Everyone knows that Pirates of the Carribean (plus the music, the visuals and the quirks of the main character) are copies of the computer game Monkey Island.
When I saw the first Pirates for the first time at the cinema.. and Sparrow tries to lure the dog in jail with a bone to get the key, I yelled: "This is monkey island!" ..but in swedish =)
1. The first Monkey Island games are inspired by the Pirates of the Carribean back when it was just a theme park ride, and also the book "On Stranger Tides".
2. A Monkey Island movie is written by Ted Elliott, but the film is cancelled.
3. Later, Ted Elliott writes the Pirates of the Carribean movies. They are VERY similar.
4. The fourth Pirates of the Carribean film is based upon "On Stranger Tides", the inspiration for the inspiration for the series. Confused yet?
err.. wrong.. the creator admited that he said he was inspired by theatraction, cose it sounds better... he took most of the stuff from a book... cant remember the name thou...
Really? Well in Tales Of Monkey Island chapter 1 in the voodoo lady's shack when you click the statue the voodoo lady says it's a statue of "Nor Treblig". That's Ron Gilbert backwards!
Yes, but do you see cannibals? An army of the undead? An actual bar? A voodoo lady? Sure, it was inspired by it, but there's still tons of extra content added on to the original concept, so Monkey Island was still very original. There are so many things that Pirates of the Caribbean took from Monkey Island, it makes me mad. That's probably why Disney decided to make the trilogy as epic as possible. To get away with using Monkey Island as a base for everything that goes on in the trilogy.
some time ago, they wanted to produce a 2D monkey island movie (cartoonmovie like the third part of MI Curse of ..) but they didnt do :( so they took the ideas from monkey island and made Pirates of the carribean ... :"( i would have liked it when they made a cartoon movie from MI...
I just read about Monkey Island on wikipedia yesterday:
"Ron Gilbert has openly admitted that sections of Monkey Island 2 borrowed extensively from the original Disneyland ride, such as the famous "dog holding the keys to the jail-cell". However, he has also said that he thought the second movie (Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest) may have 'borrowed' from the Monkey Island series."
creo que si supierais los problemas que ha tenido Ron Gilbert con Piratas del Caribe,no diriais habriais usado imagenes de esta pelicula y mucho menos llamarlo "TRIBUTO"
Kira as Elaine in this tribute seems oddly appropriate, but it sucks that after "Curse of monkey island" they decided to scrap the british elain for an american sounding one. hmmm.... I like British elain better.
Actually, the creators have long said that the game was inspired and based on the POTC ride. Certain elements were placed as homages. That being said, it was a very original creation and all characters and situations in the game were unique to the game.
If they made a monkey island movie, everyone would think is a rip-off of Pirates of the Caribbean =(...Only real Monkey Island players would know the truth >=)
stupid nub fuckers - potc is knowingly a make of monkey island - even one of the script writers for monkey island was involved! idiots! and monkey island came out a LONG TIME BEFORE YOUR STUPID DISNEY RIDE U RETARDED KID
you do realise that potc movie came out hell of along time after the ride also knowingly to the face "pirates of the carribian" is a very common name obviously theres gonna be a ride of it and the ride is not the same as the movie plus, how can a 5 hour long video game copy of a 60 second ride?
No, I'm right. The story was inspired by the ride. Look up "Pirates of the Caribbean (film series)" in Wikipedia. It clearly says "They are based on a Walt Disney theme park ride of the same name".
Of course!!!! Pirates and gold and boats and stuff didn't exist prior to Disneys fecking ride did It!??!?! go back to your box, turn your egg timer upside down and don't come out until the sand is in the bottom... nugget...
fuck that movie pirates of the C.!! it'S a copy of monkey island,.. they make such a movie which has many parallels to monkey island and change a few things and the names.. for example will(guybrush) loves the daughter of the gouvernour(elaine) and the villian is the zombie pirat barbossa. aaach fuck that movie its just imitated!!!!
It are both Ghostpiratestorys, as all I knew when I was a child. A big evil Ghostpirate, his manship, swordfights, a woman and a secret with gold, etc..
One of the script writers invlved with the scrapped MI film idea was also in Pirates (for those doubters - i forget the name but if i get messages asking nicely without any rudeness i will go back over the sources and dig out his name fo you along with a source)...so...
He may have brought his ideas from the MI Project (which is very ovbious that he has done)...then there are the other writers bringing their own ideas...then there is the people who paid for the film who want some ideas of there own to be incorporated into it...then there is the ovbious influence from the disney ride of the same name....all that is mixed up together...the film then evolves naturally into something which, all in all, is very similar to MI!
And Jack is Captain Dread, of course, with quite a deal of Stan in him too. Both characters even have similar navigation devices (Stan's compass especially).
Too bad Will's a bit too much of a pansy to be a good Guybrush, he'd need Norrington's snarkiness. :p
Pirates of the Caribbean could have used a barbershop quartet, and EL POLLO DIABLO.
enmartinsen81 2 months ago
Hans Zimmer ain't got nothing against the true Monkey King
BuddhaMaster84 2 months ago
Everyone knows that Pirates of the Carribean (plus the music, the visuals and the quirks of the main character) are copies of the computer game Monkey Island.
levlobotomy 3 months ago
lol why does it sound like something from banjo kazzoie?
theMyl0 3 months ago
I thought the film was originally a Monkey Island one, but they cancelled it, and then Disney picked up the script, or something?
EnglandKeepMyBones 4 months ago
When I saw the first Pirates for the first time at the cinema.. and Sparrow tries to lure the dog in jail with a bone to get the key, I yelled: "This is monkey island!" ..but in swedish =)
Amalekites 5 months ago 2
Order of Events:
1. The first Monkey Island games are inspired by the Pirates of the Carribean back when it was just a theme park ride, and also the book "On Stranger Tides".
2. A Monkey Island movie is written by Ted Elliott, but the film is cancelled.
3. Later, Ted Elliott writes the Pirates of the Carribean movies. They are VERY similar.
4. The fourth Pirates of the Carribean film is based upon "On Stranger Tides", the inspiration for the inspiration for the series. Confused yet?
Nickelburg1 8 months ago 8
@Nickelburg1
So... the movies are based on a game based on the original park ride based on a book...? Mind = Blow
Haha, I already knew that and I think its actually pretty cool that we somehow got a MI movie in the form of the PoTC series. :P
SammEater 2 months ago
eingetlich wärs fluch der karibik scenen aus monkey island...
grimli16 9 months ago
USE... quill and stick... WITH... key in tentacles
crimsonrose 10 months ago 3
Where can I acess the soundtrack?
spawn1390 1 year ago
@spawn1390 Look up the Mega Monkey Remix by Amigamer on the scummbar.com
MrFerder 1 year ago
will turner with some jack = Guybrush Threepwood :D
TatitotitoxD 1 year ago
The Characters of Jack can be assimiliate to Edward van elgen in the curse of monkey island
arkanikorde 1 year ago
both, the movie and the game are epic... GIMME SOME GROG !!
777digger777 1 year ago
Jack is of course Mancomb Seepgood
willscomix 1 year ago
2:58 Davy looks so cute :D
Thoran666 1 year ago
i like the last music part, what song is it?
Sirmalice192837 1 year ago
its so true
hathen54766918 1 year ago
lol! and it fits
waddlerobloxxxx 1 year ago
What's the first part music?
alexandremacleod 1 year ago
It's fan-done version of the Scumm Bar theme by AmiGamer. I think you can find it on the scummbar website.
MrFerder 1 year ago
Wow that music surely fits with those scenes. Now im sitting and learning the first part on my guitar. Its so cool xD
pipenissen 2 years ago
err.. wrong.. the creator admited that he said he was inspired by theatraction, cose it sounds better... he took most of the stuff from a book... cant remember the name thou...
Cangooro 2 years ago
@Cangooro The book is "On Stranger Tides." The next Pirates of the Caribbean movie will be based on this book too. It's all gone full-circle.
MrFerder 2 years ago
MI and pirate of carribean are both inspired by the disneyland "pirate of carribean" attraction.
usernametoleico 2 years ago 3
yup ron gilbert admitted he created monkey island after visiting pirates of the carribean
Locke147 2 years ago
Really? Well in Tales Of Monkey Island chapter 1 in the voodoo lady's shack when you click the statue the voodoo lady says it's a statue of "Nor Treblig". That's Ron Gilbert backwards!
MEGAJASONGUY08 2 years ago
knice!
Locke147 2 years ago
and in part five, when Galeb keeps giving different names (since he can't remember quite well what his own name is) he says it's "Nor Treblig"
i didn't know it was at the beginning as well though! that's cool.
inabeautifulplace 2 years ago
Yes, but do you see cannibals? An army of the undead? An actual bar? A voodoo lady? Sure, it was inspired by it, but there's still tons of extra content added on to the original concept, so Monkey Island was still very original. There are so many things that Pirates of the Caribbean took from Monkey Island, it makes me mad. That's probably why Disney decided to make the trilogy as epic as possible. To get away with using Monkey Island as a base for everything that goes on in the trilogy.
DulvluSpa 2 years ago
Jack is clearly the lovechild of Captain Dread and Stan. :D
Darnaguen 2 years ago 6
one word...PERFECT (I need to play this game again) 5*'s
StueyLestrange 2 years ago 2
some time ago, they wanted to produce a 2D monkey island movie (cartoonmovie like the third part of MI Curse of ..) but they didnt do :( so they took the ideas from monkey island and made Pirates of the carribean ... :"( i would have liked it when they made a cartoon movie from MI...
xXJonestarXx 2 years ago
Actually, Monkey Island is based on the PotC attraction in Disney.
Although I admit that some stuff are TOO similar.
DPAGW 2 years ago 2
I just read about Monkey Island on wikipedia yesterday:
"Ron Gilbert has openly admitted that sections of Monkey Island 2 borrowed extensively from the original Disneyland ride, such as the famous "dog holding the keys to the jail-cell". However, he has also said that he thought the second movie (Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest) may have 'borrowed' from the Monkey Island series."
Dukefazon 2 years ago
creo que si supierais los problemas que ha tenido Ron Gilbert con Piratas del Caribe,no diriais habriais usado imagenes de esta pelicula y mucho menos llamarlo "TRIBUTO"
Lobacho82 2 years ago
Come to think of it, Captain Jack looks a lot like Captain Dread. He navigates similarly too.
SamSimaX 2 years ago 2
Never thought about that. But you're right. XD
Galgamos 2 years ago
the new part of monkey island game will come out tomorrow!! :D
rasta2 2 years ago
Kira as Elaine in this tribute seems oddly appropriate, but it sucks that after "Curse of monkey island" they decided to scrap the british elain for an american sounding one. hmmm.... I like British elain better.
ZombieGorePrincess 2 years ago 5
She got her British accent back in Tales.
DragonKazooie89 2 years ago
GREAT!!!
Where did you get the soundtrack?!
Please answer!
VoodooHarp 2 years ago
Mega Monkey Remix by AmiGamer from worldofmi
MrFerder 2 years ago
Thank you so much!!
VoodooHarp 2 years ago
the idea from the game and this movie comes from the same attraction of disneyland... sry my english is bad
johnson906090 2 years ago
Aaah, not every pirate story comes from the disney ride. :)
Stupoider 2 years ago
you can read it at wikipedia..^^
johnson906090 2 years ago
because Wikipedia is the all knowing never wrong source for all factual information.
ZombieGorePrincess 2 years ago
Actually, the creators have long said that the game was inspired and based on the POTC ride. Certain elements were placed as homages. That being said, it was a very original creation and all characters and situations in the game were unique to the game.
ferretsrcrunchy 2 years ago
Loved it!
Nice updated music! Brings me memories!
Monkey Island Rule!!!!
Glorymajor 2 years ago 2
hey! hey! hey!
lol caribien movie looks like it ha all the monkey island elements.
Aur0rah 2 years ago 4
Amazing! btw watch this in high quality wide screen by adding &fmt=18 to the URL
Vulle123 3 years ago
They should make a monkey island movie <3
Zambaku 3 years ago 5
they made a monkey island play. google it. pretty interesting
xxdelta77xx446 3 years ago
yeah the play is actually funny, but a movie would be AWESOME, and since Star Wars is over... why the hell don't they capitalize on it??!!!
VoidKeeper 3 years ago
The public would render it a rip-off of Pirates of the Caribbean, which ironically, is the other way around.
Skarloey123 3 years ago 4
yeah, kindah like Fallout 3 being called a rip-off of BioShock xD
VoidKeeper 3 years ago 2
If they made a monkey island movie, everyone would think is a rip-off of Pirates of the Caribbean =(...Only real Monkey Island players would know the truth >=)
PrYa08 3 years ago 56
@PrYa08 Sad but true.
BanjoOz 1 year ago
whatever is true, Monkey Island rules anyday :)
satanssuperior 3 years ago 4
were will takes the key...perfect music lol.
Azoolapazoo 3 years ago
Then the sequels evolve on their own too (incorporating even more MI and other ideas from other piratey stories) :)
bootboy1988 3 years ago
Shipwreck Cove reminded me a lot of Woodtick from Monkey 2
Metalmanic666 3 years ago 3
monkey island, the best video game...
monikalovaz 3 years ago 4
Monkey Island is older than Pirates of the caribbean! The story is the same, only Captain Jack is new...
gothic3rockstar 3 years ago
The story isn't the same. Monkey Island is about someone wanting to become a pirate. This doesn't occur at all in PotC.
whoweare 3 years ago 2
People, keep cool!
KGElf 3 years ago
stupid nub fuckers - potc is knowingly a make of monkey island - even one of the script writers for monkey island was involved! idiots! and monkey island came out a LONG TIME BEFORE YOUR STUPID DISNEY RIDE U RETARDED KID
ka1d3n 3 years ago
Pirates of the Caribbean
Locations and opening dates
Disneyland March 18, 1967 --> FROM WIKIPEDIA
As we can see, the disney ride (potc) opened in 1967, which means, it came out 23 years before Monkey Island 1 (1990)
it seems that you should return to school, to learn 2+2=4, that dogs have four legs, and those hard and professional things you dont seem to know.
Owned greets.
Perez360K 3 years ago 5
you do realise that potc movie came out hell of along time after the ride also knowingly to the face "pirates of the carribian" is a very common name obviously theres gonna be a ride of it and the ride is not the same as the movie plus, how can a 5 hour long video game copy of a 60 second ride?
ultimablaze5 3 years ago
the story for potc was written AFTER monkey island . DO you think the story was there before?:Dhahaahahaa
it was just a ride with pirates and a title;)
so shut up
youngromeHLBG 3 years ago 3
pirates of the carribian dtole from Monkey Island...those fuckers
arrogantworms4life 3 years ago
Actually, the Monkey Island games were inspired by a POTC ride in Disneyland, as the POTC movies were.
DevilMaster 3 years ago
what? are you ... very wrong ? A STORY WAS INSPIRED BY A THEME PARK RIDE ? Maybe you just wanted to say that this ride is really old?
izvunzemen 3 years ago
No, I'm right. The story was inspired by the ride. Look up "Pirates of the Caribbean (film series)" in Wikipedia. It clearly says "They are based on a Walt Disney theme park ride of the same name".
DevilMaster 3 years ago
Of course!!!! Pirates and gold and boats and stuff didn't exist prior to Disneys fecking ride did It!??!?! go back to your box, turn your egg timer upside down and don't come out until the sand is in the bottom... nugget...
Gaz134 3 years ago
wikipedia isnt always valid
cloudwind1 3 years ago 2
un consejo quitale el sonido a la pelicula
demonic193 3 years ago
Monkey Island is based on the Pirates of the Caribbean in Disneyland as is Pirates of the Caribbean the movie.
As good as Jack Sparrow is...he'll never be live up to Guybrush Threepwood...mighty pirate.
BrendanCanty10 3 years ago
fuck that movie pirates of the C.!! it'S a copy of monkey island,.. they make such a movie which has many parallels to monkey island and change a few things and the names.. for example will(guybrush) loves the daughter of the gouvernour(elaine) and the villian is the zombie pirat barbossa. aaach fuck that movie its just imitated!!!!
youngromeHLBG 3 years ago
Thank you so much! I always though I´m the only one who thought the movie was an unofficial Monkey Island movie
Xerosch 3 years ago
It are both Ghostpiratestorys, as all I knew when I was a child. A big evil Ghostpirate, his manship, swordfights, a woman and a secret with gold, etc..
Pommes1983 3 years ago
There's a clear view that there isn't a guybrush-like character in PotC.
whoweare 3 years ago
well technicly if u fused captain jack personality with wills looks and blonde hair you would get guybrush threepwood
ultimablaze5 3 years ago
I wouldn't say Jack and Guybrush have the same personality at all. =/
whoweare 3 years ago 25
really hmmm guess not then :S
ultimablaze5 3 years ago
@whoweare I think Guybrush and William are not the same but more alike.
cero815 1 year ago
@whoweare The Pirates character who ultimately has more in common with Guybrush is Will, minus the personality of course.
printthelegends 1 year ago
@whoweare
Jack = Captain Dread
Will = Guybrush
Elizabeth = Elaine
Barbossa = LeChuck
(Guybrush is spilt btw Jack and Will, in my opinion)
SnarkedGirl 3 months ago
very true.
One of the script writers invlved with the scrapped MI film idea was also in Pirates (for those doubters - i forget the name but if i get messages asking nicely without any rudeness i will go back over the sources and dig out his name fo you along with a source)...so...
bootboy1988 3 years ago
He may have brought his ideas from the MI Project (which is very ovbious that he has done)...then there are the other writers bringing their own ideas...then there is the people who paid for the film who want some ideas of there own to be incorporated into it...then there is the ovbious influence from the disney ride of the same name....all that is mixed up together...the film then evolves naturally into something which, all in all, is very similar to MI!
bootboy1988 3 years ago
Jack is pretty much Captain Dread from Monkey Island 2, filled with a different personality.
totallyRebb 3 years ago
not much. both of them r drunken u.u
FRMmega 3 years ago
Hee, that was brilliant. :D
And Jack is Captain Dread, of course, with quite a deal of Stan in him too. Both characters even have similar navigation devices (Stan's compass especially).
Too bad Will's a bit too much of a pansy to be a good Guybrush, he'd need Norrington's snarkiness. :p
Darnaguen 3 years ago
its a shame no1 makes a Monkey Island movie ( a real one ) its nice thou that "potc" got that Monkey island feeling about it :D
thyalmighty 4 years ago 3
oh my god... monkey island was my first one and will be the last...
awesome music!
potc will never be as genious as monkey island :).
OneLove260507 4 years ago 3
pirates of the cariibean is a monkey island rip off , shame on them , they should have called it monkey island
jmm1233 4 years ago 8
That would tarnish the name.
shadyparadox 4 years ago 4
hahahah funny:D
satisfeccellent 4 years ago
Monkey Island borrowed some elements from the ride, and the movie in turn may have borrowed some elements from MI.
SouthernGospelRocker 4 years ago
Well, they ARE based on the same ride...
Supermagle 4 years ago 2
It is suspicious how many scenes in the POTC movies match up with those in the Monkey Island games, isn't it?
GuanoLad 4 years ago 4
Brilliant!
ukashley 4 years ago
That was pretty good! The LeChuck song could have gone on for a little while longer though. Regardless, very nice.
TheHande 4 years ago