Added: 1 year ago
From: TEDtalksDirector
Views: 377,986
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (2,889)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • @Maloparic Speak for yourself, mate. I'm a gamer. I have a girlfriend, I have lots of friends, I know how to cook (really well), I go out every other day, and I'm also a lawyer, I am a gamer AND I am also a person that is actively involved in society.

    What we think of others is frequently what we think about ourselves, and in my very personal opinion, you should make some introspection about your own self.

    P.S. With all due respect.

  • She really is full of shit. I WAS a gamer and all I have to say is... WTF?

    Everything she said is confined to the "virtual world". In the real world, gamers don't even meet the person the play the game with. They meet pixels that REPRESENT that person. Gamers are usually so lazy they don't even make their own food, and they are "so urgently optimistic" they avoid any type of work so they could play some more.

    Gamers are lazy, incompetent, hybrids that don't know how the real world works.

  • LOL I just sent Athene this video after watching his video about Shawn. Good that he already knows! :D

  • 20 minutes women yapping should be fun ??

  • Please marry me :')

  • Athene sent me here

  • @krazykid12345 Suck his dick more nerd.

  • TTTT athene army... story time !!!

  • TTTT

  • Like if Athene brought you here.

  • Fallout 3 & New Vegas is the answer to this video !

  • exactly fuck school, play more videos games, save the world, got it

  • 21 billion hours of gameplay'o week, You don't solve problems, You want to make all of us sit in on our asses playing games all day? Makes no sense... Good try, but in my opinion, Get back to the kitchen...

  • @DeLunaticoMan Adding the 'kitchen' meme clarifies how little you use your brain, I suggest you suck my dick.

  • Saying gaming is an anwser to our problems is the same as saying

    alcohol is the awnser to our problems.

    Gaming just makes me lethargic and psssive in real life

    and it closes up my third eye . . ..

  • I'm glad that she sees so much positivity but I don't agree with any of this . .

  • Gamers are already solving real world problems.

    Scientists created a puzzle game to help solve a problem they have had with protein structures in AIDS.

    Its pretty cool.

  • 358 ppl play checkers.

  • "This is true. I believe this."... So is it true, or do you just believe this? If it's true, then you wouldn't need to believe it. It would just be true.

  • Bottom Line: People are more enthusiastic/motivated, more willing to solve problems and co-operate when playing video games, we need to apply those skills to the real world.

    7:04

    We try harder, solve more problems, and have a stronger will to win when we play video games, than we do at work, at school, etc. etc.

    Important Points: [8:55] [9:17] [9:53] [10:10] [10:59] [11:22]

    Very Important Points: [11:50] [13:37] [16:15]

    Most Important Point [18:00]

  • She is talking about harnessing the collective brain power of a social group as a problem solving machine. It just so happens that gaming is a very successful way of bonding people into dedicated social units with singular purposes.

    Organized religion is kind of the old school way of doing this. If the need for meaning and a sense of belonging is an inherent and biologically hardwired part of the human psyche, then gaming is the 21st century way of worshiping.

  • To the people who are dissing this concept and bashing her for an idea.

    Are you all so ignorant to see that shes not actually saying directly that playing games will solve world hunger? She wants to use the concept of the attitude human beings have towards games towards real life. If we can all have the same attitude and drive and motivation we have to finish and complete and win in a game as we do in real life. We would have innovated beyond our mindset and closed minded shit already.

  • We need a new analytic: Gross Domestic Epic Win

  • Comment removed

  • To all the people that says this is shit and doesnt explain anything: I think what shes trying to say is that we must be in real life like we are in games, never giving up and all that stuff.

  • she practically said nothing, this is just a nerd fest speech full of nolife wowers on the theatre being brainwashed by master nerd, im so ashamed by watching this nonsense

  • @jazamora2006 You didn't watch past the first 5 seconds did you? The whole point of this video was about being as motivated in real life as you are when you're playing a video game, and applying the same enthusiasm and drive into your every day work.

    Most people try harder in video games than they do in real life, if you weren't so fucking quick to judge you'd understand what she was talking about But hey, you're just some 40 year old guy who records puppies why would you care.

  • @TheATFStudios i did watch whole 20 mins... unfortunately.. and i fail to see any point on this video, there were no evident or solid conclusions to her 'speech' it was just all mumbo jumbo epic win speech nerds like to relate to...playing mmos, socializing online with ppl u dont know, instead in real life is having a no life, period, you want a better real life, stop playing mmos. thats pretty much it imo. lol@ 40 year old, fyi I take care of gsp breeds for sell..

  • @jazamora2006 Good for you. gtfo and have a shitty day.

  • now, tell this one more time to my parents

  • How to solve world hunger?

    >play more games

    >>use more electricity

    >>>burn more coal

    >>>>increased greenhouse gases

    Yep i dont see "cure world hunger" anywhere in there.

  • @KiloSierra13 Maybe you can join her team and made one "World Saving Games" about the world hunger ^^

  • @KiloSierra13 You did not hear about learning to co-operate to complete difficult tasks?

  • @KiloSierra13 If you had the attention span of more than ~20 seconds you would've seen what she meant.

    18:00 is when she says when actual solutions are suggested by groups in Superstruct to actually solve real world problems.

  • I am a gamer and this is complete bullshit. Back to the kitchen lady.

  • She's a fucking genius....

  • Because in online RPG's, we are forced to socialize and team up with other players so we will be rewarded with an epic item that we are personally interested in. We'll have to socialise/team-up or else nothing can be acchieved. And as you mentioned, that we can also simulate some types of future disastrous events that will take place in real-life, so we can learn how to prevent it. Ms. McGonigal, I would like to thank you and your team for your research! This idea has enormous potential! TY =)

  • I really hope that in my lifetime, we can realise your idea's at some point. For the last centuries people were only mass-stimulated only for a period after when a war took place. Because only then, people reached out for each other and are more willingly progressive for a greater cause (the country). I think that it's logical, that we would also experience the same kind of motivation while playing multi-player games, but obviously without the disastrous pre-event that has to take place first.

  • I love how she talks about how people are out to collaborate with you... and conveniently forgets to mention the vast culture of teabagging, noob-fragging and all those wonderful things we do to each other online out of love and humanity <3

  • but.. what if its an epic fail instead? :(

  • I'm a Kitchen and i find this girl offensive.

  • 2:27 this video is an EPIC WIN

  • hoped she would show tits....

  • That's me on the picture. (Really no jokes here)

    I made the account just to comment :D

  • congratulations, you're making blizzard more money with your crazy ideas

  • WoW = "meaningful work"!?!?!?! lol

  • Comment removed

  • i love her justification for gaming totally awesome

  • I learned more about Economics in a week of World of Warcraft than 10 years of school.

  • @Vwong114 stop trying

  • WOW taught me to be a murdering bastard who preys on the weak when possible.

  • @norgulon That's just you

  • Holy shit people take things way to literally.. this whole presentation is a message. Its not telling you to sit on your ass and play games all day and contribute nothing. Pay attention and stop being stupid..

  • my mom needs to watch this ...

  • 355 people are technophobes who never touched a video game.

  • +20 speaking, there you go.

  • She should be called Jane McGonagall :(

  • I don't think we become the best version of ourselves in video games.

  • Gamers does obiously not have anything even remotely close to superpowers. Real workers change the world, gamers game, and they always will.

  • @Fr1jd atleast we know how to speak english

  • wait. to fight obesity, we need to sit on our asses and play all night?

  • i want to marry her *-* xD

  • @diegoyev you got competition bro

  • i would never want to look like this guy while an epic win...

  • I am a gamer, and I totally disagree with your point.

    I would be more happy if I could leave home and my PC and Games behind. But I am too addicted to do that.

  • @PandaKunX I Totally agree with you!

    The Gaming is rouing our life's!!!!

    But I agree with the woman in the video up to a piont.

    We show our best side(or the worst) in gaming. Socioty is accepting us as we are in person, not our looks, wealth etc.

    If this only could be this way IRL .... :/ *suck*- Swedish for " Puhh"

    Sorry for misspelling :P Not my strong side !

  • OH MY GOD ! EVEN THIS VIDEO RECEIVED BAD RATINGS !

  • i now really feel like playing a game

  • lol consider games like fallout 3.. in that game, every playthrough I was murdering and stealing whenever I felt like it. even when I was a 'good' character ahaha

  • Back to 9GAG :3

  • @likomania lmfao

  • @likomania Wait people actually go on 9gag. Or are you just joking?

  • Every time I had cooper-test in grade school, I reminisced on the WoW characters and realized that they could run forever. I ended up first. Fuck yeah.

  • we need people like her in this world....

  • she's sexxy :P

  • @teddyaldo  wtf really for?, where r u from?

  • Most of the people can never understand this unless they are gamers themselves..

  • Jane for President of Earth.

  • 23 years before we face extinction!? I wish I knew exactly what quest(s) I should take in order to avoid that!

  • question : is the "real world" in danger and needed to be saved ?

  • @mamamia511 yep look around..

  • @mamamia511

    You live on the moon?

  • I think SWTOR would have been a better example than WoW, but this was also made in 2010, so we didn't have that.

  • well if she promised me i'd respawn after I die I'd so go save the world!! :P

  • I am a gamer, and SHE is crazy XD

  • 9gag

    

  • Form a team and cooperate in real life like in world of warcraft to solve bigger problems...

    ALRIGHT CHUMS! LET'S DO THIS! LEEROOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOY!!! JENKIIIIIIIINSSS...

  • Fuckt this Shit. 358.956 views!? SPREAD THE WORD GAMERS!!! :D

  • I just peed a little...

  • 19:34

    Bald, Bald, Bald, Bald...

  • Okay is she crazy sorry girl but no offense

  • @lsgh3 "hey guys, I think the Earth is round!"

    "hey guys, I think we evolved from monkeys!"

    "hey guys, I think we should totally go to the moon and stuff!"

    "hey guys, I think gamers have an enormous potential that we can use!"

    Crazy doesn't mean that its the wrong way to go or that its the wrong way to think.

  • I don't know why, but... I can't take this seriously. xd

  • @FruityLumi keep an open mind :)

  • interactive transcription, please

  • I learned english in onlinegames, fuck school :3

  • @KiinqBaLu Me too, much less frustration and much more fun!

  • @KiinqBaLu U made my day because of that smiley in the end... (thumbsup)

  • @KiinqBaLu

    I learned english as a nearly native language from games and I hardly had to study for history Civ 1 - 4 ftw

  • @KiinqBaLu I learned english from facebook and games ^_^

  • @KiinqBaLu exactly!

  • @KiinqBaLu LOL me too!!!!! XD

  • @KiinqBaLu Haha, looks like you're not the only one :D Grand Theft Auto taught me my english and last year I had five A-grades in the class tests without learning anything :D

  • She forgot one very important aspect. "RAGEQUIT"

  • @MusicOfJohnny thats almost a CoD community thing... i dont remeber to RAGEQUIT on Uncharted, Mass Effect, Battlefield, Swtor, Skyrim, Deus Ex and so on...

  • @fabry6969 a joke.

  • So ein Schwachsinn.

  • I learned economics and typing from World of Warcraft

  • Comment removed

  • 9gagers INCOMING

  • tell that to my mom

  • @sean2rist lol man, so true :P

  • You lost me at climate change. How sad that a smart woman like this would still be so foolish and out of the loop that she believes the already proven fraud of what was formerly "global warming" and to become the ambiguous term "climate change". Her ideals and soul are beautiful and I admire her tenacity. The world is changing regardless of any output now. A game will not change a world, but people sure as hell will! We are evolving intellectually in real time. Love, health, and peace 2 all.

  • WoW

  • How about GTA?

  • I think she should have worked more on her speech if she wanted her audience to understand better and not laugh at it, for example: using an "epic fail" in her speech made it sound kind of cheesy, not everyone there is a gamer and those people might feel like she can't relate to their point of view so they laugh. She should have read a few books on how to express yourself on the stage or something similar. This is just my opinion, sorry for my bad English.

  • What she is saying can work, in theory. But what kind of a world would we live in where every problem has to be viewed as game in order to get anyone to do anything? The only idea from her presentation that I really like is that we should make everyone collaborate on solving real world problems. That really appeals to me.

  • I want what she's smoking! I sincerely hope her 'research' isn't being funded by the taxpayer. I'd say the basis or drive is probably only to attempt to attribute more credit to gamers. It's a simple reaction of her feeling gamers are getting less respect than they deserve, which is of course completely false. Some of the garbage she's come up with a 10 year old can show flaws in.

    Also, if your goal is to be taken more seriously, restrain yourself from using the 'epic win' stupidity constantly.

  • @brettenator well she is serious enough to be talking in TEDx , and her ideas are based on research and facts...on the other hand you are just a close-minded idiot with no serious counter-argument, please if you are so smart TED community is waiting for your speech, don't be shy...oh wait they would prolly kick you out cause you are a retard with no innovative ideas...don't be so jealous of other peoples success, go make something with your miserable life isntead, friendly advice ;)

  • @rimodimiourgos13 I could certainly make a speech destroying this insane woman's 'facts', but I doubt TED would want to hear it. She wastes 20 minutes telling people that people basically enjoy playing games and are more enthusiastic about playing them that they are about everyday things in reality. You would think she would have a shred of evidence that this enthusiasm can carry over to the real world, but she doesn't. But you are correct to say that I have no innovative ideas

  • @brettenator i guess time will be the judge of her idea then xD

  • @rimodimiourgos13 indeed it will my friend

  • global

    extinction

    awareness

    system

    Geas, code Geas -_____-

  • I tried to put it all together and it came out complete bullshit. This is the worst plan ever

  • You eat too much shit per second.

  • I think this is the shittiest plan i've ever heard.What the fuck is wrong with your brains,americans?

  • If people would eat less if they game, why are most overweight children gaming like there is no tomorrow?

    anyways, She makes some sense in some parts but other parts is just complete nonsense

  • waaaaaaa

  • Professor Mcgonigal will save the world

  • HEY, have you met Ted ?

  • fuck that bitch i missed raid

  • The game industry is largely underestimated...

  • time to play some fucking videogames!

  • Also, who the hell is TED?

  • I think a good intermediate step would be to try to make educational games that were actually fun. I think if I knew half as much about the atomic elements as I did about pokemon elements, I would have probably aced all my chem classes. There are some games out there that can actually teach you some stuff, but they're too few and far between. Oh and as far as improving yourself goes, i spent as much time exercising as I've spent grinding in final fantasy, I'd have the body of a God.

  • with sopa we cant do that

  • This is bullshit. Games are played for fun. If you want to instill productivity in future generations, get them a good education, not a damn game console.

  • @Chromeo33

    how about combining both?

    It is proven that you can learn more and better when you get the needed information through playing games or watching films (not documentations).

    So if you would fill all games and films with true informations and existing problems to solve, it would really help you to react in the right way and find good solutions in real life.

  • @Chromeo33 well i think part of the point she was making is that the kids get the game consoles on their own. A better education would be wonderful, but we don't already have that. we already have a game console in most houses in america, so how can we use that to our advantage? also, i think learning and being productive is fun, and that's what you do in those games. most people who play games must agree because if they didn't they'd spend their free time sleeping or watching tv.

  • Why Gamers are spend so much time in virtual reality, rather than real reality?

    Virtual Worlds have a more simplistic model. This makes them easier to manage by ordinary people.

    So we need just better "management" of the world to achieve what she is talking about. Due to good management being able to simplify the "work" process for people.

    Ah yes, Thumbs UP something "smart" for instance. Rather than a sheeply comment about how you got here.

  • Lots of bosses to demonstrate teamwork and you pick: "KILL THE SPIKES NOOBS"??

  • thank you jane you gave me hope in the humanity again. hope in humanity +20 (completely restored!)

  • this will shut my mom up when i spend an hour or more on a game

  • We have ways to invent energy. Just go to trollscience. There's your answer.

  • Life is already like World of Warcraft: It sucks.

    AHWHAWHAWHAWHAWHAWHAWHAWHAWHAW­HAWHAWHWAHWAWaw

  • gawd... this seriously makes sense... we need to apply this...

  • AUDIENCE...Y U LAUGH O_o ?!

  • Oh well, still idealism doesn't get you anywhere, I doubt this girl has ever helped ANYONE at all, outside a game

  • @EXHellfire so what are you saying. Because she hasn't yet helped anyone, you have no reason to help anyone either? That's a horrible way to think.

  • @TheCalimbaKing No, you just led yourself to understand that. I didn't mean that. I just said mere idealism doesn't get you anywhere, meaning I hate people that talk but don't act. I don't waste my time around saying everyone should help the ones in need, I actually get my ass off the chair and go help. Whenever a homeless person asks me for some money, I give them some. Whenever someone is troubled, I listen to them and help them with some psychology. That's not a horrible way to think.

  • @EXHellfire And how did you get the information that she doesn't give homeless people money or listen to people in need? You're assuming things from a 20 minute talk. Besides, she's giving a possible solution for changing things on a larger scale, and if you don't think that there's creativity and a lot of thinking (and talking) needed to solve the big problems we're facing, you're way more naive than her idea is in your opinion.

  • @bloodymalkavian I just said that I don't like people that talk and don't act. I don't know this girl so I am free to assume whatever I want that hasn't already been proven wrong, so you aren't proving me naïve at all. You know only about what I said earlier, you don't know even my name, and less idea you have about what I am like, so shut up, It's not like this conversation is going anywhere anyways,

  • @EXHellfire you aren't being very helpful by criticizing her work. Besides, I consider this action. She's taken the liberty of sending her idea out to the world. How do we know she doesn't practice what she preaches? This does not say that this is all she does. She follows her plan. That's why she made it. She just wanted to share it with the world. And I can already see that someone agrees with me. You've lost this.

  • @TheCalimbaKing I've lost what? You thought this is an argument? What the fuck, I just replied to you because you suddenly attacked me though 1- you don't even know me and 2- you can't possibly change my mind over a youtube discussion

  • @EXHellfire it's cute that you feel so threatened. Nobody attacks you, and certainly nobody cares what your name is or who you are. You commented on a video, people disagreed with you. And if you're as good in conversation in real life as you are here, you should probably not try to help people talking about their problems :)

  • @bloodymalkavian So if this wasn't an argument what was it? You disagreed and started telling me I was wrong. It's really different from people telling me their problems. This has no point at all. I'm aware nobody attacks me, but you make the second person that tells me I'm wrong. I don't actually think I am, therefore I won't tell you you're right. That's it. This is truly going nowhere.

  • @EXHellfire I don't get it. You say this isn't an argument yet you tell bloodymalkvavian "So if this wasn't an argument what was it?" And me not even knowing you does not change anything. Whether I know you or not, this conversation would've been gone the same. Nobody on youtube knows how to back up their comments anymore.

  • @TheCalimbaKing Yeah, it did become an argument since you guys keep trying to bash my opinion, and find me wrong. I didn't intend it to be an argument at the beginning, but to hell with that. And yeah, if what you said is true, that it is true that nobody on Youtube can back their comments up, then why do you ask me to back myself up here? Seriously, this is going nowhere, why keep at it? Let's just call for a break here, it's meaningless.

  • @EXHellfire alright I can be reasonable. Truce. :)

  • @EXHellfire Nobody 'bashed' your opinion, I'm just telling you that if you get offended when someone disagrees with you, you probably shouldn't comment on a video in the first place. Saying 'shut up' and repeating 'you don't know me' really goes nowhere, and makes it seem like you don't really think before you post. And if this is going nowhere, why do you keep replying? :)

  • i dont get it....

  • id tap that

  • @MrSchmuff dahhaha fuck no

  • from 15.00 i'm not on board anymore

  • amazing this is an actual great idea this could really help even though humanity doesn't see it that way and doesn't give it a change anyway im in full support.

    why? because she's one of the few with a real idea so if you gonne say something first think that you're a lazy prick that's not helping anyway school boring games are great combine them and we reach our ultimatum.

  • Yeah i am a gamer,and i thought this is porn :(

  • playdota got me here !

  • lol, gamers...

  • She's scary right ..

    

  • why does "let the world changing games begin" remind me so much of the hunger games? haha not a good sign

  • you know gaming has taught me something and that is politics

    

  • Wtf is she talking about !! so we should ignore about our problems in real life and start playng fkn games ? the games are only for fun .. the real world is at the out side ! in the end everyone have to face with their problems !! playing games and getting fat is not going to make world better ... this woman needs a life .. the games are only for fun ... and good job at advertising blizzards games ..

  • @4d3m92 did you ever try to listen to her?

  • @jon15 Yes i listen to her .. good advertisement about blizzard ... i m stdyng game design and do u know what i m seen when i walk into the class room ?? a people all their lifes is about games no social life they dont have any trust to go outside and talk with other people .. Games are just for fun .. and i m only interested in design or being artist ..

  • @4d3m92 looks like someone didn't watch the whole video

  • Video games my my childhood cooler, and I become cooler.