Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (420)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • im quite sure most if not all of the ppl saying the sir playing this in the video sucks can not even play a piano let alone read sheet music. So hush. This is pretty good

  • This is good, do you know where you can get sheet music to learn this song?

  • I love this song so much... Good job! I can play it but it's kinda hard to reach a whole octave so fast... Anyway good Job, it was awesome.

  • you kinda screwed the song up at 1:40. you shouldn't have been playing all of the keys at once. otherwise, your cover is pretty good.

  • Man such a great cover, if it was slowed a little it would have been perfect, I liked the added part at the end and how you changed the vocals to piano for when shadows and Rev would have been singing at the end

  • id like to do a vocal cover, for this amazing piano cover :D

  • Soz if many peeps alreayd said this but it is way too faaaaaaaasssssst =)

  • hey man. you did really well, I mean I know I've only been playing for 6 years, but I still could never learn how to pick that out just by ear. I can't wait until they come out with the real sheet music. You did a great job!!

  • donde conseguiste la partitura? me la podrias pasar xfa (:?

  • WWAAAYY to fast dude!!!

  • nice ;D

  • thats not what he does on the lower part in the intro, he hits each note seperately with a low C after every couple, hard to explain but if u listen closely u can hear

  • 0.0 i semi-played a while in my piano.. and .. OMGG! I COULDNT! E_E I NEED BIGGER HANDS! I COULDNT REACH C - C! my fingers hurt! y.y

  • WAYYYYY TOOO FAST!

  • Too fast.

  • Good job.

    But, as everyone else said,

    It's a little rushed.

    I didn't thin you got the memo.

    (Sarcasm..)

  • Perfect but your a little too fast for the song

  • BEAUTIFUL, BUT A BIT FAST, SLOW IT WAY DOWN AND IT WILL BE BETTER THAN ANY OF THE OTHERS POSTED ON HERE. EVEN MY FAVORITE GIRL. I HAVE U TO MY FAVORITES, CAUSE I LOVE THIS SONG, BUT CAN'T PLAY THE REAL VERSION IN ALL AUDIENCES. PLEASE TRY TO DO SCATTERED BROKEN DREAMS , THAT WOULD BE AWESOME , THE BEGINNING SOLO BY THE REV WAS WONDERFUL,, THANKS FOR SHARING

    PEACE, SA

  • How are you claiming you "learned it by ear" and you "have no sheet music" for this song, yet in the video, you can CLEARLY see the sheet music on your piano for this song? :|

  • @MisturPuffy Sorry to disappoint you, but it's a sheet for another song called ,,The heart asks pleasure first´´ by Michael Nyman. I forgot to put it aside. If you don't believe me, buy the sheet and check it ;)

  • @MisturPuffy You rational is flawless friend...

  • Dude your Hella beast!

  • Fuck the haters I think its amazing!!!

  • That was awesome :D good job

  • Dude, you got to make a tutorial of it! I want to learn it to!

  • You are going so fuckin' fast.. DISLIKE!

  • You people who are insulting him are ignorant and I bet you couldn't play near that good! It was beautiful and I know it is a really difficult piece ! Ignore the rude comments they know nothing!

  • @krishathatsme actually it is one of the easiest avenged sevenfold to learn.

  • slow down slow downn

  • Comment removed

  • thats was very good man

  • Amazingg

  • Slowwww down a bit bro....

    Otherwise it was brilliant. :)

  • Comment removed

  • too fats, very bad :/

  • too fast man :/

  • Great:)

  • eu quero muito aprender tocar essa musica , nossa , perfeito! *-*

  • Toooo fast :c

  • 3 Words Great + Awesome! = Perfect!!

    LLOOVVVVEEEE IT! =)

  • Пи*дец....

    темп вообще ужасный взял.....

    АВТООООР, НУЖНО СДЕРЖАННЕЕ ИГРАААТЬ

    И не загонять такое произведение, нужно уметь чувствовать....

  • way too fast but it still sounds good though.. i need to learn how to play this.

  • absoltely beautiful ...like others said a little fast with the tempo but other than that perfect. :)

  • That piano hook is down right creepy. I LOVE this song.

  • the left hand is completely wrong...

  • @taravaishnav his left hand looks fine to me xD

  • @taravaishnav I know. He's not supposed be banging all of the fingers at once, he's supposed to play each key seperately.

    (Wow, that sounds dirty o.o)

  • @taravaishnav I know. It's supposed to be an arpeggio on the bottom. Well not an arpeggio, but C G C C G C C G C. You know what I mean. I don't know music terminology.

  • its awesome that you were able to figure it out by ear (it took me about two weeks to get completely, and i dont play the vocal part) but just a little suggestion: if you use a metronome and match the speed as close as you can with the song, and then play with that it wont be so inconsistent

  • fuck everyone who says youre doing it too fast its a great song and you dont have to do it perfectly. you did amazing!! i wish i was that good on piano. keep doing what you do piano man :D

  • i don't care if it is fast! damn! he's still good!

  • Fast, but good.

  • how about play it in the god damn right speed? douchebag

  • <3

  • Who cares if it was too fast? It's still great! Nicely done!

  • Ya'll need to shut up...DUDE, my husband and I have watched this video several times...To all of you putting this guy down....SHUT UP...I would like to see you play this song...not to mention he can play fast which also means he could play slow if he really wanted to....I THINK YOU DID AN AWESOME JOB!!!!!

  • @mrbillbl I'm not putting him down, but sometimes it is easier to play faster. If you played piano and/or guitar you would understand.

  • You played the main riff way too-

    Oh wait, they told yout that already?

    Nicely done by the way.

  • sounds epic fast so people stop complaining haha

  • this is awesome :)

  • Wow my iPod died right after finishing this video!

  • 19 people are stupid. great cover. slow down the main riff tho.

  • C'MON

    was just me that liked the main riff fast?

  • Cool....

    But too fast ....

  • kind of fast but still great job

  • tab?

  • wow too fast but still a beast :)

  • hey not to be spamming but I did a cover of fiction to, and I wanna see if it's any good? so please check out my channel:) MariaAndersonTV. :) thanks guys!:)

  • wow shut up, it was still good, who cares if it was played fast

  • the Cm accompaniment chord during the main riff should be arpegio'd. Just saying. :)

  • Too fast. It really sound like a orchestra song.

  • too fast

  • it's really good. i suggest slowing down a bit. other than that, good job.

  • RIP Rev, 1 year ago, not on this day, but a few earlier we lost the best drummer in the world. He will always be in our hearts, and he will teach the angels his ways of drumming R.I.P

  • wow

  • Oh, i love it *--* It sound beautiful

  • Holy shit. You learned that in a few hours and by ear?! /impressed

  • Sound a little too fast.

  • I CANNOT FIND SHEET MUSIC FOR THIS ANYWHERE!

  • @paramore364 Same here, I'm gonna try to lean by watching covers on youtube/by ear.

  • no sheet music? then whats that thing on ur stand?

  • @ChoreoProBoy what's on the stand isn't the sheet music to this song

  • @ChoreoProBoy if you have guitar pro, the piano part is on ultimateguitar

  • @ChoreoProBoy if you look at the sheet music on his stand, you can see that it is clearly not the sheet music for fiction.

  • Do you have any sheet music for this? Let me know if you do or send me a link.

  • my hands got soooo effin tired when I played this, and where did you get that note, I looked and looked and looked for it & I just couldn't find it, PLEASE I BEG YOU, TELL ME :'[

  • beautiful slow down you have my sub!

  • loved it loved it loved it!!!!! Although i do still agree that you were a little fast

  • sheet music?

  • if i'm not mistaken, the right-hand part for the verse is played differently in the song....

  • The faster you play , the worse the song is :[

  • Too fast , slow down and it'll be perfect :]

  • Wil you please please give us the sheet music?

  • right hand is way too fast

  • I can see the papers you are looking at...is it the right song? and could you maybe scan them?

  • great :)

  • yeah, you played the main riff a lil bit too fast, but still thanks for sharing man, AMAZING JOB! :))

  • Fiction on speed...

  • Way too fast!

  • Comment removed

  • To fast...

  • My first kiss was when I was listening to that music

  • @SonicPedroTurbinado You got your first kiss while listening to a song about death?

  • Comment removed

  • Great job man!

  • Dude you are great at playing the piano but next time take it slower but u still got SKILLS

  • yes.. it is way too fast... you are stripping the song of its deep meaning and epic nature... yes we see you can play it quickly.. wish it was done right tho

  • @AvengedAngel13 Sounds basically the same. Its not too fast to lose the feeling. Calm down.

  • @AvengedAngel13 It wasn't that bad. You should try to play it once if you think you know best. Try the chorus, I have had 3 years of piano lessons and I think it's really hard to play. You will certainly fail. Good luck.

    He was too fast, I know. But still, don't say it was so bad.

  • @AvengedAngel13 dude, there's no meaning if there aren't any lyrics, this is piano instrumental...

  • Do u have the sheet music for this? if u do can u plz sumhow send it to me? :)

  • yeah dude i dont think theres a reason to rush in the chorus but very good tough sincerely

  • Nice. 

  • Play it as fast as you like, but it doesn't really make sense to be so fast and energetic in the riff and then go so slow in the verses.

  • caaa-aattchy tune

  • It dont matter how fast their playing it I think its gr8. Mentagulis Im now a fan. Keep up the good work. foREVer

  • amazing

  • This, is simply awesome. Slightly too fast, but doesn't matter at all, your playing compensates it all. GREAT! ;D

  • I don't know if I already commented on the video. But you nailed it!

  • too fast :<

  • Your going to fast...

    The rev plays the piano

    way slower then you do..

  • Gorgous. Just, gorgous.

  • Although a little fast, but you have great talent. =)

  • People who are giving this person crap on being to fast are jerks themselves if all they see is how precise they are when attempting this instead of enjoying and shutting their trolling trap they would see the beauty in this but again no talent losers will try to find anything to rip on when they see an excelent instrumental player or anything else to make themselves feel better! Shut up! Enjoy! Or I will report u for herassing him!!!

  • i think im gona cry +}

  • The Rev Was A True Musical Genius and Sadly for all his Fans This Was His Last Masterpiece he will never be Forgotten ♥ ♥ foREVer ♥ ♥..♫ ♫ ♫ 

  • damn dude slow the hell down oh and btw the bottom notes are played as arpeggios and its all one tempo if u used a metronome you would know that wouldn't

  • damn dude slow the hell down

  • outstanding !!!!

  • i love you :D

  • You were way too fast in the main riff, but it was still very good.

  • @MShadows17PSN he had to crap

  • Fucking amazing. =]

  • you did a sick ass job on the chorus big dog.

  • well aside from what other people say, i think it sounds great, ya it is a little fast at parts, but it sounds good, and pretty correct, so i say good job to you :)

  • awesome.....i like this!!!

  • TOO FAST ASSHOLE

  • BEAUTIFUL!

    favorited, and liked :D

  • this is crazy awesome. i wish i had the skills. :( RIP THE REV.

  • really really good(: yes a bit fast but it dosnt realy matter. you still did really good(;

  • nice man i got put in piano at scool so i was thinking bout learnin this

  • Where did you get the sheet music for this song??

  • where did you get the music to this?

  • Beautiful :) I'm gonna start learning this!

  • awesome! just a lil to fast

  • I think the rev would be proud. I thought this cover was pretty fucking sweet.

  • bit fast ._.  still awesome.

  • to fast to fast but other than that it was good

    

  • This is awesome, I wish I could play piano

  • whoa way too fast

    but better than others ive seen

  • is there anywhere that I can find the sheet music for this? online or in a store somewhere...

  • you rock

  • how hard is this to play on piano or kyeboard or whatever?

    coz im gonna start leanring how to play keyboard, i play guitar btw :P

  • That was So NICE!

  • The Rev would be sooo proud watching this.

    All you guys who give credit to him are awesome.

    Anytime I play this song,it chills me,cause I feel like Jimmy is sitting right behind me,with a big smile on his face,watching me,hitting my cymbals all the time.

    You would've been proud when he could see all these covers.

  • the rev would be proud :)

  • Dude this was amazing, it was so helpful, i learned the song within an hour, thanks abunch!!!!!

  • Where did you get the sheet music? I'm also looking for warmness on the soul :)

  • Where did you get the sheet music? :)

  • @royal6526 or u could just download atube catcher

  • What's the first part? I can see it's B-C (two tones at the same time, a fifth?), but not the rest.. :P I'd like to learn this one too.

  • Awesome job!!! I would have slowed it down some in the beginning though.

  • its really good... <3

    just a bit fast D:

  • Aside from some rushed moments, amazing job! 8D

  • your very good!!!!!!

  • Dude tht was tasty

  • Apart from the begining being a little too fast, fucking amazing. Great job.

  • What kind of piano is that

  • some parts reminded me of sherlock holmes. =P

    great cover