Added: 2 years ago
From: OasisILove
Views: 83,695
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (167)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • His voice doesn't much this song but I like his voice.

  • CHE ORRORE!

  • I'd rather Liam singin' it

  • As much as I love Noel and think he has a good voice, Liam really owns this song. The aggressiveness and vigor with which he sings is perfect for these types of songs. This isn't too bad though.

    That being said, Noel is truly the only one who can sing Don't Look Back in Anger. It's perfect for his voice.

  • It gets better after 1:00 I think

  • this is why noel would never have been half as big without his bro, great song writer only ok singer though

  • looks like liam has listened to this more then once(3 disslikes) :) lol

  • not bad

  • How stupid can Noel be....Get over it dude...Get the band back together...You and LIam together are rock gods...apart, you ain't that much...sorry.

  • @s743bd his album made number one you cunt 

  • @Jackonsinit #1, I'm not a cunt. Second, we all have opinions and mine is that Noel's genius is in his songwriting and guitar, definately not his voice. It's kind of the same mistake that Van Halen made when they got rid of David Lee Roth. Think about it and have a great life my friend.

  • @s743bd some of oasis' best songs are sung by noel. Take don't look back in anger and the importance of being idle. Liams voice was great at first but then started to drop off. Beady eye are shit bt the high flying birds are better than most of oasis' albums (excluding the first two)

  • @s743bd Noel's voice is better than Liam's now, because Liam lost his voice. I'd rather listen Noel singing his songs (old and new) than listen Liam butchering the classics. I love Liam, but he should've done something to save his voice, he didn't.

  • @JohnKulo imagine Liam "saving" his voice in Maine ROad, Finbury Park and Wembley. You would´nt have some of the best vocal performances ever. So stop crying your heart out.

  • @vitornoel13 He could've hired a singing teacher, change his singing pose or at least rest his throat better. He did not, and even kept smoking cigs and drinking. I'm not saying he should've sung less enthusiastic, I'm saying he should've done something to keep it good. He used all of his voice in the 90's, now it's useless in Beady Eye. They say it's better to burn than fade away, but Liam has burned and now he keeps fading away.

  • @JohnKulo i do agree he could do something to keep the voice better but it wouldn´t matter too much. The voice is worse now, mainly, because it´s a natural thing of age. The man is fourty now. And about being useless in Beady Eye it makes no sense. If you understand something about rock n roll´and check some videos live, like Isle of Wight or Rio de janeiro(that i went). That band is on fire, kept the Oasis level, one of the best at the moment. And prepare for the secnd album.

  • Don't make this personal. Don't tell me I dont understand rnr, I do! I have listened to Beady Eye, live and studio, and I have tried to like it, but I just can't. I just can't make myself like it, because it's just not good IMO. I loved Liam in Oasis and I still think he's hell of a performer, but his voice is what made him so great to me. It is possible to save your voice; listen to RJ Dio from 60's to 2009. Steven Tyler same thing. Liam just didn't care, which is a shame.

  • @vitornoel13 And besides Liam did not loose his voice because of aging, well it's not the main problem. It was his singing style. As much as I like Liam as a singer, he was not a talented singer, but had a great voice. Many times when singing live you can hear problems in his singing. A singing teacher would've helped a lot, like it did do James Hetfield. Surgery would've been the final option. I'm not saying he sucks, I just think it would be great if he could still sing like in the early days.

  • @JohnKulo Well basicly we disagree about Beady Eye being a great band. I do and you don´t. And about the voice, you quoted some exceptions that can keep the voice in a high level. Although being a good singer isn´t only about achieving a high tone. In a general it is a age thing. Paul Mccartney can´t sing Oh Darling anymore, even Tyler is not the same singer he used to be, and he didn´t became a freaking saint that doesnt smoke and stuff.

  • @JohnKulo ´Still, Liam did some things to take care of his voice. He changed the way to sing and it´s not the same junkie he used to be. IMO he is still a great singer and i really can´t understand don´t like songs like Four Letter Word, Millionaire, Roller, Beat Goes On, Morning Sun, Bubble in a bullet. I really can´t and i´m sorry for you. The main point is that i don´t think he shloud have any regrets. But you can think whatever you want. And i´m not saying in a agressive way.Cheers

  • @vitornoel13 Meh, I just don't like his voice anymore. He's a great frontman, but the voice is just so dry and dark. It just feels so lifeless now. I do like the Roller and Beat Goes On, I've listened to them, but they just don't do anything to me. And yeah, I agree, there's nothing he should regret, but I just wish his voice would've survived the time and his lifestyle, cause I think he had the best of voice of the 90's hands down.

  • I like Noel's version better

  • I think everytime Liam pissess off Noel, Noel sings the songs that Liam sings just to show he's better.

  • Great Song

  • Can you send me the picture of Noel at 2:46??

  • I prefer Noel's voice. There's obviously a different sense in each of their voices but when Noel sings his songs it sounds totally new and fresh. It's relieving.

  • Can you say orgasm!!! I love this version.

  • Comment removed

  • noels voice is really good but lacks the raw rock and roll sound of liams.

  • Lyla sounds better with the Liam`s voice...

  • Noel is GodHead!

  • Come on back and make my world stand tall? Huh?

  • I personally think Liam's version is better but Noel version is still good and still works for me.

  • Come on people! Stop sayng you preffer the Liam's version! This is only the demo of the song

  • Liams voice is way more unique an better than Noels. Noels voice is suited for some songs but not really this one. He is a far far superior songwriter though!

  • I think this song is great and just hearing it by the man who wrote it makes it different

  • Much better with Liam!

  • his eyes drives me crazy

  • awww he sounds cute here

  • Everything Noel touches is GOLD! God Head!

  • 0:36  Playmobil

  • 0:33  Liam's face

  • Noel is god, but the Liam's Voice is special, only...

  • i think noel has the most beautiful voice. but for rock n roll.. liam all the way :)

  • Liam is a colossal dickhead, but his voice is so much better suited to this.

  • @MrJaymzey Well said!

  • the reverb it's fucking annoying xd too much...

  • I love Noel voice, but in that tune Liam rules

  • Comment removed

  • I almost always like Noel's version of oasis songs better, including songbird which liam wrote, but this just doesnt sound right, Liam's gritty voice makes this tune great, I dont think liam coulda sang this right up until about 2000 when his voice really started to get fucked, still this is better than Ke$ha any day

  • its sound weird right??? hermm.. but its cool ;)

  • One of the best tunes ever but Liams voice is much better

  • great song.

  • LIAM LIAM LIAM!

  • It would be better without the echo on the mic on the verses- Noel doesn't have enough confidence in his vocals sometimes.

  • What's The Lyrics In The Chorus Noel Saying? After Hey! Lyla!

  • @bonklers1527

    Hey, Lyla, the stars're about to fall

    Oh what you say, Lyla?

    The world around us makes me feel so small, Lyla

    If you can hear me call then I can say, Lyla

    Come on [...?] make my world stand tall

  • @Chunkazoota thanks .. now I know the lyrics .. thanks again mate .. :D

    Cheers! Mad Fer It!

  • this is THE shit

  • this is shit

  • So, that's how this song's supposed to be sung. Noel should release a demo of all his songs with himself on lead vocals. Having said that, I do like the way Liam interprets Noel's songs and sings them in his own voice.

  • One chord,probably wants it to be like tomorrow never knows.

  • I believe that noel has a better voice,technically speaking but liam is so significant that he turns himself to a charismatic frontman.

  • liam has probably a better sounding studio voice but i think noel sounds way better live. noel has a larger vocal range and canhit higher notes using a softer voice. Liam sounds like Jack Daniels and cigarettes which is a good thing.

  • liam has probably a better sounding studio voice but i think noel sounds way better live.

  • I personally think that Liam suits some particular songs like Wonderwall, Lyla, Supersonic .

    But Noel has a beautiful voice suited for songs like, DLBIA, Little by Little (Beautiful), Let there be love (Common baby), Wish he sang Stop Crying your heart out .

    But Both brothers are beautiful musicians , they deserve to live forever. Oasis lives forever.

  • @dracodude7 here ya go mate /watch?v=rKz5wxrA3nU

  • the chorus sounds great!!

  • sounds wierd.. hey !! a stormtrooper behind noel!! 0:36

  • @LordEizen according to one interview, star wars is one of the favorites movies of Noel

  • @greciasoleble cool! i like noel. but i didnt like the video where he says 10 things he likes and hates..

  • @greciasoleble good to know :D

  • Noel sings some killer tunes but this one Liam wins!! Liam sounds better singing Lord Don't Slow Me Down too.

  • i like this version.. i like noel's voice .. meanwhile i rather listen this song with liam's voice, just because is a powerfull song and liam's voice it's better here.

  • i reckon noel could sing it better than this!

  • I could do without Liam. I really appreciate Noel's talent, but I wish he hadn't taken his punk brother on the ride with him.

  • @kmvoss You do relize, that Liam created the band? and begged Noel desperatly to join, because of his songwriting.

  • @Sgtpepper212 It wasn't that, Liam joined Bonehead's band 'The Rain' with Guigsy and Tony McCarroll. Liam thought that if he joined, Noel would, and they'd use his songs. It's known that Bonehead brought Liam in to get Noel as well.

  • The more I hear this songs, the more I fucking MISS them!!!

  • "Make my world stand tall" lyric change ruins it for me.

  • Its not as Rough and powerfull as Liam's voice i reckon :) It sounds like a little girl compared ! haha :P

  • I quite like Noels version but maybe i prefer Liams one co its the offical song but Noel made a good job of this

  • no definetly not for him this song is, however it sounds interesting, but oh myy this sounds just a little bit odd ^^

  • i think i just wet my pants a little bit

  • I always thought Liam had the better voice, just different because love Noel's version here.

  • id go to a noel show and scream this at the top of my lungs with him, i dont care who sings it. liam, noel, whatever it's oasis .

  • NOEL IS GOD ^^

  • where was this recorded?

  • @WPPDuke Its a demo they just recorded somewhere! ha

  • It's OK Noel only stole a little of it :)

    search the song below

    Neil Diamond - Delirious Love with Brian Wilson (High Quality)

    Brilliant...

  • Great

  • At the end of th day Noel is God along with the beatles the who paul weller the stone roses and all british class acts

  • @izzybizzyist are you british ?

    because there are also class american acts who stand up to the guys you mentioned .

  • i love noel... but its so weird hearing him sing this, its still good though.

  • I really like when Noel sings Slide Away,

  • I only listen to the Noel acoustic of Slide Away and Cast no Shadow now.

  • dont forget fade away..

  • LIAM (L) THIS SONG LIAM (L)

  • The chorus sounds great, the verse is a bit dodgy imo. It would be interesting to hear this song performed the Acquiesce way; Liam singing the verse and Noel doing the chorus.

  • Liam is better!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • You can tell this song is totally not made for Noel's voice. He says he writes for Liam's voice so you can't expect him to deliver the same vocals as Liam...

  • Spot on! But there were the odd songs that Noel will write and not know whether or not they were suitable for him or Liam. A prime example of that would be Wonderwall

  • Yeah. And also Don't Look Back In Anger as Liam originally wanted to sing it but Noel ended up doing it. I think the balance works because there both brilliant vocalist for this type of music..

  • nah not a noel song im not havin that liam rips it a new arse

  • Comment removed

  • Oasis are better than The Buzzcocks...

  • yeah, maybe Noel has better voice than Liam, but Liam has the Oasis attitude

    Oasis Rules!!!!!!1

  • prefer original tbh or the other one lmao

  • naaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa aguante liam (L)

  • noel has better voice than his little brother

  • MUCH better!!!

  • nowdays he does back to the past Liams was better

  • @nick43v3r4444 na hes a better singer but Liam has the better voice

  • @nick43v3r4444 that's so not true

  • @nick43v3r4444

    He has now, from Definitely Maybe to Standing on shoulder of giants Liam had a great voice. Too bad he never learned how to sing properly, singing always from the throat is bad for your voice :(

  • @nick43v3r4444 Better yes. But Liam's is more effective 'cos it's alot more unique and in away makes Liam better for singing.

  • @nick43v3r4444 I actually think it's the other way round.

    Liam's got a better voice,

    Noels the better singer.

  • good, but Liam's version is a lot better!

  • Can't really feel the same energy in this one as the album version with Liam. Noel is too gentle, doesn't really give it all. But it is actually comfortable to listen to this, but when you're used to the album version... it just won't do, y'know?

  • Liam saved that song!!

  • 0:43 Going for the Liam look?

  • I actually like this too, both versions are good (liam on vocals, noel on vocals)

  • where can i get that fist pic?

  • it is the cover of ...There and Then

  • he just can't sing this song....

  • Yup, both brothers have this specific gift, Liam is a brilliant singer, and Noel a good guitar player and generally a musician! I am very sorry they've broken up! What can I do, Oasis has lived a long time, even my parents where listening it earlier! I think Oasis is one of the best band ever!

  • Great! Great!

  • heyyyyy lyla.

  • When I have children, I want to name my daughter Lyla after this song...

  • loving this pure class

  • how did you get this song? great...but liams singing is better in this song....

    great, innit?

  • isnt this demo version released as b-side of Lyla single

  • i don´t think so. on my single there is lyla, eyeball tickler and won´t let you down. maybe there are other realeses in other countries, but i would know that :-) as president of the first oasis fanclub austria i have to know such things :-D

  • Oh yeah.. Its on the DVD single

  • wuppi do, president of the first oasis fanclub austria. it was on dvd but then you would know such things like that wouldn't you? they where raised not far from me guess you knew that to eh. lol

  • now, why are you twiting on me? the main problem is, that i´m from austria! this dvd wasn´t realesd in my f***ing country! so,i try my best, to know everything...and, that they were raised near you, is clear to me. who doesn´t know? they once told me:"heya, we were raised near julie2009ish, thats awsome, innit?" :-D

  • my favoruite song

  • love it!!

  • so what you say  LYLA!!! amazing!!

  • like the bridge im sorry..a little like the ending too though, with that piano

    not calling him a ocpy cat, i love oasis

    just saying

  • the ending of the song sounds like the ending of "its getting better" by the beatles

  • or like the ending of "street fighting man" by the stones

  • where does noel get his leather jackets from...anyone

  • he wakes up with them

    no one knows

    not even him

  • from very beautiful expensive designer shops in London for which i'll probably never have enough money to but anything :p

  • love it love it love XD

  • I think his voice is to soft for this tune.. Probably because i just listened to liams version i was expecting something stronger? lol Still a classy version!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!!!!

  • Liam is more of a twat than Nole, but I have to admitt his version of this song is better.

  • noel mate not nole

  • whoops!

  • If it were to be sung by Noel and we never heard the Liam version, it would definitely sound like something off Be Here Now or Heathen Chem that Noel usually sings.. I was thinking it's a bit like 'Force Of Nature' to be honest!

  • I think it sounds good...but when liam sings it sounds better xD

  • hahahah no this is not for noelllllll xd

  • (L)

  • SHES THE QUEEN OF ALL I'VE SEEN!

  • Noel is awesome +.+

    I just love him :)

  • muy bueno tio me encanta!!!

  • wow , so glad Liam sung this one

  • Agreed. Its a good example of why having two choices of lead singer worked for Oasis though.

  • where is thet from??

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more