Haley Reinhart - I Who Have Nothing - Top 4

[Imtyler247]

0:12 always gives me chills :D

[michelle8088]

i was blown away. AMAZINGGGGG

[SuperXlala]

How did she not win? I'm still in shock.

[H2oblow]

gaaaaaagaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa



[bealestbluesss]

I hate it when jlo says baby

[mrseanpride]

epic voicee

[123qqqzzz]

演歌!

[27murmurs]

i really wanted to punch jlo and randy there and then.

[coliv1977]

I've seen this dozens of times and I never get tired of it. The top 3 should've been Haley, James and Pia, IMO

[JadedAngel23]

She said this is the top 3 not top 4.

[ColdDecemberNight]

@JadedAngel23 This is Top 4. She said "This is Top 3" because she has to nail this performance to be in the top 3.

[DeathTrapDaisy13]

its cause america is retarted and votes for the wrong ppl i always know my fave will be like the top 4 and get booted. she was my fave

[thelostchildren3]

This is why I think the show is rigged. She's clearly the most talented one there. She's had the most standing ovations from the judges. She's the most dramatic, the most unique, the best vocal, and the most mature of the top three. Idol clearly wanted a Lauren/Scotty final from the beginning.

[jenniwowwfan22]

to me this girl's voice is perfect she should have won<3

[Khlaes]

This is easily one of the top five performances ever on Idol. Her eyes, her body language, her mouth. It all sells the story of this woman who is desperately in love with a man she can't have. I love it.

[julzrules45]

She should have one american idol

[hyckou]

@julzrules45 won not one

[ParisPrimeaumusic]

This performance was brilliant. she showed them!! ;D

[marcosrainha]

3rd place?? She´s fu**** brilliant

[marco114]

Haley ooouuuzzzzesss SEX

[Nhai34]

3:10 She did what Gaga advised :D. She is a good singer n good listener as well ♥.

[truongphan90]

Gaga is cute! Love her!

Haley's debut single is out on 1st March, get ready to download it from ITunes Haliens!

[Gleek1able]

They made her cry right before this.. they learned the lesson. I'm sure she'd rather have literally slapped them.

[ANTMIndo1]

great!!!

she's magnificent...

i love her.....

[fogt1430]

lady gaga is pathetic

[neurotiiko]

Haley gave us a lot of great performances, the other top two did not!

[saurusviridis]

perfetta

[gucci1keisha1]

= )

[MsLayah1]

Wow sing bitch!!

[Gleek1able]

Awkward moment where Haley sings higher than the top of her range.. quoting Randy. You see jlo thinking.. damn I shouldn't have said what I did I'm an idiot telling them inspirational but really pick what everyone knows and likes.. Then Stevens all fuck you guys I tried to tell ya.

[ThatNerdyGuy3]

Lol - how do you feel about getting a little psycho?

CRAZY LOOK!

[momoj0408]

wow lady gaga and her mole is ugly

[kazziyang]

She's a performer. ^^

[tashagirl321]

i love her reaction when gaga says how do u feel about getting a lil syco:)

[ivyVaughn]

omg lady gaga sieht ja komplett behindert aus :)

[0803blondie]

I really feel Haley won! You can't mix a soulful rocker with Country singers. Country Music has it's own nation.. so, IMO Haley won representing all the rest of us who love they genre of music she so awesomely delivered!

[Gleek1able]

@0803blondie She can sing country too.. enter blue, and gunpowder and lead. Haley is so versatile anyone could like her.

[onicahhh]

lol jlo gotta love her <3

[OGIL90]

oh yeah..!!!

[marylhere]

I'm glad they changed her outfit last minute....she was suppose to wear a white leather jumpsuit....can you imagine? The wardrobe people were on her side.  Still waiting for that album girlie.

[kasieb1987]

@marylhere the outfit she is wearing still sucks though. It looks like she is in the 80's. Not a fan. ha.

[Ms123456la]

Jennifer Lopez was wrong when she said it was one of the best performances of the year. This was one of the best performances of all time on American Idol!

[charicebiggestfan]

omg gaga and haley should do a duet

[emilyhalfacre1]

" u just reinharted ur self to the next week" lol

[stolen4eighty]

everyone go search for her VEVO

[MsBlackheartedsoul]

she is sooo pretty and has one of the most amazing voices in the world . . .<3

[emicutie101]

its goin down in here..

[Sillydilly121]

Americans, How could you not vote for this ?

[ginnyboot]

Dont listen to Ga Ga...

[Rgarvey93]

@ginnyboot sorry but gaga was right. gaga is an extremely talented musician and she wanted to make the song pop. that is how she got famous herself. making her and her music have an extra pop. an extra feel.

[Italianstallion236]

Haleys version of this song is the best version of this song. Period. End of story. Nothing else is even close.

[nicolekollman]

ShirleyBassey................

Shirley Bassey........the queen of this song....Haley look at her interpretation

[JessicaKaathryn]

I love her, and her attitude, and her voice. She's just amazing, and deserved to make it over Lauren.

[Lanefair95]

Best American Idol performance ever.

[GRomance0804]

@Lanefair95 um NO, THIS SONG WAS DONE BEST BY SEASON 6 WINNER, A THEN 16YR OLD JORDIN SPARKS.....Haley is No Jordin, Carrie, Kelly, or not even Lee D........so this comment should go to Miss Sparks...

plus this is a cabaret version of a song that is known and 1st done on idol 6...twice

[Lanefair95]

@GRomance0804 Like I said. Best American Idol performance ever.

[GRomance0804]

@Lanefair95 Yeah when Jordin Sparks did it both in British Invasion week and Top Three week.. so thanks for agreeing with me!



[Lanefair95]

@GRomance0804 No I'm not agreeing with someone whose wrong stop having wishful thinking because Jordin Spark is good but Haylee is a lot better.

[LookingAtYouFool]

@GRomance0804

Stupid logic. Jordin didn't compete against cross-kissing Christian kids that sung country-music.Since you prefer Jordin, go watch her videos. I'm not asking, I am telling you. Go!

[generationaluv]

@GRomance0804 yeah but winning doesn't mean interesting or entertaining in all cases...like this one!

[Lanefair95]

@GRomance0804 Well you have your opinion I have my facts.

[GRomance0804]

@Lanefair95 your facts are sadly wrong....but whatever

[Lanefair95]

@GRomance0804 To who..? You? I can live with that

[SilkenCountry]

HOLY GOD ALMIGHTY!!! This girl is AWESOME x 10000000!!!! She not only has range in her range but she can sing the high notes with the purity of a crystal bell and yet growl better than anyone I've EVER heard!! WHEW!!! Have a listen!!!

[Erin101Green]

gosh those are some heals! O_O

[JRAmolo]

Who says?

It's perfect, It's beautiful, It's Amazing!

Haha!

The two giant personalities' conversation.

[sisi10140]

we were hard at you before blahblahblha wathever RANDY WHAT YOU SAID WAS CRIMINAL SHE KILLED EVEN THE EARTH SONG BUT YOU CANT ADMITIT !! SHE WAS SCREAMING ?? not at all you should listen to your brother :(

HALEY REINHART YOURE THE BEST I LOVE YOU SO MUCH WAHOOOOOOOOOOOOO :D

[HudgensSistersRock]

@sisi10140 Randy Jackson isn't related to MJ :)

[Rainb0wBryte1]

@sisi10140 He's actually not Michael's brother....its a different Randy Jackson that is his brother....but I agree completely She nailed Earth Song and sang it exactly as Michael would have...Randy had no idea what he was talking about. Michael was proud of her Earth Song performance..i just know it :P

[symmetricalastic]

@sisi10140 I agree with him.

[quenquen411]

"A Mazing" *gaga voice*