Thank you for not putting the messing up scratches that happen on guitar hero when you mess up. :P and the sound quality is good while the video quality lacks the quality so I appreciate you taking the time to cover the guitar hero song with the other version instead of hearing all the clanks and scratches from guitar hero.
It's rather goofy that the animated guitarist wails away in the background while the lead singer struts wildly like Roger Daltrey, clapping his hands when Classical Gas is played very slowly for the first minute. At least they didn't have the bassist or drummer going, else it would of just been ridiculous.
Some time ago, I spent what felt like eternity learning this song on guitar. Its easy now but this makes it seem much more difficult seeing it all laid out. Guitar Hero vs Guitar is not an argument. Its a game. Nobody who plays GH thinks they can actually play guitar. Its a game. On the vid, couldnt you have used the orchestral version? Its sooo much prettier.
dude i can play this on classic guitar without even trying but ooking at all thosenotes on guitar hero just makes me dizzy i find normal guitar muc easier than guitar hero
For me these games have been valuable teaching tools. They teach rhythym, pitch, the concept of "muscle memory" and make the basic concepts of music accessible. Far better than a book and a guitar. I bought a real guitar about a month ago and while I totally suck at it I know with practice I will get it. The basics are starting to come together for me and I can actually play 1 song that I would not be ashamed to show friends! :)
No...................... guitar hero is not better than a real guitar and a book for learning.
It's good, no it's great! for awkward chord changes, stretches, faster more coordinated fingers though for real guitar. And for timing, alternate strumming hammerons pulloffs etc.etc but it will only prepare you for a portion of what a real guitar has to offer.
I have to thank guitar hero for that at least. and It got me into real guitar. But GH isn't going to get you laid
Kingpin - I agree about the laid part. Wood and wood gets laid :) Playing an instrument does get the chicks. Even if you don't play that well I guess it has a "cool" factor.
You are spot on in your reply. GH/RB IS a tool and not a replacement for practice and sweat....
When I play something right on my guitar it is far more satisfying than RB!!! But RB helped me get some of my music skills down.
Honestly. It's a fucking game. The dude is far from claiming to have a useful skill. He's showing a map he made for a video game. I play both real guitar and enjoy guitar hero. All of you are assholes. Seriously.
in REAL LIFE I AM learing this song you should try playing and messing up 4/5 times for 7 straight hoursinstead of playing a video game thinkin that you are all that
yeah man this is a bitch to learn, ive been learning it for 2 months and i still cant get it quite down, i hate hot shot gutiar hero fags who try and act cool like the actually have a useful skill
i have it down already and i have been learing for 9 days guitar playing is what i spend most of my time doing i dont know i am hearing it iss really hard i dont really think its the hardest song ever and yes i have learned the classical gas directly from mason williams songbook nothing has been cut out or simplyfied
it never said you were i said why dont you try it on the real guitar with real strings and real frets, guitar hero is not realistic at all it doesn't allow you to play frets
@twinklewonderkid91 hahaha think about this 5 buttons and one strum bar, or 6 strings with at least 12 possible notes per string . . . not including natural harmonics or pinchs or anything else..... now u tell me what is easier :P
@mest189 As someone that can play this piece by heart on guitar and has played guitar hero I'm telling you it's easier in real life. In my opinion pretty much all of it is when you get to expert level.
@twinklewonderkid91 it's not that it's harder on guitar hero, it's that real guitar players tend to suck at GH. the things you learn playing a guitar can be a detriment to your skills at GH and vice versa. besides, I doubt any real guitar players spend nearly as much time on GH as it would take to master this song. there is no way in hell this song is actually harder on GH than in real life.
christ, the fact that I even have to point any of this out to anybody depresses the hell out of me.
it's like when I first played guitar hero at a friend's house and he was talking shit because I sucked at it even though I play real guitar. yes, I play REAL guitar, not a 5-button piece of plastic. it baffles me that anybody thinks playing an instrument with six strings and many frets per string should somehow translate into being good at pushing buttons as they appear on screen. the GH guitar isn't even as complex as a normal playstation or xbox controller, let alone a real instrument.
I guess basically what I'm saying is that the two activities require completely different skillsets that don't overlap in any way at all, and it's downright idiotic to think there's a comparison to be made beyond "music is playing in both instances". Guitar Hero is nothing more than a glorified PaRappa the Rapper with a plastic guitar that has less buttons. I find this debate to be ridiculous both as a real guitar player and a real gamer (that's right I said it).
@twinklewonderkid91 i see what you mean, when the piece gets to the A section it has that triplet, on the guitar it is between the index finger and open string, but here it is ring finger and pinky (bad combination) so in some ways yes and some ways no, thats how this game is
@twinklewonderkid91 It took me a full year to learn this wonderful piece with no flaws what so ever and to sync perfectly with the school band. Playing this on guitar hero looks too easy
@TheHackerYouKnow I actually spent about the same amount of time preparing it for an examination. I just think guitar hero has a tendency to either vastly under or over estimate the difficulty of songs. I can play Satch Boogie to but the guitar hero version just completely messes me up. From talking to people I've just tended to find that guitarist aren't brilliant at guitar hero.
@twinklewonderkid91 It's true guitar hero makes songs look like there the hardest things in the world. I mean c'mon? "Through the Fire and Flames" is considered the hardest song on GH but when in reality the song on a 6 string is not that difficult.
I hope you can actually play that on guitar, cause otherwise your missing out. Playing the strings and twiddling your fingers on a classical (or acoustic) is just so perfert, fact, I'm gonna log and go get mine.
I prefer Mason... also... But Tommy, just made it harder, but still his face... looks like donkey shit with a cowlick... LOL! But still he's a great guitarist...
I'm an old person/musician who grew up with that song on the radio. My kids now play guitar hero and rock band. Having tried my hand at both I have to say that you did AWESOME on hitting all that. Great job on getting the dubbed-over music to go with your great job on the game.
hehe, i can actually play it!! haha, it did take me alot of time to learn the finger picking, but after that it was really eazy and i enjoy playing this piece of music most days! it feels really great to have the power of making music in your hands...
It actually looks pretty synced up on my computer, music might be just a hair behind, but the notes are firing pretty much on time with the music for me...
Thank you for not putting the messing up scratches that happen on guitar hero when you mess up. :P and the sound quality is good while the video quality lacks the quality so I appreciate you taking the time to cover the guitar hero song with the other version instead of hearing all the clanks and scratches from guitar hero.
TheBubbaBomb 6 months ago
Hey! Can you send me this chart? :)
GuitarHeroSkara 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Such an amazing instrumental! Check out my version (on my channel) if you have time! Cheers.
nicolasdumesnil 1 year ago
its better on real :P
trevormclink 1 year ago
It's rather goofy that the animated guitarist wails away in the background while the lead singer struts wildly like Roger Daltrey, clapping his hands when Classical Gas is played very slowly for the first minute. At least they didn't have the bassist or drummer going, else it would of just been ridiculous.
PocketPick 1 year ago
i'm sorry dudebut this kinda rape...
menno023 1 year ago
HOW DID YOU GE THIS SONG?!?
abercrombiehllstr 1 year ago
lol it looks so much harder on guitar hero. i suck ass at guitar hero but i'd rather be decent playing a real guitar :)
Medevil9908 1 year ago
Some time ago, I spent what felt like eternity learning this song on guitar. Its easy now but this makes it seem much more difficult seeing it all laid out. Guitar Hero vs Guitar is not an argument. Its a game. Nobody who plays GH thinks they can actually play guitar. Its a game. On the vid, couldnt you have used the orchestral version? Its sooo much prettier.
Ask4Tristan 1 year ago
That's great, but kinda wrong backdrop, don't you think??
torod213 2 years ago
dude i can play this on classic guitar without even trying but ooking at all thosenotes on guitar hero just makes me dizzy i find normal guitar muc easier than guitar hero
ChRIs23696 2 years ago 9
For me these games have been valuable teaching tools. They teach rhythym, pitch, the concept of "muscle memory" and make the basic concepts of music accessible. Far better than a book and a guitar. I bought a real guitar about a month ago and while I totally suck at it I know with practice I will get it. The basics are starting to come together for me and I can actually play 1 song that I would not be ashamed to show friends! :)
meyery2k 2 years ago
No...................... guitar hero is not better than a real guitar and a book for learning.
It's good, no it's great! for awkward chord changes, stretches, faster more coordinated fingers though for real guitar. And for timing, alternate strumming hammerons pulloffs etc.etc but it will only prepare you for a portion of what a real guitar has to offer.
I have to thank guitar hero for that at least. and It got me into real guitar. But GH isn't going to get you laid
Kingpin0072001uk 2 years ago
Kingpin - I agree about the laid part. Wood and wood gets laid :) Playing an instrument does get the chicks. Even if you don't play that well I guess it has a "cool" factor.
You are spot on in your reply. GH/RB IS a tool and not a replacement for practice and sweat....
When I play something right on my guitar it is far more satisfying than RB!!! But RB helped me get some of my music skills down.
meyery2k 2 years ago
Honestly. It's a fucking game. The dude is far from claiming to have a useful skill. He's showing a map he made for a video game. I play both real guitar and enjoy guitar hero. All of you are assholes. Seriously.
Unchain101 2 years ago 3
Yeah Im like pro at real guitar, but I majorly fail at guitar hero lol. Real guitar way better though eh?
Ketersimax 2 years ago
in REAL LIFE I AM learing this song you should try playing and messing up 4/5 times for 7 straight hoursinstead of playing a video game thinkin that you are all that
thekingofcactus 2 years ago
yeah man this is a bitch to learn, ive been learning it for 2 months and i still cant get it quite down, i hate hot shot gutiar hero fags who try and act cool like the actually have a useful skill
TheSmokingGuitar 2 years ago
i have it down already and i have been learing for 9 days guitar playing is what i spend most of my time doing i dont know i am hearing it iss really hard i dont really think its the hardest song ever and yes i have learned the classical gas directly from mason williams songbook nothing has been cut out or simplyfied
thekingofcactus 2 years ago
nice! i guess im jsut a slow learner haha, its not the hardest ive learned, but for some reason it gives me some trouble
TheSmokingGuitar 2 years ago
well i learnt it on real guitar in 2 weeks. Not actually that hard you should try
Ketersimax 2 years ago
i know it now. i was just off by like one or two notes in the chorus. but i got it now
TheSmokingGuitar 2 years ago
dude y dont u get a life instead of goin around utube tellin people how bad they are
CampbellsChunky 2 years ago
it never said you were i said why dont you try it on the real guitar with real strings and real frets, guitar hero is not realistic at all it doesn't allow you to play frets
thekingofcactus 2 years ago
I know eh! They could at least make it look like a damn guitar! I suck at guitar hero like hell! But its better to be good at real guitar i guess.
Ketersimax 2 years ago
learn how to play real guitar instead of all you posers playing gay guitar hero!!!!!!!!!!!
duran19914 2 years ago
it is easier to play on an actual guitar
buhdanugget1 2 years ago 2
Haha i would agree man
hewofwend 2 years ago
I absolutely love this song!!!
keywestredbeard 2 years ago
Is it just me or is this piece easier to play in real life than on guitar hero?lol
twinklewonderkid91 2 years ago
It's just you.
AlexLeff 2 years ago 4
Or maybe I just rock at real guitar
twinklewonderkid91 2 years ago 11
Maybe you do. It's still much easier to learn to do this on guitar hero than to learn to finger-pick this song well.
AlexLeff 2 years ago
actually i agree with him
TheSmokingGuitar 2 years ago
@twinklewonderkid91 hahaha think about this 5 buttons and one strum bar, or 6 strings with at least 12 possible notes per string . . . not including natural harmonics or pinchs or anything else..... now u tell me what is easier :P
mest189 1 year ago
@mest189 As someone that can play this piece by heart on guitar and has played guitar hero I'm telling you it's easier in real life. In my opinion pretty much all of it is when you get to expert level.
twinklewonderkid91 1 year ago
@twinklewonderkid91 No you're right. I play this piece on real guitar and it's not that hard. However, on this, I would miss several notes.
sjlarcadia 1 year ago
@sjlarcadia I'm glad someone finally agrees with me. There's something about guitar hero that makes songs more difficult.
twinklewonderkid91 1 year ago
@twinklewonderkid91 it's not that it's harder on guitar hero, it's that real guitar players tend to suck at GH. the things you learn playing a guitar can be a detriment to your skills at GH and vice versa. besides, I doubt any real guitar players spend nearly as much time on GH as it would take to master this song. there is no way in hell this song is actually harder on GH than in real life.
christ, the fact that I even have to point any of this out to anybody depresses the hell out of me.
DICY 1 year ago
it's like when I first played guitar hero at a friend's house and he was talking shit because I sucked at it even though I play real guitar. yes, I play REAL guitar, not a 5-button piece of plastic. it baffles me that anybody thinks playing an instrument with six strings and many frets per string should somehow translate into being good at pushing buttons as they appear on screen. the GH guitar isn't even as complex as a normal playstation or xbox controller, let alone a real instrument.
DICY 1 year ago
I guess basically what I'm saying is that the two activities require completely different skillsets that don't overlap in any way at all, and it's downright idiotic to think there's a comparison to be made beyond "music is playing in both instances". Guitar Hero is nothing more than a glorified PaRappa the Rapper with a plastic guitar that has less buttons. I find this debate to be ridiculous both as a real guitar player and a real gamer (that's right I said it).
DICY 1 year ago
@twinklewonderkid91 This song is underestimated in it's difficulty on the guitar. The timing and all is damn difficult :)
BartXZX 1 year ago
@twinklewonderkid91 i see what you mean, when the piece gets to the A section it has that triplet, on the guitar it is between the index finger and open string, but here it is ring finger and pinky (bad combination) so in some ways yes and some ways no, thats how this game is
pkingsleyisback 11 months ago
@twinklewonderkid91 It took me a full year to learn this wonderful piece with no flaws what so ever and to sync perfectly with the school band. Playing this on guitar hero looks too easy
TheHackerYouKnow 5 months ago
@TheHackerYouKnow I actually spent about the same amount of time preparing it for an examination. I just think guitar hero has a tendency to either vastly under or over estimate the difficulty of songs. I can play Satch Boogie to but the guitar hero version just completely messes me up. From talking to people I've just tended to find that guitarist aren't brilliant at guitar hero.
twinklewonderkid91 5 months ago
@twinklewonderkid91 It's true guitar hero makes songs look like there the hardest things in the world. I mean c'mon? "Through the Fire and Flames" is considered the hardest song on GH but when in reality the song on a 6 string is not that difficult.
TheHackerYouKnow 5 months ago
I hope you can actually play that on guitar, cause otherwise your missing out. Playing the strings and twiddling your fingers on a classical (or acoustic) is just so perfert, fact, I'm gonna log and go get mine.
Brouzk 3 years ago
Weird this would seem like a perfect candidate for the game maybe someday...
lasfrge 3 years ago
guitar hero 1,2 or 3??
tell me!?!?
Ketuhar12345 3 years ago
2, obviously, look at the star power meter.
Dedaluminus 3 years ago
Guitar Hero... buff... Real Guitar... GREAT! LOL!
LinkBulletBill 3 years ago
imagine Tommy Emmuelle's version.. (PS I don't really know how is last name is spelled...
LinkBulletBill 3 years ago
fuck tommy.
shamusfinanigan 3 years ago
I prefer Mason... also... But Tommy, just made it harder, but still his face... looks like donkey shit with a cowlick... LOL! But still he's a great guitarist...
LinkBulletBill 3 years ago 3
ill stick to playing it on the guitar thats real tough
puente6969 3 years ago
good job! just wondering... is the original recording the Tommy Emmanuel one or Mason Williams one the one u put over the guitar hero....
tomonated 3 years ago
I'm an old person/musician who grew up with that song on the radio. My kids now play guitar hero and rock band. Having tried my hand at both I have to say that you did AWESOME on hitting all that. Great job on getting the dubbed-over music to go with your great job on the game.
ImStarshine14 3 years ago
nice!
juitarizt 3 years ago
wow. that song is incredible. you played it well, even though you covered the audio :]
xseeareuh 3 years ago
i dont think you played that bad at all
PiPwns 3 years ago 2
Yea but since it's an all-guitar song, when I missed the whole song just cut out. It sounded pretty bad, trust me.
AlexLeff 3 years ago
i understand but i still think you played better than most people would have
PiPwns 3 years ago
Dude that was fantastic!! You did amazingly great!!
hovigster 3 years ago
The chart reminds me of an easier version of rude mood, much easier. This song is so cool and its sick to see it on GH. 5*
JacksonJ92 3 years ago
That's a nice chart; any chance of a link? :)
VengefulStick 3 years ago
isn't the original version of classical gas performed by eric clapton?
sskats 3 years ago
no.
troodon9999 3 years ago 4
Mason Williams created it, there was various edits after that, inlcuding a pop version by an Aussie kid
smokinxp 3 years ago
Ah! This is awesome!
notdaltrey 4 years ago 2
hot damn! this is #1 on my list of songs that I wished were on guitar hero. you're awesome.
KMorgado 4 years ago 2
Dude I would love to see you play this on real guitar!!
IronTrooper 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
fuck guitar hero, learn how to play a real fucking guitar
HispanicGold 4 years ago
Look at the fucking video response you ignorant, negative piece of shit. And never, ever comment on my videos again.
AlexLeff 4 years ago
Hmm, by your logic, we should all also fuck games like GTA and go kill real fucking people.
You're ignorant.
lunieomg 4 years ago 2
nice
Blindreaper8880 4 years ago
I've wanted so much for guitar hero to get away from this death metal crap and get in to classical. Thanks a lot for making/posting this.
blindlyisay 4 years ago
This song looks harder on GH lmao.
Rhyse001 4 years ago
yea thats true...hahahahah
dumfaggot12345 4 years ago
Umm... it's actually an incredibly difficult song to finger-pick, in my opinion. I can scrape by on it, but I'd love to see you guys do it.
AlexLeff 4 years ago
hehe, i can actually play it!! haha, it did take me alot of time to learn the finger picking, but after that it was really eazy and i enjoy playing this piece of music most days! it feels really great to have the power of making music in your hands...
Josefelipe11 4 years ago 2
sweet, i so want this in GHIV, i put it on my wishlist set
bonfire7437289459 4 years ago
that is so incredibly sick dude. i love this song and that chart is just about spot on. it's so intense dude i wish i could do that.
stratifymecaptain 4 years ago
Pretty sweet.
MikeN00b 4 years ago
Chart couldn't be any better man, badass job.
xenthoxin90 4 years ago
awesome chart
MedicusMaleficus 4 years ago
It actually looks pretty synced up on my computer, music might be just a hair behind, but the notes are firing pretty much on time with the music for me...
AlexLeff 4 years ago
good chart, video is out of sync though... kinda takes away from it. damn youtube.
Loderunner28 4 years ago