Siobhan Magnus - Superstition American Idol top 11

[Necros212]

Her and Haley should have done a duet for the finales. Their just that alike. They both have that jazzy voice.

[IanROX22]

wtf is with the dislikes???

[Gurizin]

The little shout at 2:33 sounded like she stubbed her toe

[ddevon18]

@Gurizin lmfao it does hahaha xD

[MissG94]

Love her, she had the best vocals on the show and she's so unique.

[potatoesrbad]

I picked Sioban from the beginning to win. She is kinda like a female Adam Lambert. Sorry 4 the redundency-lol. Lee was my second favorite. i think they made a mistake 2 save big Mike. Love u Sioban.

[UrFunnyNightMare]

I Love Siobhan her personality and beliefs she's cool her weirdness brings the best in her even though she didnt make it in Vocal Prowess she is the best and in stage presence too she is so cool she should have been the winner try to read Hieyna's comment its true her scream isnt just screaming its music i feel so sorry for her but i hope that she will get a big record deal go Siobhan Dont Give up..^.^

[pyrofreak007]

Hating on her is a waste of time. Just remember, people know her name. NOT yours.

[Hieyna]

She is anything but predictable. I'm tired of people talking about a 'scream', it is hardly a scream. Have you ever been afraid of something and screamed? That's a scream. She uses her unique talent for the best.

This week, she dialed it all down. I didn't particuarly like it, she ended up like Katie who can sing great, but not much more.

Siobhan to win. ;)

[bbljp8797]

i dont like her voice only when she screams

[evilportrait]

She was a little awkward during the first clip...

But I still hope she wins! This wasn't as good as Paint it black--which was just awesome! Crystal could also win.

[felipebbiggi]

She could sing and im telling you by j.hud

[alabamabregan]

She'll be so much fun to watch in concert once she learns how to pace herself. No need to scream every song. She's learning.

[lvu16]

love her too

[shokalatte8]

she is the cutest thing ever in the first part of this video...i love the glasses look...what a sweet voice too! and she uses the phrase "i think its wicked cool...", thats the coolest thing ever...im a different kind of person myself, i would love to meet this girl

[PaleLittleGirl1]

i was pretty disappointed, and i LOVE her! she's still amazing, though. hopefully next week she'll do something more current, more interesting.

[Rosannasfriend]

I didn't think the song was the problem. Her singing is getting predictable. That song can easily have a current vibe, and she added her own twist, but went overboard at the end.

[anherji]

Predictable? How could've you predicted this after last week.... i don't see the resemblance and if you say the scream then lol don't even mention it cause it's wayy differnt than before and well there are others doing thing more predictable than her... :|

[Rosannasfriend]

yes, I'm talking about the scream. Whether different notes or whatever(isn't that what she's supposed to do? I mean it is a different song, why do the same note, of course it was a different scream or note), it is still predictable at this point that she will do one towards the end. I am sick of it, and I'm glad that based on her comments she gets that she has to change it up. I look forward to her next week. :)

[anherji]

Ohh ok i see your point but still i think its not SOOOO predictable cause it has been like 2 weeks on a row and before that just one lol but ok i still want her to do a ballad cause she has a powerfull voice even if she doesnt do the scream (WG and HORS) i thought you meaan the entire performance was predictable lol cause i would've never though she'd sing this one

[Rosannasfriend]

@anherji ok, see for me, this is the 3rd time she's sung like this. Remember "Think'? I'm a little sick of it, and as someone who hated Adam Lambert's prolongued, constant never ending screams in 99% of his Idol performances, I would feel like a hypocrite for liking Siobhan(even if she doesn't overwhelm the song with it like he did). I HATED HIM!!! LOL.

[anherji]

Yea but "think" was outta nowhere so i kinda dont count that one heh! But i really want her to not do that and play the piano instead, a powerfull R&B ballad ;)

[dawnage01]

Siobhan was AMAZING as usual! :) You go girl! :P

[lynnwoodsmeghead]

I agreed with everything Simon had to say.

[lkmaryrob]

I agreed with everything Randy, Ellen, and the other lady said.