...he plays this like he was not interested in the music of Mozart at all, like he was only trying to DEMONSTRATE something to this Proms(?) audience...demonstrate what?...that he can produce, on demand, the semblance of the "classicist" dry sound?...anything else?..
I don't understand why he often rises his fingers when they are not playing, and having a shallow touch. That's a wrong way to play classical music. You must feel every note in deep! It's wrong just to play every note and pulse correct!
dingtou5 Everybody can have "interpretations", even shoe maker, there is talking about real professionalism. What I hear is nightmare by lung lang, there is no any musician in former soviet union, including conservatory professors, who does not agree with this opinion, I taught in America as a professor piano department, in america everything is possible as soon as there is advertisement, I have never seen as cheap and vulgar approach towards classical music, as americans have.
Real musicians understand that lang lang is fraud, still how he gets so much bizarre around him not understandable. Recently I went to Louis Lortie's recital, It was excellent and very profound performance of Liszt's Annes. Why there is not such a noise about him? Any time I hear somebody on radio banging hell, it turns out either lang lang, or yuja rtc, Forgot name.
Played exactly like Mozart should be: in a huge auditorium, with a large crowd, with lots of distracting hand gestures, letting the performer speak, rather than the music, and the facial expressions telling us that he is getting it straight from the composer, as he looks skyward.
I think he is trying to teach pianist students in audience with his expression. It tells a lot, at least to me. I had a big help when I was watching his face and body movement when I was studying Fantasie Wanderer by Schubert. He is a great teacher!
this sounds amazing. lang lang is very willful, no doubt in his interpretation, but what an imaginatiion he possesses. his hair trigger reactions to the moment is what make this rendition so interestring. a master colorist; lang lang harkens back to the days of the golden age of piano...
for people who dislike langlang, ask yourself why is he famous and he is the one on the stage playing while you are merely an audience...im so sick of seeing people saying how he doesn't understand the meaning in the music under pretty much all of his videos on youtube... if youve been to his recital in person i ensure you its an experience that will blow your mind away.....
tenendo conto che lui dovrebbe essere considerato uno dei più grandi pianisti esistenti (almeno così si direbbe dai media...) c'è qualcosa in questa esecuzione di mozart che non mi convince ma non so dire cos'è, forse è come se fosse un pò "goffa" e pesante e non cristallina e brillante come la musica di mozart di solito è..... chi mi chiarisce il dubbio? mi sbaglio? sono io che non ho i mezzi per giudicare? ciao a tutti :)
@Exsilvis All you have established is that Lang Lang doesn't interpret Mozart as a classicist. I would wager you haven't taken Schenkerian analysis; if you have, you would see the genius in the way he interprets the music forces inherent in Mozart's structure. To critique as you have fails to understand the way music develops over time. I was trained in a conservatory, and this is ok to my ear, it is full of impetuousness, yes. Do you hate Gould as well? What about Ebonics? Are you horrified?lol
I thoroughly enjoyed this video. Lang Lang plays with such clarity, accuracy, tonal variation and lightness of touch that I am only filled with admiration and envy! My personal opinion is that the way we express any piece of music is OUR OWN interpretation or copied from someone else we heard. Has anyone ever questioned Mozart or Chopin or Bach or Beethoven as to exactly how their music should to be played? Have you heard them say which interpretation is best? I doubt it. Lang Lang is great.
@Exsilvis your response is incredibly vague. What do you mean by "TRADITION - style, elegance, sophistication, finesses", and how does he not display these traits? He certainly has his own style. He is sophisticated because he knows more about this music than you do. Thats why hes playing this piece in front of 6000 people. I'm sure hes studied it and practiced it a thousand more times than you have. He also has an elegant and sensitive touch, and plays each note with finesse.
I just discovered this and at the start I was thinking are there seriously crowds like that, that would go to a concert for one song? After finishing the video, I wanna god damn see him live.
The most sophisticated and technically correct pianist in the world today! Every note he plays tells the story of the song,the way the composer would have wanted.
Mediocre is making comments like these without any justification. You don't give any parameter of what wouldn't be mediocre, or what's ideal to you. So, an 'empty' comment, just a cheap 'criticism' from someone who doesn't get to give any criticism at all because, well, I don't think you'd be less mediocre at playing this than he is... And I'd like to make it clear I'm not a Lang Lang fan, but he plays damn well. And playing the piano that well is NOT mediocre.
questa gente che non capisce niente di musica le piaciono fare questi comentari senza nessun senso soltanto perchè hanno complesso di inferiorità... mi fa schifo, non fa nemmeno riferenza di quello che 'sarebbe' non-mediocre...allora posso Io, mortale che nemmeno sa suonare il pianoforte a dire che Martha Argerich è meglia o peggiore di quello...chi sono questa gente ??? Puoi vedere che veri pianisti non comentano MAI sul youtube...
@FelipeBellani2 io parlo da profana della musica,un po meno della musica classica,ma se lang lang è uno dei pianisti più quotati e famosi AL MONDO ci sarà pure un motivo...
@danieldu7 No, No, No!!!!! But I think, that he dont understand Mozart. He plays it like something, but Mozart is NOT something. Do you understand me?
@danieldu7 no, I love Mozart!!! but lang lang cant play mozart, because he dont understand his genius. I really, really love Mozart, he is one of my favourite composers. but just because of that I cant hear how Lang Lang plays Mozart. He plays him without real understanding.
@RichterThePianist Why do you insult Richter by using his name for your userid and then post remarks like this? Why don't you lay down on a train track and take a nap? Go on, it's good for you!
@dasteufelhund no, I think, you dont understand me. I only want to say, that I dont like, how lang lang plays mozart. I dont want to say, I know how mozart is to play. but I dont think, that lang lang has understood mozart.
@dasteufelhund beeing natural is no reason for not understanding, I think. What is "too natural"? And I think, that mozart is the only one, who could understand his music.
Compare this to Justin Beiber (Beaver).
dingtou5 6 days ago
can't believe how many haters...
dingtou5 6 days ago
To you negative folks, your inability and jealousy is showing. This man is a master and you are slugs. You don't deserve to have ears.
snahomish 1 week ago
The haters think they are so right and justified while they don't even have the marginal mentality and skill of Lang Lang....
May god bless them.
cwang1004 1 week ago
bravissimo!!
5748peter 3 weeks ago
...he plays this like he was not interested in the music of Mozart at all, like he was only trying to DEMONSTRATE something to this Proms(?) audience...demonstrate what?...that he can produce, on demand, the semblance of the "classicist" dry sound?...anything else?..
fredericfranc 3 weeks ago
Where was this performed?
dingtou5 4 weeks ago
he moves around too much in his seat.i always thought that when your playing classical music your supposed to stay calm and not move around too much
inuyasha22464 1 month ago
I don't understand why he often rises his fingers when they are not playing, and having a shallow touch. That's a wrong way to play classical music. You must feel every note in deep! It's wrong just to play every note and pulse correct!
SuperFlute10 1 month ago
@SuperFlute10 Funny how you are the authority on piano playing all of a sudden.
dasteufelhund 2 weeks ago
come on.. he played nice
BassicStorm 1 month ago
A lot of haters, really means that he's actually one of the best if not the best.
FanShostakovich 1 month ago in playlist Classical Piano Music
I regard this man as a disaster in art.
liana563 2 months ago
dingtou5 Everybody can have "interpretations", even shoe maker, there is talking about real professionalism. What I hear is nightmare by lung lang, there is no any musician in former soviet union, including conservatory professors, who does not agree with this opinion, I taught in America as a professor piano department, in america everything is possible as soon as there is advertisement, I have never seen as cheap and vulgar approach towards classical music, as americans have.
liana563 2 months ago
Real musicians understand that lang lang is fraud, still how he gets so much bizarre around him not understandable. Recently I went to Louis Lortie's recital, It was excellent and very profound performance of Liszt's Annes. Why there is not such a noise about him? Any time I hear somebody on radio banging hell, it turns out either lang lang, or yuja rtc, Forgot name.
liana563 2 months ago
@liana563 Lang Lang has his own interpretations. Some "real" musicians, think these interpretations are different and not at all bad.
dingtou5 2 months ago
Uchida and Lang Lang..hmmm...I prefer Lang Lang interpretation, personally
dingtou5 2 months ago
Where was this performed?
dingtou5 2 months ago
nice...just nice. i recommend Mitusko Uchida personally.
kyleclef 3 months ago
@kyleclef I agree, Uchida is superb and is the doyen of Mozart interpreters...
cheradinine8 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
(Posted by Youtube Stream for iPhone (yst.me) on behalf of nausicaa1225 at twitter)
ystme 3 months ago
I like Lang Lang playing...his expressions...I love that.
harrycan2208 4 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Lang Lang is overrated
supermariozaken 4 months ago
@supermariozaken BOO!!!
dingtou5 4 months ago
Far behind Horowitz's version......while he was aged 80 or more !!!
flouz2 4 months ago
He plays the piano, not Mozart.
pfJHan 4 months ago
... im playing this song for my piano exam. now im really scared :\
apforeverrx 4 months ago
@apforeverrx im playing for national piano competition
dingtou5 4 months ago 34
@dingtou5 Good luck to you on the competition!
kcotsob 3 months ago
@kcotsob thanks
dingtou5 3 months ago
It is always a pleasure watching Lang Lang play :)
Taijar 4 months ago
Played exactly like Mozart should be: in a huge auditorium, with a large crowd, with lots of distracting hand gestures, letting the performer speak, rather than the music, and the facial expressions telling us that he is getting it straight from the composer, as he looks skyward.
miker2001 4 months ago
Lang Lang is a ledgend ;-)
MrJonnyblabla 5 months ago
what are they all standing up for?...sit down...relax! lol
MDkid1 5 months ago
I think he is trying to teach pianist students in audience with his expression. It tells a lot, at least to me. I had a big help when I was watching his face and body movement when I was studying Fantasie Wanderer by Schubert. He is a great teacher!
8915032 5 months ago
this sounds amazing. lang lang is very willful, no doubt in his interpretation, but what an imaginatiion he possesses. his hair trigger reactions to the moment is what make this rendition so interestring. a master colorist; lang lang harkens back to the days of the golden age of piano...
utubuser10 5 months ago
I don't get his facial expression; but musically his playing is fine indeed.
Cissy97 6 months ago
this was awsome!:D
the best that i hv heard ever
he is young i think:p
but i loved him.V.
it seems that it is very easy when he play this
not in hurry, no presure on him
that's a true pianist
ps:i think his facial expressions are so funny;P
michellesuen78 6 months ago
but I dont want to hurt anybody!!! And I simply dont like his play very much.
RichterThePianist 7 months ago
for people who dislike langlang, ask yourself why is he famous and he is the one on the stage playing while you are merely an audience...im so sick of seeing people saying how he doesn't understand the meaning in the music under pretty much all of his videos on youtube... if youve been to his recital in person i ensure you its an experience that will blow your mind away.....
justinneversleep 7 months ago 2
tenendo conto che lui dovrebbe essere considerato uno dei più grandi pianisti esistenti (almeno così si direbbe dai media...) c'è qualcosa in questa esecuzione di mozart che non mi convince ma non so dire cos'è, forse è come se fosse un pò "goffa" e pesante e non cristallina e brillante come la musica di mozart di solito è..... chi mi chiarisce il dubbio? mi sbaglio? sono io che non ho i mezzi per giudicare? ciao a tutti :)
stefano1980ify 7 months ago
You know you're good when you get a standing ovation before starting the piece...
eternalaughs 7 months ago 2
listen to Uchida, far better, Lang Lang is ok , but Uchida is no.1 for Mozart
BassicStorm 7 months ago
@BassicStorm Uchida's Mozart's are nice, but too gentle, lack the energy offered by Lang.
dasteufelhund 7 months ago
@dasteufelhund looool cant agree
BassicStorm 7 months ago
@BassicStorm how do you mean?
RichterThePianist 7 months ago
@dasteufelhund lol dude ur right! i was arrogant, Lang Lang played this great! i converted it to mp3 :D
BassicStorm 7 months ago
The left hand gesture at 4:00 is quite epic :-D
ShornSteinfeher 8 months ago
stupid 7 people
dingtou5 8 months ago
No one can play Mozart as Mitsuko Uchida,,, this is just disgusting =(
manuelspcool 8 months ago
His body language and his facial expressions are so artificial. It makes me sick.
bachmaninoff 8 months ago 2
@bachmaninoff That's a primitive mentality and there's no place for it in the modern world.
InDarknessLight 8 months ago
@InDarknessLight
There is no place for artificiality in the interpretation of ingenious music-- it speaks for itself.
bachmaninoff 8 months ago
Excellent, especially the ending, (4 people can't....aww forget it)
Crayterm13 10 months ago
haha i love how at the end when he finishes playing everbody starts coughing like fuck
TeamJacob1903 10 months ago
I highly envy you... seriously i have to play this for some retarded exam and like seriously FAIL compared to Lang Lang *sigh*
TeamJacob1903 10 months ago
@Exsilvis All you have established is that Lang Lang doesn't interpret Mozart as a classicist. I would wager you haven't taken Schenkerian analysis; if you have, you would see the genius in the way he interprets the music forces inherent in Mozart's structure. To critique as you have fails to understand the way music develops over time. I was trained in a conservatory, and this is ok to my ear, it is full of impetuousness, yes. Do you hate Gould as well? What about Ebonics? Are you horrified?lol
ronbobathon 10 months ago
eternal torment to does who dislike this. there shouldn.t even be a dislike button.
dingtou5 10 months ago
this piece is really awesome!
lixiang7349 11 months ago
I thoroughly enjoyed this video. Lang Lang plays with such clarity, accuracy, tonal variation and lightness of touch that I am only filled with admiration and envy! My personal opinion is that the way we express any piece of music is OUR OWN interpretation or copied from someone else we heard. Has anyone ever questioned Mozart or Chopin or Bach or Beethoven as to exactly how their music should to be played? Have you heard them say which interpretation is best? I doubt it. Lang Lang is great.
rubendow 11 months ago 30
@Exsilvis also, how do you know what Mozart would think of this? Are you Mozart?
termizar 11 months ago
@Exsilvis your response is incredibly vague. What do you mean by "TRADITION - style, elegance, sophistication, finesses", and how does he not display these traits? He certainly has his own style. He is sophisticated because he knows more about this music than you do. Thats why hes playing this piece in front of 6000 people. I'm sure hes studied it and practiced it a thousand more times than you have. He also has an elegant and sensitive touch, and plays each note with finesse.
termizar 11 months ago
A lovely sound! This young man's performance was most pleasantly entertaining. Thanks for posting this.
Ivanhoe2 11 months ago
he plays better than me when he's using his pinky
tfcowman 11 months ago
Langlang is so damn suited for mozart.
KantutJuice 1 year ago
@KantutJuice Totally agree. In fact I was thinking the same thing; then as I scrolled down, saw your comment. =)
jpFromNH 11 months ago
I just discovered this and at the start I was thinking are there seriously crowds like that, that would go to a concert for one song? After finishing the video, I wanna god damn see him live.
iamevildoing 1 year ago
The most sophisticated and technically correct pianist in the world today! Every note he plays tells the story of the song,the way the composer would have wanted.
Geowolffe 1 year ago
@MrKALODIA
Mediocre is making comments like these without any justification. You don't give any parameter of what wouldn't be mediocre, or what's ideal to you. So, an 'empty' comment, just a cheap 'criticism' from someone who doesn't get to give any criticism at all because, well, I don't think you'd be less mediocre at playing this than he is... And I'd like to make it clear I'm not a Lang Lang fan, but he plays damn well. And playing the piano that well is NOT mediocre.
FelipeBellani2 1 year ago
@MrKALODIA se questa è mediocre poi......
hatsepsut85 1 year ago
@hatsepsut85
questa gente che non capisce niente di musica le piaciono fare questi comentari senza nessun senso soltanto perchè hanno complesso di inferiorità... mi fa schifo, non fa nemmeno riferenza di quello che 'sarebbe' non-mediocre...allora posso Io, mortale che nemmeno sa suonare il pianoforte a dire che Martha Argerich è meglia o peggiore di quello...chi sono questa gente ??? Puoi vedere che veri pianisti non comentano MAI sul youtube...
FelipeBellani2 1 year ago
@FelipeBellani2 io parlo da profana della musica,un po meno della musica classica,ma se lang lang è uno dei pianisti più quotati e famosi AL MONDO ci sarà pure un motivo...
hatsepsut85 1 year ago
I'm going to see Lang Lang tomorrow night. I CAN'T WAIT! Brilliant
camispianostudio 1 year ago
3:34
soiswis 1 year ago
Beautiful... a master class for all who play this.
mathdawn 1 year ago
wow.....mozart es posiblemente el estilo mas dificil de dominar....increible...
belialah 1 year ago
he makes people smarter with his playing....just amazing
belialah 1 year ago
What's that boy (5:23-5:39) doing? I think he might be the one who disliked this :-)
soiswis 1 year ago
This performance is just another definition for the word PERFECT
soiswis 1 year ago
who disliked this?
danieldu7 1 year ago 27
@danieldu7 that guy who killed mozart..
FutureAbe 1 year ago 30
@FutureAbe To play Mozart in front of an audience of 6000 people in a hall with incredible accoustics is a enormous feat.
Bravo Lang Lang!!wish you just where less of a clown because you are a wonderfull pianist.
abmsghost 11 months ago
@danieldu7 Me.....
RichterThePianist 8 months ago
@RichterThePianist of course, since u could do a lot better
danieldu7 8 months ago
@danieldu7 No, No, No!!!!! But I think, that he dont understand Mozart. He plays it like something, but Mozart is NOT something. Do you understand me?
RichterThePianist 7 months ago
@RichterThePianist not really... you hate Mozart?
danieldu7 7 months ago
@danieldu7 no, I love Mozart!!! but lang lang cant play mozart, because he dont understand his genius. I really, really love Mozart, he is one of my favourite composers. but just because of that I cant hear how Lang Lang plays Mozart. He plays him without real understanding.
RichterThePianist 7 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
@RichterThePianist ok, i get you now
danieldu7 7 months ago
@RichterThePianist so i take that you understand the meanings within mozart's music right? explain then.
justinneversleep 7 months ago
@justinneversleep No, I cant explain that, because I dont know it either.
RichterThePianist 7 months ago
@RichterThePianist Why do you insult Richter by using his name for your userid and then post remarks like this? Why don't you lay down on a train track and take a nap? Go on, it's good for you!
dasteufelhund 7 months ago
@dasteufelhund no, I think, you dont understand me. I only want to say, that I dont like, how lang lang plays mozart. I dont want to say, I know how mozart is to play. but I dont think, that lang lang has understood mozart.
RichterThePianist 7 months ago
@RichterThePianist Perhaps, Mozart didn't understand his own music because it was too natural for him.
dasteufelhund 7 months ago
@dasteufelhund beeing natural is no reason for not understanding, I think. What is "too natural"? And I think, that mozart is the only one, who could understand his music.
RichterThePianist 7 months ago
@danieldu7 Probably a handful of people who find him a pretentious performer. Can you blame them?
Litawyn 6 months ago
@danieldu7 Mozart
BBalarinMusic 5 months ago
@danieldu7 probably Mozart
dingtou5 5 months ago 2
Simply Amazing
ChronosCypress 1 year ago