere. He is my uncle a few generations back!! :~)
JB
bollonbear 3 years ago 2
Ha, that's awesome! Definitely an unsung hero of English opera, well, I think so :)
33blueberries 3 years ago
wow what a beautiful, graceful voice
Geekella 3 years ago 2
I think Ms. Norman did this pretty well.
It is just a completely different Bohemian girl from the one interpreted by Joan. Maybe her mother was actually a US lady or she studied a couple of years in NYC...
Anyway, it is called arts...we don't need precision here.
Doooku 3 years ago
That dress and turban are fucking fabulous!
tenore23 3 years ago 4
Love this version to the Joan Sutherland but wish she sang Plee Said and not pleased; if you see what I mean
Enya's version takes on a different angle
Would love to see this opera tho - never seems to be on anywhere
GinnyGirl53 3 years ago
GRRRRRREAT!!!!!!!
jadoremassenet 3 years ago 2
What a knock out! Superb song which she sings so beautifully. Listen to her singing Strauss's 'Four Last Songs'.
algernon4444 3 years ago 5
I'm a Jessye Norman convert!
Why only 3000 views?
mylittlepony34 3 years ago 2
Yes, explain that!
JoFrSc 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
It might be hard to believe, but this piece has been sung by ...Enya (it has been recorder for one of her albums).
I just adore Jessye Norman, but it is so ridiculous to hear her rendition and voice - obviously TOO powerful, too fervent for this lullaby-like waltz :) Maybe it's just the influence of the somnambulistic version by Enya? ;)
SubtlyRough 3 years ago
This is an operatic aria; it was written before microphones were invented, and requires a powerful delivery in order to fill the performance space. To compare this performance to one by Enya is to compare apples and oranges.
ejtka 3 years ago
You said it: take the technology away from Enya and there's very, very little left to carry over three rows of seats in an audience. Take technology away from Norman and still end up with overwhelming music.
JoFrSc 3 years ago 13
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Score: SubtlyRough, 1; ejtka, 0.
Watch the Sutherland, it's on youtube, and is a much more endearing and touching (albeit somewhat overly-ornamented) rendition than either this or the Enya. "A powerful delivery" requires nothing more than the proper projection of the tone, which can easily be achieved by a well-trained singer at forte, or piano. It is the latter for which this, yes, lullaby-like waltz calls.
33blueberries 3 years ago
The point that I should have made - is that comparisons are pointless.
ejtka 3 years ago
oh my gosh. i've never seen this before. thank you so much for put on this...i can't believe...its so beautyful. brava jessye. again, again and again...
newhotmailit 3 years ago
I remember in 1996/7 a colleague showed me this on video. It was from a Royal Variety Society Performance. They thought it tacky but I loved it. He facial expressions, the diction the voice all wonderful. This is not available to buy which is a shame.
NART65 3 years ago
This is a really beautiful performance of an excerpt from a vastly underrated opera. The choruses in this work are magnificent. For a really different kind of rendering of this gem, check on YouTube for Ruby Helder, "the girl tenor"! Thanks for this video.
gmmix 4 years ago 3
Oops...I wanted to say "a really different kind of rendering of ANOTHER gem from Bohemian Girl." (Another senior moment!) In the way of an afterthought, one wonders how many recall the 1930's Laurel & Hardy movie based on this Balfe opera. That film contained some fine and serious singing.
gmmix 4 years ago
Joy!!!! What a joy!!! Thank you for putting this on.
godivapaw 4 years ago 3
Bravo Jessye Norman. Magnífico
Liriki3 4 years ago 2
A sheer beauty, absolutely wonderful!!! Viva La Norman!!!!
barmanjoe 4 years ago 3
Magnificent
Dhbrydon 4 years ago 4
Thank you for posting this. Over the years, whenever Jessie Norman's name has come up in conversation I have asked if anyone else remembers her performance of this aria. It was at a Royal Gala in Covent garden about 12 years ago. Sadly, it doesn't seem appear on any of her recordings. If anyone has actually found it, please post the details. Superb!
legard2 4 years ago 3
Really a fine performance. It's up there on top
musicbox99 4 years ago 3
"Pure Joy"
dongbat777 4 years ago 3
THIS IS ABSOLUTELY ONE OF THE GREATEST PERFORMANCE I HAVE EVER SEEN. Miss Norman you have acheived even greater respect and adoration from me. BRAVA BRAVA BRAVA
royalbattle 4 years ago 3
Look at La Primma Donna Assoluta looking everybit the part! What a beautiful woman inside and out!
VoyArrasando 4 years ago 7
this is delightful. how wonderful!! thank you for uploading this.
lamarcallas 4 years ago 6