The duet is great and it's great to see the younger Domingo, for a change. The quality is poor, sadly - and I'd wish there were some other conductor there instead of this gum-chewing Jude.
Is it true that the baritone part in this duet is easier when compared to the tenor's part? I heard a music broadcaster say this and wondered if any singers or musicians would care to comment.
For the average man certainly as it is a lower part but does not travel that far down. A tenor could (and has)sing the tenor part but would not be able to do soun amplified.
I have always loved this duet, it always brings tears to my eyes. This performance by a great conductor and orchestra and two of my favourite singers of all time is sublime. Bjorling and Merrill are my favourites singing the Pearl Fishers duet, but Domingo and Milnes come damned close, they are perfect together and not only are both superb singers but they are outstanding actors too.
Absolutely stunning... its so interesting that Sherril Milnes sings this so beautifully and in tune. When he doesn't artificially darken his sound its absolutely stunning. Pity he spent most of his career singing Verdi, because his voice is actually very delicate sounding here.
Absolutely stunning... its so interesting that Sherril Milnes sings this so beautifully and in tune. When he doesn't artificially darken his sound its absolutely stunning. Pity he spent most of his career singing Verdi, because his voice is actually very delicate sounding here.
what marvelous voices. hard to believe i grew up on a farm near Sherrill Milnes' farm in Downers Grove and the only time i heard him sing in person was behind a team of horses!
@muatlas I agree. They recorded the Don Carlo duet well before Milnes' vocal crisis during the early 1980s. It's a lovely version, with two young, hugely talented artists in their respective primes, or close to them:) --
For cryozo - yes they did. There is almost of full page of recit missing where Zurga sings "oublions le passé...aux portes de Candi' most likely to get to the duet more quickly.
I was privileged to see and meet Sherrill Milnes two month ago when he spent a weekend with the Asheville (NC, USA) Lyric Opera. There was a reception in his honor, then he came to the opera company's Gala later that evening. The next day he gave a master class to 6 young singers and we got to witness that event. We got autographs, pictures with him, and I got to chat with him both days. Great! And isn't this a great duet by two great stars - one now retired but the other still going strong!
I'm so jealous that you got to meet Sherrill Milnes!! He's been my opera idol for 25 years!! And yes, this was a wonderful aria -- Miles and Domingo. I remember watching this program on PBS back in the 80's. I love these two wonderful singers! Miles sang Iago to Domingo's Otello, with Renata Scotto singing Desdemona, many years ago. They got me hooked on opera.
Oh, I'm so jealous you got to see him live!! I never got that chance! But I did watch him on PBS every chance I got, and I was very happy to see him perform on PBS's recent airing of the tribute to Pavarotti. Milnes has aged gracefully, and his voice is still powerful. He sang in an aria from Boheme. What a delight to see him again, even if only on TV! But yes, his Iago is the best. I remember watching him as he sang "Credo in un Dio Crudel". Gave me boosebumps!
But it's 'Pearl FISHERS' - these guys were diving to the bottom after OYSTERS, in which they hoped to find PEARLS, which could be a hazardous occupation
Fantastyczny Domingo(jaki jeszcze młody!), szkoda,że nie słychać o takich talentach jak Domingo, pewnie są, tylko gdzie ich szukać? Sztucznie promowani Alagna, Villazon, to nie ta klasa! Operetka tak, natomiast z dużymi partiami raczej krucho.
My mom has had this exact recording with Domingo and Milnes on an old LP plastic record for the last 30 years around about, and this is the first time she has actually seen the video. She was blown away with tears in her eyes when I showed it to her. It was one of her favourites and I grew up with this stuff. Also, her recording stopped at 5:30 - so she finally got to hear (and see) the rest of it. Thank God for youtube and the internet - long may it live in freedom.
Thanks, Wansob. The best videos. Milnes and Domigo. ¿What else? Brilliant. I started loving opera thanks to this singers, and that fantastic disc of duets they made years ago..
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
great for sherril and placi!! funny to think that these two back in their pries were chasing around hoes in new york city long before their stardom days!! ha!!
OMG Thank you, Thank you, Thank you!!! What a fantastic pair these guys are! They rival jussi an robert with this duet!!! I defy anyone to say different!!! You are Brill WANSOB!
two great singers, a very beatifull music, but the sound is poor.!
alguso 3 weeks ago
Audio quality is crap. Is there a clearer version extant?
MistressRowena 2 months ago
The duet is great and it's great to see the younger Domingo, for a change. The quality is poor, sadly - and I'd wish there were some other conductor there instead of this gum-chewing Jude.
tjh58 2 months ago
Nice conducting by John C. Reilly!
therealericmeyer 2 months ago
this is my favorite duet !!!
MrFrenchaccent 4 months ago
Is it true that the baritone part in this duet is easier when compared to the tenor's part? I heard a music broadcaster say this and wondered if any singers or musicians would care to comment.
verdiwag 4 months ago
@verdiwag
For the average man certainly as it is a lower part but does not travel that far down. A tenor could (and has)sing the tenor part but would not be able to do soun amplified.
jamesgatward1985 4 months ago
Wos'n deaz fyure'n shice?
Wobby27 5 months ago
è un duetto eseguito bene ...ma non esageriamo...saluti
federic017 6 months ago
I have always loved this duet, it always brings tears to my eyes. This performance by a great conductor and orchestra and two of my favourite singers of all time is sublime. Bjorling and Merrill are my favourites singing the Pearl Fishers duet, but Domingo and Milnes come damned close, they are perfect together and not only are both superb singers but they are outstanding actors too.
Beth29252 7 months ago 2
This is the ultimate in duet singing. There is only one more comparable one to this :
In the duet of La Somambulla with Paveroti and Sutherland ." Prendi L'anel ti dono
Both are heavenly expresion of the soul. Netanel
1527XZ 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Absolutely stunning... its so interesting that Sherril Milnes sings this so beautifully and in tune. When he doesn't artificially darken his sound its absolutely stunning. Pity he spent most of his career singing Verdi, because his voice is actually very delicate sounding here.
GFlowerBari 10 months ago
Absolutely stunning... its so interesting that Sherril Milnes sings this so beautifully and in tune. When he doesn't artificially darken his sound its absolutely stunning. Pity he spent most of his career singing Verdi, because his voice is actually very delicate sounding here.
]
GFlowerBari 10 months ago
Is it just me, or is Sherrill Milnes kinda dragging the tempo, because he wants to sing more...?
delam2 11 months ago
@delam2 No, that's the way it is supposed to be sung.
pdfan33036 9 months ago
bliss...... is all i have to say
qwertyoop 11 months ago
Très belle interprêtation.
13laciotat 11 months ago
Milnes is built like a lumberjack!
windstorm1000 1 year ago
Geez, are they both sexy or what? And on top of their vocal games as well! What more do listeners want?
windstorm1000 1 year ago
These two are fantastic with each other!
LeftyHendrix93 1 year ago
. The most exquisit ,duet in all opera repetoire
Sung by by a marvelous tenor and a a bass..
A sublime expression by Bizet
Netanel
1527XZ 1 year ago
what marvelous voices. hard to believe i grew up on a farm near Sherrill Milnes' farm in Downers Grove and the only time i heard him sing in person was behind a team of horses!
rockyhoss1 1 year ago
This is the best duet of the "Pearl Fisher" I have ever heard. These two voices are
perfect together, also in other operas. Absolutely wonderful!!!!
ALYSSA09MUSICSTARS 1 year ago 2
I don´t think Jussi Bjorling and Rober Merills version will be surpassed in my lifetime (or anybody elses lifetime for that matter!)
But this is a very good version. Maybe 70 % as good as Bjorling Merill.
maxhansendk 1 year ago 2
Their duet from Verdi's Don Carlo, recorded in the early 70s, tops even this. I know its hard to believe. But just listen.
muatlas 1 year ago
@muatlas I agree. They recorded the Don Carlo duet well before Milnes' vocal crisis during the early 1980s. It's a lovely version, with two young, hugely talented artists in their respective primes, or close to them:) --
stevevandien 1 year ago
Outstanding the voices...what a great Aria !
AdrianCamus 1 year ago
my favourite opera and two had did such a wonderful duet!!!
NikolaiPen 1 year ago
thanks so much for posting!
funkboy76 1 year ago
Thank you for posting this - wonderful!
hoppersgirl11 1 year ago
Stunning.............What a wonderful ability humans have to exhume so much emotion form the soul....heaven sent wonders.
samuelorton 1 year ago
Domingo is absolutely spot-on perfect here.
nitramgnal 1 year ago
fantastic 10**********
rorypappa 1 year ago
For cryozo - yes they did. There is almost of full page of recit missing where Zurga sings "oublions le passé...aux portes de Candi' most likely to get to the duet more quickly.
BaritoneCan1 1 year ago
Did Sherill just jump over a part?
cryozo 1 year ago
Wow, three men I positively adore together, what a treat :-)
mrsRogue 2 years ago
Gack! I looked up and saw pervy James Levine. My eyes, my eyes are burning!
(but, leaving him aside, of course both great singers and an incredibly beautiful duet)
AmoreHL 2 years ago
@AmoreHL xD
MaxtheWise 2 years ago
Ha, funny, my comment got one negative vote. Apparently other pervs object to that characterization. Guess Cincinnati has been well-hushed up.
AmoreHL 2 years ago
Awesome
meluzyna55 2 years ago
Magnificent!!!
granitePillar 2 years ago
Wow! This just gorgeous.
chantdonchant 2 years ago
Domingo really suprised me here. His first B-flat was very smooth and beautiful.
revivaljesus 2 years ago
great 10*
rorypappa 2 years ago
Precioso y la interpretación brillante como todas las de Milnes y Domingo. Bravo
55patri 2 years ago
Sin duda,la verdad es que parece que no hay papel que no lo hagan de una manera impresionante
alcvdb 2 years ago
BRAVI!
dinacarina88 2 years ago
me emocione hasta las lagrimas
xxxxSpyderxxxx 2 years ago
MAJIC !!!
VIPERLOU 2 years ago
beautiful!!!
homousios 2 years ago
I was privileged to see and meet Sherrill Milnes two month ago when he spent a weekend with the Asheville (NC, USA) Lyric Opera. There was a reception in his honor, then he came to the opera company's Gala later that evening. The next day he gave a master class to 6 young singers and we got to witness that event. We got autographs, pictures with him, and I got to chat with him both days. Great! And isn't this a great duet by two great stars - one now retired but the other still going strong!
OperaBuff1935 2 years ago
I'm so jealous that you got to meet Sherrill Milnes!! He's been my opera idol for 25 years!! And yes, this was a wonderful aria -- Miles and Domingo. I remember watching this program on PBS back in the 80's. I love these two wonderful singers! Miles sang Iago to Domingo's Otello, with Renata Scotto singing Desdemona, many years ago. They got me hooked on opera.
Peppi94 2 years ago
I saw him singing Otello in 1972 in Boston with the Met. He is the perfect Iago: sardonic, forceful and stunning.
juanmlleras 2 years ago
Oh, I'm so jealous you got to see him live!! I never got that chance! But I did watch him on PBS every chance I got, and I was very happy to see him perform on PBS's recent airing of the tribute to Pavarotti. Milnes has aged gracefully, and his voice is still powerful. He sang in an aria from Boheme. What a delight to see him again, even if only on TV! But yes, his Iago is the best. I remember watching him as he sang "Credo in un Dio Crudel". Gave me boosebumps!
Peppi94 2 years ago
@Peppi94 Milnes is THE best Iago! He oozes evil, very imposing to say the least.
pdfan33036 9 months ago
@pdfan33036 Yes, indeed!! Evil AND sexiness!! :)
Peppi94 9 months ago
@pdfan33036 I met Milnes at the Met and he is imposing in person as well. Very nice man:-)
pdfan33036 9 months ago
Sheer bliss!! Thank you so much!
But it's 'Pearl FISHERS' - these guys were diving to the bottom after OYSTERS, in which they hoped to find PEARLS, which could be a hazardous occupation
Bagoponies 2 years ago
Fantastyczny Domingo(jaki jeszcze młody!), szkoda,że nie słychać o takich talentach jak Domingo, pewnie są, tylko gdzie ich szukać? Sztucznie promowani Alagna, Villazon, to nie ta klasa! Operetka tak, natomiast z dużymi partiami raczej krucho.
meluzyna55 3 years ago
Domingo fantástico!!!
kkloko103 3 years ago
would be intersting to speculate.. do u think in the Milnes prime he could've been able to join the tenor on the Bflat?
a28594 3 years ago
Definitely. Check out watch?v=dl0TQ6zAjAo and you'll hear him hit Bb and it will seem like hes not even singing that high.
moh672 3 years ago
IShicovianista says: I've heard him do it in Otello. I have a video tape to prove it.
WolfofSega 3 years ago
Milnes sings a Bb in the Lucia Di Lammermoor Decca recording with Sutherland and Pavarotti.
chkjns 2 years ago
Incredible rendition of one of the most beautiful Tenor-Baritone-Duets in opera!!! Plácido is and will be forever... THE GREATEST!!!!
Fehlzeiten 3 years ago 11
heilt einastandandi. kærar heilsanir from Faroe islands.PSDD
Perfect.
peddydavidsen 3 years ago
My mom has had this exact recording with Domingo and Milnes on an old LP plastic record for the last 30 years around about, and this is the first time she has actually seen the video. She was blown away with tears in her eyes when I showed it to her. It was one of her favourites and I grew up with this stuff. Also, her recording stopped at 5:30 - so she finally got to hear (and see) the rest of it. Thank God for youtube and the internet - long may it live in freedom.
jerramy 3 years ago 6
Viva Bizet!
saribu 3 years ago
So gorgeous. My favorite.
clairdeloon 3 years ago
Beautiful. Thank you.
emilysis 3 years ago
anyonw know who is the conductor of the orchestra in this video?
dlam9265 3 years ago
James Levine
rewyand04 3 years ago
PERFECTION
alex4fred 3 years ago 2
Thank you for the best duet of pearl fishers I have heard ever!
renamunich 3 years ago 8
Thanks, Wansob. The best videos. Milnes and Domigo. ¿What else? Brilliant. I started loving opera thanks to this singers, and that fantastic disc of duets they made years ago..
xx
Snowss 3 years ago 4
precioso
55patri 4 years ago 4
Wow - Levine is brilliant with the baton, but his hair! Funny how it hasn't changed in over 20 years!
5isgrace 4 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
great for sherril and placi!! funny to think that these two back in their pries were chasing around hoes in new york city long before their stardom days!! ha!!
operabitch77 4 years ago
Too bad they are not doing that still. I'd be available for either one.
junehilde 3 years ago 3
hahaha!
it's true
meriomeri 3 years ago
OMG Thank you, Thank you, Thank you!!! What a fantastic pair these guys are! They rival jussi an robert with this duet!!! I defy anyone to say different!!! You are Brill WANSOB!
kamikazekate 4 years ago 4
Thank you :-))
wansob 4 years ago
@kamikazekate I'll take up that challenge! Combine the two versions and give us Placido & Robert...that would be PERFECTION!!!!
cantorga 1 year ago
@kamikazekate
I think that Jussi Bjorling & Robert Merrill made this duet a bit, very little, but still slightly better :-)
ForAll23 1 year ago