I prefer Hamelin's version -- my ear (which is subjective, of course) tells me Hamelin's dyamic shadings are sharper, crisper. Also, Hamelin has a better sense of narrative "drive" without necessarily playing faster. In fact, Lang may be playing a faster tempo, but somehow the pulse seems a bit flat.
I don't know . . . just an opinion. He's certainly a lot better than I could ever hope to be.
Although i don't like Lang Lang, i agree that he is doing great here! The tone, the nuances and some surprises are awesome, and imho they all fit in Haydn's character! I just wouldn't rush so much, there's no need to rush at all.
Thank you Lang Lang for the great contribution and sacrifice that you have made to the world of piano.
I appreciate your unique perspective on Haydn - the same thing with Mozart and Beethoven. Your clarity, stability, evenness, sensitivity, dynamic rang and beauty of tone are a constant wonder to me.
I wish you the best in all of your future endeavours.
I am learning this piece right now, and have learned a lot from this lang lang video. He has helped me gain exitement for this piece because before it was a drag for me to play.
I wonder why people focus the attention on Lang Lang face. Cover the video and listen and if you played piano at more than good levels, you will understand why his fame is going so impressive day by day. Haydn .. a simple song. But he makes it new with a really surprising interpretation. We know how much such songs risk to be so similar to a MIDI file :) So enjoy Lang Lang ! Bravo !
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
simple? yeah RIGHT
i've played this piece for a year
and there are SO many sublte musical things to do. mozart, haydn, etc. they all sound pretty simple to an average human but trust me, it's not.
and as for lang lang's facial expressions, i do agree that if you don't look at him, his music is amazing. but then again, as a performer, people will be watching your facial expressions so you can't really say "don't look at him!" haha i wish he woudl jsut cover his head with a paper bag and play
Hi, with simple I meant something like not as Scriabin or Rach....more soft and fluid. It was not a dislike at all !
I really believe we can not complain or judge his faces. He has a really mimical face and he can not help it. So ... I take the whole package ... faces too ;)
速度太快, 趕住去投胎!
MrEbaby2011 3 months ago
This peace is not easy at all. It holds many possibilities to sound silly.
zzausel 4 months ago
one of the better lang lang interpretations
jyoo21 5 months ago
wwooooow cool
qristinaful 8 months ago
Qui peut le beaucoup plus... peu le moins!
Il me fait apprécier une des sonates de Haydn que je trouve, la plupart du temps, insipides...désolé pour les pas difficiles!
L'extrème sensibilité ainsi que la plus prodigieuse technique pianistique qui ait été donné à un homme se trouvent réuni dans cet être.
Le bon qualitatif accompli est tout simplement prodigieux!
Les autres...tous sans exception...sont à des années lumière!
josajpnide 1 year ago
I prefer Hamelin's version -- my ear (which is subjective, of course) tells me Hamelin's dyamic shadings are sharper, crisper. Also, Hamelin has a better sense of narrative "drive" without necessarily playing faster. In fact, Lang may be playing a faster tempo, but somehow the pulse seems a bit flat.
I don't know . . . just an opinion. He's certainly a lot better than I could ever hope to be.
jbarbri 1 year ago
We just cannot play like him!
musicheaven1 2 years ago
Well played, I don't like Lang Lang on some things but this is a very good interpetation.
pianoOBBSESED 2 years ago 7
Although i don't like Lang Lang, i agree that he is doing great here! The tone, the nuances and some surprises are awesome, and imho they all fit in Haydn's character! I just wouldn't rush so much, there's no need to rush at all.
trms83br 2 years ago 7
Thank you Lang Lang for the great contribution and sacrifice that you have made to the world of piano.
I appreciate your unique perspective on Haydn - the same thing with Mozart and Beethoven. Your clarity, stability, evenness, sensitivity, dynamic rang and beauty of tone are a constant wonder to me.
I wish you the best in all of your future endeavours.
May God bless you and your own.
Concerto35
concerto35 2 years ago 14
This has been flagged as spam show
Very good but il looks like a monkey smiling for his studies!
too much studied!
richardre06 3 years ago
Awesome! Thank you.
musicheaven1 3 years ago 5
I am learning this piece right now, and have learned a lot from this lang lang video. He has helped me gain exitement for this piece because before it was a drag for me to play.
1dcsedtaxi 3 years ago 10
This comment has received too many negative votes show
BWHAHAHA Lang Lang always cracks me up.
at 3:35, he vaguely reminds me of Shrek roflmao
RSFREAK969 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
lol
Desdemondia 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
actually he does..... lmfao
Desdemondia 3 years ago
I rarely like LL's interpretations, but this one is absolutely superb!!!
voolare 3 years ago 10
I wonder why people focus the attention on Lang Lang face. Cover the video and listen and if you played piano at more than good levels, you will understand why his fame is going so impressive day by day. Haydn .. a simple song. But he makes it new with a really surprising interpretation. We know how much such songs risk to be so similar to a MIDI file :) So enjoy Lang Lang ! Bravo !
LukeMD 3 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
simple? yeah RIGHT
i've played this piece for a year
and there are SO many sublte musical things to do. mozart, haydn, etc. they all sound pretty simple to an average human but trust me, it's not.
and as for lang lang's facial expressions, i do agree that if you don't look at him, his music is amazing. but then again, as a performer, people will be watching your facial expressions so you can't really say "don't look at him!" haha i wish he woudl jsut cover his head with a paper bag and play
pianogurly 3 years ago
Hi, with simple I meant something like not as Scriabin or Rach....more soft and fluid. It was not a dislike at all !
I really believe we can not complain or judge his faces. He has a really mimical face and he can not help it. So ... I take the whole package ... faces too ;)
LukeMD 3 years ago 6
Check out Lang Lang's Widmung by Liszt on youtube. He supresses his facial expression. I think that's his latest video so far here on youtube.
rshace4 3 years ago
True. His tone and clarity is amazing.
He is a musician not an actor so should really LISTEN rather than watching.
This piece may sound quite simple but not that simple.
Really impressive.
ph2trademe 3 years ago 16
I am currently learning this song and I find it very good for technical application. Played w/ the correct technique it is actually pretty simple.
adrienhhunter 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is crazy! Lang Lang playing Haydn!? I thought that'd never happen.
beryllium2 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Uhmmmm haydn translate to a chinese language...
ytpiano7 3 years ago
Yeah. He plays it a bit fast at most fortes but great performance.
konzolmester 4 years ago 7
I've never heard this particular sonata before. Beautifully executed, thank you.
Strav777 4 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
lol he looks like he's on drugs when he smiles like that but still, wonderful playing
RandomCoke 4 years ago
it is great!
murxl 4 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
urgh.. his face... the camera... just... urgh...
but great skills tho..
pianoismusic 4 years ago