"Rrose Sélavy", così firmò il suo corto Marcel, con un gioco di parole su "Eros, c'est la vie", e con un altro anagramma creò il titolo: anémic=cinéma. In maniera provocatoria e ludica rompeva con il concetto tradizionale di cinema come arte visiva e narrativa : il suo è un cinema assolutamente libero, slegato dal senso, che pone il caso e l'immaginazione alla base della creazione artistica, in linea con le idee dissacratorie delle avanguardie artistiche, specie Dada. Ma la musica??Di chi è?
@gianbiv:@gianbiv : veramente su una cosa devo contraddirti,Rrose Sèlavy non riguarda per niente la firma del primo corto di Marcel, perchè l'opera in discussione si riferisce ad una foto, dove Duchamp è ritratto in vesti femminili,dalla la foto emergono elementi importanti, le mani non sono le sue ma bensì della moglie di PICABIA', e la foto è stata appunto scattata da PICABIA', come gli stessi vestiti che indossa sono della moglie dello stesso. E' una foto dedicata appunto all'eros per la vita
"DADA speaks with you, it is everything, it envelops everything, it belongs to every religion, can be neither victory or defeat, it lives in space and not in time."
I am in love with this video! It is so fascinating. I think the music goes perfectly...it gives one the feeling of anticipation. I wish I could read what those lines said though...is it translated anywhere?
@dgivy I am a francophone and I cannot translate the lines. Duchamp played on the double sense of words. For example, at 5:48, ''Moi j'avais l'habite en spirale'' could be translated as ''Myself, I had the lives in spiral'', which makes no sense, even in French. The play on words suggests that he had '' la bite en spirale '' (so, his dick in spiral). You can translate the one at 5:19 by (the following comment)
Thank you so much for taking the time to respond to my inquiry! This clip is terribly interesting...I am sure it was thoroughly enjoyed in it's time, and still holds a certain trippy simplicity today. I like both versions of your translation. I could see that ''Myself, I had the lives in spiral'' could take on many poetic meanings. Then again, so could "La bite en spirale" I suppose :) Again, let me thank you...your translation enhanced this video enormously!
@alohamaari Apparently it doesn't translate properly into English, there is an essay on possible multiple meanings online somewhere...can't find the link though sorry. Try searching your question google
Using chord progressions of the 'Western tradition' (that are highly symbolistic) in a Futuristic film that is highly anti-developmental, directionless, with absence of contextual relationships is not so smart!Why do you think Satie`s music in Entr'acte fits the film just right?Because the chords SUCCEED each other, they do not PROGRESS.....Read Experimental Music by Michael Nyman.Good stuff!
I highly doubt this film could be considered futuristic, "highly anti-developmental, directionless, with absence of contextual relationships" it's a precise description of Dada. Even if the futurism worked more often with geometrical figures and visual illusions, it was a very structured art, "ceci n'a queu ni tête".
Thanks for this video! I always wanted to see the roto-blades in motion.
But what is it that people that love contemporary art have such bad taste in music? The banal and badly performed guitar cliché-music doesn't go together with it. Duchamp and the music have ompletely different aesthetics.
I second, or third, the motion to turn the music off when watching this. I'm shocked that Kino would add a soundtrack to it. The reason to turn off the soundtrack is not whether you like the music or not. It's pleasant enough. But do you go to the Louvre to look at the Mona Lisa wearing earbuds listening to Leo Kottke? If there were sound available in 1926, Duchamp *MIGHT* have added sound. But it wouldn't have been this, that's for sure. This is his work and it should be viewed like he made it.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
This is bad. There, I said it. I'm not intellectual enough to understand the delicate beauty of black and white circles with French shit written on them turning around. I'll never be as intelligent as you people. I hope this makes you feel better about yourselves; that seems to be the only purpose the avantgarde serves.
I agree, but this is the music provided on the Avant Garde Cinema of the 20's & 30's DVD release. If you have a problem contact Kino Video or turn off the sound.
Nice, but I must say I prefer the installations, colour really adds to this piece. I think what's interesting about this piece and it's related installations, when it's compared to Duchamps more famous work, is that it's so aesthetically pleasing. Personally I find it quite fulfilling to know Duchamp wasn't all ready-mades, chess and stubborn disinterest.
@MrFishus oh I am sure that's what people from the 11th century would ask you about ur ttaste in music.and to me this ok .pretty much what you hear from bands these days and for my generation this would be considered golden oldies or old school.have a nice day :)
@expatleanie Also, I don't think many people in the 11th century listened to music too often, since there was no recording technology as of yet, and peasants were in general too poor to affort musical instruments and/or musical education at the time. Not to mention that they usually died at the age of around 30.
@MrFishus oh I am sure that's what people from the 11th century would ask you about ur taste in music.and to me this ok .pretty much what you hear from bands these days and for my generation this would be considered golden oldies or old school.have a nice day :)
It's very very difficult to translate what he is saying correctly into any language. I would recommend the essay by Katrina Martin for translating into english, though.
The music is contemporary. I would assume that the film was originally a silent film, and for this DVD collection, music was composed...? Would anyone happen to know if there was ever original music?
without doubt the music is wrong. The duchamp piece is amazing. The music leads it astray and renders it meaningless by virtual. This video should be removed as it totally confuses the essence of duchamps work.
Regarding the music, well the film is from 1926, and I feel it deserves something more macabre opposed to the folky meanderings of the guitarist. Just my opinion that's all.
I think the music is interesting and should definitely not be taken away, especially when there is a mute button and several other versions without music. In a sense, what we have here is editing which displays exactly how much music effects film. This is a new reading of this film, focusing on the simple repetitive beauty of Anemic Cinema, highlighted by the repetitive music. It may not display Duchamps original intentions but neither does, arguably, reading Hamlet in a psychoanalytical manner.
Non fa nulla, cmq non studio cinema nello specifico, ma all'università stiamo studiando il futurismo cinematico e qui rientrano questi film d'avanguardia ;)
be divertitevi! io ho un debole per queste cose, le ho fatte quando ho studiato al primo anno il cinema delle origini, e abbiamo trattato anche il cinema d'arte o delle avanguardie.
This has been flagged as spam show
amazing .. thanks for sharing .. god bless
fivequotes 6 days ago
This goes so much better with "Roller Coaster" by the 13th Floor Elevators.
Saskatchewan00 2 weeks ago
what dvd did you get this from?
MichaelHansenFUN 3 weeks ago
La musique est composé et interprété par Donald Sosin.
Donald Sosin et Joanna Seaton proposent et interprètent des musiques pour les films silencieux.
Leur site: silent-film-music (Youtube refuse les hyperliens dans les commentaires...)
Important:
A l'origine, la projection de Anemic Cinema était silencieux!
TheCaillard 1 month ago
Comment removed
TheCaillard 1 month ago
Esquivons les ecchymoses des Esquimaux aux mots exquis.
rosemonfort 1 month ago
I love. ♥
Babintone 2 months ago
Great - thanks for sharing
PorroFirst 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
There is a new Dada, London Dada. We are kick stARTing the new millenium.
Moral protest and perception. Just as in 1916, when the art world changes the world will change.
LondonDada 2 months ago
I keep playing this over and over and over and over and over. I don't know why!!!!
castoni2 2 months ago 2
@castoni2 Hypnosis
AntoineBoy 2 months ago
Non c'è alcuna correlazione, né affinità, tra musica e immagini. Voto per la scelta del sonoro: 2
cataleo1 3 months ago
is this the whole film? someone knows whre to find the torrent of it
mikarapeyoureyes 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
thanks for the post rock theme
Chakademus 3 months ago
Comment removed
Chakademus 3 months ago
would reccomend this /watch?v=NUqnPYwoiF4&feature=related
FromTartu 3 months ago
this song dosent fit here at all
FromTartu 3 months ago
what song is this?
selshaffei 4 months ago 8
@selshaffei nobady knows what song is it?
BloodedKnife 2 months ago
@BloodedKnife Duchamp made this a silent film.
bruniquel 1 month ago 2
@selshaffei s'il vous plait,
mute is so much better
bain donc
entityforeclosure 2 weeks ago
@selshaffei It's Explosions in the Sky!!!! Don't know the title of the song off-hand.
bernhardsart 4 days ago
me encantaría con subtítulos en spanish... pero igual, es muy bueno, me encanta el DADA!!!
may3764 4 months ago
"Rrose Sélavy", così firmò il suo corto Marcel, con un gioco di parole su "Eros, c'est la vie", e con un altro anagramma creò il titolo: anémic=cinéma. In maniera provocatoria e ludica rompeva con il concetto tradizionale di cinema come arte visiva e narrativa : il suo è un cinema assolutamente libero, slegato dal senso, che pone il caso e l'immaginazione alla base della creazione artistica, in linea con le idee dissacratorie delle avanguardie artistiche, specie Dada. Ma la musica??Di chi è?
gianbiv 4 months ago 2
@gianbiv di John Cage
kapone10zx 3 months ago
@gianbiv:@gianbiv : veramente su una cosa devo contraddirti,Rrose Sèlavy non riguarda per niente la firma del primo corto di Marcel, perchè l'opera in discussione si riferisce ad una foto, dove Duchamp è ritratto in vesti femminili,dalla la foto emergono elementi importanti, le mani non sono le sue ma bensì della moglie di PICABIA', e la foto è stata appunto scattata da PICABIA', come gli stessi vestiti che indossa sono della moglie dello stesso. E' una foto dedicata appunto all'eros per la vita
saturamente 3 months ago
"DADA speaks with you, it is everything, it envelops everything, it belongs to every religion, can be neither victory or defeat, it lives in space and not in time."
(Francis Picabia)
vondelpark1973 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
No way this is the music provided on the DVD release, if so the responsable must die!
Setherian 4 months ago
Comment removed
Setherian 4 months ago
Magnifique!
acida17 4 months ago
I want to see so idertsing expermental videos of present days
argver 5 months ago in playlist early experimental cinema
... Copyrighted by Rrose Sélavy
en(dot)wikipedia(dot)org/wiki/Rrose_Sélavy
NicleT 5 months ago
I am in love with this video! It is so fascinating. I think the music goes perfectly...it gives one the feeling of anticipation. I wish I could read what those lines said though...is it translated anywhere?
dgivy 6 months ago
@dgivy the words mean nothing really. when translated the words dont make sense in their own sentences and dont relate to any of the other lines
calumrb22 6 months ago
@dgivy I am a francophone and I cannot translate the lines. Duchamp played on the double sense of words. For example, at 5:48, ''Moi j'avais l'habite en spirale'' could be translated as ''Myself, I had the lives in spiral'', which makes no sense, even in French. The play on words suggests that he had '' la bite en spirale '' (so, his dick in spiral). You can translate the one at 5:19 by (the following comment)
FourteenInTheMAking 4 months ago
@FourteenInTheMAking
Thank you so much for taking the time to respond to my inquiry! This clip is terribly interesting...I am sure it was thoroughly enjoyed in it's time, and still holds a certain trippy simplicity today. I like both versions of your translation. I could see that ''Myself, I had the lives in spiral'' could take on many poetic meanings. Then again, so could "La bite en spirale" I suppose :) Again, let me thank you...your translation enhanced this video enormously!
dgivy 4 months ago
@dgivy 5:19 = '' Among our articles of lazy hardware, we recommend the faucet that stops flowing when you don't listen to it. ''
FourteenInTheMAking 4 months ago 3
@FourteenInTheMAking
Thank you so much! I absolutely love the translation! It makes this video so poetic. Cheers!
dgivy 4 months ago
fanculo..a me la musica piace..
seedsacidpsycho 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
He is one of my favorite artists check out my art blog: readymade-fountain (dot) blogspot (dot) com
slthlrdz 6 months ago
yeah, the music sucks
Nanushkia 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
If you enjoy this please check out my channel.
kanzelone 7 months ago
The music sucks.
Refrescospepito 8 months ago
Is this the original music? The first couple of bars sound like "Corduroy" by Pearl Jam. I wonder if this was an influence.
humbucker08 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
as it is called the DVD that has all these videos (movies)??
insoporhcp 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
as it is called the DVD that has all these videos (movies)??
insoporhcp 8 months ago
as it is called the DVD that has all these videos (movies)?
insoporhcp 8 months ago
Comment removed
dramatizetheworld 9 months ago
too happy song for a dada work... i think it was better a psychedelic/sperimental song
MorbosDevilGrinder 9 months ago
Una de las mejores piezas del siglo XX que los cineticos han sabido muy bien recuoerar, al final la historia siempre pone las cosas en su sitio.
Acindinos 9 months ago
Esquivons les ecchymoses des Esquimaux aux mots exquis
Avez-vous déjà mis la moëlle de l'épée dans le poêle de l'aimée?
Parmi nos articles de quincaillerie par essence, nous recommandons le robinet qui s'arrête de couler quand on ne l'écoute pas
L'aspirant habite Javel et moi j'avais l'habite en spirale
PereBoniface 11 months ago
Bains de gros thé pour grains de beauté sans trop de bengué
L'enfant qui tète est un souffleur de chair chaude et n'aime pas le chou-fleur de serre-chaude
Si je te donne un sou, me donneras-tu une paire de ciseaux?
On demande des moustiques domestiques (demi-stock) pour la cure d'azote sur la côte d'azur
Inceste ou passion de famille, à coups trop tirés
PereBoniface 11 months ago
It's Marcel ... The Best ... The Greatest ......... The Universe <3333
KishoAudioVisual 11 months ago
can anybody translate the french texts?
alohamaari 1 year ago
@alohamaari Wikipedia does
Sylanze 11 months ago
@alohamaari Apparently it doesn't translate properly into English, there is an essay on possible multiple meanings online somewhere...can't find the link though sorry. Try searching your question google
LEOSAYSAYS 11 months ago
Ace, I love it
LEOSAYSAYS 1 year ago
speechless...
CraterMuffin 1 year ago
check out this sweet marcel duchamp t shirt!
at red bubble!
jaseguitar1 1 year ago
what is the song called during this film?
RocketFistband 1 year ago
♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥
malvinstar 1 year ago
still so inspiring!! especially the music.
Egberdien64 1 year ago
put some subs. haha please I liked but I couldn´t understand at all. sorry . but grate job for the upload .
mindi3 1 year ago
Futuristic in the irony. He saw the raise of Hollywood and how it will gangrene cinema.
LQueb 1 year ago
art will never die.....
Thejohnjackjoe 1 year ago
Just great!
willyshakur 1 year ago
Make you soundtrack bitches, lets see what you got.
Guitarbailey204 1 year ago
Using chord progressions of the 'Western tradition' (that are highly symbolistic) in a Futuristic film that is highly anti-developmental, directionless, with absence of contextual relationships is not so smart!Why do you think Satie`s music in Entr'acte fits the film just right?Because the chords SUCCEED each other, they do not PROGRESS.....Read Experimental Music by Michael Nyman.Good stuff!
sophocha 1 year ago
@sophocha
I highly doubt this film could be considered futuristic, "highly anti-developmental, directionless, with absence of contextual relationships" it's a precise description of Dada. Even if the futurism worked more often with geometrical figures and visual illusions, it was a very structured art, "ceci n'a queu ni tête".
G0parra 1 year ago
l love marcel duchamp he was so ahead of his time:))
dubstar456 1 year ago
the music is perfect, stop complaining like a bunch of pussies.
Sophistaphunk 1 year ago
Thanks to the uploader. Music is annoying but easily mutable. I can't believe Kino did this!
prbilger 1 year ago
Anemic is a good title for this. Sorry, I know this is a classic, and avant garde for the time, but....
textcavation 1 year ago
what a ugly music nooooooooooo
susanitalugano 1 year ago
Much respect to Pierre Pinoncelli for containing the Duchamp religion of fraudulence.
beradification 1 year ago
es una obra de arte... me encanto :) solo nose que dicen en esos "mensajes" xD! pero en fin una buena y bella obra
electronica2014 1 year ago
Duchamp we miss you
rosiejenny 1 year ago
this is a test
bartschoenmakers1 1 year ago
what does the french spirals say?
fruhko 1 year ago
@fruhko spirals are not french
beradification 1 year ago
@fruhko it's all puns and alliteration. None of it really makes any sense
Punk13405 1 year ago
great !
NUDEbox 1 year ago
Love Ryan Larkin!!!!!
a Good Canadian!!!!!
great vid!!!
backwoodsgps 1 year ago
eh!
Huffinearts 1 year ago
Well...we know where the twilight zone got the into from
SABRENOSE 1 year ago
fascist music that eats the video. it turned this into pop.
aura113 1 year ago
annoying guitar
Roopfert 1 year ago
I just turn off the sound and listen to 4:33 by John Cage
FORD5000solo2001 1 year ago 69
@FORD5000solo2001 where can I download a copy?
mcmanusdown 1 year ago
@FORD5000solo2001 Ha good one...I cannot believe there are MP3's of it on Ubu
SABRENOSE 1 year ago
@FORD5000solo2001 mate that's so fucked up. im going to try it too...xd
LENIN990 1 year ago
Thanks for this video! I always wanted to see the roto-blades in motion.
But what is it that people that love contemporary art have such bad taste in music? The banal and badly performed guitar cliché-music doesn't go together with it. Duchamp and the music have ompletely different aesthetics.
So I turned of the sound and could enjoy Duchamp
roparre 1 year ago
this video is best if you listen merzbow! 4REAL! (I did it)
noisesionoise 1 year ago 2
Don't you know it's Lou Reed
pushiwallboy 1 year ago
It's better without sound.
animula88 1 year ago
I second, or third, the motion to turn the music off when watching this. I'm shocked that Kino would add a soundtrack to it. The reason to turn off the soundtrack is not whether you like the music or not. It's pleasant enough. But do you go to the Louvre to look at the Mona Lisa wearing earbuds listening to Leo Kottke? If there were sound available in 1926, Duchamp *MIGHT* have added sound. But it wouldn't have been this, that's for sure. This is his work and it should be viewed like he made it.
harvardkarbodie 1 year ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is bad. There, I said it. I'm not intellectual enough to understand the delicate beauty of black and white circles with French shit written on them turning around. I'll never be as intelligent as you people. I hope this makes you feel better about yourselves; that seems to be the only purpose the avantgarde serves.
HammerOvThor 1 year ago
@HammerOvThor
y.a.w.n.
Marenqo 1 year ago
Indeed, my friend.
HammerOvThor 1 year ago
horrible music.
dominustecum 1 year ago
Who permited himself to rape this experimental film with this awful music?
Adding or changing content from an audio visual work is illegal. Please delete this music or charges will be proceeded against you.
Fapsamup 1 year ago
I agree, but this is the music provided on the Avant Garde Cinema of the 20's & 30's DVD release. If you have a problem contact Kino Video or turn off the sound.
mrratigan 1 year ago 34
@mrratigan nah, I'd rather complain here.
supravista 1 year ago
Who's going to press charges? You?
HammerOvThor 1 year ago
Cual es el nombre de la canción?? whats the name of the song?
burroreloaded81 2 years ago
Imagines que ce cercle, ces cercles, soient toi, tes expériences, et ta vie.
Retour incessant vers le point de départ, vers ton essence.
(Inspirated by Hegel and Simon)
librestlaliberte 2 years ago
it looks much like if it was made with a computer, although computers did not even exist in 1920's
PabloPlacebo 2 years ago
the music does not suck. maybe i'm too used to it?
Xcokedav096 2 years ago
omg 1920s.
Ioveasy 2 years ago
Nice, but I must say I prefer the installations, colour really adds to this piece. I think what's interesting about this piece and it's related installations, when it's compared to Duchamps more famous work, is that it's so aesthetically pleasing. Personally I find it quite fulfilling to know Duchamp wasn't all ready-mades, chess and stubborn disinterest.
Metamusik 2 years ago
Ah! solo puedo pensar en una sola persona... Bonito, bonito.
RanitayUvita 2 years ago
real facsinating film! fond of it just like the computer generated art today! love Duchamp
nathen607 2 years ago
Who the hell added the goddamn music!?
MrFishus 2 years ago 6
It's the soundtrack that comes with the DVD.
FuriousEggs 2 years ago
FOR SHAME!!!
MrFishus 2 years ago
well... I guess its not too hard to hit the mute button.
MrFishus 2 years ago 2
@MrFishus oh I am sure that's what people from the 11th century would ask you about ur ttaste in music.
expatleanie 1 year ago
@MrFishus oh I am sure that's what people from the 11th century would ask you about ur ttaste in music.and to me this ok .pretty much what you hear from bands these days and for my generation this would be considered golden oldies or old school.have a nice day :)
expatleanie 1 year ago
@expatleanie Thankyou. For bringing up a valid and sound point. However, it is Irrelevant and has nothing to do with my previous statement.
This has nothing to do with my taste in music, but the fact that this is a visual work of art, originally created with no sound.
The fact that it is being spliced with someone else than the creator's music diminishes its value.
Also, the music doen't seem to correlate wit the artist's intentions or style at all.
Still... The mute button isn't far off.
MrFishus 1 year ago
@expatleanie Also, I don't think many people in the 11th century listened to music too often, since there was no recording technology as of yet, and peasants were in general too poor to affort musical instruments and/or musical education at the time. Not to mention that they usually died at the age of around 30.
MrFishus 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@MrFishus oh I am sure that's what people from the 11th century would ask you about ur taste in music.and to me this ok .pretty much what you hear from bands these days and for my generation this would be considered golden oldies or old school.have a nice day :)
expatleanie 1 year ago
love it
ThatSArtFolks 2 years ago
donald sosin noo
elliexyzlee 2 years ago
This music is amazingly bad for this film. I am shocked every time I see this.
SUICIDEDEATHCULT 2 years ago 6
placed into my playlist of Marcel Duchamp, thanks
meesterschilders 2 years ago
This is a film made by Marcel Duchamp, Man Ray and Mare Allégret.
Odyzea 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this is nice, the sound track goes really well with his work. nice!
seanarrative 2 years ago
if you like to see the cinema history watch *BIRTH OF CINEMA* in youtube and enjoy!!
spirmessi 2 years ago
Bien qu'on ne parle pas français, c'est formidable!!! merci beaucoup!!!
armeniabaja 2 years ago
Where can I find a translation? I don't read french!
Solomente l'Italiana...
ThomasFMPayne 2 years ago
It's very very difficult to translate what he is saying correctly into any language. I would recommend the essay by Katrina Martin for translating into english, though.
weirdhotshot 2 years ago
"Larry Marotta: Silent Movie Soundtracks Vol. 1:
Solo guitar scores for the silent films Anemic Cinema (1926, Marcel Duchamp)".
jturnover 2 years ago
Who performs the background music for this? I would love to hear more of their composistions!
sblaney66 2 years ago
Well, some films had scores that went with them, even if the ACTUAL film was silent. I'm thinking for example of Vertov's Man with a Movie Camera.
demainneviendra 2 years ago
The music is contemporary. I would assume that the film was originally a silent film, and for this DVD collection, music was composed...? Would anyone happen to know if there was ever original music?
demainneviendra 2 years ago
perfect sound!
mik3la88 2 years ago 2
And for 1926, this music is just so visionnaire.
Merci Marcel (et Man Ray, très probablement).
gousse111 2 years ago
At the risk of disagreeing, I seriously disagree : Ifound it fabulous, the movie as well as the music.
And since when does an artist have to do pieces that fit with his work ?
That's his work, right ? then it fits.
gousse111 2 years ago
Did anyone think to turn the volume.... off?
Iamfoltzy 2 years ago
music sucks!!!!!!
SACRILEGE!!!!!!!
Noroxyn 2 years ago
This music is blasphemous!
Liasad 2 years ago 4
I agree with you. This cliché music doesn't belong to the film. Cage would suit its purpose better
bitachar 2 years ago 2
i saw this film at an art museum, and this is the music that accompanied it.
AnyaInTheBanya 2 years ago 4
without doubt the music is wrong. The duchamp piece is amazing. The music leads it astray and renders it meaningless by virtual. This video should be removed as it totally confuses the essence of duchamps work.
transphormetic 2 years ago 2
thanks for posting this but the music really is WRONG!
martindishwater 2 years ago
nice video, but the music really sucks :P
praqmelissa 2 years ago
music sucks
bddgm 2 years ago
Very nice...
azulo65 2 years ago 3
Don't like the music.
andresgualdron 2 years ago 4
you could have added smth like...
Cinema Strange ..
that fits even the title *.*
or even a smth classical...
nice vid ..^.^
Wolfchapman 2 years ago
The electric guitar was a respose to the aestehtic desires expressed by these artists, it apt.
KENKENNIFF 2 years ago
Really? I think it's wholly incompatible.
shazam99 2 years ago 2
Why ?
KENKENNIFF 2 years ago
Firstly if you've posted this - thankyou
Regarding the music, well the film is from 1926, and I feel it deserves something more macabre opposed to the folky meanderings of the guitarist. Just my opinion that's all.
shazam99 2 years ago 5
I agree. Some John Cage, Schaeffer, or even one of Duchamp's pieces.
glun 2 years ago 4
I really enjoy the music..its pretty!
still210 2 years ago
music doesn't go with it.
DeathShamans 2 years ago 3
ありがとう。thank you.
chitantubouchi 2 years ago 2
I think the music is interesting and should definitely not be taken away, especially when there is a mute button and several other versions without music. In a sense, what we have here is editing which displays exactly how much music effects film. This is a new reading of this film, focusing on the simple repetitive beauty of Anemic Cinema, highlighted by the repetitive music. It may not display Duchamps original intentions but neither does, arguably, reading Hamlet in a psychoanalytical manner.
kidfromkibble 2 years ago 5
PLEASE LEAVE SILENT (or at least add some music that would be relevant...based in the time period maybe?)
grasswitharoot 2 years ago
I love the music.
Also the complaining people, too stupid to understand volume controls are hilarious, trite and desperate to find offense where none is intended.
The music is on the Kino DVD "Avant-Garde vol 1" that this film was stolen from.
NathanSt 2 years ago 4
destroying a beautifully subtle artwork by adding super banal music, that has no relation to the piece is a really bad thing to do.
benmeyk 3 years ago 24
Thank you. Ugh. Let's score a Maya Deren movie with a song by Hootie and the Blowfish!
DustinReynaud 3 years ago 5
Heartily agreed.
The music is atrociously incommensurate to the content.
ChadSmith1452 3 years ago 6
oh my god, you guys are awesome. I love you. XD
casanovahagfish 3 years ago
Absolutly, what is it with people these days, they have to add some rediculous Indie to everything.
akeefe 2 years ago 3
@benmeyk
THANK YOU!
jehouse 1 year ago
@benmeyk
bartschoenmakers1 1 year ago
@benmeyk yes i really don't know why you couldn't have just muted it and moved on
Bayplaces 1 year ago
i agree with jayro... the music fucks it up.
LesAus 3 years ago
this film doesn\t need any music, especially not one, which would add a kitch type of sentiment.
jayropinsky 3 years ago
questi film me li hanno fatti vedere a lezione all'università, però le musiche erano diverse.
EDRJHBREUYFHREBUYF 3 years ago
Perchè questi film eran muti, la musika viene aggiunta adesso per questioni visive. Ma dovrebbero essere muti.
shidolionheart 3 years ago
allora anche i film spagnoli surrealisti come un chien andalou...
EDRJHBREUYFHREBUYF 3 years ago
Yeeessss :)
shidolionheart 3 years ago
fai cinema anche tu come me per caso?
EDRJHBREUYFHREBUYF 3 years ago
scusa ho guardato il tuo canale adesso, nn sapevo fossi uno dei cosidetti channel...ti ho fatto una domanda un po sciocca prima...
EDRJHBREUYFHREBUYF 3 years ago
Non fa nulla, cmq non studio cinema nello specifico, ma all'università stiamo studiando il futurismo cinematico e qui rientrano questi film d'avanguardia ;)
shidolionheart 3 years ago
be divertitevi! io ho un debole per queste cose, le ho fatte quando ho studiato al primo anno il cinema delle origini, e abbiamo trattato anche il cinema d'arte o delle avanguardie.
EDRJHBREUYFHREBUYF 3 years ago
ok grazie. In effetti sono parecchio interessanti :)
shidolionheart 3 years ago