This is many ways is a better version, especially with the extra harmonies. Was this recorded at his house? Him alone? Also, can it be bought somewhere? Tuna in the Brine has always been my favourite song. It moves me more than anything else i've ever heard. And i agree that he is comparable in talent to famous classical composers such as beethoven.
The harmonies in this song are much better than the studio version, much more pronounced and intricate. Definitely one of my favourites from the album.
I dreamt of listening to this song last night. Actually I don't use the word epic, but I think in this case I must say "tuna in a brine" is an epic song. I'm so in love with Daniels voice and it's absolutely great how much it developed.
I have never, ever heard a band so brilliant as these guys, and that even goes beyond 2 of my favorite bands (well, now silverchair is pretty much it for me now). To think I grew up in this era and just recently rediscovered their popular songs and newly discovered all this other stuff I had never heard before. Pure orgasmic genius doesn't even begin to cover Daniel and his talents ♥
@mychemicalgirl4 It's as interesting as it is exciting isn't it? I had the exact same experience aboutt 5 years ago. Although I don't know if it was... as orgasmic for me. But genius yes! Oh what am I saying? I'm gay for em.
This whole album is amazing. When it first came out I listened to it for atleast 2 years straight. And this song is such a genius song. The Demo is a rough version that sounds raw and boundless. Then you have the album version that is a polished sparkling gem in the crown jewels called Diorama. Diorama is a piece of art. When Daniel pressed the record button and let their demo's be recorded over by silence, it was the best thing he could of done. It led the way to make this.
@dr3amsofglass - it came from the dvd Across The Night The Creation of Diorama. Its one of my fave dvd's they made. You most likely have to order it off Chairpage. I had to order from there. Make sure it NTSC format first.
This makes me dizzy in its brilliance. It's on the level of Pachelbel, Bach or Beethoven. A modern day classical composer with exceptional genius is what he is.
The more I hear from this album (this is the first time I actually listen to, research, and attempt to analyze this album) the more it starts sounding like a heavier Elliot Smith sound. I don't know if it's just me, but I noticed some similar qualities.
@punkguyrich Yes! I've been a long time chair fan, and only recently started getting into elliott smith. I definitely hear similarities between him and daniel johns. Elliott even sings with a bit of an australian accent.... in my opinion. But yeah, definitely, I agree.
respecting everyone's else opinion... the different part, at the end, seem better in the album version, because i particularly like that falsete tecnique he uses...
this is just genius. i hate how people say young modern isnt silverchair. because then [especially this] diorama isnt either, and parts of NB. open your mind a bit, please!
he's sooooo hot at 5:26. even if it's just a quick blur. heavenly.
ha...i've thought the same thing. that 2nd vocal harmony is some of the most interesting melodic content he's ever written. how could it have been cut? it's not like the inclusion of it would have made the song too over the top. lol
Seriously, this version, because of that end, is 10x better than the album version. Not to say the album version isn't great, but this is just... so much better.
i cant find this version on internet >:( can someone send me a link with this version please? hahahah
pluginaxo 2 weeks ago
I can never get enough of this fine artwork, absolutely insane talent and abilities. Wish they were still together!
Tool19781 5 months ago
What effects does Dan use on his vocals in this album?!?! I WANT THEM!
surfsup004 5 months ago
This is many ways is a better version, especially with the extra harmonies. Was this recorded at his house? Him alone? Also, can it be bought somewhere? Tuna in the Brine has always been my favourite song. It moves me more than anything else i've ever heard. And i agree that he is comparable in talent to famous classical composers such as beethoven.
trolleygoround 5 months ago
The harmonies in this song are much better than the studio version, much more pronounced and intricate. Definitely one of my favourites from the album.
jdawg1692 8 months ago 2
the 49 people here know what real music is all about :D and im happy to be one of them
lorndarken 9 months ago
@lorndarken This is definitely one of the most underrated bands ever. So much talent and everything they've done is absolutely brilliant.
WhySoSerious55 9 months ago 3
Comment removed
lorndarken 9 months ago
God I just can't get over how beautiful this song is. I think I like the demo even more than the Diorama release.
sardoniclysane 9 months ago 3
I dreamt of listening to this song last night. Actually I don't use the word epic, but I think in this case I must say "tuna in a brine" is an epic song. I'm so in love with Daniels voice and it's absolutely great how much it developed.
ixlovexrain 1 year ago
Comment removed
lenief 1 year ago
I have never, ever heard a band so brilliant as these guys, and that even goes beyond 2 of my favorite bands (well, now silverchair is pretty much it for me now). To think I grew up in this era and just recently rediscovered their popular songs and newly discovered all this other stuff I had never heard before. Pure orgasmic genius doesn't even begin to cover Daniel and his talents ♥
mychemicalgirl4 1 year ago 2
@mychemicalgirl4 It's as interesting as it is exciting isn't it? I had the exact same experience aboutt 5 years ago. Although I don't know if it was... as orgasmic for me. But genius yes! Oh what am I saying? I'm gay for em.
malcalm 1 year ago
SILVERCHAIR IS SOMETHING ELSE ..
joseluisrl 1 year ago 2
Wow, i've been listening Diorama for about 10 years until yesterday, and never get bored with it.. Daniel, You are so Damn Genius...
lidzhet 1 year ago 3
This whole album is amazing. When it first came out I listened to it for atleast 2 years straight. And this song is such a genius song. The Demo is a rough version that sounds raw and boundless. Then you have the album version that is a polished sparkling gem in the crown jewels called Diorama. Diorama is a piece of art. When Daniel pressed the record button and let their demo's be recorded over by silence, it was the best thing he could of done. It led the way to make this.
zinzky1 1 year ago 2
favsong in this album
sainsable 1 year ago
can someone tell me where the footage at the beginning comes from? the part where he's singing in the studio..
dr3amsofglass 1 year ago
@dr3amsofglass - it came from the dvd Across The Night The Creation of Diorama. Its one of my fave dvd's they made. You most likely have to order it off Chairpage. I had to order from there. Make sure it NTSC format first.
zinzky1 1 year ago
@zinzky1 Thank you so much. :)
dr3amsofglass 1 year ago
@martyniullka agreed! Diorama is the healing album
PKJackM 1 year ago
i like this more than the album version omg
k4n3k4n3 1 year ago
I love the line: "you're busking for change... and changing everything/ my pregnant paws aren't changing anything"
lenief 1 year ago
This makes me dizzy in its brilliance. It's on the level of Pachelbel, Bach or Beethoven. A modern day classical composer with exceptional genius is what he is.
lenief 1 year ago 41
@lenief
together with matthew bellamy, dont you think?
Starcloud1986 1 year ago
Comment removed
lenief 1 year ago
@Starcloud1986 Tee hee :( I certainly don't. Johns is miles and miles ahead of him.
runnersdialzero333 1 year ago
The more I hear from this album (this is the first time I actually listen to, research, and attempt to analyze this album) the more it starts sounding like a heavier Elliot Smith sound. I don't know if it's just me, but I noticed some similar qualities.
punkguyrich 1 year ago
@punkguyrich Yes! I've been a long time chair fan, and only recently started getting into elliott smith. I definitely hear similarities between him and daniel johns. Elliott even sings with a bit of an australian accent.... in my opinion. But yeah, definitely, I agree.
eyeballhorror 1 year ago
This demo version felt different compared with the album version, yet it's still fantastic.
agpfrick 1 year ago
Tuna in the brine is such an awesome song, and this version is amazing
elvorette 2 years ago
respecting everyone's else opinion... the different part, at the end, seem better in the album version, because i particularly like that falsete tecnique he uses...
gufok 2 years ago
this is just genius. i hate how people say young modern isnt silverchair. because then [especially this] diorama isnt either, and parts of NB. open your mind a bit, please!
he's sooooo hot at 5:26. even if it's just a quick blur. heavenly.
BLueEyeButterfly 2 years ago
4:22 daniel looks sooooo sad :'(
luiseche 2 years ago
Nice, but why have the footage from Across the Night? The timing is off...
rr8ch66 2 years ago
I keep singing the harmonies now on the album version.
sardoniclysane 2 years ago
I love this voice.
Love Silverchair and Dan!!!!!!!!!
arthemisjohns 2 years ago 2
The final is really just amazing!! dunno why they didn't keep it on the final version....
FredSilmo 2 years ago
It's genius, I tell you. Genius!
VoidTerraFirma 2 years ago
omfg!! 5:03 to the end is magic beauty love in musical form.... why the hell didn't that make it into the studio cut?? !
tigerlilywobo 3 years ago 2
ha...i've thought the same thing. that 2nd vocal harmony is some of the most interesting melodic content he's ever written. how could it have been cut? it's not like the inclusion of it would have made the song too over the top. lol
avedic 3 years ago
Seriously, this version, because of that end, is 10x better than the album version. Not to say the album version isn't great, but this is just... so much better.
sardoniclysane 2 years ago
Closer to everything
dionath 3 years ago
beautiful <3
slade443 3 years ago
Fuckin' awesome!!! The demo version is so good as the studio version!!!
To me, this is the BEST Silverchair song!!! I never get tired to listen it!!! Great!!!
Thiago2069 3 years ago
this song is nice héhé :)
0371998 3 years ago
increible
silversebas 3 years ago
it's cool to see what the song developed into
adeburke 3 years ago
neat :)
chairlover721 4 years ago
gotta have these demooooss....*drool*
sojabean 4 years ago
soo beautiful
druhyzmysel 4 years ago
This song is insane!!!
Birkone 4 years ago
wow where do you have all the demos from?
1killingjoke 4 years ago
they are on the across the night single i believe.
chaser180 4 years ago
And can also be found in the Diorama Box
rolatimiseba 3 years ago