Added: 3 years ago
From: McLovin4real
Views: 62,378
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (486)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • walang kwentang show walang laban sa protege

  • needs more breath support

  • walang kwenta ang judges,.....shame!!!!!

  • shes an okie singer,, but a very bad performer.. like she just didnt do much on stage,, didnt eally feel the song while she was sick..

  • pang karaoke

  • how did she win the idol? mediocre lang ang boses nya.

  • @911766 gov ang erpats e ska voting yan myaman cla

  • binili nya ang boto, taga biliran ako, at alam ko lahat! hehe

  • ahm gretchen ginulat mo ako dun.." that was awful".... im not sure the judges are singers. I mean "real singers"

  • How did she win? It can't be because of her singing..... that was horrible....the judges need to take their ear pieces out. x.x

  • di marunong mag sustain

  • She's good naman eh. It's just that she lacks stage presence and her performances are forgettable.

    Bottomline is - this GMA franchise sucks. I dunno... BAKA if ABS-CBN kumuha nito baka mas successful? Look at Pilipinas Got Talent = very successful franchise, diba?

  • maybe mayaman sa text votes!!!

  • para siyang natatae or something

  • kahit s.o.p. di maka-extra...shes the ultimate disaster champion

  • nanalo lang dahil sa voting.....napaka cheap naman ng pinoy idol for sure....walang kwenta....boses palang walang K! as in K! at quality....nakakahiya....

  • yeah! mas better pa ung NANALO sa PHILIPPINE IDOL! kesa sa PINOY IDOL! >.<

  • para lang clang nakatindig s harap ng videoke s SM ung sa may arcade.haha.mas magagaling pa yung kumakanta sa talentadong pinoy.kesa s mga to

  • napaka daming magagaling n pinoy kumanta bakit mga nakapsok parang mga walang k.marunong lang kumanta mga walang x factor ang boses nuh bayan.

  • ichura ni jolina sa 1:54 parang....haaaaaaaaaayyyyyzzz.­.. hehehehe

  • pinoy idol is the worst idol franchise ever.... the winner wont stand a candle to any american idol finalists....

  • she's one of the members of UP Singing Ambassadors

  • bad bad bad

    

  • ang ganda ng settings.. pero pag sa final 12 pumangit ang stage..

  • The worst Idol winner ever!!!!! And Pinoy Idol is the worst Idol franchise ever! Panget ang host,panget ang mga Judge,panget ang editing,lighting ,stage. walang X factor! I balik sa TV5 ang Idol franchise!

  • @renrono ibalik ang original philippine idol!!!

  • perapera lang yan nako , ung nakuha nya dyan blik taya lang ung lumabas

  • 1:51

  • Comment removed

  • RIP mr tracy

  • kantutin n lng kita.. aus pa

  • panget.... panget na singer, panget pa boses... 

  • dios me day napakahabaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa pang praktis...kinawawa mo ang kanta...wla talaga kwenta sa 7 mg build up

  • for gd sake......my god...ang "singer" daw...."pinoy idol " pa....eh miski aq d aq mgiging fan nian...my ogd......super chaka...walang wala kay mau....ampness.....i was very excited that finally gma will franchise the phil. idol...

    jusko...nung ngsimula na..wla na....im so sad......puro retoke gaga na yan...tsktsk......mau is the best philippine idol.!tpos!

  • sana c JAY-ANN na lang nanalo..

    maryosep tong babaeng to..

    nagSOP yan tas hndi pa LIVE ung kanta?? is that an idol??

  • hay grabe di ko talga typ to kumanta ala naman dating badtrip

  • hinde naman judges ang pumili sa kanya. diko rin sya bet . kya lang, kagagawan ng txter kung bakit sya nanalo. bat nyo ba sinisisi mga judges? mga engot nmn pla kyo. isip nga muna bgo magcomnt......

  • kc may pera kya kahit milyong text kayang gastusin lol... parang money contest bwahhahaa, tama ka anya di judges ang pumili :)

  • hangin sa ilong... pwersa lang ang gnagamit... boring, low pitch, o.a.,.. Ginulat? magdirect k nlang.. whats the connection of expression to the voice quality... nonsense...

  • napakawalang kwenta ng pinoy idol..sorry....kung abs cbn ang humawak ng pinoy idol bka nagkaroon pa ng kwenta to

  • yun na yun? hayss.. walang kakaiba! >.< hindi pang singer nu ba yan! OUTSTANDING na ba yun? err! E MAS MAGANDA PA VERSION NG PINSAN KO NYAN E! tamad lang mag-auditions.. hmf.. HINDI DESERVING..

  • by singing this song, she risked being compared to original Idol, Mau Marcelo. Obviously, Gretchen pales in comparison. Siguro, nagtatawa lang si mau habang pinapanood tong video na to hahaha!

  • bakit ganun??

  • hindi naman sa judges un guys. talagang mayaman lang sila. Biruin mo, governor ata un papa niya. Pero ang gagaling ng mga ka batch niya. Akala ko nga dati sa BUKAS NA LANG KITA MAMAHALIN e tsugi na siya. Parati kaya siya inookray. Wah kasi musicality, stage presence, etc.

  • pag sinabing pinoy idol dapat hangaan at proven na dapat kang idoluhin ka ng mga pinoy when it comes to singing why this???pinoy idol eh ordinaryo lng kumanta.sana ang title nalng nung show nila is judges idol.kc hindi kaidoidolo ang kanta nya.i go to mau marcelo mahiya naman xa kay mau sa pagkanta nya nyan.d nabigyan ng justice

  • ate sana sa banyo kanalng kumanta walang wala kang K PROMISE.ordinary voice walang x factor

  • sya lng ang my project sa gma.. ung iba?? waley na LOL.. lov u chen i lov u so much muah muah muah

  • zzzzzzzzz....

  • nyetang pinoy idol yan

  • dapat sya nanalo.

    watch her na lang sa DIVA

  • ok namn yung version nya huh.. d lg ganun ka ganda... but full of emotions...

  • @ladygreen03 SUSMARYOSEP NA IDOL ITO. PANO NANALO ITO WALANG KA STYLE STYLE KUMANTA. KALA KO MAJORITY NG FILIPINO MAGALING KUMANTA. PATUNAYAN NAMAN NATIN. PANO MISMONG JUDGE DI MAN KARAPAT DAPAT UMUPO SA PANEL. SANA ANG JUDGE ME TENGA SA MAGALING NA PERFORMER. PAGKA GANYAN ANG PINOY IDOL DI ITO TATAGAL GAYA NG IBANG IDOL SA IBANG BANSA. KATAWA TAWA TAYO KASO CLAIM NATIN MARAMI TAYONG MAGAGALING NA SINGERS PERO BAKET ANG ATING IDOL VERSION AY PANIS. SA TOTOO LANG I DONT INTEND TO OFFEND.

  • @sakosana d ko nman cnabi na super galing xa,, sabi ko ok namn ang version nya, my puso.. u dont have to shout para madama mu yung emotions nya sa pagkanta.. i know wat u min walang x factor

  • mayaman kana pala noon pa manahimik kana nadagdagan na nagayun ang yaman mo mahirap ako e

  • tang ina!!! eto ang nanalo? walang kwenta. daming mas magagaling dyan bakit tong babaeng to ang nanalo?

  • ay puta! eto ang nanalo? mas magaling pa kumanta ng on my own katulong namin! mas magaling pa yung bulag na taga iloilo nung auditions pa lang, pero hindi pinasa. hahay...

  • she can sing.. but not as good or versatile as yung penelope.

  • actually palakasan kc ang pinoy idol ..

  • daming sabit.. pakinggan nyo, sintonadong sintonado..

  • there's a lot of filipinos who are better than this champion.. Idol format doesn't work here in the philippines.. mas maganda cguro kung one fone number, may maximum votes lng allowed. kaya ayun, txt ng txt ata pamilya neto.. hehe

  • woooh! this is a boooh for pinoy idol.. how come she won? ..cguro naman yung botohan ay hindi talaga boses ng pilipino, boses yun ng espina's clan.. haha! its a booooh!

  • where is she now?

  • and beside check 2:25 the background and her melody didnt match, see the point, flaws are something you cant remove from a person whose voice isn't suited for the song

  • the song choice is something that isnt meant for her, her voice is not the type for this song.. compare to the original and mau's version, this is no match

  • For me destinct ang boses ni Gretchen!!!

    Alam mo na siya ang kumakantah!!!!

  • yeah true.. mas magaling si mau

  • @monferg1988 agree! ilang doble kaya mas magaling kesa dito..

  • yuck......paborito ko si jolina....pero para yatang bingi silang tatlong judges....lalo na yung matanda...sana maisip nyo si mau marcelo...ewan ko na lang...cguro maputi at mayaman kaya pinapanalo...artistahin daw ha ha ha....akala nila bebenta...ngek...

  • pastilan tawon nganong kani may nkadaug?????? mgkano kaya bnayad ng fmily nya pr maging artista????? di hamak na mas magaling pa ng sampung beses c MAU MARCELO kesa dito!!!!

  • WTF... ito ba yung pinagmamalaki nyon pinoy idol, eh di hamak na mas magaling sila Mau Marcelo... what a mess...

  • nothing Special!!! PpIiiFFF!

  • omg what kind of singer is that

    i dont like her voice her stance her timing her range the quality, i try to watch and listen her on stage in sop just ruin my day

  • is she the winner?why did she won?

  • wahhh...! what the hell was that?? The First PHILIPPINE IDOL WINNER VERSION is so so so better than this... watch the Mau Marcelo version..

  • I really hate her for using her money to win! just wasting my time to view her video. I must proceed to those who are DESERVING!!!

  • saan nya nakuha ung lyrics nya?? 1:28

  • @tenshikuh sa baba di niya kinaka bisado heheheh

  • ba yan..

  • mas maganda siyang walang make up or light lang

  • she doesn't deserve to win.. boring performances and deaf judges!!

  • Huh?? ano daw sabi nya sa 1:27?? nde ko nakuha...

  • she's defn8ly a SONG MURDERER

  • @amhell2008 DAPAT IMPROVING ANG ATING IDOL VERSION BAKET PA WORSE. WALA NA BANG IBANG MAAYOS KUNG DI MAN MAGALING KUMANTA KESA DITO.

  • ataya!!!! ung mga judge hindi marunong mag judge!!!how shameful!!!bwisit....u murdered my song....

  • correct....nakakagulat talaga na nagulat sila hehehe..... fine no comment na nga ako..... sana kumuha ng magaling na judge..... un marunong makinig hehehe

  • fangit naman hehehe.... wala man lang power un voice nya.....ewan....

  • pwe!

  • Pasaway mga judge, ano kaya nakakagulat dito...

  • Oh God, is this the Pinoy Idol? This song was obviously selected to match Mau Marcelo's winning performance, and sadly this Gretchen failed miserably. Ang tawag dyan eh karma for not recognizing Mau, who's far more talented than any of these Pinol Idol contestants combined. You try to watch Mau Marcelo's performance and see for yourself guys.

  • duh season two?! jusme! pera perahan nangyari dito walang magic yung pagkapanalo! MAU pa rin! ayan lugi si GMA hahaha kaya malabo si season two at bumnat pa sila ng "are you the next big star?" hahaha jusme ulit! kamusta naman eh mukhang need gumawa ng magic at kung anu anung anik anik para sumikat sila magaling na mga wanna be performer hahaha! jusme ulit!

    at anu nakakagulat dito ?!

  • .,.sana may season 2 ng pinoy idol!...

  • sana nga

  • lintek.walang kwenta.anu bang klaseng mga judge to..

  • I find her rendition just so-so. Simply because Its hard for me not to compare it with the likes of Mau Marcelo and others who gave this song such a soulful and heartfelt rendition.

    But then again, maybe she was the best in her batch.

  • ang pangit ng arrangement ng kanta nya...

  • omg...wala syang appeal..

    wala rin syang talent!

    not deserving at all!

  • there's something lacking....

  • di xia deserving!!!!!!!!!

  • i hate her so much because she ruined the song of pink in the aniversary of GMA. Gosh ampangit ng pagkanta nya nun. Idol ko po si pink and marami ng kumanta nun na mga singer dito kaso yung kanta niya ang pinaka pangit. I dont like her and her voice. She doesn't deserve the title... BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!

  • weeeee. maraming salamat sa lahat ng nag-aabang sa album launch ni ms. gretchen espina.

    guys eto na! the album that we're all waiting for!!!!!!!

    "SHINING THROUGH under Sony Records this JUly..=)"

    konting paghihintay nalang.....let's all support gretchen espina.

    favor to those who has a video of gretchen during the anniversary of gma (can anyone upload it here? thank you!)

    go ate chen! sobrang lapit na! weee =)

  • talaga anong exact date sa July Irerelease

  • penelope is sooo much better than her..

  • for me both gretchen and penelope are amazingly great

  • i knew it..i think...baka meron talagang rason siguro kaya siya ang tinanghalian..si sue and si penelupe...sigurado may mga kontrata na yun.....hindi naman nila makakalimutan si sue at si penelupe..

  • mga walang kwenta ang mga crirics d2 kaya lawlaw mga pinoy pati judges lawlaw din ..

  • pang fiesta lang tlaga no offense meant..hirap n hirap simpleng birit

  • walang kabuhay buhay

  • korek!

  • Ito pala nanalo? Yong naka violet na judge na strict, bakit kaya parang mabait sya dito, hmmm? Buti na lang magaling sa comedy ang GMA. hehehe.

  • she sucks!!!!

  • o asan na 2ng gretchen na 2? pInoy idol pala hindi man lang alam kilala ng buong sambayanan!

  • shet! wala man sya sa kuko ni CHARICE!

  • punyeta hindi xa idol material.,

  • pilit bumirit eh! panong nanalo to? nagka career ba?

  • she deserved it!!

  • "WTF! did we hear the same thing

    dude she sucks

    LAARNI is soo much better

    they just picked her because she had the looks...

    even i can sing better than that and im 13

  • No, Gretchen is way way better than Laarni.

  • Wala siyang panama sa galing ni Mau Marcelo!

  • Trying Hard maging si Mau Marcelo!

  • kya cguro di n nag-renew GMA for another season , sayang lng ee hehe ... asan n b mga sumali d2 , wla n ata ako nki2ta khit isa lalo n 2ng grand winner n toh , hehe ...

  • does wingard know what he's talking about?

    @ 2:12 she went an octave lower.. and that was unforgivable for an idol winner..

    i wonder how much the family has spent to power vote for her.. LOL

  • She gave her Best on finals

    so I Think she deserved that!

  • ok nmn xa eh.. pwo di super galing.. pwo nice.. pwomis!

  • did she win because shez rich??? did she buy all the votes?? was there any helped or bribes from her governor father?? coz honestly shes not that good..she dont deserve to be the winner.. yeah she can sing but she is not the best... pls!! filipino judges judge by the talent not by the fact that theyre rich!! geez.. theyre bunch of crap.. this is bullshit.. she should have juz entered showbusiness instead of joining this coz she didnt need the money anyway shez already rich..soo unfair !!

  • oh.. she's filthy rich..

    their family has been giving 300pesos worth of prepaid loads to the voters from their province..

    youre right, she should have just entered showbusiness, cauz she is really beautiful in person..

    juz sad cauz..

    this show is suppose to be as brilliant as american idol..

  • shes not even that pretty... i dont think she has that star quality but all those freakin crawler people will try their best to put her on top of everything...

  • she is not that beautiful on screen..

    but she is pretty in person..

  • ano bayan... ang pangit ng pinoy idol... mga judges ay hindi mga deserving na maging judges...

  • this show is a joke!

    from the judges to the contestants..

    hahaha.. parang comedy show to eh.. lol

  • honestly, i didnt like it..

    juz so sad cauz..

    she's the reigning "pinoy idol"..

    and if there will be an asian/world idol,

    she will represent our country..

    if she sings there,

    other countries will discriminate us again..

  • sumikat ang pda dito sa pinas pero sa america 2 weeks palang kinancel na ung show. wala tuloy winner.

  • sinayang lang nila ang show na to... ang dami pang pwedeng pagpiliin... the impact of this song is the middle part lang... sori!!!!

  • hi chen...

    i miss you..

    i met her family at napakabait nila..

    down to earth..

    you are great chen..

    dito lang lagi kuya greg mo..

    idol ka namin..

    we love you...

  • dapat 70 to 90% galing sa mga judges hindi sa texting lang! that's why i hate reality shows that require texting... grrr.... opinion ko lang to..

  • hai nako.,

    boring.,

    mas maganda Ung version jan ni mau.,

    Ang FIRST PHILIPPINE IDOL!!!

    hahaha!

    agree ba kau mga friends??

  • siguro wala nang pinoy idol 2??hindi maganda naging result ng 1 ih..o baka hindi pa lang sumisikat si gretchen??popularity contest kasi..di xa popular,pero nalamangan nya yung iba sa votes.. :)

  • pag umuwi siguro ako Phils... I will surely win if my parents will sell my inheritance just to buy votes... hahaha

  • she's acting not singing..

  • no comment.:)

  • cheapppp...

  • 224abc123

    "magaling pa ako dyan"

    yabang moh din eh nuh? sigurado ka bang mas magaling ka sakanya? baka naman wala kang ibubuga at pagyayabang lang ang alam moh...

  • ano vah nmn toh ala wenta mgaling ung kpit bhay nmin sknya eh tsaka ung mga judge shunga eh ang dming mggaling jn...although she got nice skin kc nga nmn myaman pero voice hmmm ok lng... sorry sa mga fans nia huh im just saying the fact that she really doesnt have the quality

  • Yan ba ang pinagmamalaki nilang first pinoy idol... "anong very good"!!!! mga judges...di magagaling...

    Panget!!! Magaling pa ko dyan!!

    at marami pang mga talent na magaling dyan!!

  • masyadu naman po syang emotionallllllllll....but not the song i feel , is to song dapat for him

  • she's got the voice but she doesnt know how to bring it out...she keeps it on her throat..she's controlling it

  • she can sing but shes not good.. obviously the result was manipulated or they really spent a lot of money for the text vote just to win the contest..

    where's the essence of the contest here? too bad!

  • mas magagaling pa yung kumakanta sa karaoke sa powerstation... hay naku...

  • Pop Idol isnt on now is it? cus theres X Factor now its similar to it but its racking ratings tho....

  • ...no words can explain how much this girl sucks. she only got in because her father works for the GOVERNMENT. GIVE ME A BREAK!

  • Hi guys, i didn't know that we have this show as well. C'mon, PinoyS are good singers! We can do it!

  • Hindi ko naabutan ito. Kailan nagsimula ang Pinoy Idol? Kasi umalis ako from the Philippines 5/6 years ago. Sa tingin ko mababa masyado ang boses nya...pero okay lang.

  • ...

    asan na sya?!...

    bkt ndi na sya nag-eexist sa music industry?!.

    duh!.naturingan pa nmn 1st PINOY IDOL(daw!)

    :]]

    tsk!.panu nlng pag-natuloy ung asian idol season 2?!.

    edi lalo nang walang pag-asa kung si mau na MAS magaling jn ky gretch. ndi nanalo.

    what more kung xa pa?!

    this is just my opinion:DD.

  • oo nga eh, sa vote p naman ang basis nun..haha..si charice n lang panlaban natin, pero may season 2 p daw ng Pinoy Idol pero early 2010 p daw un, sawson 2 muna ng SP!

  • mababa boses nya ala kwenta noh b yan

  • duh... PINOY IDOL sucks... for real... mas maganda pa nga ang PINOY POP SUPERSTAR e,...!!!!!!

    ibalik na ang Philippine idol....

  • d niya kaya bumirit ng mataas...

  • the judges sucks! even the director! camera shots are so old school! even wilma galvante sucks the overall in-charge for casting! so dissappointing.......!!!!! philippines idol is far better than pinoy idol,, from the judges to directors and contestants.... a BIG DISAPPOINTMENT !!!

  • i agree with brazillian.

    mau is better than gretchen.

  • Guys!! Bad News f0r us FILIPINOS!!

    Kasi Magkakar0on ng ASIAN IDOL 2. Ive read it that it will happen on October or November!!

    Eh bakit Bad News c0z our rep will be Gretchen Espina. HELLO!! Anu nalang sasabihin ng mga other countries satin.

    U know naman who and what is Gretchen is capable of. No talent, No voice, Hindi man nga sikat!! She just won because of MONEY.. And we all know that.

  • Gosh! Kunt tutoo itong Asian Idol, I hope huwag matuloy ang pagpapadala kay Gretchen as representative! She is just not good. Hindi naman kasi siguro maganda ang mentorship ng GMA7 sa contestants di tulad ng American Idol na kitangkita ang transformation ng contestants from raw talent to professional performance level.

  • sa october o november pa naman eh, hindi lang basta ipapadala dun si gretchen sa asian idol na tulad ng ipinakita niya sa pinoy idol, i'm sure idadan ng gma7 sa intense and hard training si gretchen bago ipadala sa asian idol

  • Hay!! Im worried Baka sabihin nila wala ng Talent ang Phil.

    Gretcen I know u that u dont deseve it!! Pls back-0ut!!

    Mga Gagu din kasi ung JUDGES!!! Lahat ng bumuo Jan!!

  • goddd.. xa ba champion? GMA tlga oh lol

  • CONGRATULATIONS To RAM FOR BEING THE 1ST IDOL TO DO A THEME SONG FOR A GMA TELENOVELA (UNA KANG NAGING AKIN ) AND 1ST IDOL FINALIST TO RECORD AN ALBUM AND WRITE ALL 11 SONGS OF THE ALBUM TO BE RELEASED THIS 1ST QUARTER OF 2009 DISTRIBUTED BY VIVA RECORDS.RAMCHAVESBAND ROCKS!GOOD LUCK SA CARRIER SINGLE NA " HIWAGA "

  • Mudsville1-halatang bobo kang viewer. wlang alam sa music. sinu-sinu ba ang mga judges ng PDA? Ryan Cayabyab, Kitchie Molina and Monet Silvestre.mga teacher ng voice. goodluck nman sau. d mu ata kilala ang mga to. e sa GMA- Jolina? DTOSME. e singing career nga nia, ndi nia macriticize, sa iba p kya. basta jologs ang GMA. ewan koba. pangMASA tlga. e krmihan sa MASA jologs. wlang taste. khit sa mga soaps.. chaka. purompambata. npaghahalataang mababa ang taste ng pgi2ng viewer mu.

  • mas magaling pa yung top 6 ng PDA!!!

  • mas magaling sa pagkokolekta ng basurahan ang top 6 ng pda mo

  • yikes ito ba nanalo? kadiri naman ang gma di mas hamak na mas magaling si penelope!!! bingi yata yung mga judges! hahaha poor gma!

  • she's cute! but she's good in recycling song from tha fiest original season of philippine idol.. the entire gma pinoy idol is a complete mess! shame on them! meron bang talent search na unlimited ang voting? pano naman ung mga mahihirap na mas magaling pa kay grech?

  • she's is so kind kahit mayaman siya.. sobrang down to earth..

    grabe..

    she's blessed..we love you chen..go!

  • nakakatawa missmaganda..

    halata na insecure ka.

    i met her and she's pretty ano.

    napakabait...

    i wqatched her concert with aogi and malubay ang galing..sobra..

  • Ba't nakangiti habang kinakanta 'yan. Hawig sya kay Pokwang who is also a good singer.

  • hawig siya kay pokwang who is also a good singer, i love pokwang which means i love gretchen too.

  • haha.,.

    tapos n ang competition eh.,.,

    wala n kaung mggwa., khit ako ayaw ko sknya pero wla n akong mggwa eh.,

    ganyan tlg.,.,

    hmm.,., be happy nlang. goodluck sa tanang career bhe.

    -----------------

    wag k nlng kakanta s sop/.,.

    pnira k eh.,.,

  • judges ba yn??? hindi marunong magjudge..siguro natakot sa dad nyan.. di ba congressman???