Added: 2 years ago
From: amandapalmer
Views: 8,326
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (41)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • she's got lungs of steel! O__O

    i get out of breath after the first two lines... xD

  • Good dancing from Elyas :)

  • Holy hell, that was amazing.

  • why the hell there is "yes" written on her cleavage? XD

  • I was here!!! :D

  • Two words:

    Motherfucking BREATH SUPPORT!

    Okay, three...

  • Dear Amanda,

    You never cease to amaze me. Thank you for being one of the few magnificent real musicians. :)

    xoxo Ashleigh

  • HORN HERTAS!

  • how does she breath

  • @vblhlvw She doesn't o.o

  • @vblhlvw you dont need air when your badass :)

  • That sounds awesome with the horns!

  • Whoaaaa, that is one badass trombone player! (Sorry, marching band geek here :D) Amanda, I must see you live at some point in my life...

  • WKAP has a bit more of a produced sheen to it. The first TDD album will always be my favorite for its rawness; the fact that you only need a piano and drums to rock that fucking hard.

  • @fffitgc I completely agree. I still love Amanda and WKAP, but TDD album can't be beat in my mind. Fuck. That sounded cliched, but oh well.

    ~Systa

  • this is an extremely hard song to sing. My sister and I tried today and... well, we're recovering as well as can be expected :)

  • @DroppinTheGloves Haha, I've been there! Lungpower is imperitive!

  • It's impossible to sing it properly, she admitted herself in an interview that they had to edit the voice track together in the studio for the album. No human being can exhale for that long :D

  • she does do a damn good job doing it live though XD

  • My only problem with this recording is the piano should be louder.

  • that was bitchin

  • I love when she smiles in this video...brings personality to it that wouldn't normally be caught in a pre-planned recording

  • okay i've always wondered.. what is the difference between amanda being solo and then the dresden dolls. think about it. the songs are like practically the same. but they are still awesome anyway

  • Even more freedom: Brian isn't there to play along and doesn't have any input. And usually Amanda solo is just vocals+piano.

    The difference is subtle, I guess. She does have here strong presence in anything she's involved in of course.

  • I actually find a great difference between TDD and AFP. Amanda is more crazy solo, and went all out. I really can feel a difference without Brian's drums, bass, guitar, vocals and other inputs he had. Both are awesome, however.

  • Agreed. TDD are great and all, but if you've listened to WKAP TDD always seem kind of underpowered somehow.

  • i wanted to go to this concert. travel all the way to the States. But.. unfourtunatly, I'm and broke. as always. Love Your Songs Manda!!!!

  • I stand by my opinion that 'Who Killed Amanda Palmer' is alot better than 'Yes Virginia'.

  • ditto.

  • Agreed, and even out of all the Dresden Dolls stuff I think No, Virgina is still the best.

  • I love this song!!! :D

  • <33333333

  • Holy hell. I never liked this song up until I heard this live performance. Like I'm hearing it for the first time. 0_0 Amazing.

  • Wonderful. The new album is great and this song is one my favourites. You are perfect as always ;-)

  • This song is sooooo good. I love it & you Amanda...

  • Awesome, Amanda!

  • Great song Amanda! I suppose you can be glad for one thing... at least you know who your family is!

  • Wow it sounds so cool with the trumpets...

  • i love this song!!!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more