How about, I think Mary grew up listenin' to the song and wanted to sing it herself...Yes, it's that simple... You don't have to have some fucked up motive... You just have to love music and have the same love to sing it... How come so many people wanna hate on YouTube? Oh yeah, because you're not doin' well in your own life... So, just listen to the music and shut the fuck up!
been listening 2 this and love don't live here anymore. wondering wtf i did or didn't do, said or didn't say...just messed up rt now. F-word, hate this feeling....
Agree with the opinion of "hisawesomecreation". That is the difference between the music now and the music "then". The same applies with the Beyonce - Etta James comparison. Etta should have been upset. When it comes to singing - Beyonce is "no" Etta James. Not even close to "Big Red".
If you only knew what went into the making of this record!!! ENJOY........Chief Recording & mixing Engineer Whitfield Records my old pala call me Col.DISCO
@REALand RAWW obviously you are too young to appreciate Rose Royce. Everything that Mary J. Blige does is a remake of someone eles music or style. If she would get her own music or style then she would be a decent artist but all she does is whine. You are one of the ones who actually got sucked into the whole vitim mindset that she possess. There are many women who have been abused and have gotten over it. Come on how long is she going to milk the abuse thing? Get over it and move on.
what ??? you really believe that dont you ?? lol, Deniece Williams has an awesome voice, Mary wishes her version was as dope as this, DONT GET ME WRONG, i like Marys version, but i love this version...
Stay tuned for the DJ Killahbee mixtape entitled "Who Stole the Soul V1" ...this record is on there.. It's some of the best soul music ever assembled in one mixxx
IF IT'S NOT BROKEN DON'T FIX IT, GOOD JOB MARY, BUT THIS IS 1 OF THOSE GEMS BEST LEFT ALONE, SUNG PERFECT THE 1ST TIME. BUT THANKS FOR YOUR VERSION MISS BLIGE.
wish i could send this to That Special Someone Maybe he could actually get it if he heared the words inside Hey, Puc can ya feel me or hear me Now ???
Its being the worst love pain of my life... i never thought one would hurt so bad. i guess its true when they say things come back to you... I am very sorry for all i've done.
i grew up on rose royce waking UP SATURDAY MORNING to MY MOM BLASTING THERE SONG ON THE STEREO AND FOR ME mary j fucked this song up as well as chaka "sweet thang"
Yes! I've said it once and I'll say it again... Gwen's voice was able to convey her feeling without her having to over-sing her lyrics. Sometimes all a song needs is someone to sing it - not scream, wretch, add every octave imaginable, or elongate every note sung. I typically don't like ballads, but Rose Royce is the exception because of the smooth sophisticated delivery of Gwen's vocals. Only one RR remake have I liked ( a version of Wishing On A Star), everything else I prefer RR's originals
the difference between this version and mary version is the difference between music then and now in general. Gwen sang this with passion and you could hear the pain in her voice. Mary sounded like, just as many of todays artist, like she just wanted a pay check.
@macewindu67 i dont agree with that just my opinion mary sang that with alot of passion. its one of my favorite songs of all time. no disrespect to ms. gwen but i didnt know about the song until mary sang it and im 40.
@muggledon1 "i didnt know about the song until mary sang it and im 40"
Are you serious? You never watched "Car Wash," like, a million times growing up? I'm 37 and the first time I ever heard this song was when my moms and step-pops were watching "Car Wash." I was about 7 or 8 then. I think the main reason I watched "Car Wash" was because of the music in the movie. Anyway, they both did their thing (Gwen and Mary).
rose royce IS amazing, and i dont think it was mary j. blidge's intention to outdo rose. still doesnt take away from either artists, mary is a legend just as much as rose royce is. thank you
Sorry to tell you this BUT while you ARE right about Gwen's REAL name, her stage name WAS "Rose" and was given to her by Whit (Norman Whitfield). In fact, her FULL stage name WAS Rose Norwalt.
My sister was swearing up and down that Mary J Blige was the only person to sing this song. I told her that Mary's version didn't sound the same to me, and she insisted I just didn't remember. I'm glad I decided to check twice.
11 comments, this is what true r & b sounds and feels like! Benosang, Jennifer Holla, and Keyshia Outinthecold, need to sit down study their music and learn how to lean into the note, stay on key, for the whole song and let you feel the music, not switch from station to station, to see if the same thing ain't on that station! Real music is missing and if you spot it, please call 1-800-Ifoundrealmusic!LOL! Peace!
Damn! Highschool
this is the shit baby!
clubmidnightsun 4 weeks ago
this is so so so sweet
filthypanda 1 month ago
my favorite song (:
ManuelSKTboard 1 month ago
OMG...i've been looking for this song for hours. So happy I finally found it <3
idontwantyourdrugs 1 month ago
Oh my God just found out this was a cover! Gotta love MJB for doing this such justice. How did I not know Rose Royce did this?!
VioletSpanxx 2 months ago
Man this takes me back to my prom. Where's my pink tux, baby? ANd I got find my earth shoes a or my cryon shoes.
qtip1064 3 months ago
I like I'm going down. 2 thumbs up!
AdoreTheApes 4 months ago
Beautiful video-totally in sync with style of the era.
cagervin 4 months ago
just blaze...oh baibe :) lav u Cam'ron.nice sample
MrMKONGWE3000 5 months ago
How about, I think Mary grew up listenin' to the song and wanted to sing it herself...Yes, it's that simple... You don't have to have some fucked up motive... You just have to love music and have the same love to sing it... How come so many people wanna hate on YouTube? Oh yeah, because you're not doin' well in your own life... So, just listen to the music and shut the fuck up!
roBEARtoEHarwoodJr 6 months ago 8
@roBEARtoEHarwoodJr well said
huggybear271 3 months ago
been listening 2 this and love don't live here anymore. wondering wtf i did or didn't do, said or didn't say...just messed up rt now. F-word, hate this feeling....
AZtailgater 6 months ago
Agree with the opinion of "hisawesomecreation". That is the difference between the music now and the music "then". The same applies with the Beyonce - Etta James comparison. Etta should have been upset. When it comes to singing - Beyonce is "no" Etta James. Not even close to "Big Red".
lkn4bling 7 months ago
Sister Gwen Dickey has a sweet and a dynamic sexy voice.
Rose Royce were a great soul and old school group and they made classics so powerful.
Rose Royce, the greatest soul and old school group ever.
peasah2005 7 months ago
Quarter Parties this was the S**T
spaceangel1961 8 months ago
someone got the mixing just rite with this version
streetfightchamp07 8 months ago
Luv it.
walesfan1 9 months ago
she sampled Camrons song and went back in time, Im sure of it
ImDino 9 months ago 2
If you only knew what went into the making of this record!!! ENJOY........Chief Recording & mixing Engineer Whitfield Records my old pala call me Col.DISCO
Leababy131 9 months ago 2
i neva knew mary remade dis put ya gul royce sounds great
independentmama1 10 months ago
I love this song...brings powerful meaning to my life at this time!!
smithmic66 10 months ago
Yoo I was sooo ignorant thinking Mary sung this first HA! I can't believe this is an 1976 song wow Royce's voice is so amazing!
B1eSSinGNdisGuisE 11 months ago
i sing this all the time
msdreapooh22 11 months ago
Gwen tears this ish UP. One of the best song ever to hit the planet!
Janissi42 11 months ago
Wow.... I had absolutely NO idea that Rose Royce sung this song! This song kicks major ass!
LilAfricanDude 11 months ago 2
i love this version and Cheryl Pepsi Riley rocked it!!!!
pryncyss 11 months ago
thumbs up if Madea's big happy family brought you here!!!!!!
pryncyss 11 months ago 2
best song<333
rrcortina 1 year ago
Chaka Khan with her seriously BADASS self. Wasn't nobody better. And she looked good! Still had that same wig though
pa6786 1 year ago
I love this video!!! PROPS to you!
thebittersister 1 year ago
Mudvill Mr Pelon 209
pelonh67 1 year ago
uqh REALandRAWW just drove me learn to appreciate real music iAm 20 && iWuld rather listen to dusties over the music these days..
mzderickasjenkins 1 year ago
sing it baby!!!! sing it!!!
cheesered23 1 year ago
I ain't got no plans, C.N.
queenmary4344 1 year ago
@REALand RAWW obviously you are too young to appreciate Rose Royce. Everything that Mary J. Blige does is a remake of someone eles music or style. If she would get her own music or style then she would be a decent artist but all she does is whine. You are one of the ones who actually got sucked into the whole vitim mindset that she possess. There are many women who have been abused and have gotten over it. Come on how long is she going to milk the abuse thing? Get over it and move on.
blackbig70 1 year ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Mary J. Blige's version is waaaaaay better! Mary gave soul, conviction, & range. This is a mess!
REALandRAWW 1 year ago
@REALandRAWW
what ??? you really believe that dont you ?? lol, Deniece Williams has an awesome voice, Mary wishes her version was as dope as this, DONT GET ME WRONG, i like Marys version, but i love this version...
TheUncleBungle 1 year ago
@REALandRAWW You done lost your mind Mary cannot sing and her version does an injustice to this song. booboo.
bombay447 1 year ago
@REALandRAWW You done lost your mind Mary cannot sing and her version does an injustice to this song.
bombay447 1 year ago 2
@REALandRAWW You's a straight fool if you think Mary's version is better. I invite you to listen to them back to back.
bmoreed 4 months ago
OMG, THIS IS THE JAM RIGHT HERE!!!!
rpy76 1 year ago
don't get depressed cause theres alway downs and for that there are up so fuck the small shit
Marrsattack1 1 year ago
Comment removed
perezmcc 1 year ago
6 people who dont know about good music
perezmcc 1 year ago
Stay tuned for the DJ Killahbee mixtape entitled "Who Stole the Soul V1" ...this record is on there.. It's some of the best soul music ever assembled in one mixxx
supreemeDJ 1 year ago
LEGEND LEGEND FIRE LOVE DIS TUUUUUNE.....
vquestt2 1 year ago
these are real singers , remakes are great to hear but give me the original!
238238033 1 year ago
how did mary J get a hold
Mellowman53 1 year ago
aint nothing like the Original!!
tweetie35 1 year ago
IF IT'S NOT BROKEN DON'T FIX IT, GOOD JOB MARY, BUT THIS IS 1 OF THOSE GEMS BEST LEFT ALONE, SUNG PERFECT THE 1ST TIME. BUT THANKS FOR YOUR VERSION MISS BLIGE.
moonabes 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
since u left my world smokey, my whole worlds gone up side down. im so blue....going down!
missnicli 1 year ago
since u left myworld smokey, my whole worlds gone up side down. im so blue....going down!
missnicli 1 year ago
Camron and Juelz Santana Oh Boy,,
KRod0213 1 year ago
really nice video the poem was excellent
modelchick4life 1 year ago
This version is the definitely better than Marys. Can't mess with a classic;)
Dustinluva07 1 year ago
ROLLS royce at 0:02 in the video... lol
toast5oos 1 year ago
Cam'ron- Oh boy
ritepisstake 1 year ago 2
so good but so sad!
truck5145 1 year ago
COSMO THEATER E. 116ST el BARRIO WHAT MEMORIES......ALL GOOD!!!! MISS U (GLADYS E. 109ST 2nd ave.)..... :>(
Rmarty1955 1 year ago
this song is so true!
vintagefame 1 year ago
hate this song ! it screwed me over, but i love it
zcupcakez 1 year ago 2
beautiful song
starzchik85 1 year ago
THE ORIGINAL IS ALWAYS THE BEST
velez3031 1 year ago 4
shit rose royce misic dominate atl's oldies 4lovers only radio stations and IM sure many other minority filled big cities stations as well
fuckdatify 1 year ago 4
....Just Blaze! Ooooh boy! :D
RobsenSTiDDA 1 year ago 4
wish i could send this to That Special Someone Maybe he could actually get it if he heared the words inside Hey, Puc can ya feel me or hear me Now ???
ttekcupycnan 1 year ago
Great Song!
PKat313 1 year ago
reeeeeeelmuzik! I love this song.
genevasolomon 1 year ago 2
nicee
JayJuBo 1 year ago
GR8 video! purrrrrrrrrfect
cillysnow 1 year ago
Its being the worst love pain of my life... i never thought one would hurt so bad. i guess its true when they say things come back to you... I am very sorry for all i've done.
mrdeniserangel 1 year ago
man i love dis song n car wash we sang car wash @ my skool last year
PrincessMonique121 1 year ago
i grew up on rose royce waking UP SATURDAY MORNING to MY MOM BLASTING THERE SONG ON THE STEREO AND FOR ME mary j fucked this song up as well as chaka "sweet thang"
tweetie35 1 year ago
Rose Royce, beautiful songs.....those were the days...r
rokoping 1 year ago
great visuals, loved every scene..thumbs up. aj
AnomalyJonez 1 year ago
i love this song even if it is an old song
nicki98761 1 year ago
i didn't want to hear this song for the longest b/c everyone who sung it sounded a hot mess. the original is clearly better.
cjadream7 1 year ago
i love dhisz sonq even thouqh itsz old um qoinq down;;;*
TiERRiCA15 1 year ago
does anyone know what year this was made? it would help alot! thanx[:
chicanagirl96 1 year ago
1976
illtelligent11 1 year ago
It was recorded in 1976 as part of the Car Wash soundtrack, but the single was released in 1977
daretosayit 1 year ago
@daretosayit ok thank u so much!(:
chicanagirl96 1 year ago
mary is gospel now....
TheLittletazz 1 year ago
They should let all new school bring back all this old skool music the world would be a better place I bet more love in this music
supperspecial 2 years ago 5
i love this jam!!!brings back memorys
B1GS3XY1 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
ZZZZ I am the fly ZZZ man this licked down in carwash mmmm
dreadz808 2 years ago
I think Mary's cover was okay but THE ORIGINAL...you can feel her pain...I get more chills listening to Gwen's voice
watsup018 2 years ago 7
Yes! I've said it once and I'll say it again... Gwen's voice was able to convey her feeling without her having to over-sing her lyrics. Sometimes all a song needs is someone to sing it - not scream, wretch, add every octave imaginable, or elongate every note sung. I typically don't like ballads, but Rose Royce is the exception because of the smooth sophisticated delivery of Gwen's vocals. Only one RR remake have I liked ( a version of Wishing On A Star), everything else I prefer RR's originals
daretosayit 1 year ago 9
Classic baby, simply classic!
odinspromise 2 years ago 3
i think if mary sung this song with passion and the same arrangement she would killlll it
vexedup 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
"i think if mary sung this song with passion and the same arrangement she would killlll it "
They used the exact same arrangement as Rose Royce (maybe same track) & passion can't be taught.
luvureally 1 year ago
im going down!,333
flawlesslx 2 years ago
oh boy
danihali 2 years ago
LOVE THIS..
KillaAngel1989 2 years ago 3
BIG UP!! beautiful video.
screwface1011 2 years ago
this is a very beautiful video i loved the poem in the video. Exellent job.
luvcandi2 2 years ago
emotional song when i hear dis bring me memorys
1essjsharkyloc4 2 years ago
i love this sonnnng.<3
its such a pretty sonnng.
never heard of her but heard
the verson on sister sister, haha
sara092693 2 years ago
lol, that's where I first heard it when I was younger! ha :)
LoveMeFLAWSandAll 2 years ago
Does anyone know where I can find the sheet music for this song?
steffkulis 2 years ago
the difference between this version and mary version is the difference between music then and now in general. Gwen sang this with passion and you could hear the pain in her voice. Mary sounded like, just as many of todays artist, like she just wanted a pay check.
macewindu67 2 years ago 7
Yea I agree back then Mary just wanted a paycheck!! BUT NOW!!!!! Sistah got a whole new angle!!! I Love her now!!!!!!Her whole spirit has changed!!!
hisawesomecreation 2 years ago 26
@macewindu67 i dont agree with that just my opinion mary sang that with alot of passion. its one of my favorite songs of all time. no disrespect to ms. gwen but i didnt know about the song until mary sang it and im 40.
muggledon1 6 months ago
@muggledon1 "i didnt know about the song until mary sang it and im 40"
Are you serious? You never watched "Car Wash," like, a million times growing up? I'm 37 and the first time I ever heard this song was when my moms and step-pops were watching "Car Wash." I was about 7 or 8 then. I think the main reason I watched "Car Wash" was because of the music in the movie. Anyway, they both did their thing (Gwen and Mary).
manfocused 6 months ago
rose royce IS amazing, and i dont think it was mary j. blidge's intention to outdo rose. still doesnt take away from either artists, mary is a legend just as much as rose royce is. thank you
bluedevmike 2 years ago 2
The UNTOUCHABLE Rose Royce!!!
Jyssica5150 2 years ago 7
i luv dis song
Musiciswifmeh 2 years ago
Just finished seeing them live in concert!!! They rocked the shit out of the Mcdermont!
raidervato11 2 years ago
Mary J version is OK. But Rose created a real masterpiece. Her voice and the more complicated musical arrangement make this version far superior!
solusmysterion 2 years ago 69
@solusmysterion
The lead SINGER is NOT named 'ROSE'
The GROUP was called 'Rose Royce'
The lead singer of the group
is named 'Gwen Dickie'.
Just thought you might like to know that. =D
And YOU ARE RIGHT -- 'Gwen Dickie'
is an absolutely AMAZING singer !!! =D
EmailTubeYou 1 year ago 7
Sorry to tell you this BUT while you ARE right about Gwen's REAL name, her stage name WAS "Rose" and was given to her by Whit (Norman Whitfield). In fact, her FULL stage name WAS Rose Norwalt.
Bassplayershadow2023 1 year ago
@Bassplayershadow2023
No need to apologize.
That's good info to know.
Besides -- no matter her name -- her singing is amazing! =D
EmailTubeYou 1 year ago
@solusmysterion
i could not say it better, Mary J got famous because of old skool!
seb1tube 1 year ago
Marys version is a piece of booty doo compared to this amazing piece of work
MsRavenBlack1988 2 years ago 9
I could tell a huge difference b/t this and Mary;s version. Wow...... She actually broke down and cried
bojackBroly09 2 years ago 3
i heard this song on tv
SongsLover03 2 years ago
=[ good song to listen too when u get ur heart broken by the one you love,
dgshppng7 2 years ago 2
That statement is so very true but it also hurts a lot. ='(
Imamazing4life 2 years ago
This song haunts me. We have all been there, ladies. Give me a hoot, hoot!
willblakerose 2 years ago
I got da movie & soundtrack & dis is da ORIGINAL bay bay. Nuthn else compares to ROSE ROYCE
elway806 2 years ago
My sister was swearing up and down that Mary J Blige was the only person to sing this song. I told her that Mary's version didn't sound the same to me, and she insisted I just didn't remember. I'm glad I decided to check twice.
adferty 2 years ago
11 comments, this is what true r & b sounds and feels like! Benosang, Jennifer Holla, and Keyshia Outinthecold, need to sit down study their music and learn how to lean into the note, stay on key, for the whole song and let you feel the music, not switch from station to station, to see if the same thing ain't on that station! Real music is missing and if you spot it, please call 1-800-Ifoundrealmusic!LOL! Peace!
LGKids 2 years ago
I love Gwen Dickies Voice.. Saw them in concert a few years back and she can still belt some tunes..
fifthavehottie128 2 years ago
I thought this was Mary's original song. Didn't know she covered it. I like this one better.
nicdraw 2 years ago 2
da bomb
xyzdavid12345 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
¸¸„ø¤º°¨¸„ø¤º°¨ post to 3 other vids
¨°º¤ø„¸ Copy „ø¤º°¨ press F5 twice
¸„ø¤º°¨Paste ``°º¤ø„¸ OK
¸„ø¤º°¨¸„ø¤º°¨¨°º look at ur background
amazing!! :)
OR ULL die Today
(sorry! it scared me and i had to do it!)
iceies21 2 years ago
OH BOY
azaproc 2 years ago 3
This song is perfect!!!
Thanks for posting!!!
HOUSEADDICT1 2 years ago
absolutely beautiful video!!!!!!! I love it!!!
lloydbankslover21 2 years ago
Woeeeeeeeeeeeee totally lovin your video! One of my favorite songs, one of my favorite groups and ROSES a big favorite! 5 stars for you!
rosequeen49 3 years ago
rose royce
UTBigVic 3 years ago
You is so creative!!!!!!!!!!!!!
c2i4n6d8y10 3 years ago
You so da bomb Tracy. 10 thumbs up. I remember this one.
AleshiaHowell 3 years ago