AI4- top 4 -Anthony Fedorov - If you don't know me by now

[Nivlektehfudger]

You know what... Carrie Underwood married NHL player Mike Fisher...

Even more interesting, Anthony Fedorov shares a last name with former NHL player Sergei Fedorov

[HisTwinFlame]

Constantine was my number one, but when I was forced to let him go, he became my favorite. And then I was crushed. x_x 

[melbomelba]

Anthony is one of the best male singers in Idol history.

[shystonerlove420]

What happened to him!:( I had the biggest crush i the world on him! lol, I bawled when he was eliminated!

[CookandJohnsGirl]

thumbs up if Anthony brought you here, not stefano

[HisTwinFlame]

@CookandJohnsGirl >.> Who's Stefano. *only watch AI when it was a good show* XD

[sweetiepea13]

stefano sucks and so does he. never sing this song cause youll suck at. no one pulled this song off in my opinion. same as suspicious minds and turn the beat around.

[2436dan]

stefano sang this better in my opinion

[hot4jacob]

Anthony is kick ass and he can have me for all i care.

[mauno76]

He's a very good singer.

[riejin]

Love Him...until now, wish that Carrie and Him end together haha:D nice couple buddies!

[katherineoa]

..thanks for sharing..

[kay2164]

He was better than Bo. I don't know about Carrie, but I thought he was better than Bo.

[MMRP2141]

ohhh anthony.. i remembered when i was crushed on him.. hes so amazing singer. i hope we can hear more about this guy..

[qCLEFJones]

great inspiration 2 me...

[shannonk68]

I think Simon's problem was the Anthony outsang their chosen one, Carrie and he needed to say something negative to keep Anthony from totally outshining Carrie.

[milly2011]

I love how Carrie and Anthony were like best friends and sang the same song! It was so cute.

[abranson89]

ok shut up dont even compare carrie and anthony especially since they were really good friends so just stop

they're both good

[hwanmig]

Carrie's version suck big time. Can't believe Anthony got booted instead of her.

[ridhwan1820]

she outsang her..yes!

[sphumi]

she? anthony is a girl now? o_O

[cartmanboy]

Carrie's version was so much better!!!

[ch3a]

damn right :D he's good but not as perfect and amazing as carrie

[idolfreak92]

No it wasn't.

[maica3320]

my boyfriend's cuter

[blisskasden]

Simon is nuts here. This was a kick ass performance. Anthony has a great voice and great stage presence.

[serengettiboy]

sometimes nice guys has nice voices

[ouano]

gvkhg

[ash4evagrl]

i was like 10 yrs old when this season aired... i loved him :) only guy i ever actually liked on AI besides david archuleta!

[extrinsicessence]

i didn't kno about this guy until today (never watched ai until this season)...love his voice!!

[djparrish01]

What a cutie.

[chengfei]

I think Anthony and Carrie decided to sing the same song together since they are good friends in the show. And omg, the key is so high.

[pattykad]

I really, really liked this guy. Reminds

me of a young John Farnham. Great voice...

where is Federov now?

[siny888]

He will be on Edy's ice cream promo CD starting this month and he will start touring with Simply Ballroom in March.

[y0ugakulover]

god he has the whole package.

hes damn great!!

i love his voice!!

[Ssymour]

This was his best performance, but it was too much, too late. He wasn't as consistant as the other contestants (Although I did perfer his version over Carrie's)

[finfan103]

I disagree with ilovemusic Dan. Anthony is much better than an average karaoke singer, and although Carrie is great, Anthon's version was better.

[elfwood]

he actually sang it on the same key as carrie for this song.

[hidouhak]

IMO this is Clay-lite's best performance. I'm glad he made top 4 over Scott and Constantine LOL

[nobssagittarius]

Anothony made it very interesting.

[ilovemusicdan]

I don't get it... I thought that Carrie sang way better than Anthony... Anthony was lucky to stay until the top 4 and he is just an ok karaoke singer..

[AK2AK2AK2AK2AK2]

Anthony was amazing, I loved this song choice.

[werdnanotroh]

While I think this guy is rad, and although he certainly can reach the high notes - they're not BIG and solid. But he's still WAY amazing!

[cupid1984]

I dont get it. Why did Carrie sing this song in the top 4. Can you do that? This version was better than Carries though.

[disneyrox1]

who won?

[jerryleejam]

carrie underwood. living under a rock?

[disneyrox1]

EXUSE ME?! as a mater of fact, i no live in america so i no watch american idol

[theforeman118]

bad idea to go against carrie with the same song

[Merenwen4]

This version is definately better than carrie's. Anthony rules. Listen to him. I dont get why he didnt get any further.. :(

[rbowboy]

Carrie was the best this year but anthony sang this song better.If anthony had done american idol a year later he might have won cos he sings better than the soul-less patrol

[shado474]

oh he's sooo cute, and yeah some notes were so high!!

[JPSexy4Ever]

I think he is cute <333

[sweetnothings887]

why did carrie and anthony sing the same song on the same night?

[highnote32]

I like how he hit that C5. It gave me chills.

[gaioschi]

gay

[highnote32]

He's had a girlfriend or more. Although, some people think that he's gay.

[Jesusfreak1688]

hes not gay. Hes is so hot though. He so should have won

[RythmOfMyHeart]

Why the hell didn't he win? I've never seen american idol, I sure as hell love his voice, and he's adorable to :)

[Delea06]

I didn't mean only black people have soul. I just say we more listen to this type of music. Not saying that white people don't some actually do. But to sing this song you have to be soulful. He sung it better

[hpsimsoap92]

786886969886978 times better than farmbot

[janerazor]

No offense to Carrie--she is a great singer--but Anthony sang circles around Carrie this week.

[nascarkraz]

Clay has done IYDNMBN live before though.  JSYK.

[Houseofbrokenhearts]

I hate Carrie I think Bo Of This Guy Should Have Won

[carolinagurl79]

i like his version better than carries...i do like carrie but anthony was my fav

[Delea06]

This was better than Carrie's version. I'm sorry Carrie fan but Carries wasn't good at all. She didn't have soul but he did. Go anthony. I like Carrie but this song wasn't for her. As a member of the black community we more listen to that kind of music it's not a racial thing but he the black community would have enn very proud of his version more than Carrie's.

Because I didn't like hers at all even if the band didn't mess up hers was still not good.

[ourgirlisabitofalush]

only black people have soul? damn. I'm the wrong color, apparently. geez.

[BrianMcCallister]

This was way better than Carrie's imo. More emotion and such, and Carrie's only good part with the song were the long notes. -.-

[ferreroR]

oh god...i used to think he had a good voice in the beginning at the auditions, but his voice sounds horrible as the competition went on. This version sucks...nothing close to carrie's version at all...I can't stand his voice...too much of a weird accent...his voice is just weird, relies too much on loud notes.

[fedorov21]

watch some of his new videos from this summer. His voice has grown a lot

[matchboxx20]

Anthony nailed the song and was obviously better than Carrie - no doubt here. About Clay's version of IYDNMBN....don't forget guys that Clay recorded it in the recording studio when you polish every note and Anthony singing live .... Still Anthony did a better job on it !

[WestSideSunDance]

Clay's version was HOT! But Anthony did a good job performing it live.

[idoltyler06]

He did it great. Carries vocals were better. But the band did screw up on Carries with the stops. I caught that. His was Good though

[shejean]

Clay is even better on the KMART bonus track

[dapa14635829]

Very Good, he worked it out, but Carrie was better.