@laikyn34 As I always reply, only a true Amy Lee would be able to differentiate their voices and tastes. Also, Amy isn't the only person with an accent, it's only natural Carly have a similar accent since they both come from the same region. On another note, Carly sang classic rock before WATF dragged her into their clutches, while Amy sings gothic/hardcore rock.
@Raeshuu ok...Carly is from Ireland and when she moved to the States she lived in San Diego. Amy is from Riverside, California, but she says her home is Little Rock, Arkansas since that's where her family eventually settled after moving around the country a lot. How are the gonna have a similar accent???? Carly crearly speaks with an Irish accent.
No-one will ever be anywhere as good as Ann Wilson,she is the queen of Rock as far as i'm concerned,no-one has ever had a voice to match either!!!!!!!!
she added words like oh [and] and or something its like and oh i hope it wont end though, and the night goes by so very slow. shes retarded. totally screwed up the meaning.
I'm not a vocalist (I drum), but I sometimes think that her sense of rhythm is just a little off at some points. She is a fantastic singer though and will do great with some more performances under her belt, studio time, and, not to mention, she has been asked to sing with all the former members of Evenescence.
Her voice is top notch......I don't like all of her phrasing, however and feel like she gets lazy at the end of phrases and, therefor, drops the pitch just a bit.
LOL... that's funny, Carly has a huge chest voice and transitions beautifully from head, throat and chest! It is not a weak performance at all, she just sang it differently, more mellow really, that's all!
allison is not half as good. allison sounds "gd" on tv with all the music to back her up, take awy all the music make her sing with just a piano as an accompliment like what carly did. she will never sound as good as carly.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
You are sadly mistaken!... Allison did "I Don't Wanna Miss A Thing" accompanied strictly by piano and sang it 2x better than she did when she had the band behind her!
i like allison better than carly but those two are my fav american idol contestants ever (including adam) andi think all three of them is gonna go very far i cant wait till carlys album comes out
Ramiele should have picked another song. Bad song choice. She knew that she's going to be compared with Carly and if you can't won't the battle, pick another song
I like that Heart & Underwood performance alot. Best so far, yes :) But we haven't had a full band accompaniment version with Carly in it yet! Where she will push the limits with her voice and passion. Only acoustic piano or guitar versions.
Shes way better than that ram girl.. HER VOICE IS MORE POWERFUL!!!! which is what this song needs, the other girls voice is too small for this song and it's too big for her!!! Carly is better at this song by a mile, even though ram, is a really good singer!
what do you mean? I really like ramiele, but please, let's not compare, they are both wonderful singers. I think Alone by Ramiele was the best studio version of the season, and I think she sang that song so well because she IS a wonderful singer. but come on, you are telling me carly did a bad job? are we watching the same video? she did an amazing job and she really is an amazing singer, just like rami :)
sorry if I ofended you, but someone can catch the wrong idea with your post. best wishes!
Can't believe how someone horrible like Brooke White got farther in the so called "competition" than Carly did. It's hard to believe Jason got farther than her too, even though I liked him. They had an excellent winner this year, but I'm no longer weatching the show. It's just too ridiculous now.
she has a good looking.
JOSENILTA 4 months ago
Hot lady and hot voice. MMMMMMMMMM
birdy808 11 months ago
Very silky voice
TheWsop1972 1 year ago
Lying Cunt!
justschr 1 year ago
she sounded a little like the lead singer of evanascence
percussion86 1 year ago
ughghghg horrible.... freakin Amy Lee wanna be
laikyn34 1 year ago
@laikyn34 As I always reply, only a true Amy Lee would be able to differentiate their voices and tastes. Also, Amy isn't the only person with an accent, it's only natural Carly have a similar accent since they both come from the same region. On another note, Carly sang classic rock before WATF dragged her into their clutches, while Amy sings gothic/hardcore rock.
Raeshuu 1 year ago
@Raeshuu ok...Carly is from Ireland and when she moved to the States she lived in San Diego. Amy is from Riverside, California, but she says her home is Little Rock, Arkansas since that's where her family eventually settled after moving around the country a lot. How are the gonna have a similar accent???? Carly crearly speaks with an Irish accent.
Angierory 1 year ago
@laikyn34 How is she a wannabee? She isn't trying to be like anyone. She doesn't sound anything like Amy Lee nor does she look like her.
xxviciousbeautyxx 1 year ago 2
i really idolize her..go carly!hit it!
sweetdane22 1 year ago 4
No-one will ever be anywhere as good as Ann Wilson,she is the queen of Rock as far as i'm concerned,no-one has ever had a voice to match either!!!!!!!!
bungaboy66 1 year ago
domijess.............you are either totally deaf or the worst judge of talent on this earth.
I think everyone will agree you have a serious problem.
bestoffrank 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
[yeah] alone. shes so bad wow.
domijess 1 year ago
she added words like oh [and] and or something its like and oh i hope it wont end though, and the night goes by so very slow. shes retarded. totally screwed up the meaning.
domijess 1 year ago
I'm not a vocalist (I drum), but I sometimes think that her sense of rhythm is just a little off at some points. She is a fantastic singer though and will do great with some more performances under her belt, studio time, and, not to mention, she has been asked to sing with all the former members of Evenescence.
palermo131 2 years ago 3
Her voice is top notch......I don't like all of her phrasing, however and feel like she gets lazy at the end of phrases and, therefor, drops the pitch just a bit.
shawnuel 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This song sing Celine Dion, I think>D
janeskoHC 2 years ago
who sing this song?
coxanh84 2 years ago
Celine Dion covered it but the original is 80s rock band Heart.
muza86 2 years ago 3
amazing amazing a-fucking-mazing
johnj1232 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
she sucked
domijess 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Good but to weak, she has to take the note from the ground and out of the fucking skull. Dont wuss around!
jopar003 2 years ago
... too weak? She has one of the most powerful voices I've ever heard...
mlhaynes4 2 years ago 7
LOL... that's funny, Carly has a huge chest voice and transitions beautifully from head, throat and chest! It is not a weak performance at all, she just sang it differently, more mellow really, that's all!
MEE051677 2 years ago 15
she is the best in in thier season of american idol among girls vocally and she has the star quality..
go carly..
gpln15 2 years ago 4
it should have came down to david archuleta, carly, david cook and syesha, not in that order tho
matt9682 2 years ago
I LOVE YOU!
I LOVE YOU!!
I LOVE YOU!!!
Mariano (Argentina)
DavidArchuletaArg 3 years ago
allison is not half as good. allison sounds "gd" on tv with all the music to back her up, take awy all the music make her sing with just a piano as an accompliment like what carly did. she will never sound as good as carly.
deterdettol 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
You are sadly mistaken!... Allison did "I Don't Wanna Miss A Thing" accompanied strictly by piano and sang it 2x better than she did when she had the band behind her!
MEE051677 2 years ago
i like allison better than carly but those two are my fav american idol contestants ever (including adam) andi think all three of them is gonna go very far i cant wait till carlys album comes out
AlyxAJxLuver 2 years ago
yeah totally. i can't wait for carly's album to be out too. have you heard it, it sounds pretty cool when she's in the studio!
LOLCOPTER 2 years ago 2
carrie underwood kicked butt at this song.
domijess 1 year ago
i want a carly album! not the crap from before either!
Y2Kyle10 3 years ago
This girl's really good.
urgrad03 3 years ago 5
omg i love carly shes better than david cook i can tell you that
piobair750 3 years ago 6
Best vocalist of the whole season and ever on Idol. Carly rocks!!!
12345carlyfan 3 years ago 7
The best female vocalist of season 7
lilahhl0vesyue 3 years ago 8
I love it when she sings this song acoustic like here and at The Field. Amazing!!!
12345carlyfan 3 years ago 3
Carly is just great on this song.
cbotten106 3 years ago 2
I absolutely love her ! She does anything she sings justice.
NYCITALIAN82 3 years ago 2
This was good, but Hollywood week was better.
rednaticat 3 years ago 3
Ramiele should have picked another song. Bad song choice. She knew that she's going to be compared with Carly and if you can't won't the battle, pick another song
tclover88 3 years ago
Sung with passion, just the way it should be!
Nice.
porcelaincougar 3 years ago 4
I have just heart the original and I have to admit: This can't compete.
It's ok, but the 'Heart' version is so much better!
Migaira 3 years ago
I love Carly to death, she was my girl from the very beginning. That being said...
...FLAT! Tune it up or transpose it down, sweetheart.
wickedphant0m 3 years ago
she performs better outside of IDOL... like this one... or when she sang U2's ONE with Michael Johns...
but on IDOL she wasn't that good.. so being booted earlier is good for her.. she can now make her own music
chatterbox1229 3 years ago 4
she's incredible..
eijisenpai 3 years ago 4
BEST version of Alone! =)
Darchuletafan17 3 years ago 3
dont pick on poor ramiele.
RamieleDavidFan 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I ♥♥♥♥ Carly..She is
SOOOOOOO talented! Hey yall go check out my video, I sing this exact song!
AlyGass 3 years ago
she sounds a million times better here than she did on idol!
sarahfan56 3 years ago 6
she always sounded this good....
thats why she shouldve won
BlingyDamon3 3 years ago 15
I like that Heart & Underwood performance alot. Best so far, yes :) But we haven't had a full band accompaniment version with Carly in it yet! Where she will push the limits with her voice and passion. Only acoustic piano or guitar versions.
lissun 3 years ago
The absolute BEST performance was when Carrie Underwood & heart did "alone" carly smithson still has alot of passion & did very well
Ike1023 3 years ago
Shes way better than that ram girl.. HER VOICE IS MORE POWERFUL!!!! which is what this song needs, the other girls voice is too small for this song and it's too big for her!!! Carly is better at this song by a mile, even though ram, is a really good singer!
GPXgirl 3 years ago 5
what do you mean? I really like ramiele, but please, let's not compare, they are both wonderful singers. I think Alone by Ramiele was the best studio version of the season, and I think she sang that song so well because she IS a wonderful singer. but come on, you are telling me carly did a bad job? are we watching the same video? she did an amazing job and she really is an amazing singer, just like rami :)
sorry if I ofended you, but someone can catch the wrong idea with your post. best wishes!
bregieirofernandes 3 years ago
Can't believe how someone horrible like Brooke White got farther in the so called "competition" than Carly did. It's hard to believe Jason got farther than her too, even though I liked him. They had an excellent winner this year, but I'm no longer weatching the show. It's just too ridiculous now.
LindseyT15 3 years ago
Brooke's personality is the one that gets her farther in AI. There were times when I think Brooke is brilliant but she's inconsistent
tclover88 3 years ago
Beautiful love her voice, brillant.
beachbutterfly 3 years ago
she is amazing! i wish she got further on american idol!
brandonboydluver 3 years ago 2