What song is best for Bella's Lullaby? Yiruma or Burwell?

[HollisterGal08]

1st one all the way

[JBobsession201815]

i think carter burwell's lullaby was better for the movie, but yiruma wrote a better song overall.

[costanzi59]

defiantly the river flows in you, it gives the picture of how it should sound from when she describes it in the book.

[KingdomHeartsVids18]

River flows in you is beautiful

I really think they shouldve picked that one

[EatHumblePies]

Bella's Lullaby by Carter Burwell. River flows in you is just too...IDK, sweet? Boring? While Bella's lullaby has an edge to it.

[24MoNi24]

i think both are great...but i think bellas lullaby by yiruma is better, because its played on the piano...on the burwell version are many other instruments...but maybe burwells version is more emotive song :) i cant choode between them... i liked lullaby by yiruma but now, im depend on the burwell :D :D :D its twilight like twilight, i like it all :D (also supermassive black hole which you gave on the beggining of this video :))

[paradisegurl]

Both are great, the first is realy sweat for the couple, but just like this, to ear, i prefer the other for the piano

[agentonyx]

Yiruma is so sweet. I would choose that one only because it feels like a true lullaby. However, the piano in Carter's is very beautiful and I would have liked to have hear it by itself.

[GoSensGoxx]

Yiruma is so much better.

I only like Carter's near the end but I've always loved Yiruma :)

[mrsiero93]

i think both of them are really good

i love the one by yiruma!

but i think Bella's lullaby is better for the movie because of how it's in the movie :P

i love them both!

[DanRadcliffeluvsme]

i persanally really like both as music pieces, but if i had to choose for the movie then it would definitly i think be, Yurima but im not sure, im still debating :]

[melabrazil]

A BILLION TIMES YIRUMA!!

[soonear]

YIRUMA!

[JordanDupuis101]

Definitely Yiruma. I've learned both yiruma's and burwell's songs on piano, and yiruma's made the biggest impact on me. I could feel the passion in it while I was playing it. So yeah, definitely yiruma's :)

[amy2171987]

Burwell.

[leiagirl12345]

yiruma, i think. were they ever considering it?

burwell would be 100x better w/ just piano! then it'd be equal.

[coryxxhsm]

yirumaaa , all the waay,

you can feel the emotion, and it's JUST SO TWILGIHT <3

[saradeanne92]

I like the Yiruma song much better but they r both good

[roxy4566]

the first one!!an second idk...................

[emmetrocksmysocksoff]

yiruma b/e 1. its on the piano like in the book 2 its sweeter and nicer peaceful and when i think of like violins moving fast kinda its like not peaceful to me but yea

[marietierradeborinqu]

I prefer Yiruma. As you mentioned the music is so much sweeter, just as I imagined when I read the book. GREAT VIDEO as always!!!

[princessemma26]

i like burwell's better except without all the violins and everythin just the piano part i think that that was more like i imagined it

[musicmadness330]

yiruma but man they need to change her actor. i dont think ppl want a frecken pot-head to play bella

[TheTwilighters]

Wtf? She's not a pothead.

[saradeanne92]

yea i hav been seeing that everywhere, the tabloids are being retarded, there pics are from a new movie she is working on...the one about Joan Jett or whatever

[musicmadness330]

ya it was all over the news. it showed her and her boyfriend smoking pot then it went to rob just smoking normal cigs. and have some drinks its like WTF!!? im glade rob is smart

[KaliaBroussard010]

huh?

what happend?

[bowchikawahwah08]

i like the 2nd one except without all the violin stuff in the begginging!

[madison01024]

i like the Yiruma one becuase it more like how they described it in the book and the one by Burwell has other insturments in it too. It is supposed to be all piano.

[carmagirl321]

i personally think the Yiruma one is better.

cuz if u read Edward's description of the song in Midnight Sun, the song is played like that.

and im just not a big fan of the other one.

[TheCoolestPinkGirl]

Uhhhh...I like both Lol xD

[bellamasoncullen]

River Flows in you by Yiruma because it's more like the lullaby in the book.

(wow that was hard to explain)

[TheTwilighters]

Burwell! Its like I imagined, I really don't like Yiruma. l:

[xxStephy]

neither lol. I actually don't care for either of them :s. Your video was great though!

[EdwardCullen4321]

yeah, i'm not really sure about either off them. if i had to choose i'd say Yiruma because it was more... i dunno, more like i imagined it i guess.