Bon sang ! Je la connaissais de nom, mais ne l'avais jamais entendue... Elle me te nous vous fait le saut de deux octaves du récitatif comme s'il s'agissait d'une simple formalité... Ca ce n'est pas du soprano-marketing de salon, et quel tempérament ! Et de la technique aussi ! Encore une que les majors du disque ont oubliée...
Pauline Tinsley was an immense singing actress and known as a kind ,generous. lady. It's interesting how we all react differently to vocal timbres. I too find Renata Scotto's voice unappealing - even on her early Puccini/Verdi recital discs. It's that upper register that bugs me every time! Listening to Tinsley here is a more pleasant experience for me than listening to Scotto.
And very versatile as well, she performed Donizetti, Bellini, Wagner, Verdi, Strauss, Handel, Mozart, Mascagni, Puccini, Ponchielli, Britten, Stravinsky and many others. Greatly ignored by the record companies and Covent Garden!
It's always a thrill to encounter Pauline Tinsley's magnificent performances. I was lucky enough to see her with Scottish Opera (Kostelnichka, Lady Macbeth) and what was then Sadlers Wells Opera (Donna Elvira, Elvira in Ernani) in Glasgow and Aberdeen. The Haddo House Turandot is another special memory, so I think I'll post an excerpt.. Thank you for sharing!
I heard Pauline many times at WNO at the new theatre cardiff in the the 1970s and early 80s. She was fabulous. I have no idea where she is now. I think she is now in her 80s.
I had great fun singing in the "other parts" for her Turandot rehearsals at Haddo House in 1990, what a star, I love her and she's so easy to get on with, a true diva in voice but a gem of a person.
Sure it's your right to have your opinion and to express it.
My point was another: you don't criticize Scotto you just call her names, and your priase of Tinsley doesn't ring true, it reads as an excuse to have a bash at Scotto.
Scotto has indeed produced unpleasent sounds in her day, but there are other aspects of her interpretations that are truly unique.
As for the right to criticise being proportional to cachets! please leave that logic in your local shopping mall.
Wonderful ! She is a personal friend and I consider her the definitive Abigaile, Turandot and Lady Macbeth and I have seen all the so called greats. She is still singing at the age of 80!
Thank you for this rare treasure. I actually worked on a production of NABUCCO with her in Holland. Apart from singing the guts out of this role, she was an extrodinarily warm hearted lady, totally unpretentious. I seem to remember her spending most of her free time knitting or something of the likes. In private she was just like your favourite Aunty, but when she got out on stage, she adored being fierce and unpleasantand knocking out top C's! A remarkable woman!
I have long lost Pauline's address it was in my passport that was stolen. I have tried to find her but to no avail. Would you please say the tall Canadian from Vancouver and now OZ says hello, and sends her my love.
Bon sang ! Je la connaissais de nom, mais ne l'avais jamais entendue... Elle me te nous vous fait le saut de deux octaves du récitatif comme s'il s'agissait d'une simple formalité... Ca ce n'est pas du soprano-marketing de salon, et quel tempérament ! Et de la technique aussi ! Encore une que les majors du disque ont oubliée...
andranik77 2 weeks ago
I saw Pauline in Fidelio at the Albert Hall in the early seventies. She just blew us away.
voicemad 2 weeks ago
Pauline Tinsley was an immense singing actress and known as a kind ,generous. lady. It's interesting how we all react differently to vocal timbres. I too find Renata Scotto's voice unappealing - even on her early Puccini/Verdi recital discs. It's that upper register that bugs me every time! Listening to Tinsley here is a more pleasant experience for me than listening to Scotto.
Tenortalker 1 year ago
Thanks so much. Great performance and remarkable sound quality. Is this commercially available??
gratecourt 1 year ago
A much better singer than Josephine Barstow, but for some reason Barstow got the roles at the ENO & Coven Garden.
mazzone1 2 years ago 9
beautiful voice, a true spinto, and a great actress too - her Turandot and Abigaille were gems. why so few recordings? a fiery elettra...
mariahelleberg 2 years ago
And very versatile as well, she performed Donizetti, Bellini, Wagner, Verdi, Strauss, Handel, Mozart, Mascagni, Puccini, Ponchielli, Britten, Stravinsky and many others. Greatly ignored by the record companies and Covent Garden!
robertdonkers 2 years ago 5
It's always a thrill to encounter Pauline Tinsley's magnificent performances. I was lucky enough to see her with Scottish Opera (Kostelnichka, Lady Macbeth) and what was then Sadlers Wells Opera (Donna Elvira, Elvira in Ernani) in Glasgow and Aberdeen. The Haddo House Turandot is another special memory, so I think I'll post an excerpt.. Thank you for sharing!
starrman22 2 years ago
Marvellous Pauline. I had the privilege to sing many Lius opposite her Turandot
CharlotteinWeimar 2 years ago 3
@CharlotteinWeimar
I heard Pauline many times at WNO at the new theatre cardiff in the the 1970s and early 80s. She was fabulous. I have no idea where she is now. I think she is now in her 80s.
barneswriter 11 months ago
She is now 83! At her 80 th birthday she was still singing marvelously. See her "Duet des Chats" de Rossini....
just amazing.
tdi11 11 months ago
a great colleague and a true artist!!
Greetings from the Bass/Baritone in Holland and in Germany!
SINGINGOPERAFAN 2 years ago
I had great fun singing in the "other parts" for her Turandot rehearsals at Haddo House in 1990, what a star, I love her and she's so easy to get on with, a true diva in voice but a gem of a person.
Rattywotin 3 years ago 2
She's absolutely amazing!
shaun20483 3 years ago 2
I remember her roles at Welsh National Opera including an outstanding Turandot. A lovely dramatic singing actress.
barneswriter 3 years ago 2
Wonderful dramatic soprano. Too bad we don't have more recordings from her and less from Scotto, the screamer.
t y 4 posting
rockgor 3 years ago 6
It seems you praise Tinsley just as an excuse to make nasty comments about Scotto, that's bitchy!
CzarDodon 3 years ago
Part of being an opera buff. Love some, hate some.
If you can criticize me, surely it's fair if I criticize a public performer who is being paid big bucks.
rockgor 3 years ago
Sure it's your right to have your opinion and to express it.
My point was another: you don't criticize Scotto you just call her names, and your priase of Tinsley doesn't ring true, it reads as an excuse to have a bash at Scotto.
Scotto has indeed produced unpleasent sounds in her day, but there are other aspects of her interpretations that are truly unique.
As for the right to criticise being proportional to cachets! please leave that logic in your local shopping mall.
CzarDodon 3 years ago
@rockgor Don't be rude La Schreecherola was a fine performer
albafango 1 year ago
Wonderful ! She is a personal friend and I consider her the definitive Abigaile, Turandot and Lady Macbeth and I have seen all the so called greats. She is still singing at the age of 80!
Nevilleauk 3 years ago 2
Amazing singing! Brava!
Racheltaylordiva 3 years ago 2
Fantastic, real singing and yes she is a gorgeous person always willing to help others with their singing.
robertdonkers 3 years ago
Thank you for this rare treasure. I actually worked on a production of NABUCCO with her in Holland. Apart from singing the guts out of this role, she was an extrodinarily warm hearted lady, totally unpretentious. I seem to remember her spending most of her free time knitting or something of the likes. In private she was just like your favourite Aunty, but when she got out on stage, she adored being fierce and unpleasantand knocking out top C's! A remarkable woman!
iskenderuna 3 years ago 4
She's my Grandmother in Law and that's a pretty good description of her!
1Andiedrums 3 years ago
Hello,
I have long lost Pauline's address it was in my passport that was stolen. I have tried to find her but to no avail. Would you please say the tall Canadian from Vancouver and now OZ says hello, and sends her my love.
highbaritone 2 years ago