ptdr de rire.... et l'autre idiote qui dit????quelle horreur ce vibrato!!! mais une voix belcantiste vibre, vit, même dans le cas présent où la bellissime Ricciarelli est plus qu'en fin de carrière. Loin, très très loin de tous ces eunuques dévertébrés qui encombrent les rayons de disques et autres scènes d'opéra au titre de la vérité (quelle vérité?) musicale d'époque et autres grandes prêtresses du baroque (voix fixe, vibrato quasi existant, chant monotone)
M SCUSATE MA CHI è COSTUI CHE ACCOSTA LA DIVINA CALLAS A ALLA RICCIARELLI . MA COME SE FA ... CAPISCO BELLA VOCE GRADEVOLE MA CHE FATICA CHE FATICA E IL TEMPèO ? DOV'è?????
It's a shame she came of age when she did. One of the best voices, a terrific technique, the ability to emote, the ability to engage with an audience...and she was hot, too.
But being a runner-up in the popularity contest to Caballe isn't exactly a disgrace.
Her best time was already passed, those portamento are out of stile today and sometimes she is out of time, but I do think she has been one of the best singers ever!! When her voice was good, the timber was even better than Caballè. She use to sing like an angel. And still her interpretation of this aria is really MOVING!!
her attack is so pure! like in the old days, like it should be. Her sense of voice placement is always consistent and the timbre is so round!!! LOVE this!
Very beautiful, shame the recording is so soft. Another nice one is the performce of the "older retired" singers such as Caballe and Gencer, that is if you are not a purist.
It's well known she lost her vocal power in the middle of her career, reasons she is the one to know. I don't know in theater, but some of her early recordings are worth listening to. This video shows clearly that she indeed knew how to sing, though her instrument was damaged.
I have great weakness for Her Art ! Nevertheless- her sensibility is ,again, one of the tops! Brava, Katia!!! She moves our hearts, and that is the only sense and purpose of the singing, and-art- an general.
What does Bartoli's voice got to do with Ricciarellis voice... Two totally different ways to sing. And every singer is/has an unique instrument. Some prefer passion, other technique, and some "muthas" even have both! I mean it in positive way, but it's rare! Singers like Corelli had that amazing ability to perform the role emotionally and sing it purely. There's no much of "muthas" like that these days!
I think that all those portamento and the fact that she takes the notes from the bottom is not stilistically correct. I study with a singer of S. Cecilia and she correct me always when I do this things and a singer like her should not do that always like she does.
I agree with you sabry, it's not the correct way to sing portamento. But this seems to be a bit old video aswell, this is not the best Ricciarelli I've seen.
Ok, she is good at doing the pianissimi, but what else? I agree with TheAlienSpoon about being a block of ice. Italian Proverb: "Fatto il nome scendi in piazza"!
Wow it was RAI (Italian National TV) auditorium... I sang Carl Orff "Carmina Burana" in there two years ago... lol
Well actually I prefer Cecilia Bartoli's performance, even if Katia Ricciarelli has been a real diva, too, but pay attention, she was: at her time... Today's way of singing respects some other parameters, musical "gusto" changes everyday, so... we can enjoy all of these performances thanks to god!! ^_^
AAAAAH what beautiful singing, love the versions of the "older" singers like Caballe, Gencer and Ricciarelli. Ok the purist it may not do, for me it certainly is preferred.
Totally agree. Ceclia Bartoli has a wonderful voice, incredible technique and most of all, a real stage presence. She is really expressive, while K. Ricciarelli looks a bit like a block of ice when she sings this aria...
Alem do que, Ricciarelli às vezes não chega, nos agudos, a frequenci correta. Tem uma voz aveludade e muito bonita mas falta paixão, falta dor, falta saudade.
No es por comparar... pero incluso a mí me sale mejor!!! al menos no me sale una voz tan completamente áfona!!! Katia ha tenido mejores momentos que el que aquí se muestra...... es que vamos, esto es para dormirse..xD
Merci beaucoup laurentius76 pour ton soutien! J'ai eu l'immense honneur et plaisir de voir ricciarelli à plusieurs reprises sur scène, elle a un charisme et un talent incroyable. Elle a marqué profondement et à tout jamais ma mémoire.
LOL.... siento decirlo, pero no me ha gustado nada. Flojo, flojo, flojo... mucho portamento, poco apoyo, voz muy oscurecida... no sé si es por la mala calidad del audio...pero no me ha gustado. XD
Beautiful controlled rendition of this glorious aria by the great Ricciarelli. Beautifully poised and full of emotion. Unfortunately the recording is not of great quality however Katia still shines.
This has been flagged as spam show
The angel of seasickness...I just can't take the vibrato
Snutih 6 months ago
C'est un masacre c'est à peine si je reconnai l'air!!
sweehietysop 9 months ago
Cara Katia ascolta la Signora Montserrat Caballè nel Concerto di Madrid del 1979.
Immensamente Superba, canta con il cuore in mano; di una tale bellezza che vedrai commuove anche te
clatnt 1 year ago
Katia Ricciarelli singt Sposa son disprezzata THE BEST!!
7bbuwe 1 year ago
ptdr de rire.... et l'autre idiote qui dit????quelle horreur ce vibrato!!! mais une voix belcantiste vibre, vit, même dans le cas présent où la bellissime Ricciarelli est plus qu'en fin de carrière. Loin, très très loin de tous ces eunuques dévertébrés qui encombrent les rayons de disques et autres scènes d'opéra au titre de la vérité (quelle vérité?) musicale d'époque et autres grandes prêtresses du baroque (voix fixe, vibrato quasi existant, chant monotone)
marioj34 1 year ago
M SCUSATE MA CHI è COSTUI CHE ACCOSTA LA DIVINA CALLAS A ALLA RICCIARELLI . MA COME SE FA ... CAPISCO BELLA VOCE GRADEVOLE MA CHE FATICA CHE FATICA E IL TEMPèO ? DOV'è?????
Aperlini 1 year ago
Vergogna!!non conosce niente di suono ,attacco,tempo e gusto barocco!!
vivacecilia 1 year ago
It's a shame she came of age when she did. One of the best voices, a terrific technique, the ability to emote, the ability to engage with an audience...and she was hot, too.
But being a runner-up in the popularity contest to Caballe isn't exactly a disgrace.
ChristophePhilippe 1 year ago 2
piuttosto che ascoltare questa tizia preferisco 1 calcio nel culo!
AlyandAjitaly94 1 year ago
ma era malata?
montale64 2 years ago 4
????quelle horreur ce vibrato!!!
atlantyss75 2 years ago 4
@atlantyss75 Vous avez bien raison c'est du pur massacre
sweehietysop 9 months ago
Come sempre, DIVINA KATIA!
fuocoeferro 2 years ago
Comment removed
Aperlini 1 year ago
Tessitura troppo bassa. Peccato, la voce è sempre bellissima.
AleRoma1968 2 years ago
Una voce sicuramente superiore alla Caballe, neanche è accostabile, ma qui comunque l'aveva dimenticata a casa. Non prende.
sp3nk1 2 years ago
Terribile, non si può ascoltare...
modette1979 2 years ago 3
la voce secondo me è bella, il problema è che non ha una buona tecnica.
bachorg 2 years ago 2
Her best time was already passed, those portamento are out of stile today and sometimes she is out of time, but I do think she has been one of the best singers ever!! When her voice was good, the timber was even better than Caballè. She use to sing like an angel. And still her interpretation of this aria is really MOVING!!
guendy77 2 years ago
I agree with you, I do not care about those portamentos and that she is out of time, her intepretation is awsome
robertdonkers 2 years ago
Puaj! que parto doloroso!
lamarce3010 2 years ago
Comment removed
morachioli1 2 years ago
Puaj??? HAHAHHAHAHA so funny.
opera46 2 years ago
I don't like her vibrato
madziua90 3 years ago
her attack is so pure! like in the old days, like it should be. Her sense of voice placement is always consistent and the timbre is so round!!! LOVE this!
DanyelHawkes 3 years ago
Un filo di voce per un'interpretazione intimista di tutto rispetto (concordo però sugli acuti a cucchiaio e le terzine rubatine), non c'è che dire.
1970heinz 3 years ago
to die for... her emotions...ah! senza parole!
Coloraturissimo 3 years ago 2
Very beautiful, shame the recording is so soft. Another nice one is the performce of the "older retired" singers such as Caballe and Gencer, that is if you are not a purist.
robertdonkers 3 years ago
It's well known she lost her vocal power in the middle of her career, reasons she is the one to know. I don't know in theater, but some of her early recordings are worth listening to. This video shows clearly that she indeed knew how to sing, though her instrument was damaged.
gabohuaroc 3 years ago
FATAL!!! Como todo lo que cantó en su vida!!
energyandpower 3 years ago
I find this version quite lacking in emotion, I find Bartolli so moving, this one, quite disappointing.
buelligan123 3 years ago 2
I have great weakness for Her Art ! Nevertheless- her sensibility is ,again, one of the tops! Brava, Katia!!! She moves our hearts, and that is the only sense and purpose of the singing, and-art- an general.
Thank U, sutherland9 ! C.
Coloraturissimo 3 years ago 3
Imperfect yet extraordinary. Her 'tame' attack is heartbreaking. Few singer bring you into their introspection the way La Ricciarelli does,
Aidan55 3 years ago 2
What does Bartoli's voice got to do with Ricciarellis voice... Two totally different ways to sing. And every singer is/has an unique instrument. Some prefer passion, other technique, and some "muthas" even have both! I mean it in positive way, but it's rare! Singers like Corelli had that amazing ability to perform the role emotionally and sing it purely. There's no much of "muthas" like that these days!
Moffolover 4 years ago
I think that all those portamento and the fact that she takes the notes from the bottom is not stilistically correct. I study with a singer of S. Cecilia and she correct me always when I do this things and a singer like her should not do that always like she does.
sabry972 4 years ago
I agree with you sabry, it's not the correct way to sing portamento. But this seems to be a bit old video aswell, this is not the best Ricciarelli I've seen.
Moffolover 4 years ago
she has no passion when she sings_cecilia bertoli is better
MiNaPuRiTaNiA 4 years ago
There is no comparison between this version and bartoli's,to begin with this is an operatic singer while the other is a record singer.
If you want to hear the greatest version hear Caballe's.
susejf 4 years ago
caballe is eveb more so.
ClaudiaSwann 3 years ago
Ok, she is good at doing the pianissimi, but what else? I agree with TheAlienSpoon about being a block of ice. Italian Proverb: "Fatto il nome scendi in piazza"!
sabicol 4 years ago
Great performance, splendid voice and deep feelings : not a SINGING COMPUTER !
KILLERADVICE 4 years ago
Wow it was RAI (Italian National TV) auditorium... I sang Carl Orff "Carmina Burana" in there two years ago... lol
Well actually I prefer Cecilia Bartoli's performance, even if Katia Ricciarelli has been a real diva, too, but pay attention, she was: at her time... Today's way of singing respects some other parameters, musical "gusto" changes everyday, so... we can enjoy all of these performances thanks to god!! ^_^
ioaletto 4 years ago
AAAAAH what beautiful singing, love the versions of the "older" singers like Caballe, Gencer and Ricciarelli. Ok the purist it may not do, for me it certainly is preferred.
robertdonkers 4 years ago 2
nice,but i prefer bartolis version
sagagossard 4 years ago
Nobody tops Bartoli.
senoramariposa 4 years ago
Que me perdonen los que no concuerden conmigo, pero nada que ver!!!
Esta version es la mas pobre de las tres que estan evaluandose aqui. Me sigo quedando con Cecilia.
yap04 4 years ago
elle ne donne pas les notes justes
hache332 4 years ago
She is the great, unique, wonderful, amazing, incrédible! Ricciarelli the best in this aria.
ioSonoCallas 4 years ago 3
Nice job, bad audio though. Of course, I prefer Cecilia's.
callastoujours 4 years ago
Totally agree. Ceclia Bartoli has a wonderful voice, incredible technique and most of all, a real stage presence. She is really expressive, while K. Ricciarelli looks a bit like a block of ice when she sings this aria...
TheAlienSpoon 4 years ago
Acredito que a maioria prefere Cecilia Bartoli.
Alem do que, Ricciarelli às vezes não chega, nos agudos, a frequenci correta. Tem uma voz aveludade e muito bonita mas falta paixão, falta dor, falta saudade.
pcosta.floripa
pcostafloripa 4 years ago
Cecilia Bartoli's version is much better
sakurayoma 4 years ago
Ma ke "beatiful controll" qui già era rovinata.
pavarottithebest 4 years ago
Quel charme, quel talent, un legato unique, un art du chant consommé! Madame Ricciarelli vous êtes merveilleuse et émouvante. Merci
ioSonoCallas 4 years ago
No es por comparar... pero incluso a mí me sale mejor!!! al menos no me sale una voz tan completamente áfona!!! Katia ha tenido mejores momentos que el que aquí se muestra...... es que vamos, esto es para dormirse..xD
Njamh 4 years ago
Il bello è che si permette anche di darsi le arie! Acuti a cucchiaio, terzine TROPPO rubate per lo stile e voe tutta indietro!
zebatida 4 years ago
A mí me gustó porque nunca había escuchado esta aria con orquesta, sólo con piano. Thank you!
Cledezma 4 years ago
No le llega ni a los talones a Cecilia Bartoli
lsalv2 4 years ago
Madame Ricciarelli tiene mas ligado(legato) i talento que la Bartoli. Bartoli e una grande cantante seguro, pero Ricciarelli e unica aqui!
ioSonoCallas 4 years ago 2
Ricciarelli unica!!! totalmente ok!!! Il talento de la Ricciarelli immenso!
laurentius76 4 years ago
Merci beaucoup laurentius76 pour ton soutien! J'ai eu l'immense honneur et plaisir de voir ricciarelli à plusieurs reprises sur scène, elle a un charisme et un talent incroyable. Elle a marqué profondement et à tout jamais ma mémoire.
ioSonoCallas 4 years ago
LOL.... siento decirlo, pero no me ha gustado nada. Flojo, flojo, flojo... mucho portamento, poco apoyo, voz muy oscurecida... no sé si es por la mala calidad del audio...pero no me ha gustado. XD
Njamh 4 years ago
Beautiful controlled rendition of this glorious aria by the great Ricciarelli. Beautifully poised and full of emotion. Unfortunately the recording is not of great quality however Katia still shines.
Bainer34 4 years ago