Oasis - She's Electric (live)

[spacewagonhaha]

I thought Liam didn't sing it becasue he couldn't hit the high notes

[larwhelan]

It's just not the same with Noel singing

[VoVikMakaR]

Liam probably said "fuck off" to noel that night again...so he sang it haha

[nadjonion]

Why do you say worst lyrics ever?

You need a sense of humour ...

[nadjonion]

Is there a video where Liam is singing this?

[Geiernasenkokser]

worst lyrics ever

[BJCobbledick]

@Geiernasenkokser That's becasue you don't get it.

[86Stooy]

@Geiernasenkokser Worst lyrics ever ? Have you ever listened to rap or rnb music ? It's pure dogshit

[markfederer]

Noel is the fucking man!!!!!!!

[myroribrallan95]

ain't these the same chords as in married with chlildren?

[justinwgrover]

@myroribrallan95 Yep!

[ReubenM882]

Fuck you Liam

Come on Noel.

Noel left because of the things Liam did to him. I watched a program about it. Noel is better all round and Liam (nowadays) cannot sustain notes or go higher or lower in tone

[wickesm]

I don't know if he wrote this song, if he did credit to him for that. But on the flip side, dreadful timing throughout song, flat voice, completely charmless, when it's such a good tune, that's a crime. Sorry mate, but it's the truth.

[TheLmfaodyl]

really not as good as liam sang it.

[bartimus283]

he doesnt sing it because he cant hit the notes anymore

[114underground]

Liam doesn't sing it and never has because he hates the song

[kimallenbewick]

Am I the only one who prefers Noel singing it? Specially now that Liam can't sing any song.

[21xnaomi]

y does liam never perform this live ???

[mct1207]

is she gallagher's family from ?

[headstock48]

Ow, my ears.

[ForzaDarren]

Where the fuck was Liam? I never heard him sing this one live...anyway, I hope some day things sort out and they´re back together at some point. The world need the Gallaghers, they are history!

[gene101303]

Come on Noel, why are you singing this song???

[damoos]

Has Liam EVER sung this live ? I dont think he has.

Anyone know ?

[lauraacanas]

one of the many favorite songs from them!!

[alexander80686]

Liam is the best from Liammackintosh

[MrLarsiboy]

he is not singing, but talking. anyway... they are one of the best artists/band in the world. God make these brothers go back together in Oasis!

[MrSaskie1]

i love noel but i think liam might be made to sing this :)

[LgFaver]

Liam's version is, well... better.

[czech698]

she had been lying by the stone wall all day. And the sun was so hot that the blood beating in her ears sounded like the White Man's fire-horse that had just pulled a freight train into the station, and was grunting and drinking down at the water tank a hundred yards away. She was an old squaw. For week s she had been half dead; she was only an old Paiute squaw

[nufctoonnufc]

Noel is not ment to sing this song liam would sound much better. however in singing all together noel is 10 times better than liam now

[tdk2592]

@nufctoonnufc

Liam is a john lennon wannabe

[IamLav]

Latest Liam interview about everything and new Oasis. Click on my name for anyone interested.

[cosmosticality]

i think liam sounds better. But Noel wud be my 2nd choice for the song rather than any other singer in the world

[history384]

Oasis interacted with a crowd like no other!

[mcenlyhh]

noel the best liam is a brave

[dedemaister]

in my opinion and only in my opinion noel sings this waaay better than liam but that's just my opinion and please don't put thumps down i'm just saying what i believe.

[rudeswan]

well said

[pegger18636]

one of the worst i've ever heard noel sing.

[rocksteady3681]

@pegger18636

Your're right... Noel sings so much better than this!!!

[MassaDayLewis]

liam never sung this song live, right?

[rob5000x1]

one of my favorite songs, and no offense to the song writing god noel, but liam was meant to sing this

[YouTSWE]

i agree...

[IDyNaMiCkzZx]

they jst liked to take turns;)

[Vegaskid483]

qualitys shit

[JewishOnSunday]

telefunken a pressione

[anveedi]

isn't liam supposed to sing this tune??

[harper13]

Yes but he cant hit the notes anymore

[yosssup]

one of the best fucking song evarrrrrrr

[filstones]

Чума!!!

[karolecP]

sh!t quality, awesome song...one of their best

[restlesspride666]

Lol. I thought liam sounded beautiful on the studio album of the song. Eh. I thought liam was a baritone like his brother. Isn't that how it works? Becuase my brother is a baritone so i always assumed i was too genetically.

[shazandbono]

EXCELLANT tune *_*

[PooTingHoleTing9999]

OASIS FUCKIN RULE!!!

[keeblin]

God. Noel Gallagher is an amazing songwriter. I'd kill for just a little bit

[welshcun]

wheere was this recorded? love the G boys!

[tbell04OLSP]

Barrowlands, Glasgow

[addannato]

oasissssssss are a goooodddddddddddd

[Teveztostay]

love this song..love oasis..:D

[flyswatter92]

He does on the album, but he doesnt like the way he sang it. So whenever they do it live, Noel just belts it out (8) :L

Incidently, Liam also hates Digsys Dinner at wont sing that anymore (Not like they perform it live anyway) :L

[desmond17oreilly]

i though liam sang this song?

[andy04GE]

I am electric too...god bless Noel!!!

[pcamitan]

Still the best band in the world for me...!

[eoinfennessy]

I love Blur!

[HTHawk]

Good for you, I like Blur too...I like Oasis too..hence the reason I'm watching an Oasis video.

[EyeofyourMind84]

Wow, a member of Oasis playing a Strat, cool...

[lfcmm100]

very beatle-esque

[joshjosh1999]

Can I be electric too?

[laimnoelOASIS]

no ur a douche

[helmet959]

i miss alan's drumming in oasis... he was the perfect drummer for them

[Kababb95]

wtf sophasoph how are Oasis 'a-holes'

they are one of the best bands in the world.

[holysmoke45]

you and me me you lots and lots for us to do lots and lots for us to see, taking lines from this 70's show what a legend you are noel

[bilgon23]

I think that Noel sings better than Liam... but this music songs better with Liam singing ^^

[bawbaw222]

WOW, fantastic :)xxxxxxxxxx

[eoyispunk]

taringueraaa! jaja.

(gonnza)

[shazmeister2005]

does noel ever play leads any more?

[jworpington]

yea course but he can have a break from that now cos he's got gem instead of bonehead alongside him

[Cuybackandblack]

still like this song since the first time i listened to it awesome pals

[tsubasa211]

simply wrong

[List3nUpp]

quite wrong. and we will wait for your groundbreaking, lifechanging musical prowess to present itself on youtube and worldwide instead. twat.

[abo944]

You make no sense at all ...... nonsense infact!

He is and will always be a minger ..... and should retire now instead of carrying on making crap music!

[BlindSupernova]

I have no fucking idea why they stopped playing this song live????////

[thebigdv88]

fuck me mate last time i saw them they didn't even play live forever

[BlindSupernova]

Yea when I saw them in December they didn't play Live Forever. Wish they did cause they rarely come to America.

[gimmeviews]

they dont play it anymore because liam doesnt like singing it

[jae475]

immense

[bellesandwhistles]

eh... too fast

[luiggioasis]

why is he shouting insted of singing?!!!!!!!!!!!

[columbya36]

gem's singin along^^ watch 1.01-1.010

[tdawg0993]

what kind of amps does noel play through?

i'm pretty sure they're marshalls, but i dont know which model?

[welshmandem]

i like the song buh not wen they sing it live :( DISAPPOINTED

[playerofguitar]

I know this is going against most people, but I rather like Noel singing this,I dont really know why though lol

[MaardyBuum]

I like it too .

[SiMags]

Bring this song back to live set - PLEASE!!!

[dontlookbackinanger0]

I agree with you liam is The Singer for this song,but I can´t imagine him singing The importance of being idle

[Mousey568]

Agreed. Noel just doesn't have that little grunt that Liam has that is needed for She's Electric. On the other hand the Importance of Being Idle wouldn't sound good from Liam for two reasons. 1, that grunt; 2. the range is too difficult annd too high for him. But that's the advantage of having two quality vocalists, you get an incredible range and diversity.

[babgp]

I agree with you!!

Really!!

[LgFaver]

i don't know man...i mean i used to feel the same way until i heard Lord don't slow me Down with Liam on vocals.

[phillmo182]

a similar point to what i was trying to make, i wasnt saying noel was a bad singer i was saying he cant sing this song very well, but you arseholes took it the wrong way

[LgFaver]

he just doesn't deliver it the way Liam does.

for example, once you hear a song like Wonderwall, CS or even Whatever(eventhough Noel has sung all of them at one point) with Liam on vocals, hearing Noel's versions just doesn't sound right.

[PhilSupernova88]

Listen to the studio version of this then the live version. Unfortunately, Liam would strain his vocals if he tried to hit the high notes, that's why on Live Forever, Noel sings the "you and I are gonna live forever" when it's performed live. Same on Morning Glory and the other songs that need Liam to hit high notes. He can do it in the studio but on the road he can't.

[fedsom]

even in the studio albums doesnt noel sing those parts?

[000oo000000]

si hace segundas voces

[DennieCook]

i think this song sounds better when liam singing it, but others noel sounds better. dont look back in anger for example.

[RyanRotten80]

how do you know noel sounds better than liam with dont look back in anger? liams never sang it

[PO0WAGiRL]

this last comment was for phillmo182

[hollynathouse]

GOT MY TKTS FOR GLASGOW.. looking forward big time. DOYS is the best yet.. 10\10....

[tractorcat1]

If Noel did'nt stand in for Liam whenever he throw's a wobbler we would'nt see half the mega Oasis footage we do!!! Just ENJOY!!!!!

[Snipinranga]

does anyone have a live version with liam singing?

[letsgomets1108]

This is really good. Different. Noel doesn't need to push his voice. Very powerful, I love Oasis so fucking much.

[bilmu]

sorri but i really dnt lyk this i lyk oasis but i guess im comparin his singing to liams

[letsgomets1108]

Liam sings this on the album right?

[pietrocarini]

yes

[rowlands4ever]

shut up he has a great voice. faggot.

[Moosemousemoose]

faggot

[PO0WAGiRL]

Can you do it better ?

No. Shut up!

[faver87]

Noel rocks here, but the Liam sang version is miles better.

[fanofthemusic1090]

love this sing, love every song by these guys, but man are noel and liam jerks.

[yorke1111]

this concert is when liam out from oasis??

[rfclidorfc]

yorke1111 no i was at this concert liam just didnt perform 3 or 4 songs during this gig. the gig that liam didnt perform in was the mtv unplugged show i think.

[obloom39]

i think that liam can sing it better but noel still rocks at it!!!!!! WOOOOO GO NOEL!!!

[MusclesfromB]

wahaha

[IKilledElviss]

Noel's probably singing it because Liam can reach the high part on 'And I want you to know...' He's admitted he can't sing that high.

[willber94]

he also said how much he thought this song was gay

personly i disagree

[Snipinranga]

i have never seen liam sing this song live.

[khra81]

good but i prefer liam singing it

[lilgilly07]

i think liam is 10 times btter at this song

[davidbeast123]

i like both singin it

[DannyMPD]

i have always love this song and yeah i kinda prefer Liam but this is so great

[littleterminator]

I prefer Liam singing this song

[elmartox]

"'cause i dig you, and you dig me", there's lots and lots for us to see, lots lots for us to do.

i like it better that way rather than the original way

[725pete725]

@elmartox

no mate, it's not "dig". it's "i'll be you and you'll be me"

[elmartox]

i know, but i like to sing it that way, one way or another ...means the same right?

[725pete725]

haha ok, whatever floats your boat...

[PDhfc]

i was there top fukin nite at the barras

[BigBadSaint]

Noel is soooo much better at this particular song, Liam's voice sounds quite childish and whiney compared to Noel's which is deeper, plus the pace on this version is better

[Gibberish1983]

I reackon Liam's voice fits so much better with this song, Noel's is good too but sounds a bit boring here, he's better for songs like Dont look back in anger. The "childish" (I'd say more childlike) thing about Liams voice is what gives the extra edge to this song, which is perfect.

[BigBadSaint]

I get what you mean, but Noel's grittier and more ' fuck the mainstream ' style is just better imo.

I'm afriad we must agree to disagree on this 1 :)

[davidbeast123]

yes i agree

[dctopboots01]

r u kiddin? liams vocal 4 dis song is amazin

hes voice is amazin 4 d whole whats the story album

sayin he sounds childish is stupid

[PUTLAND]

What fucking planet is this bloke on?

[elmartox]

noel's my hero, i luv him

this tune gets me in a such a good mood :D

[alexmurta]

WHO CARES OASIS RULE

[herringthorpe]

sheeeeeeezzz from mexbraa

[Beatles39]

Alot of people dont get that NOEL writes 99% of ALL Their songs, Liam just sings the majority of them. They are Noels songs. Its just been recently that other band members are bringing songs to the table

[paulmorris2]

Thought everyone knew that!

[faver87]

everyone knows that.

but there are songs Noel SHOULDN't sing, this one i don't mind, but Wonderwall, Some Might Say and some others simply don't HAVE "IT" when Noel sings them, Cast No Shadow sounds great whoever's singing it.

[DannyMPD]

I cant agree with you about Wonderwall but you forgot Hello, it is asong Neol should bever sing, 100% made for Liam

[Theo130262]

no liam sings the song way better!

[jworpington]

i disagree.i like both of them.i think this version adds a kinda laddish feel to it

[Angel2006Oasis]

OASIS RULES

[noelwannabe]

yeah its at the barrowlands

[neilybob04515]

Is this at Glasgow Barrowlands anyone know?

[faver87]

where the hell is Liam, Noel did a good job at singing this but I WANT LIAM!!!

[SPFrobber]

noel wrote the songs, singing them makes it more authentic. liam can sing yes, but i like it from the man who wrote it.

[owenzio4]

oasis without liam is like saying taxi driver without deniro! his presence makes oasis!

[flipinjackass]

I love this song, but it could have been performed better. Their 'Hello' live performance really raised the bar for thems!

[Glitchio]

Beatles fans bring up the intro to DLBIA a lot.

Noel said it was Imagine and he used it to help the song echo through more generations... He wanted it to be remembered. It was so obvious because people were meant to go "Hey, that's Imagine... I remember that song". But they were too stupid to realise it.

[yoreich]

liam never sang this live, so u cant find a version with him...

[mat876]

i love oasis, lets kick liam out of it, lol, come on even noel himself has said same, oasis would much better without liam,

[Cloudburst]

Noel says its Liam's band, if Liam left the band would dissolve.

[lostdestroyer]

THAT PERFORMANCE was pretty shit lol

he kept missing the into bits. and comming in to l8.. then speeding up to catch up lol

i can do better :P

[cptmaca]

you rock man, keep it up

[XxLibz07xX]

I Love This Song! I Dont Think You Can Think Of It As Copying They Just Like There Music And Are Inspired By Them. Lots Of Songs Have Hooks Of Other Songs That You Pick Up. I Can See The Similarity Of While My Guitar Gently Weeps! Oasis Rock! Love The Beatles Too!

[Logsdon1988]

oasis didnt copy the beatles jus a similar style thats all.oasis proved with first two albums there amazing and have had so many good songs recorded and released its untrue

[oasischic]

i love this song and noel sings it so top=)

[thebluerabbitt]

i have scoured the internet but havent been able to find a vid of liam singing this.

[putthisin]

Pm me if you want any song from oasis in mp3 format ;)

[ludde1991]

thx for uploading=)

[gabrieloverboard]

you mates are wrong, the ending of "she is electric" is identical to "with a little help from my friends" from the sgt peppers album!

cheers!

[madforit]

If you listen to "Wonderboy" by the Kinks, the only part that sounds similar to "She's Electric" is: "I'll be you and you'll be me there's lots and lots for us to see" (oasis) vs. "I see you and you see me and ain't that wonder."(kinks) I have no idea about the "While My Guitar Gently Weeps" though.

[byronrogers2007]

I think there all on glue it sounds nothing like The Kinks Wonder Boy or The Beatles while my guitar gently weeps

She's electric Classic!

[xolalalabamox]

umm i just listened to both while my guitar gently weeps and the kinks song....and i see no similarity. the only similarity IVE ever heard...is dont look back in anger and Imagine by john lennon

[Ramu911]

more of a mix between imagine and let it be. The solo (of let it be)is quite similar to the one in Don't Look Back In Anger. But yeah the introes of the two song are allmost identical.:) Noels brilliant though...