I'm sorry, but I have to critique this. You need more facial expressions. You know as well as I do, at least I hope you know, that ASL is a very expressive language. I was just bored watching you because all you were doing was moving your hands. I mean, you are telling a story to the rhythm of a song. You NEED more facial expressions. It was very boring for me to watch.
I loved this. I thought it was great. This is the song I base my life around and you did an amazing job. I don't know asl but omg you did awesome. I love you! You're freaking amazing. You rock keep it up.
Thank you Sai... your measured, thoughtful, respectful and touching interpretation of this, one of my favorite songs ever, is a work of art. Although I know barely a handful of ASL words and am lucky to get all the letters, I would not need to watching this. I just hope you do more. Wig in a Box and Midnight Radio would be... just so awesome. Best to you and thanks again. ~R
I'm an ASL interpretation student and I have to interpret a song as a final project. Despite being a Hedwig fan I had never even thought to do OoL. Thanks for the interpretation!
Oh, of course! I'm a hands-on type learner and if I just copied someone else I wouldn't remember it two seconds later. Doing the actual interpretation helps cement it in my head.
You can find on youtube an excellent animated adaptation with English subtitles of the text of Plato that inspired "Origin of Love" : it is titled "Speech of Aristophanes". Type it in the search engine.
Very cool. I couldn't stop watching it. Communication via gestures is very interesting, and seems like it could convey more meaning than spoken words. Hearing is definitely a sense I take for granted. Thanks, saizai.
You'd have to ask a deaf person. When I have done so, the answer is yes-sorta. Not in the same way as hearing people do, but they can feel vibrations (and are more sensitized to doing so), watch visualizations, etc. Plus whatever hearing they do have. Plus non-audio-requiring "music", e.g. this or sign-poetry or the like.
I'm sorry, but I have to critique this. You need more facial expressions. You know as well as I do, at least I hope you know, that ASL is a very expressive language. I was just bored watching you because all you were doing was moving your hands. I mean, you are telling a story to the rhythm of a song. You NEED more facial expressions. It was very boring for me to watch.
Jaguarzone 3 years ago
I can't speak sign language, but you are awesome for doing this. I love this song.
metalnotplastic 3 years ago
No one could ever "speak" a signed language ... lol! It's manual :D
20saul09 1 month ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
u suck
TAHSIN00HASAN 3 years ago
this is amazing.
sarathelatteboy 3 years ago 2
I loved this. I thought it was great. This is the song I base my life around and you did an amazing job. I don't know asl but omg you did awesome. I love you! You're freaking amazing. You rock keep it up.
colinf89 3 years ago 2
bravo u r so nice:)
manosthess 3 years ago
Wow, this was beautiful.
harper09 3 years ago
Thank you Sai... your measured, thoughtful, respectful and touching interpretation of this, one of my favorite songs ever, is a work of art. Although I know barely a handful of ASL words and am lucky to get all the letters, I would not need to watching this. I just hope you do more. Wig in a Box and Midnight Radio would be... just so awesome. Best to you and thanks again. ~R
randygetsmail 3 years ago
Ummmmm, Might you explain what you're doing? Serious question... I don't get it, like... you study this?
masterofunicycles 4 years ago
No, but I used to. I just do this because it's fun.
If you mean what I'm doing from a technical perspective, see my "linguistic & interpretive analysis of an asl 'terp" vidseries.
saizai 3 years ago
I'm an ASL interpretation student and I have to interpret a song as a final project. Despite being a Hedwig fan I had never even thought to do OoL. Thanks for the interpretation!
luckyalbatross 4 years ago
Glad to help. Hopefully you'll be doing your own interpretation though and not just ripping off mine. ;)
And you should post it to YT when you do it...
saizai 4 years ago
Oh, of course! I'm a hands-on type learner and if I just copied someone else I wouldn't remember it two seconds later. Doing the actual interpretation helps cement it in my head.
Plus, stealing is just rude. ;)
luckyalbatross 4 years ago
You can find on youtube an excellent animated adaptation with English subtitles of the text of Plato that inspired "Origin of Love" : it is titled "Speech of Aristophanes". Type it in the search engine.
PIOUPITZA 4 years ago
Brilliant! I just started studying ASL a few months ago, but this is really lovely. Great job!
sccello 4 years ago
Hedwig in ASL!!! BUWHAHAHAHA!!!
Love his sign for Zeus!!!
Blessed Be!!!
Ratdog93 4 years ago
This is a truly gorgeous interpretation of a beautiful song. Thank you!
OddBob552 4 years ago
the sign for making love is beautiful.
moskeetophreek 4 years ago
The one I did with ILYs is closer to 'making love' per se, the one with As is just 'being together'.
There are other signs of course.
saizai 4 years ago
You're my favorite now :-)
zander8605 4 years ago
I love you so much. <3
Crevanblackpaw 4 years ago
I'd love to have those fingers inside me...
sally1112 4 years ago
... O.o
I can't tell if this is spam or someone being silly.
saizai 4 years ago
wow, you are amazing human being for doing this. you and your interpretation... so beautiful. thank you!
hallospacegirl1013 4 years ago
This is the coolest thing ever! I've been learning ASL for a while, so that makes it even more neat!
heyletsmoo 4 years ago
You are a Beautiful on the Inside and the Outside...I can tell you are a Kind Person
atomicboy2000 4 years ago
you're so wonderful. thanks for that.
apexpark 4 years ago
Beautiful. Thanks, mate!
EH
electrohallaca 4 years ago
Very nice from you to do this!!!
bettomx 4 years ago
This is my favorite song and I am so glad someone is signing it, I've been wanting to sign it, it's beautiful you did an awesome job!
sawat90 4 years ago
This - is - really - amazing!
marcoiacomelli 4 years ago
Wow. This is quite incredible, just watching you hands. Love the movie, love this clip. Thanks
BuffyLover01 4 years ago
You are an awesome person to translate this song.
whodunnit5 4 years ago
That was really cool.
Willocwen 4 years ago
This is so sweet. I absolutely adore it.
asingularity 4 years ago
this is my favorite song and it was really interesting watching your video.thank you..
marytsouf 4 years ago
Welcome. :-)
saizai 4 years ago
Very cool. I couldn't stop watching it. Communication via gestures is very interesting, and seems like it could convey more meaning than spoken words. Hearing is definitely a sense I take for granted. Thanks, saizai.
na5m
na5m 4 years ago
It's not "gestures". ASL is a quite complete language with vocabulary, syntax, grammar, etc etc. :-P
saizai 4 years ago
I can't imagine not knowing what music sounds like, not being able to hear. Is there any way a deaf person can enjoy music? Thanks again, saizai.
na5m
na5m 4 years ago
You'd have to ask a deaf person. When I have done so, the answer is yes-sorta. Not in the same way as hearing people do, but they can feel vibrations (and are more sensitized to doing so), watch visualizations, etc. Plus whatever hearing they do have. Plus non-audio-requiring "music", e.g. this or sign-poetry or the like.
saizai 4 years ago
aw what a great song to interpret. this was really lovely :)
whiplashgirlchid 4 years ago
??, i think you're an interesting guy and I especially enjoy your videos that clarify arguments about agnosticism and atheism.
tidwell312 4 years ago
... thanks? I'm confused why you post this to my ASL 'terp though.
saizai 4 years ago
but i still rated it a 5.lmao
lovesiinger 4 years ago
your kinda strange. and i have no idea what you are talkinga bout.haha.
lovesiinger 4 years ago
...?
saizai 4 years ago
p.s. did you see the lyrics? -->
It's music. I'm not 'talking about' anything except in the intro, which should be pretty clear.
saizai 4 years ago