I know this comment is rather late but I just found it lol. I agree with rmaxam3, can't judge if you can't see. And I'm also wondering if you know what a French accent is cause Lumiere definitely had the whole French thing goin on. I haven't seen pinelands (whoever that is) so I can't really say much about quality. What I do know,however, is that I as well as plenty of others had loads of fun doing this show. That's kinda what matters to me anyway. Sure does bring back memories lol
of course, this video was put up for the sole purpose of being compared to Pinelands. >.> No accent in the slightest? Are you listening? Second, how can you possibly judge how much energy there is...you can't make out any facial expressions and the audio is kinda crappy.
I played Lumiere in this video and I had some of the most fun I've ever had on stage. I'm happy to see someone who shares my joy of having played this part, but it's too bad he had to be such a snob. Thank you for your criticism
I don't think this Lumiere is all that bad. So much depends on the size of the school and the size of the student body, and the director.
I've watched a bunch of these clips, the best Lumiere I've seen so far is from a clip that had VRMP and VRHS in its title. His acting and emotion were both excellent.
Is this Lumiere for real? I played Lumiere for Pinelands, and had an absolute blast. This kid looks like he had to force everything out of him. He does not look excited to please Belle in the slightest. No accent in the slightest, I'm not trying to sound pretentious, but I don't really understand how you can compare this to Pinelands' performance.
ITS A HIGH SCHOOL SHOW AND ONE VIDEO OF ONE PERFORMANCE!!!! There were many other performances and they were great. So what if our school wasn't as good as urs...big deal.
my school just did beauty and the beast and were soooo mcuh better than both schools. sorry. haha. my school was amazing. the set, the cast, the costumes, etc. everything was better!
Eh, it wa decent, but I liked Pinelands more. The thing is it seems a little dark for Disney, let alone beauty and the Beast. So Pinelands wins for set design. The choreography was ok, but it seemed some of the time that the actors just weren't enjoying themselves. the end they got better, but still. overall, Pinelands wins for choreography. Last, the acting. They were once again ok, but you cannot even say they were better than Pinelands.
Lumierre could've been a LITTLE more enthusiastic, Cogsworh could've been way more tight and wound up, and the two Mrs. Pots don't even compare! If you can't aknowledge at the very least that their Mrs. Pots was better, then you have classic 'our school is better because i'm in it' which is common, but not reliable if you say it is better. Sorry, but Pinelands wins by a landslide.
LOL LETS ALL JUDGE A HIGH SCHOOL MUSICAL.
totallygenni 3 months ago
I know this comment is rather late but I just found it lol. I agree with rmaxam3, can't judge if you can't see. And I'm also wondering if you know what a French accent is cause Lumiere definitely had the whole French thing goin on. I haven't seen pinelands (whoever that is) so I can't really say much about quality. What I do know,however, is that I as well as plenty of others had loads of fun doing this show. That's kinda what matters to me anyway. Sure does bring back memories lol
TiGeRxXmoose 1 year ago
of course, this video was put up for the sole purpose of being compared to Pinelands. >.> No accent in the slightest? Are you listening? Second, how can you possibly judge how much energy there is...you can't make out any facial expressions and the audio is kinda crappy.
I played Lumiere in this video and I had some of the most fun I've ever had on stage. I'm happy to see someone who shares my joy of having played this part, but it's too bad he had to be such a snob. Thank you for your criticism
rmaxam3 2 years ago
you cant have Beauty and the Beast without the cast having fun. Thats what makes it good.
clarky1216 2 years ago
I don't think this Lumiere is all that bad. So much depends on the size of the school and the size of the student body, and the director.
I've watched a bunch of these clips, the best Lumiere I've seen so far is from a clip that had VRMP and VRHS in its title. His acting and emotion were both excellent.
renteriaaria 2 years ago
Is this Lumiere for real? I played Lumiere for Pinelands, and had an absolute blast. This kid looks like he had to force everything out of him. He does not look excited to please Belle in the slightest. No accent in the slightest, I'm not trying to sound pretentious, but I don't really understand how you can compare this to Pinelands' performance.
jetblacknewyearxx 3 years ago
ITS A HIGH SCHOOL SHOW AND ONE VIDEO OF ONE PERFORMANCE!!!! There were many other performances and they were great. So what if our school wasn't as good as urs...big deal.
techiechick91 3 years ago
my school just did beauty and the beast and were soooo mcuh better than both schools. sorry. haha. my school was amazing. the set, the cast, the costumes, etc. everything was better!
elloyd1209 3 years ago
then let my see your video of the show so i can see if its better or not
inuyashakg 3 years ago
Eh, it wa decent, but I liked Pinelands more. The thing is it seems a little dark for Disney, let alone beauty and the Beast. So Pinelands wins for set design. The choreography was ok, but it seemed some of the time that the actors just weren't enjoying themselves. the end they got better, but still. overall, Pinelands wins for choreography. Last, the acting. They were once again ok, but you cannot even say they were better than Pinelands.
Sorkymork 3 years ago
Lumierre could've been a LITTLE more enthusiastic, Cogsworh could've been way more tight and wound up, and the two Mrs. Pots don't even compare! If you can't aknowledge at the very least that their Mrs. Pots was better, then you have classic 'our school is better because i'm in it' which is common, but not reliable if you say it is better. Sorry, but Pinelands wins by a landslide.
Sorkymork 3 years ago