Aw, you did a wonderful job. NMH is my favorite band and this happens to be my favorite song. I can agree with Zenfive, I typically don't like covers, especially NMH ones... but you did it justice.
My only criticism that that it sounds like you're trying to sound too much like Mangum. Its cool, it happens a lot with covers. Otherwise, good cover. Mangums lyrics are deceptively hard to remember and delivery correctly.
I would only say to work on the energy with which you enunciate the chords. This song is supposed to shake you to the core, and the guitar should be played fast and hard.
ovations are for kids - the roundness of the back renders it awkward to hold... - not to mention the below average quality of trashy wood that its composed of and thin neck anything beats an ovation - good cover tho
Wow. This cover is so good, it goes beyond the usual level of "The original, but worse" and actually just becomes "As good, but different in a good way." Sorry if that doesn't make sense/came out weird.
tl;dr- It's a damn good cover of a damn good song.
neutral milk hotel is SUCH SUCH a good band. it sukcs that jeff mangum doesnt like being in the spot light.. but then again for that same reason maybe thats why his music is so epic
Oh!! Wow! I didn't even notice this wasn't the real song. I was like "Hm. Jeff's voice sounds kind of strange." I wasn't watching the video...But this is very well done! Kudos to you, my man.
I constantly stumble back over this video, forgetting I've watched it before, and am always blown away by how amazing it sounds. You truly are awesome!
it's obvious. it's nice to put the voice to a face. it would be more interesting. of course, it music and there is no relation, but so what. THis is not radio..it's video! I would pefer seeing the face too. But hey, you don't want to for some reason, so whatever. i mean, it's your choice. however, one could only assume it's because of an insecurity.
I loved this! You dont see alot of neutral milk hotel covers, Do you possibly still have the chords for this? It would be great if you could send them to me.
a lovely cover, but post it as a fucking cover and not neutral milk hotel-naomi...I was excited because I thought I found a version I hadn't seen them play live.
woot. lovely cover.
roasteducks 2 months ago
my name!!!
98nomes 4 months ago
Literally crying.
toiletcloger 6 months ago 3
Aw, you did a wonderful job. NMH is my favorite band and this happens to be my favorite song. I can agree with Zenfive, I typically don't like covers, especially NMH ones... but you did it justice.
Lalevine1 9 months ago
I usually hate covers, Good job (y)
ZenFive 11 months ago
I wish someone would show me the fucking Ab chord lol
jdmhondapower0831 1 year ago
Comment removed
Heroofbrandon1 11 months ago
@jdmhondapower0831
4
4
5
6
6
4
Heroofbrandon1 11 months ago
You really do have talent, you've perfected this song unlike most other YouTube covers.
Ancubius 1 year ago 2
FUCKING AMAZING! <33333333.
shhmellshlikeasshhhh 1 year ago
youre missing some up strokes. but aside from that its probably the best naomi cover ive ever heard.
iwannawatchrratedvid 1 year ago
Can you cover "Several Arrows Later" by Matt Pond PA? If you do, please let me know. I think you could do amazing things with that song!
Thanks and great job here. You have a stellar voice!
Dave13676 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I keep coming back. (:
QUEERBAIT 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I keep coming back. (:
QUEERBAIT 1 year ago
This was... More than beautiful.
melissamacca 1 year ago 2
youre the like first person who actually attempted to sound like mangum
much respects for a good cover =]
deezyweasley 1 year ago
Pretty fucking sweet, man. You rock!
Clerks0 1 year ago
the guitar sounds exactly how it should sound.
not perfect, but so original and honest.
ucankissmyass 1 year ago
I love this. Easily forgiven pal.
SeedsAreUs 1 year ago
My only criticism that that it sounds like you're trying to sound too much like Mangum. Its cool, it happens a lot with covers. Otherwise, good cover. Mangums lyrics are deceptively hard to remember and delivery correctly.
firetruckgreen 1 year ago
*O*~
naomi182cfc 1 year ago
Man, great job.
brandonmcmahan 1 year ago 2
Good voice, well done.
I would only say to work on the energy with which you enunciate the chords. This song is supposed to shake you to the core, and the guitar should be played fast and hard.
starguts 2 years ago
Wow... I must say.. Phenomenal cover of this song.
10/5 stars buddy. Keep posting and keep playing!
KalVasTENKI 2 years ago 3
Jeff Mangum is an impossible act to follow, but that's as good as it could possibly have been. Thanks for posting!!
LostBoyScout 2 years ago 2
BEAUTIFUL!
what are the chords by the way?
bebopalulahola 2 years ago 4
Thank you!
Chords are Ab-A-E in the verse, and then E-C#m-D-A in the chorus :)
BotswanaBabyBullet 2 years ago
yes it is, i want to see the persons face when they play, its fun to watch the expressions of faces while singing.
atleast when they sing with passion..
deatheater459 2 years ago
you missing some strings bud?
TheWindowSeat 2 years ago 2
No, they're just shadowed from the lighting
BotswanaBabyBullet 2 years ago
Usually I hate youtube covers, but this was incredible. It had the integrity of the original but became a new piece of art. =)
Great job!
celticXrain 2 years ago 11
this was wonderful
igotrapedbynancydrew 2 years ago
Music is supposed to be covered bro.
Expand the culture, live the music, experience the decadence.
Awesome cover bro.
fsufan850 2 years ago 6
i play an Ovation Custom Balladeer Ovation knows how to make em
FarmerChords23 2 years ago
ovations are for kids - the roundness of the back renders it awkward to hold... - not to mention the below average quality of trashy wood that its composed of and thin neck anything beats an ovation - good cover tho
camelspider99 2 years ago
hey man. fantastic cover of a great song.
AntiCitizenOne1 2 years ago
this is amazing.
Sometimes when I want to listen to this song, I listen to your version instead of Neutral's.
Cinderandsmokeable 2 years ago 2
i almost like your version better then the original :P
awesome job dude!
babsyboo240 2 years ago
Wow. This cover is so good, it goes beyond the usual level of "The original, but worse" and actually just becomes "As good, but different in a good way." Sorry if that doesn't make sense/came out weird.
tl;dr- It's a damn good cover of a damn good song.
Dshort33 2 years ago 2
I was really convinced this was actually Jeff (:
Your voice is just as lovely as his
dieinterimsliebenden 2 years ago 2
What an amazing comment. Thank you :)
<3
BotswanaBabyBullet 2 years ago 2
what kind of guitar is that, dude?
jonas2k2 2 years ago
That is an Ovation Celebrity, with the bowl shaped back-end
BotswanaBabyBullet 2 years ago
i really enjoyed that, thumbs up from me.
AnthonyWeston 2 years ago 3
sounds pretty good dude!
aicfan85 2 years ago 2
this works. it actually doesnt sound bad.
wolfgirleatsbaby 2 years ago
wow your so amazing...probably the best person yet who can sing as well as jeff mangum...i love it!?!?!
krissyduffy 2 years ago
its amazing what you get when you youtube ur own name :)
really like this! xx
imoansthename 2 years ago
i agree
brokenhailo 2 years ago
my name is naomi, too.
its awesome hat its imoan backwords
i love your screename :)
NaaomiLeon 2 years ago
Amazing
accountfrozen 2 years ago
neutral milk hotel is SUCH SUCH a good band. it sukcs that jeff mangum doesnt like being in the spot light.. but then again for that same reason maybe thats why his music is so epic
brokeass89 2 years ago 4
sometihing about the guitar playing is very nmh-reminiscent. =)
birdmadgirl108 2 years ago 2
perfect!!!
neurosis20 2 years ago
wow. if i didn't know any better, i'd think it was jeff mangum.
vgibson122389 2 years ago
Awesome!
DinaGhoulina 2 years ago
Good job dude
syko500 2 years ago
this is great. good job.
nicolemariekelly 2 years ago
you got every tone pretty good. It's hard to do all those drop's and rises while keeping your voice flat. That made no sense.
JustineCredible08 2 years ago 3
great job dude! the best cover of that song i've ever heard
lipao1313 2 years ago
that was great! i want to learn
yabbadabbadooozy 3 years ago
thank you, thank you, thank you for doing a respectful cover of NMH. this is the ONLY cover of NMH i've listened to all the way through. props.
titojack8 3 years ago 3
SUCH a good cover.
alliedeathsquad 3 years ago 2
wow you did a great job, man. my fave song off avery island
olgasavestheday 3 years ago 2
By far the best cover I've heard.
mistemelia 3 years ago 2
this is a great cover, good job!
JstnWht 3 years ago 2
you have A*
EmiliaTheLion 3 years ago 2
A+
udrnynndndrhdtgr
Cliix 3 years ago
you have really nice voice and you sing one of my favorite songs really well : )
EmiliaTheLion 3 years ago
beautiful, well done.
HeartsinParrts 3 years ago
i really love this song
<3
so lovely
"please... please... don't leave me"
Zombiology 3 years ago
Oh!! Wow! I didn't even notice this wasn't the real song. I was like "Hm. Jeff's voice sounds kind of strange." I wasn't watching the video...But this is very well done! Kudos to you, my man.
hard0candies 3 years ago
you sound a bit like him
wolfgirleatsbaby 3 years ago
I constantly stumble back over this video, forgetting I've watched it before, and am always blown away by how amazing it sounds. You truly are awesome!
e20ci 3 years ago
well done!
Shurekien 3 years ago
well done man, im posting mine soon.
yazanmasad 3 years ago
The vocals are startlingly accurate! Particularly the eeeEEEeee style things Jeff does. Kudos. Good cover indeed.
stenualdo 3 years ago 2
Lmao. Yeah, I agree.
NaomiOwnsYou 3 years ago
You sound great on this cover...one of my favorite songs and you more than did it justice. props, haha
lilsub38 3 years ago
yeah. you should show your face :)
unicoforever 3 years ago
This is so.... pretty >D
VivaLaShenanigans 3 years ago
you should show your face
coreydurrance 3 years ago
haha why is that?
BotswanaBabyBullet 3 years ago
it's obvious. it's nice to put the voice to a face. it would be more interesting. of course, it music and there is no relation, but so what. THis is not radio..it's video! I would pefer seeing the face too. But hey, you don't want to for some reason, so whatever. i mean, it's your choice. however, one could only assume it's because of an insecurity.
lloplop 3 years ago
oh and to add..
..def a impressive cover of naomi.
lloplop 3 years ago
that was amazing, really that was great
rvbsarge 3 years ago
Great job, you sing it very well.
turkeypizza123 3 years ago
I loved this! You dont see alot of neutral milk hotel covers, Do you possibly still have the chords for this? It would be great if you could send them to me.
rasputina993 3 years ago
just as good as NMH's! I think you sing it better
NifFinn 3 years ago
What kind of guitar is that you are playing?
Kellietherockstar 3 years ago
That is an Ovation Celebrity acoustic, that sadly broke about a month after I posted this
BotswanaBabyBullet 3 years ago
howd u break it?
kielar11 3 years ago
you're a good singer man.
jamiefigley 3 years ago
tabs plz
seanpgilmore 3 years ago
y did u say grinds? its shines
twoheadedboy14 3 years ago
I said "cries"
"shines" comes in the last verse
BotswanaBabyBullet 3 years ago
Your cover is beautiful. It has a true NMH quality. Keep up the good work!
breeeegs 3 years ago
a lovely cover, but post it as a fucking cover and not neutral milk hotel-naomi...I was excited because I thought I found a version I hadn't seen them play live.
donkeyboyjared 3 years ago
bravo! you did mangum proud.
elbucle 3 years ago
Sing better then me lol. good job man.
Guitarsessions 3 years ago
this song is so creepy I love it
bethanynum 3 years ago 2
you fucker. that was what i needed.
alabamagulfcoast 3 years ago
this song is too annoying to play
good job man
sweetallie22 4 years ago
you are so talented! thx for sharing!
LiberNami 4 years ago
What chords do you use in the middle section?
Pinkfloyd12320 4 years ago
E C#m D A
BotswanaBabyBullet 4 years ago
I thought it was E G# D A.
But nevermind that, awesome cover and awesome singing!
djubreXD 3 years ago
replace the G# with a Db and you've got it.
bilbomarks 2 years ago
Brilliant job man, never heard a cover of this song that I could actually enjoy listening to.
5omething 4 years ago