Very nice! This band fits any situation/feeling. I've only known of them for about a month and they are definitely one of my favorite bands of all time :D
Does not this song merit all the stages of life? the lyrics describe the process of growing old, and th music gives common sounds of growing and maturing. Genius, genius band and one of the greatest Cd's of the 21st Century. Keep going.. Why?!!!
GOD DAYUM! ppl need to know about this up commmming threat! Moth ppl are extreamly dangerous and can make white gurlz go crazy.... as shown in dis MAGNIFICENT video:)
P.S
Please thumbs up this video to spread DEADLY Moth men awareness... Thank You.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Quite simply, The dumbest thing I've ever seen! Reminded me of William Hung, Was waiting for him to jump up and say "She Bangs,She Bangs!" Therfore,I wont watch it anymore.
If you can think outside the box and not be freaked out by quirkiness, rather take a few minutes to soak in something new and listen to deep, powerful lyrics, then Why? is the shit
hey, you should upload a higher quality video of this! my friends and i really like it. you should send it to why?, too. i think they'd appreciate it, it's beautiful!
Whats the deal with the weird old Asian kid? Was he a child, or just mentally impaired? And why was he wearing those ridiculous pajamas, only a small child would wear them. I DON'T GET IT AT ALL.
@butterw Kind sir, he's mentaly impaired, and its about him falling in love with the one girl, then not understanding its wrong to kiss the other girl. Its a fairly simple story to understand but I must admit at first I couldn't understand it, I hope you enjoyed this song, WHY? is the best band ever.
@richard07960 I thought he understood it was wrong, but that the friend kissed him deliberately in order to break him up with his girlfriend, because she couldn't bear the thought that her friend was seeing him.
Eskimo Snow is a great album also, deven though it ended up getting panned because critics were expecting more of the same from Yoni. Into the Shadows of My Embrace, These Hands, January Twentysomething, The Blackest Purse, Eskimo Snow...these were some of my favorite songs of last year.
That refers to the line 'i want a verb and you give me a noun'. Dream and tongue are verbs and nouns aswell- this is a nice lil word play Wolf implemented.
@Ryufire I actually have always thought that little bit was the most interesting and creative line I'd heard in any song. Why? is such a great band. =]
that was boring, like if you heard that song on the radio you'd be like.. what the hell is this crap? do they just let any garbage on the airwaves these days?? I'm so sick of people saying its a great song just because the lyrics are "cool" or "insightful". if its annoying to listen to, whats the point? its better left as a poem for someone to read.
You can think what you will, but you don't have to be a cunt about it. At this point you're just being a bitch for the sake of being a bitch, there's nothing constructive about it.
If you dont like dont listen or watch you stupid idiot I mean it is pointless to listen to something you clearly hate it so much try and think Ms.Bitchy
Dope video! the lyrics in this song hit close to home.... and im sorry oatmeal but the asian guy does have Down syndrome! but i think its kool, ppl in directors position dont usually use them as a protagonist. But i think that the video is beautiful and original! And Why? is already one of the best so do another video for one of their new songs im sure it will be Dope as well.
Turning in your drug dry sleep. When I ask you to kiss my pulse, you offer to start the shower. I ask for a verb and you give me a noun, what do you dream up while I tongue you down?
grapefruit soap ~swag~
parishynes 2 days ago
Love the video, really sweet :)
Curiousonic 3 days ago
THIS ISNT DUBSTEP!?!
MexicanBeans15 2 weeks ago 4
@teejscorner "is all that we see or seem but a dream within a dream?" edgar allen poe,1849. read the whole poem. its amazing.
theblazeking89 1 month ago
@teejsconer theres a star trek episode from the 60s with the exact same plot from inception its aaaaaaaall copied :(
heSHnry9119 1 month ago
I want a verb and you give me a noun. What do you dream up while I tongue you down?
jeefereee 1 month ago 3
great fan video.. why would approve :}
lagginswag 2 months ago
the guitarist, matt meldon, is my guitar teacher! cool guy
Mustangofdoo 2 months ago
Slenderman needs you in Burma right away.
MrOkkervils 3 months ago
Very nice! This band fits any situation/feeling. I've only known of them for about a month and they are definitely one of my favorite bands of all time :D
7O0OL 4 months ago
I thought this was the proper video till I read the info. Could easily pass for the real thing. Great work by all!
Gatorade237 4 months ago
awww this video is cute. lil azn man likes hot girl. why is fucking amazing everyone. and anyone who doesnt agree is a p.o.s
shitsandgigglez 4 months ago
Audio sounds like a vinyl rip. Great work, anyway.
EctInc 5 months ago
genius
lmaokristenwtf 6 months ago
so high, so in love.
hockeyyismylife 6 months ago 2
Crappy audio quality but good video/song!
FozzleMop 6 months ago
Man I'm so in love with this song, idk how someone could hate this. I can't seem to get this tune out of my head, especially the chorus.
"There was a moth caught in the soap dish laminated in lye, will you still remember me well? If I don't get two oh oh five, my dead line Gemini."
SebbyG0 6 months ago in playlist Indie2.
a great song full of exuberance and personality
nobody2612 8 months ago
Dat ass @0:38
sicktransitwhittier 8 months ago
beautiful
ibenyo 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
my favorite song right now.
hockeyyismylife 9 months ago
This is a great video.
dzikimberly 10 months ago
Definitely an interesting video. Kept me engaged.
DSHC224 10 months ago
wth
SOxxLegit 10 months ago
this is one of my favorite songs of all time. the video just made that fact extremely clear.
kmsabia 10 months ago 2
Does not this song merit all the stages of life? the lyrics describe the process of growing old, and th music gives common sounds of growing and maturing. Genius, genius band and one of the greatest Cd's of the 21st Century. Keep going.. Why?!!!
FratDeltaTheta 11 months ago
That guy is def a gemini
murgaferd 11 months ago
My question would be: Why not?
seart911 11 months ago 2
farout this guy is so skuxx
DrumAndBassCunt 11 months ago
Great work Christopher. Don't ever stop!
vegankatzman 11 months ago
4:45-5:05 is giving me goosebumps everytime i listen to this song and i think i have more than a hundred plays.
best band in the world
brostyletyp 1 year ago 2
GOD DAYUM! ppl need to know about this up commmming threat! Moth ppl are extreamly dangerous and can make white gurlz go crazy.... as shown in dis MAGNIFICENT video:)
P.S
Please thumbs up this video to spread DEADLY Moth men awareness... Thank You.
GibyForce5 1 year ago
This is the most adorable thing .. I'm gonna cry. ; w ;
metroscene 1 year ago
this is great.
Dealyo5 1 year ago
I'm speechless as the tears well up in my eyes... Simply brilliant.
missmuddykat 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Online dating brides **busizz4me.info**
bolgendolki 1 year ago
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA what the fucuuuuuuck!?! oh my god hahaha
Greenjumper25 1 year ago
THis is one of those songs you listen to and once you hear the chorus it brings back some memories
Sagefrakrobatik 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Quite simply, The dumbest thing I've ever seen! Reminded me of William Hung, Was waiting for him to jump up and say "She Bangs,She Bangs!" Therfore,I wont watch it anymore.
yamahajim906 1 year ago
@yamahajim906 skank.
XxDJKRONIKxX 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@yamahajim906 skank.
XxDJKRONIKxX 9 months ago
Excelent video, brilliant.
yossariancomplex 1 year ago
i know them for 2 hours and i like them more than all the indi bands i know
jeroenvlas 1 year ago 16
know them for like 2 hours and i like them more than all the indi bands i know
jeroenvlas 1 year ago
I love this man, so great.
puintinqocher 1 year ago
Dream within a Dream hahaha So Inception isn't as original as we thought....
teejscorner 1 year ago 12
I know how it feels,feeling out of place with somebody that you consider to be so much better than yourself.
Well done.
Foxhound936 1 year ago
0:44 u can see her tits haha XD
pokerfacelovesme 1 year ago
@pokerfacelovesme Haha, I noticed the same thing
ezequielbarrios 1 year ago
omg hes the alien i dreamed about ahhhhhhhhhh!!!!!!!11
yamelt89 1 year ago
aww:( hulk sad....hulk dont smash....
pokerfacelovesme 1 year ago
ah, this is beautiful
NoBusesx 1 year ago
If you can think outside the box and not be freaked out by quirkiness, rather take a few minutes to soak in something new and listen to deep, powerful lyrics, then Why? is the shit
macrofocus1988 1 year ago
great video! very impressive
shanemoore02 1 year ago
sik vid
UKherps 1 year ago
why cant any thing indie have a happy ending
imnotheretobelittle 1 year ago
ima gemini do i win something
jojaeda 1 year ago
hey, you should upload a higher quality video of this! my friends and i really like it. you should send it to why?, too. i think they'd appreciate it, it's beautiful!
Pecoae 1 year ago
Wow, I have been listening to this song for Years!
Good vid, but why the down syndrome people
WHY?
OM3N1R 1 year ago
love is always like a dream
kcnumbernine 1 year ago
Whats the deal with the weird old Asian kid? Was he a child, or just mentally impaired? And why was he wearing those ridiculous pajamas, only a small child would wear them. I DON'T GET IT AT ALL.
butterw 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
hes got down syndrom. hahahah
noonelikesalexD 1 year ago
@butterw Kind sir, he's mentaly impaired, and its about him falling in love with the one girl, then not understanding its wrong to kiss the other girl. Its a fairly simple story to understand but I must admit at first I couldn't understand it, I hope you enjoyed this song, WHY? is the best band ever.
richard07960 1 year ago
@richard07960 I thought he understood it was wrong, but that the friend kissed him deliberately in order to break him up with his girlfriend, because she couldn't bear the thought that her friend was seeing him.
fionndempsey 1 year ago
Favorite song ever. This video is so self-indulgent though.
arlinkingmartin 1 year ago
Aw =/
I love this song <3
shakinsharah 1 year ago
id recommend the entire alopecia and elephant eyelash albums..pure genius
pksk8er 2 years ago 4
Eskimo Snow is a great album also, deven though it ended up getting panned because critics were expecting more of the same from Yoni. Into the Shadows of My Embrace, These Hands, January Twentysomething, The Blackest Purse, Eskimo Snow...these were some of my favorite songs of last year.
negatyve 2 years ago
I absolutely adore this song and video. Does anyone know of any similar songs?
MakingFaces 2 years ago
crushed bones
MegalonsRevenge 2 years ago
just found this band this morning and holy shit
734jow734 2 years ago 122
@734jow734 if u havent already listened to the vowels pt 2 u have to im od on it:)
boutthatx 1 year ago
@734jow734 you are in for a ride! they rock! check out Anna's Cabin/Elephant Eyelash/Alopecia....all my fav albums!
tengajenga 8 months ago
@734jow734 Congratulations
JasmineGhiotto 8 months ago
@734jow734
JasmineGhiotto 8 months ago
good job!
welchesgod 2 years ago
awesome song. awesome band.
KlahreBruehe117 2 years ago
Yoni <33333333333
AmandaAmazzing 2 years ago 3
WHY? = Awesome. Look it up.
HonorableZealot 2 years ago 2
i just became a fan of them now LOL
sariH512 2 years ago
This made me teary. Nice job, compliments a wonderful song.
futurejessica 2 years ago
love the song and the video! good job! very good job! xD
lockypocky 2 years ago
5*'s favoring. Amazing :)
MaxBemisingod 2 years ago
What a beautiful video...
mundi420 2 years ago 3
fanmade video?... mindblowing!!!
kyebaby003 2 years ago 5
really great video... really emotional
arcticpew 2 years ago
Does anyone of you got the tabs for piano for this song??
I love it♥
TheLunea 2 years ago
Quite amazing. I admire the fan that created this video.
Theobtusellama 2 years ago
it wasnt a fan. its official
markrochman94 2 years ago
It is? eh..oh well. The description said it was a fan made vid.
Theobtusellama 2 years ago 3
oh yeah! sorry! i just figured because it was on the anticon thing.
markrochman94 2 years ago
What is this I don't even
hottjosh777 2 years ago 3
"should we be tempted by thief or by saint"
i love that.
it's a thief that cheats with your significant other, or a saint that caues you to.
elf4life420 2 years ago 4
is this really fanmade?????
insaneSadcl0wn 2 years ago
awesome
JimmyFuzz 2 years ago
i lovelovelovelove this video
shlong15 2 years ago
this is so wonderful
elbigotegrande 2 years ago
Brilliant, brilliant video
PyroD00d 2 years ago
i cry everytime i hear this song
its all the exact same things that my boyfriend would say to me.
really good song and video.
rosenrot415 2 years ago
anticon is always good. I love Why?
dziregl 2 years ago
what do u think up while i tongue u down... lol
PierceThomasCramner 2 years ago
Its 'dream' instead of 'think'.
That refers to the line 'i want a verb and you give me a noun'. Dream and tongue are verbs and nouns aswell- this is a nice lil word play Wolf implemented.
Sorry for the disturbance :-)
Ryufire 2 years ago 20
@Ryufire I actually have always thought that little bit was the most interesting and creative line I'd heard in any song. Why? is such a great band. =]
insert1wittynamehere 10 months ago
@Ryufire same with kiss and pulse!
OldBearful 7 months ago
@Ryufire and offer and shower too!
well played mr.wolf.
OldBearful 7 months ago
why can't i get this song out of my head?
it's pure poetry
yourmomandimakelove 2 years ago
I WANT A VERB AND YOU GIVE ME A NOUN
feminizzle420 2 years ago
all i can say is amazing
timestopsforever 2 years ago 2
Stupendous video!
By funny coincidence, i watched Vanilla Sky last night.
cooloriginaltwic 2 years ago
quite good.
BlameTheSpam 2 years ago
The video is really great. I've woken up just like that, you're greeted with a flashback you really don't want to have. Brilliant video.
badname1986 3 years ago
this video makes me wanna cry... its amazing.
MetricJustice 3 years ago
There was a moth caught in the soapdish laminated in lye
will you still remember me well?
ChadwickLynch 3 years ago 6
He's so cute.
By the way, this is an amazing video, kudos to the fan that made it. My heart goes out to you.
xmadisonmassacre 3 years ago 2
My heart goes out to you and the kid in the video.
makhtari 3 years ago 2
so sweet..
cohexu 3 years ago
i can't describe how much this song means to me- and the heartfullness of this video.
-may 30th
shaddartshaddart 3 years ago 4
i love this!
i'm june first
zepass 3 years ago 2
great.
theyounghegelian 3 years ago
Pretty amazing
Quarters 3 years ago
does anybody know who the man is?
this is freaking awesome music video..
it gives me goosebumps
aiur00 3 years ago
This video was so well done! Great job to the director and it fits the song so well.
:D
defdetband 3 years ago 4
awesome!
seanarrative 3 years ago 3
Wauv, this is one of the coolest musicvideos I have ever seen... goes for the song too
thormj 3 years ago 3
Amazing!!!, I cant belived that is a fan video!
10 starts (if this is possible)
bladerunnerchile 3 years ago 5
for now i understand that the blonde bitch wanted to destroy his relationship.
tristero1 3 years ago
could anyone explain me what is that video about ?
tristero1 3 years ago
The guy is so funny!
SCSNIP3R 3 years ago
That was excellent! Very well done.
mikebanana81 3 years ago 2
that is great!
linathechic 3 years ago
Really great interpretation with awesome visual application!
sleepily 3 years ago 2
well your a loser cause you wont notice i said that
JaminDamon 3 years ago
hello kyeti
JaminDamon 3 years ago
a fan did this?
this is sooo cool!
newbie201111 3 years ago
oh wow, this was a fan video?
fantastic work!
POCKETS2thaMAX 3 years ago
i didnt get this at all, but it was so beautiful
Somone23 3 years ago
great video, nice job Chris.
Why? is excellent, there needs to be more videos like this one
davestonechucks 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I'm an gemini cheeck out my video gemini it says about a gemini and how I'll make a video for your sign if you tell me your sign.
cat3312 3 years ago
lol his hat says denis
jugglelulz 3 years ago
wow, this video was perfect! good job!
NicolaLovesMusic 3 years ago 5
Comment removed
3x4R4x3 3 years ago
Comment removed
3x4R4x3 3 years ago
Comment removed
3x4R4x3 3 years ago
to funkymonk25
you listened the beatles on the radio aswell, poor "indie" jackass
fjgarrid 3 years ago 3
the video was similar to a modest mouse video exept this one was a little confusing . what was that moth thing?
jugglelulz 3 years ago
"there was a moth caught in the soapdish laminated in lye"
Choppah 3 years ago 2
i guess i missed that. It all makes sense now.
of course :}
its almost too easy
jugglelulz 3 years ago
sick serously inspiring.
ratsnasty 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
wow. tried to give anticon another chance.
it still sucks.
cdirty220 3 years ago
wow... that was a really... really great video
FlanJa 3 years ago 2
this is a good song.
totallythweet 3 years ago 2
...
curtez 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
that was boring, like if you heard that song on the radio you'd be like.. what the hell is this crap? do they just let any garbage on the airwaves these days?? I'm so sick of people saying its a great song just because the lyrics are "cool" or "insightful". if its annoying to listen to, whats the point? its better left as a poem for someone to read.
PrincessSupersam 3 years ago
your not a dead line gemini so you would never know
mason510 3 years ago 2
Oh dear - if you talk as your write you would know all about being annoying.
'Like'.
BTW, people are saying it's a great song because that's their opinion - is that, like, ok with you?
sfa2 3 years ago
So I have to accept that other people enjoy the song and think it is fantastic, and am not allowed to voice my opinion, while they are?
Can anyone cry hypocritical?
PrincessSupersam 3 years ago
You can think what you will, but you don't have to be a cunt about it. At this point you're just being a bitch for the sake of being a bitch, there's nothing constructive about it.
ZoneGrise 3 years ago
"like if you heard that song on the radio..."
See there's your first problem, you're listening to the shit on the radio.
funkymonk25 3 years ago 2
Yes but your opinion is idiotic and no one cares so just shut up already
PunumMute 3 years ago 2
If you dont like dont listen or watch you stupid idiot I mean it is pointless to listen to something you clearly hate it so much try and think Ms.Bitchy
PunumMute 3 years ago
what are you 12?!
cieramichelle 3 years ago
heartaching
phiu 3 years ago
awsome video
nocarsgohey 3 years ago
very cool music video.
futureforscenerios 3 years ago 3
Dope video! the lyrics in this song hit close to home.... and im sorry oatmeal but the asian guy does have Down syndrome! but i think its kool, ppl in directors position dont usually use them as a protagonist. But i think that the video is beautiful and original! And Why? is already one of the best so do another video for one of their new songs im sure it will be Dope as well.
pezgraph 3 years ago 4
this so in super sad, super beautiful, and why's evolution has been incredible
shiftphake 3 years ago 4
This Video makes me want to cry.
oatmeal5001 3 years ago
I did, man! Gosh, I love this band.
homsar1988 3 years ago 2
I swallow a coal, and follow my breath
Turning in your drug dry sleep. When I ask you to kiss my pulse, you offer to start the shower. I ask for a verb and you give me a noun, what do you dream up while I tongue you down?
Tishagi 3 years ago
almost cried... lol
fraankiefraank06 3 years ago 3
great song, touching video. don't we all have this kind of dream? i know i do.
togetherless 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i like it but that the guy's face sucks. it really bothers me.
drdazzle 3 years ago
dude. he has down syndrome.
Primo13144 3 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I hope your just joking. It's obvious that he's Asian not mentally challanged.
oatmeal5001 3 years ago
this is pretty wild. i wonder if yoni's seen this.
warofthewells 3 years ago
Best music video ever. Yoni Wolf is a brilliant lyricist, and my favorite MC.
KingOfCarrotflowers 3 years ago 2
the video is perfect. nothing to compare about its simply great
lpfan92 3 years ago
brilliant video!!
filzbaum 3 years ago
this is one of my fav videos
my mom hates my music but cried when she watched this
nanaimodude 3 years ago
You are a genius. Great job.
ParableFunction 3 years ago
that chick is hot
AnThOnYrox8 3 years ago