I am a 15 years old boy and I'm learning guitar, and musical theory. I like Jazz, Jazz Fusion, Progressive Rock, and Progressive Metal/Death... my brother is learning drums, could you guys check my channel and watch my videos of original songs that we made, we are working in this, and we will re-record the song but this time with more instruments, can you check???
I LOVE what JR is doing here. I hate when people complain about him being "note-y" If I wanted to hear the PT complete version I'd listen to it. Since this version doesn't have drums or bass I think it's the perfect version to have open interp. 2 of my favorite musicians.
Lol you guys are saying I'm going to invite Charlie Sheen and not expect him to win, Petrucci to play a banana instead of guitar. Stop arguing, Steve Wilson is a genius and I'm sure the whole purpose Rudess was there was cause of respect. Steve Wilson respects this man, and is willing to let him write on top of a song he wrote.
No one is ruining the song, Jordan just gives more vibes by playing some really fitting solo stuff. In no way it's exaggerated, it makes the song interesting, especially because it's live, if you want to hear the album version, you can listen to it, but where would be the need of playing this song with Jordan Rudess, if he's playing exactly the same like Barbieri does.
Jordan Rudess who??? Richard Barbieri is THE man. Simple, yet profound. The difference in the outlook of the 2 keyboardists emphasises how PT is different from DT. While DT is all about technical flaunting, PT pampers us with pure music!
Man, I love both DT and PT to death but in this clip, I can't help but feel that Mr. Jordan Rudeness was treading on Mr. Wilson's creativity with a heavy hand...or TWO
@LesPantinsDansent I personally don't find his keyboard playing emotionless redundant piano. Emotionless redundant accoustic guitar strumming if anything.
@kuehling83 I find the piano play by JR to be a bit too, for lack of a better word, flying. He is a masterful piano player, yes, but I find his piano play in this performance to be too.. extravagant. Too fancy. It still fits in the song, but I still like the original better. And yes, redundant repetitive guitar play. Nothing too fancy. Steven Wilson more or less composes every song from scratch, so playing the redundant guitar is outweighed by the composition and his beautiful voice.
Where did this come from and why don't those two play together more? Thos are literally like the two most creative musicians on earth and they were in the same room? MUST HAVE MORE!
@zbusterzsabre My guess is this is from the Blackfield tour - as thats the same acoustic Aviv Geffen uses and the left handed P-Bass in the background is also the same one the Blackfield bassist used on their Live In NYC dvd.
By the gear, I think it's a Porcupine tree show (maybe) or a Jordan Rudess solo show (most likely). It's awesome, but i like it more with Richard Barbieri in keys.
@Stinechk because Rudess ruins the song by showing off. It doesn't fit the original at all, nor Steven's guitar play here. It's just a misfit. Steven himself says it's not the technical complexity of songs that makes Porcupine Tree, it's the composition and layering. So ruining that composition is the worst thing you can do to a PT song and that's exactly what Rudess does here. The beautiful, subtle melody by Barbieri is gone and what we got back sounds like muzak.
Do you really think Steven Wilson didn't know Jordan would show off all over the song? It's not supposed to be the original, and I think it'd be insulting to assume Steven didn't know what he was getting into with this collaboration.
It's been talked about for years now, mentioned in interviews of all three members for quite some time. They all insist that it will happen sometime, but that they're never all free at the same time to do so.
Don't get your hopes down just yet, apparently they have already started without Portnoy, though he'll be on board soon enough. There are interviews on Blabbermouth and Metal Injection, dated to this year last month, of Steven Wilson and Mikeal Akerdfelt already starting on the project without Portnoy, for now, and all ready have 15 mins of material that they came up with. Their all still on tour so it will be another while before it really kicks off
Hats off to Rudess, just check the score or stems for that track and you'll see how much it relies on layered strings and synth, but the dude does it with just piano. Don't get me wrong, i think Barbieri is far better for PT and does a better job of the song live, but can't deny the guy props.
This song is so... I wish I had another word beside awesome ... beautiful? stirring? I can just listen to it over and over. (Though I prefer the studio ver ;-)Thanks for posting!
Here's a collab. idea: Townsend, Rudess, Tony Levin, Phil Collins
"The Baldies"
psyoptica 3 weeks ago 2
I wish Rudess would play with Wilson and Akerfeldt on the "Storm Corrosion" project.
stalmeseto 1 month ago 2
They are gods
moreover, Jordan Rudess is checking his mails while playing :P
Miniboulet1994 1 month ago 10
four chords that made a million
DhieP9 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I am a 15 years old boy and I'm learning guitar, and musical theory. I like Jazz, Jazz Fusion, Progressive Rock, and Progressive Metal/Death... my brother is learning drums, could you guys check my channel and watch my videos of original songs that we made, we are working in this, and we will re-record the song but this time with more instruments, can you check???
vaxkors95 2 months ago
did steven wrote that song with jordan, or richard?
ryonafan 2 months ago
@ryonafan He wrote it on his own.
willregnier 4 weeks ago
Rudess is a traitor.
MlKEPORNTOY 2 months ago 2
@MlKEPORNTOY I laughed so hard!
TheYtseMan 2 months ago
Wilson/Rudess/Minnemann/Levin would probably be the best supergroup ever.
aligatorsandwitch72 3 months ago
@aligatorsandwitch72 You do know Steven is currently touring with Minnemann, and That Jordan Rudess played on his latest solo album right?
deliciousjammusic 2 months ago
@windriderr that song is less about the chords and more about slimy businessmen selling "edgy" music to stupid teenagers with no taste in music
omgitsaoe 4 months ago
@omgitsaoe I know, that was a pun about another PT song ;)
windriderrr 3 months ago
It could be 3 or 4 chords but they were made by god.
felixcf1 4 months ago 4
Who cares about "how many chords are used in this song".....
It may be 1, 2 or 1000..... the song is great.
WHO CARES!!!
EduEVLN 4 months ago 2
4 chords that made a million.
windriderrr 4 months ago 4
@windriderrr Ah, I like it :)
Arachnidius 3 months ago
@StatedSoul bravo
placebo67 4 months ago
It's a 3 chord song nevertheless. But not in the literal sense of the word.
dyurth 5 months ago
What feeling.. This it's true music and true musicians.
xXxgotmetal 6 months ago
@xXxgotmetal It's really awesome Rodrigo Andrade xD
97Luis97 6 months ago
Why on earth didn't Rudess handshake get returned (4:33)?>??!?!??! :(
I wudda died for that.
laypyu 6 months ago
2 gods.. <3
tikunakilljoy 6 months ago
an awsm accstc trk.....jst amazed....
faraz007able 6 months ago
I LOVE what JR is doing here. I hate when people complain about him being "note-y" If I wanted to hear the PT complete version I'd listen to it. Since this version doesn't have drums or bass I think it's the perfect version to have open interp. 2 of my favorite musicians.
DirtyCleAnDRuMMer92 6 months ago
Lol you guys are saying I'm going to invite Charlie Sheen and not expect him to win, Petrucci to play a banana instead of guitar. Stop arguing, Steve Wilson is a genius and I'm sure the whole purpose Rudess was there was cause of respect. Steve Wilson respects this man, and is willing to let him write on top of a song he wrote.
aznhxor 6 months ago
Comment removed
aznhxor 6 months ago
No one is ruining the song, Jordan just gives more vibes by playing some really fitting solo stuff. In no way it's exaggerated, it makes the song interesting, especially because it's live, if you want to hear the album version, you can listen to it, but where would be the need of playing this song with Jordan Rudess, if he's playing exactly the same like Barbieri does.
Lovemetallica93 6 months ago
In the beginning, does SW say "I'm a gate-crasher"? Love that guy haha
AEStheist 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Apparently 20 people in the world have no ears
rafacm52 7 months ago
Someone really is fond of notes, yeah?
bobnoxiousbr549 7 months ago
Only a word "WOW"
agaliareth78 7 months ago
AWESOME!!
jpaulom 7 months ago
OMFG!! My favorite pianist playing my favorite PT song OMG
ccofmight 8 months ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
Jordan Rudess who??? Richard Barbieri is THE man. Simple, yet profound. The difference in the outlook of the 2 keyboardists emphasises how PT is different from DT. While DT is all about technical flaunting, PT pampers us with pure music!
Dhruvlfc90 8 months ago
Comment removed
Dhruvlfc90 8 months ago
Man, I love both DT and PT to death but in this clip, I can't help but feel that Mr. Jordan Rudeness was treading on Mr. Wilson's creativity with a heavy hand...or TWO
Riffronan 8 months ago
Rudess is great and I love his music, but I found him overkill for this song! This song is supposed to be extremely light, uncomplicated...!
rutwicksees 8 months ago 4
Best 3 chords song ever...
Fikmonskov 8 months ago 38
@Fikmonskov its actually 4 :P there is a Cm# when he sings "My david dont u worry ..."
mike1992p 5 months ago
@mike1992p Sorry.
Best 4 chords song ever ;)
Fikmonskov 5 months ago
@Fikmonskov Hahaha no probs mate ;) you re welcome ! :P Best 4 chords indeed!
mike1992p 5 months ago
@mike1992p In fact there's 7 different chords in this song : verse A / A Maj7 / D, bridge Cm# / D / A / E, end D / Dm / F / E / A. Enjoy ;-)
jeromefr76 5 months ago
@jeromefr76 you re absolutely right :)
mike1992p 5 months ago
@Fikmonskov there are five chords in this song.
oooledzeppelinooo 2 months ago
@Fikmonskov
This song has following chords: A, A (With a G#), D, E, F and C#.
But nonetheless its a fantastic song. :)
Odinsgade 2 months ago
@Fikmonskov More like 7 Chords. lol
Azured665 1 month ago
stunning
Posthuman2003 8 months ago
wow. jordan is really doing the business here.
mightyquaid1979 9 months ago
sooooooooo nice........
christiannandres 9 months ago
i cant describe my feeling
vishalearnest 10 months ago
amazing to see them together. i wish steven wilson was the singer for dream theater. labrie sucks!!!!!!!!
MrHliamtoh 10 months ago
@MrHliamtoh i like labrie :)
slashy04 8 months ago
non puoi far suonare rudess con i porcupine!senti che cagata che vie fuori
Vesdrajo 10 months ago
@Vesdrajo Non è affatto male, invece! Rudess è un funambolico tastierista, che bene si adatta al genio di Wilson. Per me sono un'ottima accoppiata.
noconfig 10 months ago
@noconfig
beh io amo tutti e due, però non riesco proprio a vederli insieme...per me il tastierista dei porcupine non può che essere barbieri ehehe
Vesdrajo 10 months ago
@LesPantinsDansent I personally don't find his keyboard playing emotionless redundant piano. Emotionless redundant accoustic guitar strumming if anything.
kuehling83 10 months ago
@kuehling83 I find the piano play by JR to be a bit too, for lack of a better word, flying. He is a masterful piano player, yes, but I find his piano play in this performance to be too.. extravagant. Too fancy. It still fits in the song, but I still like the original better. And yes, redundant repetitive guitar play. Nothing too fancy. Steven Wilson more or less composes every song from scratch, so playing the redundant guitar is outweighed by the composition and his beautiful voice.
Beverkake 10 months ago
@readolinski82 good music shouldn't be downloaded!!!!!!!
hammerslammer66 11 months ago
Yay! I wish this piano player was the pianist for Justin Bieber.
plasticPlaystation 11 months ago
@plasticPlaystation Troll harder nigger.
HarvestHollow 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
the goatee is where Wilson stores all of his talent.
Salaattiful 11 months ago
fantastic! thanks for this live!!!!
nick40nick40 11 months ago
Would so love to see this live
MupNaz 1 year ago
I would eat my own poop for a good recording of this.
boarwood 1 year ago 4
Can't get any better than this!
Fuzzbuggy 1 year ago
left-handed bassist.....;)
Ippiti88 1 year ago
Where did this come from and why don't those two play together more? Thos are literally like the two most creative musicians on earth and they were in the same room? MUST HAVE MORE!
kylemctreehugger1991 1 year ago 3
@kylemctreehugger1991 Rudess opened for Porcupine Tree on one tour.
zbusterzsabre 1 year ago
@zbusterzsabre Ok thank you. I wish I would have seen that. It would have been a dream come true.
kylemctreehugger1991 1 year ago
@zbusterzsabre My guess is this is from the Blackfield tour - as thats the same acoustic Aviv Geffen uses and the left handed P-Bass in the background is also the same one the Blackfield bassist used on their Live In NYC dvd.
theakstonsrock 1 year ago
BAD crowd. It took them almost 15 seconds till Wilson sang to know its lazarus.
Rudess is a fuckin era. Rudessness should be a word.
agrexxion 1 year ago
I think I just had a progasm.
TheFalseStory 1 year ago 5
Good thing the mic wasn't on Rudess, all you would have heard is his humming.
legendofzelda101 1 year ago
I can't believe this is a thing. This is too good to be true. I am literally crying at the beauty of this.
13ondor 1 year ago
my dream is play with steven wilson, jordan rudess, adrian belew, julie slick, ,marcus miller etc. is a SMALL dream :)
CristianTejadaU 1 year ago
I don't know but this is the first song I heard from them and everytime I hear it I want to cry ♥
LiizisDrunkFirefly 1 year ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
When and where did it happen?
idolovetopoop 1 year ago
Wilson and Rudess, fucking epic!
astrophonix 1 year ago 3
17 people know nothing about music.
This is...simply incredible. Two of the most ingenious musicians of our time on the same stage. Wish I'd been there.
drummerkid904 1 year ago
Stineck: I hear ya'. Unbelievable. This performance is nothing short of *gorgeous*.
msclvr48 1 year ago
@MistaMeeetch Iron man sucked. Porcupine Tree rules.
PantericA85 1 year ago 6
@PantericA85 OH MY FUCKING GOD, HOW YOU CAN SAY THAT
CristianTejadaU 1 year ago
so enormous, beautiful
joedestroy46 1 year ago
HOLY SHIT
sutherlandan 1 year ago
Awesomeness ^^
Naathiw 1 year ago
Incredible.
SuperGuitarBitch 1 year ago
simply perfect and beautiful.. :]
bengochiva 1 year ago
16 viewers are aliens and thus incapable of listening to human music.
lefphilip 1 year ago 3
By the gear, I think it's a Porcupine tree show (maybe) or a Jordan Rudess solo show (most likely). It's awesome, but i like it more with Richard Barbieri in keys.
mrteclasN5 1 year ago
smallest stage evere
jack0eagle 1 year ago
jordan q monstruo es exelente
juanluisinho7 1 year ago
Demasiado talento para un escenario tan pequeño!!!!
Aracem 1 year ago 4
Does anyone know where the footage comes from ?
Zoury 1 year ago
OMG.. a piece of Porcupine Tree.. with a piece of Dream Theater?..
now I can die Happy..
you Know..
i follow you doown.. to the valley of MUSIC
LJZN 1 year ago 5
too much talent for one stage
ADHDforTHEwin 1 year ago 7
Plmafios01. I just envy master jordán , dont take it too serious
oscar1974 1 year ago
Great
GeneticAsymmetry 1 year ago
Legend... wait for it..(5min&4sec later)...DARY
Linio88 1 year ago 3
Haahaha, so, if Rudess stores all his talent in his goatee then where does Wilson store his? Wait... I know this... it's his hair.
Melodies4guitar 1 year ago 4
keyboard mistake at 2:50...
oscar1974 1 year ago
Comment removed
cobainx15 1 year ago
@oscar1974 Ur a mistake
PLmafios01 1 year ago 6
I'm so sad for Dream Theater falling apart...
andreagrimaldi 1 year ago 2
my two favourite bands.Wow
blebamies 1 year ago 4
Wonderful song, wonderful singers..Steven is a Genius and Jordan is a Keywizard!!
TheMrBeardfish 1 year ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
Hey, if you like Porcupine Tree then check out Grey Skies Fallen on my channel!
CraigGSF 1 year ago
How can 14 people dislike this?!
Stinechk 1 year ago 63
@Stinechk maybe they don't appreciate the quality of sound.. :D
thalyon22 1 year ago
@Stinechk Justin Beiber wasnt patient enough to create a fifteenth account!
pratishray 1 year ago
@Stinechk Nickelback fans.
SteveTheWonderLlama 1 year ago
@Stinechk 14 people who haven't graduated to the big leagues when it comes to perceiving GREATNESS.
rayholtz 1 year ago
@Stinechk Too much info to process for their 5 neurons, probably Lady Gaga fans.
intestinomedicino 1 year ago
@intestinomedicino Hahaha yeah, or Justin Bieber LOL. Couldn't agree more!
ikkejick 1 year ago
@Stinechk 19 now! I guess, frustrated musicians!
ronaldmoracastillo 1 year ago
@Stinechk 14 people like Britney Spears?
bertonifilms 9 months ago
@Stinechk because Rudess ruins the song by showing off. It doesn't fit the original at all, nor Steven's guitar play here. It's just a misfit. Steven himself says it's not the technical complexity of songs that makes Porcupine Tree, it's the composition and layering. So ruining that composition is the worst thing you can do to a PT song and that's exactly what Rudess does here. The beautiful, subtle melody by Barbieri is gone and what we got back sounds like muzak.
kekburloller 7 months ago
Do you really think Steven Wilson didn't know Jordan would show off all over the song? It's not supposed to be the original, and I think it'd be insulting to assume Steven didn't know what he was getting into with this collaboration.
lastdayinsin3 6 months ago
@kekburloller go fuck urslf....
faraz007able 6 months ago
@Stinechk Deaf perhaps?
ZachValkyrie 6 months ago
the perfect song
spitty4986 1 year ago
oh man what's the song that follows this?
halfacat1 1 year ago
goosebumps
WickedOne942 1 year ago
Did the audience really not recognize the song before he started singing? That intro is very recognizable in my opinion.
Annulable 1 year ago 3
where was this?
cipicipitio 1 year ago
holy shit i think im crying... btw kevin moore is better still!
rockstarsupernate 1 year ago 2
@rockstarsupernate
I agree. Imagine a Porcupine Tree/O.S.I. colab...
nhonho23 1 year ago
Profesor Rudess :):)
MegaDadys 1 year ago
I wish that someday I could play like Rudess. =o
I think I'll go practice piano now.
Also, this is an absolutely beautiful version.
DiffCliff 1 year ago
beautiful. :D
PBandJeIIy 1 year ago
wowwww =)
Megaflare93 1 year ago
Jordan Rudess is the best living pianist!
92Misfit 1 year ago 25
@92Misfit Greatest living penis what? he is a keyboadist
VlogTheateR 11 months ago
@VlogTheateR We get it. You're hilarious.
BruisedEyeSockets 10 months ago
@BruisedEyeSockets i appreciate your sarcasm very much :)
VlogTheateR 10 months ago
@92Misfit Greatest living penis what? he is a keyboardist
VlogTheateR 11 months ago
hell ya! Great emotion in this track
wurmart43 1 year ago
I'll kick the 13 asses that don't like this ¬¬
scrEamoOxXa99cOrE 1 year ago
Jordan Rudess makes a mistake at 1:45. Quite unusual...
FutureHyperion 1 year ago
@FutureHyperion
2012 man!!!
headshota1989 1 year ago
@FutureHyperion Yeah, you are right. It's also like Steven is looking at him after that mistake.
JordEs1980 1 year ago
wow...
Mynamesketan 1 year ago
Such a beautiful song and JR really suits it,don't often hear Him play like that in DT.Wicked.
andrewbroughton65 1 year ago
metropolis part 3: it's not gonna happen
panamanian911 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hey guys, if you like Porcupine Tree then check out my band Grey Skies Fallen on my channel!!!
CraigGSF 1 year ago
@BenMurrie Metropolis Part 3: Scenes from a Deadwing
UnforgivingCritic 1 year ago
I hope people realize what they're seeing here. This is two unbelievably talented artists performing a once in a lifetime dream.
Jordan Rudess can do no wrong in my eyes. The man plays straight from the heart -- genius.
OneSteveUnderGod 1 year ago 3
great track :)
spirit2001uk 1 year ago
I can't wait for the project with Mike Portnoy, Mikael Akerfeldt and Steven
HateHumanity 1 year ago 4
@HateHumanity where is there evidence of this existing?
OnionFather41 1 year ago
It's been talked about for years now, mentioned in interviews of all three members for quite some time. They all insist that it will happen sometime, but that they're never all free at the same time to do so.
Aniland 1 year ago
@HateHumanity Seriously? Where have you heard that?
passgodtpaadegselv 1 year ago
@passgodtpaadegselv It's true, but don't get your hopes up. The article I read it from was from back 2006.
Deathshuck 1 year ago
@Deathshuck Ah, okay. I guess it was just too good to be true anyway. But thank you!
passgodtpaadegselv 1 year ago
@passgodtpaadegselv
Don't get your hopes down just yet, apparently they have already started without Portnoy, though he'll be on board soon enough. There are interviews on Blabbermouth and Metal Injection, dated to this year last month, of Steven Wilson and Mikeal Akerdfelt already starting on the project without Portnoy, for now, and all ready have 15 mins of material that they came up with. Their all still on tour so it will be another while before it really kicks off
NightmareCinema42889 1 year ago
@NightmareCinema42889 Oh, really? That's just great! I'll try and stay updated then.
passgodtpaadegselv 1 year ago
My dream come true ♥ (:
Jash612 1 year ago
It warms my heart to see Steven Wilson this close to Dream Theatre. Porcupine Tree is such a hidden gem. An absolutely amazing band.
JOELAB1020 1 year ago 2
OMG! no fucking way!!! awesome!!
Bastardoom 1 year ago
the goatee is where rudess stores all of his talent.
TigerTaint 1 year ago 85
Rudess Tree :D
Croketas 1 year ago 3
Prog-gasmic
whosaidsoup13 1 year ago 2
what a treat!!
neomatrix124 1 year ago
RUDESS IMMENSO.
jacopinothebestia 1 year ago
Beautiful. And it is so nice to see Steven Wilson smile, he doesn't smile often
xlicix 1 year ago 2
When I saw the video title my face nearly melted off
SebVettel18 1 year ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
boring pop song, but jordan and dream theater are gods!
bonfirejovi 1 year ago
I think wilson and rudess is a pretty cool guy. eh plays musics and doesnt afraid of anything...
jeffreybp 1 year ago 5
@jeffreybp
I think jeffreybp is a pretty cool guy, eh makes witty comments and doesnt afraid of anything! hehe thumbs up dude! Love this version :)
ChromeXk 1 year ago
Hats off to Rudess, just check the score or stems for that track and you'll see how much it relies on layered strings and synth, but the dude does it with just piano. Don't get me wrong, i think Barbieri is far better for PT and does a better job of the song live, but can't deny the guy props.
theakstonsrock 1 year ago
"Dream Tree"
BiorythmicDrifter 1 year ago
@BiorythmicDrifter
I think Porcupine Dream sounds better, mate.
nhonho23 1 year ago 3
@nhonho23 Porcupine Theater sounds even better XD
goldenfire88 1 year ago
Dream Tree :-)
Rishro 1 year ago
@Rishro
Porcupine Theatre
luthierjustin1 1 year ago 8
what next? gavin and portnoy having a drummoff? this is awesome!
toolfan92 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Porcupine Tree fans will also like Koi, search for Koi Album Trailer!
WTCSchannel 1 year ago
This song is so... I wish I had another word beside awesome ... beautiful? stirring? I can just listen to it over and over. (Though I prefer the studio ver ;-)Thanks for posting!
IYAMNI 1 year ago
@IYAMNI captivating.
TheAwesomeClub 1 year ago
i can't believe how amazing this sounds live.. :O
nemis111 1 year ago