AI 5 Finale - Carrie, Kat & Taylor - Made it Through the rai

[mermaidofsuburbia]

Carrie is nothing special - she's just another pretty blonde girl with a mediocre voice. Taylor is the most original Idol ever.

[yesitsme9]

@mermaidofsuburbia Totally agree. Soul Patrol for-evah!

[newflava89AGAIN]

two best idol ever!!! Carrie Underwood and Katharine McPhee.... both of them my fav singer now!!!!!!!! Kat in pop and Carrie in country :)

[stevieray1722]

Katharine outshines them both!

[JenniJaco]

Carrie and Taylor sound great together..they should do a duet like Joe Cocker and Jennifer Warnes did together

[row759]

@JenniJaco , get real, Carrie sounds a lot better than Taylor and she is better than Taylor.

[JenniJaco]

@row759 I prefer a voice with a little more soulful character, like Taylor's. Everyone has their own preferences.

[row759]

@JenniJaco , whatever Carrie's got a more clear voice than any of them combine. That's why Carrie is the best of the Idols, but that just my preference.

[JenniJaco]

@row759 Good singing comes in many different styles. Carrie had the pure tone, while Taylor clearly displayed the most emotion and connection with the audience, which brings me back to my original point: Carrie and Taylor would complement each other well in a duet. Silk and Whisky

[row759]

@JenniJaco , Carrie got just as emotion as Taylor Hicks, maybe even more. I know Carrie has become than Taylor. What the heck has happen to Taylor Hicks, he seems to have gone nowhere as far as I know.

[TheBboh61]

S5 had the most talent of all the seasons.

[mylast1stkiss]

@TheBboh61 i always thought this season and the 3rd season was the best too

[15joel22]

carrie is the best!!!!!!!!!!

[bigbilly2006]

Is it just me, or does Katharine McFee look like Vannesa Hudgens?

[uuyyuuyy]

they arre soo good!!

btw taylors voice remindes me alot of danny gokey's (season 8) , danny deserved to win!

[yesitsme9]

Taylos is HOT!!! I love that man!

[20Shelbi12]

Carrie is amazing!!!

You go girl :)

[CarrieUnderwoodful]

Carrie and Kat rock!Carrie is the best

[batfan903]

I wish that they had Fantasia, Ruben, Kelly, Bo, Clay, Diana, and Justin there!! That would have been perfect the first five top 2 reunion!!

[musicislove234]

Taylor! :)

[teeftaller7]

If taylor & kat had the right songs & ppl to help like kelly & carrie they would be up there with them..

[JayMe2823]

Um, not a chance .

[qg6ff]

I think Katharine's pretty damn close up there.

[AldairON]

Poxa, saudade dessa temporada, pra mim foi a melhor !! Saudades....

[chatterbox1229]

wow.. Carrie has improved so much! Taylor was really good it's just a shame that he wasn't given the right attention and management...

[x0comeon0x]

Wow

[teeftaller7]

Season 4 was the best

[torimonkeys]

i agree

[girlbuckeyefanatic]

This was the best season!!!!!!

[Skyinthebluesky]

totally agree!!

[stephanieb36]

I totally agree, the BEST!!

[teeftaller7]

I wanna see kelly ruben fantasia carrie taylor jordin & david sing together with next season's winner & runner-up

[jaymejean28]

how about no fantasia or taylor then it would sound amazing!!

[jessicacanta10]

kathaterine is wonderfull and beautifull and has better voice then taylor,i can't she diden't win!

[SteelAVic18]

This was the best season ever of American Idol. Katherine should have won. I wish the Finale would have been between Katherine and Mandisa!

[marieu2704]

best season ever!

[krissings]

I love Carrie and Katharine, Taylor sucked and never should have even made it to hollywood!

[umcapul]

made it through the rain was much better performed by d 3 black divas in AI (fantasia, latoya&hudson)during their finale presentation.... i really had goosebumps watching it!

[ronnald89]

I agree with you!

[7Caelin7]

Kat should've won.

Taylor doesn't have a good voice at all.

[RAACHCHEL]

you know carrie underwood seems soo like the oldest one there. not like age but she feels soo comfrotable on stage singing like she seems better then the rest. but thats jsut my opinion.

[CareBear31083]

Carrie is better than the rest..&& she's been on tour && doing this for a year or so ..

[CareBear31083]

Thats because IS better than the rest!!!

Best Idol=CMU<3

[chilidog5693]

Katharine has the most beautiful voice!

[whuhumuch]

it should of been katherine out of these two but out of the whole season it should of been chris daulgery

[jaymejean28]

HAHAHAHAHA not even

[TaylorHickslover978]

taylor hicks look gorgues!

omg hes sooooo talented and sexii

hahaha <3333

[jaymejean28]

um are you blind? haha.

[Rebereyes]

carrie is so beautifullllllllllllll

[animeotakumoe]

How did taylor win!?!?! After soo long i still think Katharine is WAY better she has a MUCH stonger voice

[Rebereyes]

he won because people liked him, because the people voted for him, not for kat

[jaymejean28]

VFTW

[tutorgirl082594]

i love this performance so much. carrie was amazing, everyone was. i love carrie's hair though.

[mjt1206]

Carrie sucks....how did she win with that voice. Kast sounds great

[bigbluegrl23]

ur probably a fan of taylor hicks... u kno, someones whos tone deaf

[bigmike2788]

GO CARRIE!!!!!!!!

[carlos312]

katharine and carrie are amazingly gorgeous. i think kat is hotter though

[allthatjas5]

yes she is

[woodsmic1]

like duhhh

[iheartmusick]

When was this performed?

[cevichexconxpescado]

May 24, 2006

[lilmisfit23]

I still think Carrie blew them all out of the water

[bigbluegrl23]

u are right

[bg2185]

@lilmisfit23 i 2nd that!

[livetodancexox]

@lilmisfit23 she did:D

thats why she won the shop <3

[Jandecbs]

I'm sorry. I have no idea what you're listening to. Kat was no off the melody. She was great. She has one of the most beautiful voices ever on Idol.

[kidtaouk]

I agree!

[allthatjas5]

me too

[emmarude43]

Taylors voice made this video. He is the best

[allthatjas5]

so not

[ajamaicanparadox1]

Ohh wow.. i love this song, howeber.. i do believe Jennifer Hudson, Fantasia, and Latoya in the Top 12 Medley was better.. considering Kat is off the melody in the 1st verse. However, i must say that this is the first time I've recognized Taylor as a real singer thought